What's new

What do Iranians think about Pakistanis? (Quora Answer)

Big Tank

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Apr 30, 2013
Messages
3,333
Reaction score
5
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Amir Goharshady, lived in Mashhad, Iran
Answered Sep 16

As an Iranian from Mashhad, Pakistan was a land of mystery for me until I traveled to Lahore several years ago. I give you a brief description of what I knew and thought before, during and after that trip.

Before:

I knew that it is a neighbor of ours with a huge population, that most of its people struggle financially, and that its official language is Urdu. These, and nothing more, were taught to us in 5th grade geography. I knew absolutely nothing about the conflict with India. We were taught that both Pakistan and India are friendly countries and I still believe that (I don’t think Iran is in an alliance with India against Pakistan or vice versa).

Other than these, I read a lot of poetry from Allama Iqbal, who is called Eqbal-e Lahoori in Iran and is more famous than any other person or thing from Pakistan (and perhaps even more famous than Pakistan itself). I had also heard about Jinnah, given that an important expressway in Tehran is named after him.

During and After:

The Pakistani consulate in Mashhad acted very professionally and politely and issued my visa quite fast. I especially remember that they refused to take my payment before issuing the visa saying that “It is not halaal” if they take it and then my visa gets rejected for any reason. This was my first encounter with Pakistan and the guy at the consulate made the best possible first impression.

During my time in Lahore, I met very hospitable and friendly people and came to realize that Pakistanis and Iranians have many things in common. The culture was amazing, the food was awesome and everything seemed to be strangely foreign and Iranian at the same time. Lahore was full of surprises. I remember my surprise when I first heard the Pakistani national anthem (which I came to memorize after hearing only twice). Everything was reminiscent of home. The Urdu words that had many commonalities with Persian, the mosques, even the way people drove! I think Pakistan is one of the (if not the) most similar countries to Iran. It was a foreign country, but it felt as close to home as one can imagine.

I saw a different face of Pakistan. Our geography book was technically correct. Many people were indeed impoverished. The Western media were also correct. There are terrorist attacks and security risks from time to time in Pakistan. But what both of these sources fail to mention is the most important thing. Pakistan is much more than its problems. The Pakistan that I saw was a great nation, full of kind, respectable and hardworking people, who are actually happier than many in Europe. I also came to know about the theory behind Pakistan and the sacrifices made for its creation. It’s a great story and I think it should be taught in schools in Iran.

Overall, my current feeling about Pakistan is simply “Paak Sarzamin Shaad Baad!”
 
.
Amir Goharshady, lived in Mashhad, Iran
Answered Sep 16

As an Iranian from Mashhad, Pakistan was a land of mystery for me until I traveled to Lahore several years ago. I give you a brief description of what I knew and thought before, during and after that trip.

Before:

I knew that it is a neighbor of ours with a huge population, that most of its people struggle financially, and that its official language is Urdu. These, and nothing more, were taught to us in 5th grade geography. I knew absolutely nothing about the conflict with India. We were taught that both Pakistan and India are friendly countries and I still believe that (I don’t think Iran is in an alliance with India against Pakistan or vice versa).

Other than these, I read a lot of poetry from Allama Iqbal, who is called Eqbal-e Lahoori in Iran and is more famous than any other person or thing from Pakistan (and perhaps even more famous than Pakistan itself). I had also heard about Jinnah, given that an important expressway in Tehran is named after him.

During and After:

The Pakistani consulate in Mashhad acted very professionally and politely and issued my visa quite fast. I especially remember that they refused to take my payment before issuing the visa saying that “It is not halaal” if they take it and then my visa gets rejected for any reason. This was my first encounter with Pakistan and the guy at the consulate made the best possible first impression.

During my time in Lahore, I met very hospitable and friendly people and came to realize that Pakistanis and Iranians have many things in common. The culture was amazing, the food was awesome and everything seemed to be strangely foreign and Iranian at the same time. Lahore was full of surprises. I remember my surprise when I first heard the Pakistani national anthem (which I came to memorize after hearing only twice). Everything was reminiscent of home. The Urdu words that had many commonalities with Persian, the mosques, even the way people drove! I think Pakistan is one of the (if not the) most similar countries to Iran. It was a foreign country, but it felt as close to home as one can imagine.

