What's new

We trust China on dam: Manmohan Singh

Correct. The only loser in this scenario will be BD. If China cut water to India, we will cut water to BD.

ok here is the arguement we cut off your water and in retaliation you cut off water to bangadesh, what if we nuke you ,you nuke bangdesh too? poor BD with friendly neighbour like India who need enermy.
 
.
more then india,bangladesh can have huge affect from this dam :)

north-east is one of the wettest place in the world,huge rainfalls will do for agriculture on other hand bangladesh needs electricity
 
.
ok here is the arguement we cut off your water and in retaliation you cut off water to bangadesh, what if we nuke you ,you nuke bangdesh too? poor BD with friendly neighbour like India who need enermy.

Brahmaputra flows downstream from India to Bangladesh.

brahmapmap.gif


India doesn't have to do anything.

And if India is nuked by China , the Global economy will experience a sudden purge. :)
 
.
I understand Indian members falling back on traditional stereotype opinions about China. But you have to realize the situation has changed drastically.

Beijing backs big role for India in Asia club
NEW DELHI: In a diplomatic triumph for India, Beijing recently wrote to New Delhi saying that it would like India to play a bigger role in SCO (Shanghai Cooperation Organisation), the six-nation body which holds the key to not just resource-rich central Asia but also the security situation in Afghanistan as the US drawdown starts to take effect.
The government is looking upon this development as China’s support at least “in essence and in principle” for India’s bid to become a full member of the body, which is dominated by China and Russia, and play a more important role in the region. Russia has in the past declared support for India’s attempts to become full member but China’s position has not been clear with Beijing even stating that SCO should not rush into expansion and insisted on developing a consensus for including more members.
“This means that in principle and fundamentally, India now has support from all six SCO members for full membership of the organization,” said an official source, adding that it marked a further thaw in India-China relations after the wo sides last month resumed defence exchanges. Apart from Russia and China, the four other full members of SCO are central Asian countries Tajikistan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan.
India — along with Pakistan, Iran and Mongolia — has observer status in the organization. India and Pakistan have both applied to become full members of SCO which is also seen as an emerging counterweight to NATO in the region. Pakistan, which already claims support from China, recently seemed to have raced past India in the membership bid when even Russia expressed support for its candidature. However, emboldened by this latest assurance from Beijing, Indian officials don’t see China thwarting any healthy engagement between India and central Asia.
They believe there is a new and more evolved thinking in the Chinese establishment which is looking for fresh partnerships in the region, including Afghanistan which applied recently for observer status in SCO. Indian officials also believe that SCO is going to be one of the most crucial forums to discuss the security situation post-2014 in Afghanistan and also for putting more pressure on Pakistan to check its terror-spewing jihadi groups. China has successfully managed to reduce the trust deficit with central Asian countries and, unlike India, has managed to build a robust bilateral, economic engagement with these countries.
India is an economic power house and a military power. China has no other choice but back India. Any major entity in Asia that doesn't include India would be ineffective, be it in the spheres of trade, security or economics

It is like: can anybody ignore an elephant in a room?
 
.
Why not your neighbour ?? Is it because countries like Vietnam, SK, Taiwan don't fall into that power and money category?Shame on you.

No issues with SK and Taiwan, we have good degree of cooperation. However, SK and Taiwan doesn't get along very well. Vietnam? They are your best buddies now. They are even seeking Indian's Naval expertise. I think they will be well looked after by India and we are fine with it. India either doesn't love, when they do it will be like "Hindi-Chini Bhai Bhai" all lovely dovely. I am actually happy India trusts us with this project, hopefully we will see more "Hindi-Chini Bhai Bhai" in the coming future.

Good for China. What's the point ? We don't want any conflict with China but It's China aggressiveness which bothers us and we are preparing for that only. you made all this happening.

Wrong, we are only interested in peace. We are not here to attack India. It's not 50 years ago anymore, times have passed and things have moved on. Have you any idea how many people will get hurt and to what extent it will have on our economies if we fight again?

Taiwan ?? Do you know what a common person in Taiwan thinks about China

Surprised eh? actually Taiwanese and Chinese have no problems with eachother. Even their government is pro China. The problems lies with the ruling party and of course America being the third party.

SK ?? you are using NK as proxy against SK. You can only count NK, Pakistan even BD and SL.

It is not for you to say, you can only wish. SK actually have fewer problems with China than Japan has. The only concern is NK and its nuke. SK have already signed agreements to further strengthen our military to military cooperation and China is already in talks with NK about Nuke. Pakistan, BD and SL we don't have to explain.

Russia may be good relation but we have very good relation, Even Russia is Selling Best military equipment which will be used against China.

You don't need to get so upset and defensive. They sell you weapons and we are ok with it and the reason being? because there won't be any wars, everyone knows any war between the two will result in a nuclear war. What are the planes going to do? Sino-Russo relationship is strong my friend, they understand us well due to our ideology. We are also strong business and political partners.

Why Japanese Hate Chinese and vice-verse ??

Pretty self explanatory.

China has more problem with it's neighbour than India. So, Stop talking Illogical conclusion with India.

Lets be fair, we all do to a degree, but we won't go so low as to say if they dam us it will only hurt so and so...hahahahehehe where are they now?
 
.
ok here is the arguement we cut off your water and in retaliation you cut off water to bangadesh, what if we nuke you ,you nuke bangdesh too? poor BD with friendly neighbour like India who need enermy.

Both China AND BD:cheers:
 
.
ok here is the arguement we cut off your water and in retaliation you cut off water to bangadesh, what if we nuke you ,you nuke bangdesh too? poor BD with friendly neighbour like India who need enermy.

Incorrect.

If you stop Water, We won't have water for BD. We can and we will make various changes to fulfil our need. I am also not counting our water which flows to whole Pakistan.

If you will Nuke India, we will reply back very hard in same way in no time. We have 2nd Strike capability which is from under sea. 5,000KM is already covered. What we will lose, China will also lose same. We won't nuke BD. Common a kid also won't say that. We have "No First Nuke" Policy, if you know it. We will reply to those who uses against us. :agree:

Our Nuke is for those who have Nuke. For Bangladesh, Even BSF or 1 Naval base in Bay of Bengal is more than enough. :cheers:
 
.
Biggest problem with this dam would be water control. During Monsoon season whole NE region is flooded. Now if China decides to release water, this can create more flooding. Otherwise I doubt anyone is truly concerned about actually losing water.
 
.
India should blow up the dam, and its causing unrest in Asia and starting a arms race.

Building a dam that could prevent water to India and Bangladesh, India will try to save as much of the water that goes to Pakistan because of China threat.
 
.
To be very frank, I personally want India-China to become very good friend. Both country have enormous capability to do very well. I don't see any 3rd country like us. Don't know why there is conflict ?? It's 50 years old. Not a single shot fired on Border in last 50 years. We should resolve all issues mutually. Good for both economy. I have few Chinese friends and they are my very good mate. I don't have any problem with China. I can understand, we are on PDF, so things won't be so cozzy here. But, India-China should become good friend and actually we can if few small cold war political like scenario will be resolved.
 
.
India should blow up the dam, and its causing unrest in Asia and starting a arms race.

Building a dam that could prevent water to India and Bangladesh, India will try to save as much of the water that goes to Pakistan because of China threat.

No dude, We should make good relation with China. It's high time. Both country should take certain step. India is strong now and we can do many things, But what's advantage ?? Poor Indian and Chinese will die and American will play casino in Las Vegas. First, Chinese need to stop aggressiveness towards India. Things are not good as of now but I really hope it will improve. I seriously Hope.
 
.
No dude, We should make good relation with China. It's high time. Both country should take certain step. India is strong now and we can do many things, But what's advantage ?? Poor Indian and Chinese will die and American will play casino in Las Vegas. First, Chinese need to stop aggressiveness towards India. Things are not good as of now but I really hope it will improve. I seriously Hope.

The most sensible post from you
 
. .
i m all for good relation with india, i havent met a bad indian in real life yet ( keep my fingers cross)
 
.
India should blow up the dam, and its causing unrest in Asia and starting a arms race.

Building a dam that could prevent water to India and Bangladesh, India will try to save as much of the water that goes to Pakistan because of China threat.

This is called idiotism, do you know how much rain fall is recorded in the Bramaputra river belt, the monsoon causes almost destruction of all villages in the U bend that it takes to enter India. The dam is not to stop the water but to generate power and the water can not be stoped, if stoped the dam will fail by flooding.
China knows its a good opertunity to tap the kinetic energy of the water for a better cause. if possible we should be invited to a joint venture on that dam so that we to share the power thats generated.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom