What's new

Where's secularism, asks Emraan after being denied house

Salahadin

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jan 4, 2009
Messages
479
Reaction score
0
MUMBAI: "Am I a criminal or a terrorist?" asked an upset Emraan Hashmi on Friday. The Bollywood actor alleged he had been denied a house he

wanted to buy in the upmarket Pali Hill area of Mumbai because he was Muslim.

The actor, who was not given a no-objection certificate (NOC), believes the housing society in Pali Hill was hiding the real reason for its refusal.

"This has political connotations, so they don't want to talk about it openly. Yesterday (Thursday), they told me that I can't get the NOC. I asked them why aren't you giving me the certificate -- am I a criminal, or a terrorist or have I done anything illegal?" Emraan told reporters here with his uncle and well-known filmmaker Mahesh Bhatt by his side.


"It is strange that they don't tell you on your face that you can't get a house because you are a Muslim. It would have been easier if they would have told me openly. What they told me is that they can't allow me to live there because I am a serial kisser and my presence will have a bad influence on the children staying there.

"Being a celebrity if I'm facing problems in buying a house here, I wonder what kind of problems others would have been facing. All the time we are talking about secularism but with such incidents what secularism are people talking about?" asked the actor.

Emraan said someone suggested to him that he purchase the house in the name of his wife Parveen, who is a Hindu. "I can do that, but why should I do that?" he asked.

Bhatt said such discrimination was a serious problem plaguing the country.

"Even 62 years after independence, the virus of communalism is alive in an area like Pali Hill, which is known as India's Beverly Hills where stars like Sunil Dutt lived and Dilip Kumar is still living there. It's a serious problem and is the country ready to accept that communalism is still surviving?" he said.

"There are also certain societies in the area that do not give NOCs to non-Hindus," he said.

Emraan, who featured in films like "Murder", "Gangster - A Love Story", wanted to buy a house in Pali Hill so that he could stay close to his parents, but the actor was refused the NOC by Pali Hill's Nibbana Cooperative Society.

He has filed a complaint with the State Minorities' Commission, demanding action against the society members. The society reportedly has mostly Hindus and a couple of Catholic families.

This is not the first time Hashmi has faced such a problem.

"I faced a similar situation in August 2007, when I was looking for a house in the same area; residents and brokers told me I would not be able to get a house because I was a Muslim. But I later managed to get one," Emraan told a newspaper Thursday.

Earlier Shabana Azmi and Javed Akhtar had faced problems in getting a house in Juhu and TV actor Aamir Khan filed a litigation after being refused a house in Lokhandwala.

So called secular India


Where's secularism, asks Emraan after being denied house - Mumbai - City - NEWS - The Times of India
 
Last edited:
May be those people don't want to this guy running around kissing their daughters, wives or may be even sons.:rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::chilli:
 
May be those people don't want to this guy running around kissing their daughters, wives or may be even sons.


This is not the first time Indian Muslim actors have complaint of such discrimination in so-called secular India.
 
This is not the first time Indian Muslim actors have complaint of such discrimination in so-called secular India.

Its not only Muslim Actors....you can locate multiple incidents of people from film industry especially girls have been refused houses....just because of their industry....This incident got highlighted only because he is also a Muslim....

But I agree some people especially hardliner Hindus would not like to share living space with Muslims for stupid reasons...and that has nothing to do with secularism...just a matter of choice......Now constitution can not force anyone to rent out or sell his house to a person who one does not like ....its a personal choice........
 
Yes this stuff happens.. and i feel it is ridiculous. I think some sort of law should be put in place if any society refuses people to buy homes in this country because of its religion. These guy should be punished and should be made an example, for those who discriminate based on religion.
 
Yes this stuff happens.. and i feel it is ridiculous. I think some sort of law should be put in place if any society refuses people to buy homes in this country because of its religion. These guy should be punished and should be made an example, for those who do racial profiling.

No need to ridicule anyone here buddy,

its matter of personal choice...I was in Bangalore some yrs back...and was looking for a house ...I was refused a house just because I was a bachelor.....

I was refused a house in Noida because the landlord was a Muslim and he wanted a rent the house to a Muslim...

As I said its a matter of personal choice....the society simply does not want anyone from film background and a Muslim guy in their society....
 
Yes this stuff happens.. and i feel it is ridiculous. I think some sort of law should be put in place if any society refuses people to buy homes in this country because of its religion. These guy should be punished and should be made an example, for those who discriminate based on religion.

Ever been to Jain Building ?

I will never buy a house in a Jain or a Muslim Majority Building because

I eat non-veg and Jains vomit if they smell Meat. So they have their rules in the society.

And in Muslims society some of them eat beef which my family will not accept. My family still does not know that i eat Beef...;)

If i want to stay in their society i have to follow their rules or look for another place. No need to complicate things.
 
Its not only Muslim Actors....you can locate multiple incidents of people from film industry especially girls have been refused houses....just because of their industry....This incident got highlighted only because he is also a Muslim....

But I agree some people especially hardliner Hindus would not like to share living space with Muslims for stupid reasons...and that has nothing to do with secularism...just a matter of choice......Now constitution can not force anyone to rent out or sell his house to a person who one does not like ....its a personal choice........

false,
nothing about religion or their industry.. this happens due to eating habits... most buildings that have brahmins, vaishnov or jain residents dont even sell to other hindus (meat eaters):sick:
at my friends apartment a woman filed a FIR with cops because her neighbor (muslim) used to cook dry fish:D; next morning the muslim guy tied a goat in his parking space:rofl::flame:
 
Its not only Muslim Actors....you can locate multiple incidents of people from film industry especially girls have been refused houses....just because of their industry....This incident got highlighted only because he is also a Muslim....

You may be right but atleast in case of Muslim actors who were refused for buying houses its the religion which main reason.

Besides i think and you might agree that elite people and elite known actors buy houses in Posh areas and i do not think that elite people living these areas have anything to worry about values and traditions. Same goes for our own elite areas.

So i dont think so being from film industry, the actors bother these people from these elite areas/


But I agree some people especially hardliner Hindus would not like to share living space with Muslims for stupid reasons...and that has nothing to do with secularism...just a matter of choice......Now constitution can not force anyone to rent out or sell his house to a person who one does not like ....its a personal choice........


What can i say its your country.

The idea of secularism in India is already a flawed one
 
Ever been to Jain Building ?

I will never buy a house in a Jain or a Muslim Majority Building because

I eat non-veg and Jains vomit if they smell Meat. So they have their rules in the society.

And in Muslims society some of them eat beef which my family will not accept. My family still does not know that i eat Beef...;)

If i want to stay in their society i have to follow their rules or look for another place. No need to complicate things.



:woot: you eat beaf

damn hope RSS, Bajrangdal wont term you a Muslim :D
 
Its not only Muslim Actors....you can locate multiple incidents of people from film industry especially girls have been refused houses....just because of their industry....This incident got highlighted only because he is also a Muslim....

Pali Hill, which is known as India's Beverly Hills where stars like Sunil Dutt lived and Dilip Kumar is still living there

Well they dont mind hindu actors living near them ,the problem seems to be muslim actors
 
SHRAVAN

Ever been to Jain Building ?

I will never buy a house in a Jain or a Muslim Majority Building because

I eat non-veg and Jains vomit if they smell Meat. So they have their rules in the society.

And in Muslims society some of them eat beef which my family will not accept. My family still does not know that i eat Beef...

If i want to stay in their society i have to follow their rules or look for another place. No need to complicate things.

glomex


No need to ridicule anyone here buddy,

its matter of personal choice...I was in Bangalore some yrs back...and was looking for a house ...I was refused a house just because I was a bachelor.....

I was refused a house in Noida because the landlord was a Muslim and he wanted a rent the house to a Muslim...

As I said its a matter of personal choice....the society simply does not want anyone from film background and a Muslim guy in their society....


Brother, who are these jains and muslims and hindus to deny an indian citizen the right to buy a house and live where he wants.

You should stipulate the requirments to be fullfilled inorder to buy a house in your society, why are they not putting it in black and white and in paper saying that such and such things are to be followed in order to qualify for purchasing a house in this locality.

What guarentt can you give that an hindu wont eat beef, a family man wont bring prostitutes, or a so called decent hindu wouldnt turns alocholic and create a rucks, and so called muslim man wont be a criminal. These are pure prejudice man, people think muslims or a section of society does so and so things, and hence they are not eligible for a right to spend their own money and buy someone eless house,

If you bring in communal colour to your Objection, that is simply not acceptable man..!!!!
 
Brother, who are these jains and muslims and hindus to deny an indian citizen the right to buy a house and live where he wants.

You should stipulate the requirments to be fullfilled inorder to buy a house in your society, why are they not putting it in black and white and in paper saying that such and such things are to be followed in order to qualify for purchasing a house in this locality.

What guarentt can you give that an hindu wont eat beef, a family man wont bring prostitutes, or a so called decent hindu wouldnt turns alocholic and create a rucks, and so called muslim man wont be a criminal. These are pure prejudice man, people think muslims or a section of society does so and so things, and hence they are not eligible for a right to spend their own money and buy someone eless house,

If you bring in communal colour to your Objection, that is simply not acceptable man..!!!!

If I have a house...I have right to rent it /sell it to anyone I like....may be I will give it to my Muslim friend or may be to my Sikh friend even though a Hindu may be offering a higher price.....its my wish....
Its about personal preferences.......

My personal life has some examples...We had a Cook from Nepal...he stole some money from my purse and i caught him...so I don't keep Nepalese Cook anymore....so its my personal preference...


Same goes to anyone....
 
Pali Hill, which is known as India's Beverly Hills where stars like Sunil Dutt lived and Dilip Kumar is still living there

Well they dont mind hindu actors living near them ,the problem seems to be muslim actors

i didn't understand your statement..
Pali Hill, which is known as India's Beverly Hills where stars like Sunil Dutt lived and Dilip Kumar is still living there
is this supposed to point out two hindus living together?

ps. dilip kumar's real name is yusuf khan
 
:woot: you eat beaf

damn hope RSS, Bajrangdal wont term you a Muslim :D

Thats a bit too extreme thinking. I hope its just a harmless joke. In case if you have some misconceptions, i am from Kerala, and majority Hindus here beef its something like the state food of Kerala and the same is the case with Andhra and Tamil Nadu. So i would say chill sis.... ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom