What If India officially request to join CPEC?

[wiseone2]

similarly no one can dictate Pakistan's attitude towards bhartis not US not even China, we can do anything to protect our interests against bhartis, if this mean saying no to China, we will not hesitate a second.

so again why would China suggest this shitty idea they simply not need us for trade with india as you pointed? how Pakistan is dependent on China? We are not taking aids... For weapons and loans?

anyways CPEC is not my priority, Two things were stoping Pakistan's rapid growth first was law and order and second was energy crisis, both are in control now, Wall street journal reported few days ago that loadshedding will end by nexy year.. I think Now no one can stop us from growing above 7%.. CPEC and controling corruption will be icing on cake.

bravado is fine. reality is different.

good chunk of your military hardware is funded partially by China - JF-17, AIP submarines etc.

Who is going to block India's NSG membership for you ?

i could give a long laundry list

I say we ask for settling Kashmir issue. It has been worked out already during Musharraf's time I guess.

you asked Uncle Sam to mediate. that did not work out. It is not clear why China would succeed where USSR and USA failed

 

[graphican]

What is East Pakistan. All your request rejected.


Looks like these guys forget one thing, India share long border with China. If am not wrong most of this billions $ are into energy projects in frm of loan. Recently Chinese company bought 40% shares in PSX. For now it is more like freight corridor. We all know Singapore port, it is top 2 port in the world.. yet their economy not crossed 1trillion $ . You guys jumping for miracle immediately. India economy falls in different league.. first prepare an proper Industrial policy.

What is East Pakistan? Have you been living under the rock?

Fine, India can grow within itself and sell things it makes itself. What would Pakistan lose by not having India on CPEC? Nothing.. its India who has to gain and India who will lose. Its your call.

 

[rustom]

India has nothing to gain from CPEC. Gilgit, Baltistan, Pak controlled kashmir is Indian territory and we only need to wait out for few years things will fall in place.

 

[Kaniska]

Guys if you want a creative discussion then troll posts should be avoided.

Before discussing this a SWOT analysis has to be made and then proper discussion can be done

 

[RealNapster]

how do u no this for certain?



india demands whole of kashmir

Na aap ka na hamara. bas half half pe baat done karo.

 

[Śakra]

A case of putting the cart before the horse. Please build CPEC first before you think about what will happen if India requests to join.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Correctly stated a horse has a better chance of joining CPEC then India

 

[Max]

bravado is fine. reality is different.

no, your thinking that Pakistan cant say "No" to China is clownish, rest all world is dependent on each other, just like you are dependent on Russians and US for arms and NSG backing does that mean you cant say no to these countries?, Pakistan is too dependent on US and Chinese arms.. Pakistan is opening new doors for arms which include Turkey, Italy, Russia, south Africa, Brazil etc

Who is going to block India's NSG membership for you ?

Its mutual interest.. Pakistan provide good cover to China for implementation of NSG rules ,

thats why we like China, never in our history our interests collided with each other..

 

[RIP Pak LAW]

Why we are bend on including India in CPEC ? Seems like more than the Indians, its Pakistan who wants Indian in. India should be our least priority when it comes CPEC.

 

[Moonlight]

lol first make CPEC and then ask the question.

you dont even know if it will be successful or a failure... and thats the problem with people ego on this forum... too big.

But the burn is faced by Indians since last couple of years.

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

Cpec will be completed in 2-3 years. India joining cpec will mean gilgit baltistan is no more disputed.

 

[Centurion2016]

By building cpec you Pakistanis have killed Kashmir dispute.

Building on a disputed land in baltistan you Pakistanis can no longer claim that status quo does not work.

As for cpec is will make no difference to.India who trades with the west far more than your poor central Asian states..a d China India trade is ten times pak China trade . So again no issues here.

 

[Valar Dohaeris]

Yes with two conditions: 1. Kahsmir 2. Water

 

[Flash_Ninja]

Close down the 6 or so "consulates" in Afghanistan.

We all know exactly what you use them for.

 

[Pandora]

This invitation is merely a courtesy call as no one is expecting india to accept such an offers. This invitation merely gives Pakistan a higher moral ground and portrays indians as jealous who dont wish regional successs. Neither Pakistan nor china want india to be part of this venture.