What comes first?Nation or religion?

[SHHHHH]

Religion forms basis of what you call a Nation. 2 Nation Theory wasn't based on territory, rather it was religion that made India split.

Why you say Kashmir will be part of Pakistan? Any other reasons other than religion?

India is a secular nation,the people of the same religion as of those in Kashmir are
living peacefully in Lucknow,Bhopal and even Delhi.
So what you posted was not appropriate.

 

[foxbat]

Religion forms basis of what you call a Nation. 2 Nation Theory wasn't based on territory, rather it was religion that made India split.

Why you say Kashmir will be part of Pakistan? Any other reasons other than religion?

Then how come we have almost the same number of Muslims in India as there are in Pakistan

 

[greatsequence]

What is your definition of nation. For me Islam is an idealogy and it is more dear to me than a line on the map.

 

[linkinpark]

Nation for me , religion cannot gather people on one platform

You are questioning the formation of Pakistan whose very basis is religion.

 

[GentlemanObserver]

OH GREAT the actual purpose of this thread emerges in post 16... Another India vs Pakistan... My willy is bigger thread.

/sigh...

 

[Materialistic]

Ya that's why we are vary of religion ..by the way your two nation theory bundled in 1971.

Well it din't go wrong at all, your claim would have been valid if Bangali people would have gone back into India, but what they were seeking was another state for Muslims.

And you can see our two nation theory proved even on this forum, Here always and all the Bangladeshi people support Pakistan against India!!

And you can see the difference between relations of Pakistan and India both people to people and government, and relations of Pakistan and Bangladesh.

Even for independence they fought against Pakistan and sought Pakistan's rivals help but still people don't have hatred, friction or any kind of racism against each other.

 

[Areesh]

Ya that's why we are vary of religion ..by the way your two nation theory bundled in 1971.

PS: for me its nation all the way.

Political establishment of Pakistan really bundled in 1971. No doubt about it. Two nation theory proved it self again when east Pakistan and West Bengal didn't merge into single entity even having the same culture and nation.

It also proved many times after also but I think above example is enough.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

What if their are two people one from your religion and one from another religion, but none of them from your country, whome will you help first??

In both the cases(yours and mine) no one selects based on religion or nation, an average person would go and help the one who is more needy!!

Yes I would help the one that needs it the most.

I wouldn't prioritise someone due to citizenship, race, religion, or anything like that.

If someone needs help I will look at them as an individual.

 

[mohan goyal]

my priority is humanity, nation and religion.

 

[Skies]

R8 n0w...Kashmir

 

[nightcrawler]

For me RELIGION

When religion says people 1st then what 2nd norm is there for the betterment of your NATION

 

[Areesh]

For me religion. Pakistan's foundation was also on religion, so religion is my first priority.

And sincerity and patriotism to my nation and country is part of my religion.

 

[graphican]

India is a secular nation,the people of the same religion as of those in Kashmir are
living peacefully in Lucknow,Bhopal and even Delhi.
So what you posted was not appropriate.

How are you cretin you can make a point on that when you couldn't convince that to Kashmiris? No wonder Kashmiris chant Pakistan se Rishta Kya, La Ilaha Illala.

Also, BJP workers Chant, Hindustan me rehna hai to wand-e-matram kehna hoga. For BJP and the mindset, its relegion that comes first.

 

[Neither Right Nor Wrong]

Political establishment of Pakistan really bundled in 1971. No doubt about it. Two nation theory proved it self again when east Pakistan and West Bengal didn't merge into single entity even having the same culture and nation.

It also proved many times after also but I think above example is enough.

Well they were not suppose too merge ..but then again two nation theory fails each and every day..because Hindu and Muslim populations of India, Bangladesh and even Pakistan continue to live together in relative harmony.

 

[graphican]

Then how come we have almost the same number of Muslims in India as there are in Pakistan

That still supports ideology of Muslim State VS Relegious Less (Theoratically) state. Kashmiris want to unite with Muslim State of Pakistan, even though they could stay with India that has almost the similar number of Muslims.

Facts are facts, learn from them. Kashmir is the Living Example before you.