I saw a different face of Pakistan. Our geography book was technically correct. Many people were indeed impoverished. The Western media were also correct. There are terrorist attacks and security risks from time to time in Pakistan. But what both of these sources fail to mention is the most important thing. Pakistan is much more than its problems. The Pakistan that I saw was a great nation, full of kind, respectable and hardworking people, who are actually happier than many in Europe. I also came to know about the theory behind Pakistan and the sacrifices made for its creation. It’s a great story and I think it should be taught in schools in Iran.

Overall, my current feeling about Pakistan is simply “Paak Sarzamin Shaad Baad!”
hahah exactly my own points.
Before i came into this forum, i thought India and Pakistan are neighbors, never knew about the wars between them, and more importantly, i didn't know that Kashmir is an oppressed piece of Islamic world in which people are being forced to stay within Indian territory. I thought Pakistan is a Muslim majority country, whom i can feel brotherhood with.

After joining this forum, damn!, i witnessed a world of hostility against Iran and Iranians, still i can see. People thought that we are massacring Sunnis of Syria, so called freedom fighters of ISIS and AL-Nusra, we are working with India in security/military levels to annoy/topple Pakistan by every means LOL, we are killing residents of western Pakistan in daily basis mortar shells (there was mortar shells but not against civilians and on desert areas against Haqqani network militants - Jeysh ul Adl terrorists mostly), we are apostate/Rafidi Shias, we are recruiting Pakistani Shias to fight our war against DEASH (The same Pak volunteers who are defending shrine of prophet's granddaughter and i believe that they will be a proud of pak people who once fought terrorism and saved their Sunni brothers in Syria and stopped displacing them) , we are displacing Syrians and transferring Shias into Syria in order to occupy Sunni-living areas (The most ridiculous one), we are trying to manipulate Shias of Pakistan and make insecurity inside Pakistan (while we cannot even save our own border guards from terror attacks, while we have weak relations with our neighboring country because of KSA's huge influence among Pak politicians and military men, however this one could completely get applied on KSA and it's madrassa kids that are blowing themselves among innocent Pak women and children) ... etc.

But i met kind guys whom were amongst them many from Lahore, don't know why do i feel good about this city, must visit one day!!!, also Most of the hostile guys were from Karachi, an other wonderful point that i conclude KSA has a major ideological influence there. Nice people from Islamabad too. Based on the location of these guys that i could see among their profile information.

After a long time, i learned that Pakistan has a great diversity within her society, and IMO why KSA couldn't operate an other Libyan/Syrian scenario in Pak, that's because of unity of Pakistani people against their common Indian enemy. It acts like a filter that Alhamdulillah keeps most of Pak people united and far away from civil war. Something that makes Saudis bothered and depressed, why USA cannot completely destroy this important member of Islamic world that based on the words of Iranian leader, her people has granted a plenty of sacrifices for sake of Ummah and shapes the most mo'min community of Islamic world whether be it's Sunnis or Shias.
@Awan68
 
.
hahah exactly my own points.
Before i came into this forum, i thought India and Pakistan are neighbors, never knew about the wars between them, and more importantly, i didn't know that Kashmir is an oppressed piece of Islamic world in which people are being forced to stay within Indian territory. I thought Pakistan is a Muslim majority country, whom i can feel brotherhood with.

After joining this forum, damn!, i witnessed a world of hostility against Iran and Iranians, still i can see. People thought that we are massacring Sunnis of Syria, so called freedom fighters of ISIS and AL-Nusra, we are working with India in security/military levels to annoy/topple Pakistan by every means LOL, we are killing residents of western Pakistan in daily basis mortar shells (there was mortar shells but not against civilians and on desert areas against Haqqani network militants - Jeysh ul Adl terrorists mostly), we are apostate/Rafidi Shias, we are recruiting Pakistani Shias to fight our war against DEASH (The same Pak volunteers who are defending shrine of prophet's granddaughter and i believe that they will be a proud of pak people who once fought terrorism and saved their Sunni brothers in Syria and stopped displacing them) , we are displacing Syrians and transferring Shias into Syria in order to occupy Sunni-living areas (The most ridiculous one), we are trying to manipulate Shias of Pakistan and make insecurity inside Pakistan (while we cannot even save our own border guards from terror attacks, while we have weak relations with our neighboring country because of KSA's huge influence among Pak politicians and military men, however this one could completely get applied on KSA and it's madrassa kids that are blowing themselves among innocent Pak women and children) ... etc.

But i met kind guys whom were amongst them many from Lahore, don't know why do i feel good about this city, must visit one day!!!, also Most of the hostile guys were from Karachi, an other wonderful point that i conclude KSA has a major ideological influence there. Nice people from Islamabad too. Based on the location of these guys that i could see among their profile information.

After a long time, i learned that Pakistan has a great diversity within her society, and IMO why KSA couldn't operate an other Libyan/Syrian scenario in Pak, that's because of unity of Pakistani people against their common Indian enemy. It acts like a filter that Alhamdulillah keeps most of Pak people united and far away from civil war. Something that makes Saudis bothered and depressed, why USA cannot completely destroy this important member of Islamic world that based on the words of Iranian leader, her people has granted a plenty of sacrifices for sake of Ummah and shapes the most mo'min community of Islamic world whether be it's Sunnis or Shias.
@Awan68

I'd like to correct you brother. Karachites aren't Anti Iranians. In fact Karachi has the biggest Shia majority. Sunnis here are also much favorable to the Iranians due to their struggle against the West. It just depends upon regardless of their hometown :)
 
.
hahah exactly my own points.
Before i came into this forum, i thought India and Pakistan are neighbors, never knew about the wars between them, and more importantly, i didn't know that Kashmir is an oppressed piece of Islamic world in which people are being forced to stay within Indian territory. I thought Pakistan is a Muslim majority country, whom i can feel brotherhood with.

After joining this forum, damn!, i witnessed a world of hostility against Iran and Iranians, still i can see. People thought that we are massacring Sunnis of Syria, so called freedom fighters of ISIS and AL-Nusra, we are working with India in security/military levels to annoy/topple Pakistan by every means LOL, we are killing residents of western Pakistan in daily basis mortar shells (there was mortar shells but not against civilians and on desert areas against Haqqani network militants - Jeysh ul Adl terrorists mostly), we are apostate/Rafidi Shias, we are recruiting Pakistani Shias to fight our war against DEASH (The same Pak volunteers who are defending shrine of prophet's granddaughter and i believe that they will be a proud of pak people who once fought terrorism and saved their Sunni brothers in Syria and stopped displacing them) , we are displacing Syrians and transferring Shias into Syria in order to occupy Sunni-living areas (The most ridiculous one), we are trying to manipulate Shias of Pakistan and make insecurity inside Pakistan (while we cannot even save our own border guards from terror attacks, while we have weak relations with our neighboring country because of KSA's huge influence among Pak politicians and military men, however this one could completely get applied on KSA and it's madrassa kids that are blowing themselves among innocent Pak women and children) ... etc.

But i met kind guys whom were amongst them many from Lahore, don't know why do i feel good about this city, must visit one day!!!, also Most of the hostile guys were from Karachi, an other wonderful point that i conclude KSA has a major ideological influence there. Nice people from Islamabad too. Based on the location of these guys that i could see among their profile information.

After a long time, i learned that Pakistan has a great diversity within her society, and IMO why KSA couldn't operate an other Libyan/Syrian scenario in Pak, that's because of unity of Pakistani people against their common Indian enemy. It acts like a filter that Alhamdulillah keeps most of Pak people united and far away from civil war. Something that makes Saudis bothered and depressed, why USA cannot completely destroy this important member of Islamic world that based on the words of Iranian leader, her people has granted a plenty of sacrifices for sake of Ummah and shapes the most mo'min community of Islamic world whether be it's Sunnis or Shias.
@Awan68
Come visit, Pakistan will become second home.Kudos
 
. .
Come visit, Pakistan will become second home.Kudos

@mohammad45 Why don't you visit Lahore. I am sure many of our members would happily host you. Although I live in Karachi but I'd surely come to Lahore on my motorbike to meet you. OR else you can visit Karachi :)
 
.
hahah exactly my own points.
Before i came into this forum, i thought India and Pakistan are neighbors, never knew about the wars between them, and more importantly, i didn't know that Kashmir is an oppressed piece of Islamic world in which people are being forced to stay within Indian territory. I thought Pakistan is a Muslim majority country, whom i can feel brotherhood with.

