Why can't Saudi Arabia and Iran talk?

[fitpOsitive]

We can do two things to make easier for both Iran and Saudia.
Let's start accepting Irani, Saudi, Russian and Chinese currency for oil.
In one night, things will change a lot, for both the countries. Dropping Dollar will losen USA grip on many things.
Let's make Saudia as official partner in CPEC.

 

[Beast]

That thing I addressed earlier. That no one is leader here. And we all can live without becoming leaders of each other.

Saudi see Iran more like a outsider with non arabic speaking population in middle east region.

Both will not back down and the feud will continue to last but Saudi is at more disadvantage with their heavy dependent on oil plus a smaller population. Oil industry will see further slip in the next 5 years.

Iran too heavily depend on oil for revenue but has build up education and ample self sufficient industries. It make not be state of art but will help Iran to weather the storm better. If my prediction is correct. Iran will eventually triumph if drastic changes not occur within Saudi.

 

[Beast]

We can do two things to make easier for both Iran and Saudia.
Let's start accepting Irani, Saudi, Russian and Chinese currency for oil.
In one night, things will change a lot, for both the countries. Dropping Dollar will losen USA grip on many things.

It is already happening and the reason u see mad dog US barking everywhere looking for trouble.

 

[Dariush the Great]

Saudi see Iran more like a outsider with non arabic speaking population in middle east region.

Both will not back down and the feud will continue to last but Saudi is at more disadvantage with their heavy dependent on oil plus a smaller population. Oil industry will see further slip in the next 5 years.

Iran too heavily depend on oil for revenue but has build up education and ample self sufficient industries. It make not be state of art but will help Iran to weather the storm better. If my prediction is correct. Iran will eventually triumph if drastic changes not occur within Saudi.

That's nonsense. Saudi didn't have any problem with Persian speaking Iranians during the Shah era. The problem here is purely political and nothing else.

 

[Old School]

Both Iran and Saudi should be abolished as states and they should become part of a new Islamic Republic which would resemble the former Ottoman empire including the Balkan, North Africa and Caucasus. This is the only solution to peace in the middle east. The second Islamic Republic should be made of PAKISTAN, Afghanistan and Khorasan region.

 

[Dariush the Great]

Both Iran and Saudi should be abolished as states and they should become part of a new Islamic Republic which would resemble the former Ottoman empire including the Balkan, North Africa and Caucasus. This is the only solution to peace in the middle east. The second Islamic Republic should be made of PAKISTAN, Afghanistan and Khorasan region.

Only if you first become part of the Persian empire (again).

 

[Old School]

Only if you first become part of the Persian empire (again).

Persian empire was long ago dead when it had embraced Islam in the eighth century. Even Iranians themselves are divided between Persians and Muslims. Iran will remain an Islamic republic for the foreseeable future.

 

[Enigma SIG]

We can ask them both to bend the knee under the protection of the Great Indus Empire.

 

[Dariush the Great]

Persian empire was long ago dead when it had embraced Islam in the eighth century. Even Iranians themselves are divided between Persians and Muslims. Iran will remain an Islamic republic for the foreseeable future.

Persian empire was alive and well until the Safavid empire and Nader shah, not so long ago. It is a well known fact that Persians changed Islam to a version of their own liking (Shia). Also, most of Iran's neighbours belong to the Iranic family and many of them have Iranian roots/names. It is natural to return to the homeland.

 

[Beast]

That's nonsense. Saudi didn't have any problem with Persian speaking Iranians during the Shah era. The problem here is purely political and nothing else.

You shall know during shah time is monarch and not islamic. Shah is not looking to be leader of Islam but revive of great persia. So no clash of interest. Arabs are happy these non arabic speaking middle East country aligned with US to be an outsider the affair of islam during the 60s and 70s.

 

[fitpOsitive]

I think that main problem is ego, in this case.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

You shall know Saudi is sunni(Arabic) and Iran is shia(Iranian). How can both get along?

Its like Greece orthodox Christian vs Turkey Muslim.

Situation is not as you presented. Actually it is very easy for Sunni and Shia to get along, the issue is not religion, but politics.

Please refrain from discussing Islamic issues which you do not have knowledge of.

Saudi see Iran more like a outsider with non arabic speaking population in middle east region.

Both will not back down and the feud will continue to last but Saudi is at more disadvantage with their heavy dependent on oil plus a smaller population. Oil industry will see further slip in the next 5 years.

Iran too heavily depend on oil for revenue but has build up education and ample self sufficient industries. It make not be state of art but will help Iran to weather the storm better. If my prediction is correct. Iran will eventually triumph if drastic changes not occur within Saudi.

Not true. There can be peace, but it has to happen with the removal of ruling classes of both countries. They are using their politics to push sectarianism, which is having a terrible effect on the region.

Persian empire was alive and well until the Safavid empire and Nader shah, not so long ago. It is a well known fact that Persians changed Islam to a version of their own liking (Shia). Also, most of Iran's neighbours belong to the Iranic family and many of them have Iranian roots/names. It is natural to return to the homeland.

Iran converting to Shiaism under Turkic Safavi empire forever broke the Persian-speaking world into Sunni and Shia.

Where before there was deep unity and a common culture, now it is rivalries and animosities.

 

[Dariush the Great]

Iran converting to Shiaism under Turkic Safavi empire forever broke the Persian-speaking world into Sunni and Shia.

Where before there was deep unity and a common culture, now it is rivalries and animosities.

Iranian Azari (turkic speaking) rulers made the right decision to convert Iran to Shiism and dividing Islam into two parts effectively ending the Arabi sunni dominance and a start of Persian version of Islam.

Islam as a religion was heavily abused by cruel rulers at those times so a fresh restart aka as the Persian version got introduced.

BTW, do you agree that the current Persian gulf dictators are... dictators ? Installed by the US to loot the region!?

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

They haven't been "talking" over a millennium!!! Hence, entities like Turkey and Pak, who can "talk" to everyone among the humanity...

 

[925boy]

But sometime US deliberately tend to help Iran like removing Saddam and Taliban.

in this situation, US didnt help Iran intentionally, it was by mistake/ignorance/errors in strategy or actions.