What is Indian culture in the modern world?

[HariPrasad]

We hear India is a democracy, but yet minorities are killed for eating beef and that too without any proof, where cinemas are burnt down and they go on riots over a fictional story. Were women and kids are afraid to go out at night, where in a hospital ward a 4-year-old is gang-raped by the people who are mean to care for her.

Nobody is killed for eating beef. Whatever few attack has happened were happened because they killed cows and not for eating beef. Whole India condemn that in one voice. In a country of 1300 mn people, how many such incident can you quote? In a population of 25 mn people, Indians and other ethnic groups are attacked and killed just without any provocation but it is just an aberration for people like you but when any such incident happen in India, world media singles it out and project as a mainstream practice of Indian society. Can we talk of per capita any such crime of Australia, Europe, US Vs India?

It is about time we ban Indians from coming into the country and it's good the government is making it harder for Indians to come in now.

Ok Ban Indians if you have the capability to run your country on your own. You advocate banning Indians from coming to Australia and simultaneously claims that you guys are not racist. I do not want make any sweeping statement like you but let me tell you that your stupid country has no guts to survive without India and Indian skilled manpower. Neither US has that Noe UK has it. I request you to educate yourself a bit more and learn about India before exposing your ignorance.

destroying their mosques and temples.

Which Minority has temples which India Destroyed?

 

[Chakar The Great]

Nobody is killed for eating beef. Whatever few attack has happened were happened because they killed cows and not for eating beef. Whole India condemn that in one voice. In a country of 1300 mn people, how many such incident can you quote? In a population of 25 mn people, Indians and other ethnic groups are attacked and killed just without any provocation but it is just an aberration for people like you but when any such incident happen in India, world media singles it out and project as a mainstream practice of Indian society. Can we talk of per capita any such crime of Australia, Europe, US Vs India?

I am sorry but thats not true,

Muslims Raped, Killed ‘for Eating Beef’

Muslims on India train assaulted 'because they ate beef'

Accused of carrying beef, teen killed on train

Man accused of carrying beef beaten to death by 100-strong mob in Jharkhand


These are just few news from Indian media houses. Just google and you ll see where India stands when it comes to beef eating. Its better you stop lying. You start your argument with a lie who is gona read the rest of comment. If Senior PDF members like yourself start to propagate a lie, what can we expect from an army of paid trolls from your country?

 

[HariPrasad]

Muslims Raped, Killed ‘for Eating Beef’

Muslims on India train assaulted 'because they ate beef'

Accused of carrying beef, teen killed on train

Man accused of carrying beef beaten to death by 100-strong mob in Jharkhand

This is nothing against the genocide f Hindus done by Muslims in India. They killed Thousands of Hindus, Killed infant children, Raped women and cleansed 5 lakh hindus from Kashmir. So quoting Isolated incident will not prove anything. We have less than 70 death in communal violence in India on an average in last few years. On Other hand, We know very well how Muslims are treated in Muslim Countries. They are literally genocide. India will take tens of thousands of years to match the figure of killing of Muslims in Muslim Country in a single year. So take your butt hurt somewhere else. We know very well how Muslim behaves with other community and also with other Muslims when they are in Majority.

 

[Placemat]

Is water Indian?



What is Indian culture after independence, in the modern world?

There is no one Indian culture although the country is gradually becoming more homogenized . Culture wise, movies, cricket politics and an emerging consumerissm are one single platform which people are getting onto creatimg a sub culture. I think for india you will never be abke to get get one distinctive culture ever due to its diversity , democracy and left leaning nature.

 

[Chakar The Great]

This is nothing against the genocide f Hindus done by Muslims in India. They killed Thousands of Hindus, Killed infant children, Raped women and cleansed 5 lakh hindus from Kashmir. So quoting Isolated incident will not prove anything. We have less than 70 death in communal violence in India on an average in last few years. On Other hand, We know very well how Muslims are treated in Muslim Countries. They are literally genocide. India will take tens of thousands of years to match the figure of killing of Muslims in Muslim Country in a single year. So take your butt hurt somewhere else. We know very well how Muslim behaves with other community and also with other Muslims when they are in Majority.

I dont care if Muslims killed you. Thats not the point. You guys keep killing each other, that doesnt concern any one from outside.
But you dont lie about the beef killing, you owe an apology.

 

[Placemat]

I dont care if Muslims killed you. Thats not the point. You guys keep killing each other, that doesnt concern any one from outside.
But you dont lie about the beef killing, you owe an apology.

Vigilantism is a problem that has come about recently. But this is not likely to last ling. I am expecting this to be passing phase and not be termed as Indian culture.

 

[rambro]

Uncultured

Op missed out on hygiene, iindia makes the poorest country on earth look like paradise.

 

[Sheena1980]

 

[PakSarzameen5823]

What did we steal from Muslims of Pakistan?

Claiming the Muslim dynasties of India (such as the Kingdom of Mysore, the Mughals or the Delhi Sultanate) when most of you are Hindu and were literally despised by them.

Beyond that, you also feel heavily attached to the history of Pakistan based purely on this Akhand Bharat nonsense. I can understand some of you taking pride in some aspects Pakistan's pre-Islamic history since it involves a few of you too (e.g some Rajput clans come from the Huna people, so I can see why some of them view the Hunas in a positive light), but why the heck are people from Bangalore and Chennai taking pride in Mohenjo Daro or Harappa?

This is nothing against the genocide f Hindus done by Muslims in India.

I thought you guys think Pakistanis are converts? Are we converts or your oppressors? Honestly, you guys don't even think about what you say a lot of the time.

They killed Thousands of Hindus, Killed infant children, Raped women and cleansed 5 lakh hindus from Kashmir.

Can't have been that bad if we spared so many of you.

Those of us more knowledgeable about history know just how barbaric India was prior to Islam's arrival to the region. You're not fooling anyone.

And I'd like to see proof of infant children being targeted and women being raped, in large numbers.

We know very well how Muslims are treated in Muslim Countries. They are literally genocide.

You are literally not able to type English properly.

We know very well how Muslim behaves with other community and also with other Muslims when they are in Majority.

If you hate Muslims so much why are you on a Pakistani forum?

 

[Surya 1]

I dont care if Muslims killed you. Thats not the point. You guys keep killing each other, that doesnt concern any one from outside.
But you dont lie about the beef killing, you owe an apology.

Few incidents doesn't make establishes anything. You guys have the history of eliminating races and cultures from your nation. Keep your stupidity with you.

Can't have been that bad if we spared so many of you.

Those of us more knowledgeable about history know just how barbaric India was prior to Islam's arrival to the region. You're not fooling anyone.

And I'd like to see proof of infant children being targeted and women being raped, in large numbers.

Even today it is very much visible who are more barbaric. We saw that in Bangladesh, we saw that in syria, we saw that in Iraq and across the world in all Muslim dominated areas.

If you hate Muslims so much why are you on a Pakistani forum?

I don't hate Muslims but facts are facts which can not be denied.

 

[PakSarzameen5823]

You guys have the history of eliminating races and cultures from your nation.

Such as?

Even today it is very much visible who are more barbaric.

A few decades is nothing compared to thousands of years of varna, sati and other atrocities.

We saw that in Bangladesh, we saw that in syria, we saw that in Iraq

You act as if mass killings and civil conflict are a Muslim only thing. Have you forgotten about Operation Blue Star? The massacres in Kashmir or Hyderabad? Or the Gujarat riots? I can name even more examples if you want.

And have you forgotten about what triggered the conflict in Iraq to occur? It was the US-led invasion.

 

[Surya 1]

Have you forgotten about Operation Blue Star? The massacres in Kashmir or Hyderabad? Or the Gujarat riots? I can name even more examples if you want

You are a plain fool.

What was operation blue star?
Who cleanse Hindus from Kashmir?
Who burnt 62 piligrims alive in train innGujarat?
And all these put togather is not just a fraction I.e even 1 pc of people killed in Bangladesh. So look at what you are rather than pointing fingers at others.

 

[PakSarzameen5823]

You are a plain fool.

You're just upset that I showed the inherent logical inconsistency of your argument.

What was operation blue star?

Your job to find out, not mine to explain.

Who cleanse Hindus from Kashmir?

Oh please, we only waged wars of expansion across the region because throughout history, you've refused to be amicable with us. Muslims first came to India as peaceful traders, and what happened? Pirates starting kidnapping Muslims from ships, and Raja Dahir refused to do anything so the Khilafah chewed him and spat him out. The Ghaznavids establish themselves and what does Raja Jayapala do? He attacks their capital in Ghazni and then the Ghaznavids finish his crippled empire. Muhammad Ghauri tried to form a treaty with Raja Chauhan and what did he do? Reject it, and as a result he was decapitated after the final battle at Tarain.

And do you know what happened afterwards? Sindh became a beacon of Islam, with people like Abu Raja As Sindhi emerging from it and benefitting the Ummah greatly. Jayapala's descendants accepted Islam, and were incorporated into the Ghaznavid ruling elite. And the Chauhans, well, you've seen how many of them we have in Pakistan. Even after humiliating you, we've usually been courteous.

You're in no position to complain.

Who burnt 62 piligrims alive in train innGujarat?

62 is a much smaller number than those who died in all the incidents I listed.

So look at what you are rather than pointing fingers at others.

You should take your own advice.

 

[BringHarmony]

The caste system is alive and well in India, where human beings are treated worse than animals, where men, women and kids are made to clean sewers with their bare hands, for less than $1 a day. Where kids are begging in the streets for something to eat, 600 million people live on less than $1 a day.

Factually you are wrong. Its more like 100-200 million below 1.9 dollars PPP.

We hear about India's health care but to be honest only the rich get proper health care if they have private cover, I wouldn't be caught dead in an Indian public hospital filthy, and disgusting are the first thoughts that come to mind. And the doctors aren't even interested in helping the poor.

Actually, you are more likely to go broke in USA with a medical condition than in India. The prices we charge for pharma is fucking insane. Prices for pharma and tests in India is extremely low. I know someone who gets his whole supply of a specialized immuno-suppresant from India every 3 years or so. Even with the travel-cost Indian pharma is way way way cheaper than exactly same drug sold privately in Canada. Its not covered in government insurance. In India, that drug is sold cheap and even poor can afford it. I think cheap pharma is certainly defining charecter of India.

I am sure Indians will come on here and post about India's shiny new buildings and the metros etc, yes there are shiny new building, and metros and roads but that is just in small pockets around the country.

True of US for that matter. Costal areas are richers and heartland is poorer. Though India takes poverty to a whole new freakin level.

 

[Chhatrapati]

Claiming the Muslim dynasties of India (such as the Kingdom of Mysore, the Mughals or the Delhi Sultanate) when most of you are Hindu and were literally despised by them.

Beyond that, you also feel heavily attached to the history of Pakistan based purely on this Akhand Bharat nonsense. I can understand some of you taking pride in some aspects Pakistan's pre-Islamic history since it involves a few of you too (e.g some Rajput clans come from the Huna people, so I can see why some of them view the Hunas in a positive light), but why the heck are people from Bangalore and Chennai taking pride in Mohenjo Daro or Harappa?

Errr! We don't claim anyone as our own, like we don't need to claim anything that flourished on our land. Because we have Muslims in India, we don't claim Middle eastern culture (same goes for Christians and Jews). If Hindus really despised Muslims, there wouldn't be nearly 200 million of Muslims in India, given the number of Hindus in India is so large, that they overshadow the Entire Muslims in the Subcontinent.

Speaking of Akhand Bharat, Indians in general do not want Pakistan or Bangladesh. We really hate to increase our population, given you're not wealthy states, have a lot more problems, making it ours is not helping.

Hunas are not Pakistanis, they were central Asians, they invaded and were decisively defeated by the Guptas, the Kingdoms in the subcontinent had big hearts which followed the principles of war, i.e never execute defeated soldiers hence they largely integrated into the society. Maybe there are Huns who integrated are now Rajput clans. Neither of this has anything to do with Pakistan, culturally.

Speaking of Kannada or Tamils taking pride in Harappa or Mohenjodaro, both those people take pride in two things, one, their language and it's ancient history and two, being Indian.

Harappa and Mohenjodaros are really excavation sites that's found both in India and Pakistan. Neither of us follow their culture it's a dead civilization. We two hold their skeletons and claims this is us is a joke.