After joining this forum, damn!, i witnessed a world of hostility against Iran and Iranians, still i can see. People thought that we are massacring Sunnis of Syria, so called freedom fighters of ISIS and AL-Nusra, we are working with India in security/military levels to annoy/topple Pakistan by every means LOL, we are killing residents of western Pakistan in daily basis mortar shells (there was mortar shells but not against civilians and on desert areas against Haqqani network militants - Jeysh ul Adl terrorists mostly), we are apostate/Rafidi Shias, we are recruiting Pakistani Shias to fight our war against DEASH (The same Pak volunteers who are defending shrine of prophet's granddaughter and i believe that they will be a proud of pak people who once fought terrorism and saved their Sunni brothers in Syria and stopped displacing them) , we are displacing Syrians and transferring Shias into Syria in order to occupy Sunni-living areas (The most ridiculous one), we are trying to manipulate Shias of Pakistan and make insecurity inside Pakistan (while we cannot even save our own border guards from terror attacks, while we have weak relations with our neighboring country because of KSA's huge influence among Pak politicians and military men, however this one could completely get applied on KSA and it's madrassa kids that are blowing themselves among innocent Pak women and children) ... etc.

But i met kind guys whom were amongst them many from Lahore, don't know why do i feel good about this city, must visit one day!!!, also Most of the hostile guys were from Karachi, an other wonderful point that i conclude KSA has a major ideological influence there. Nice people from Islamabad too. Based on the location of these guys that i could see among their profile information.

After a long time, i learned that Pakistan has a great diversity within her society, and IMO why KSA couldn't operate an other Libyan/Syrian scenario in Pak, that's because of unity of Pakistani people against their common Indian enemy. It acts like a filter that Alhamdulillah keeps most of Pak people united and far away from civil war. Something that makes Saudis bothered and depressed, why USA cannot completely destroy this important member of Islamic world that based on the words of Iranian leader, her people has granted a plenty of sacrifices for sake of Ummah and shapes the most mo'min community of Islamic world whether be it's Sunnis or Shias.
@Awan68
Livin in Karachi, originally ur imediate neighbour from Balochistan....

so come gimme a hug u goof
mrw-i-try-to-interact-with-cats-21503.gif
 
.
2 of my best friend are iranian, howvever they don't like Khamna E.. it was very surprsing when they first told me.. they cooked their food for me, gave me some delicious 'sohan'... still I am in touch with them and surely visit Iran to meet them...
 
.
hahah exactly my own points.
Before i came into this forum, i thought India and Pakistan are neighbors, never knew about the wars between them, and more importantly, i didn't know that Kashmir is an oppressed piece of Islamic world in which people are being forced to stay within Indian territory. I thought Pakistan is a Muslim majority country, whom i can feel brotherhood with.

After joining this forum, damn!, i witnessed a world of hostility against Iran and Iranians, still i can see. People thought that we are massacring Sunnis of Syria, so called freedom fighters of ISIS and AL-Nusra, we are working with India in security/military levels to annoy/topple Pakistan by every means LOL, we are killing residents of western Pakistan in daily basis mortar shells (there was mortar shells but not against civilians and on desert areas against Haqqani network militants - Jeysh ul Adl terrorists mostly), we are apostate/Rafidi Shias, we are recruiting Pakistani Shias to fight our war against DEASH (The same Pak volunteers who are defending shrine of prophet's granddaughter and i believe that they will be a proud of pak people who once fought terrorism and saved their Sunni brothers in Syria and stopped displacing them) , we are displacing Syrians and transferring Shias into Syria in order to occupy Sunni-living areas (The most ridiculous one), we are trying to manipulate Shias of Pakistan and make insecurity inside Pakistan (while we cannot even save our own border guards from terror attacks, while we have weak relations with our neighboring country because of KSA's huge influence among Pak politicians and military men, however this one could completely get applied on KSA and it's madrassa kids that are blowing themselves among innocent Pak women and children) ... etc.

But i met kind guys whom were amongst them many from Lahore, don't know why do i feel good about this city, must visit one day!!!, also Most of the hostile guys were from Karachi, an other wonderful point that i conclude KSA has a major ideological influence there. Nice people from Islamabad too. Based on the location of these guys that i could see among their profile information.

After a long time, i learned that Pakistan has a great diversity within her society, and IMO why KSA couldn't operate an other Libyan/Syrian scenario in Pak, that's because of unity of Pakistani people against their common Indian enemy. It acts like a filter that Alhamdulillah keeps most of Pak people united and far away from civil war. Something that makes Saudis bothered and depressed, why USA cannot completely destroy this important member of Islamic world that based on the words of Iranian leader, her people has granted a plenty of sacrifices for sake of Ummah and shapes the most mo'min community of Islamic world whether be it's Sunnis or Shias.
@Awan68

I'm also originally from Karachi and regularly used to get called Safavid for defending Iran. I am not a Shia either. I am as Pro Iranian as I am Pro KSA. Both nations are our friends and equal to me.

But I have special love for Iran because my dad's friend is an Iranian who had shops in Karachi and we used to go to his shop regularly. Those who spread discord amongst Pakistan, Iran and KSA are enemies of all of us, no matter what leadership role they hold.
 
.
I'd like to correct you brother. Karachites aren't Anti Iranians. In fact Karachi has the biggest Shia majority. Sunnis here are also much favorable to the Iranians due to their struggle against the West. It just depends upon regardless of their hometown :)
Thank you all bros. @DESERT FIGHTER @django @Goenitz @Mini Tank
I am sure that average citizens , regardless of their religion, would be kind. Just like average Iranians who are busy with their life and mostly are not aware of Internet fights :lol:

I should visit pak one day, it's inevitable for me. This forum with all it's good and bad points has made a big curiosity for me.

“Paak Sarzamin Shaad Baad!” :enjoy:
 
. . .
hahah exactly my own points.
Before i came into this forum, i thought India and Pakistan are neighbors, never knew about the wars between them, and more importantly, i didn't know that Kashmir is an oppressed piece of Islamic world in which people are being forced to stay within Indian territory. I thought Pakistan is a Muslim majority country, whom i can feel brotherhood with.

After joining this forum, damn!, i witnessed a world of hostility against Iran and Iranians, still i can see. People thought that we are massacring Sunnis of Syria, so called freedom fighters of ISIS and AL-Nusra, we are working with India in security/military levels to annoy/topple Pakistan by every means LOL, we are killing residents of western Pakistan in daily basis mortar shells (there was mortar shells but not against civilians and on desert areas against Haqqani network militants - Jeysh ul Adl terrorists mostly), we are apostate/Rafidi Shias, we are recruiting Pakistani Shias to fight our war against DEASH (The same Pak volunteers who are defending shrine of prophet's granddaughter and i believe that they will be a proud of pak people who once fought terrorism and saved their Sunni brothers in Syria and stopped displacing them) , we are displacing Syrians and transferring Shias into Syria in order to occupy Sunni-living areas (The most ridiculous one), we are trying to manipulate Shias of Pakistan and make insecurity inside Pakistan (while we cannot even save our own border guards from terror attacks, while we have weak relations with our neighboring country because of KSA's huge influence among Pak politicians and military men, however this one could completely get applied on KSA and it's madrassa kids that are blowing themselves among innocent Pak women and children) ... etc.

But i met kind guys whom were amongst them many from Lahore, don't know why do i feel good about this city, must visit one day!!!, also Most of the hostile guys were from Karachi, an other wonderful point that i conclude KSA has a major ideological influence there. Nice people from Islamabad too. Based on the location of these guys that i could see among their profile information.

After a long time, i learned that Pakistan has a great diversity within her society, and IMO why KSA couldn't operate an other Libyan/Syrian scenario in Pak, that's because of unity of Pakistani people against their common Indian enemy. It acts like a filter that Alhamdulillah keeps most of Pak people united and far away from civil war. Something that makes Saudis bothered and depressed, why USA cannot completely destroy this important member of Islamic world that based on the words of Iranian leader, her people has granted a plenty of sacrifices for sake of Ummah and shapes the most mo'min community of Islamic world whether be it's Sunnis or Shias.
@Awan68

Let me tell you some facts about Pakistan and Iran that many people on both countries don't know.

1. Iran was the first country to accept Independent Pakistan
2. During the wars with India in 1965 and 1971. Iran provided free fuel and allowed Pakistani Jets to land on Iranian airfields.
3. Till before the revolution in Iran, Pakistan and Iran had visa free travel. (My dad told me that Indian movies were banned in Pakistan, so they used to travel to Iran to watch Indian movies of Dilip Kumar whos real name was Yousaf Khan)
4. Pakistanis have the highest approval rating for Iran than anyother country.
5. Urdu, the national language is heavily influenced by Farsi.
6. After the revolution in Iran as many as 100K iranians came over to Pakistan, many of whom then moved to other Western countries. But alot of them stayed in Pakistan and opened Irani restaurants.

Hope this helps
 
.
Back
Top Bottom