What's new

‘We are all Muslims’ By Gen (r) Mirza Aslam Beg

You've been here not even for a month, you have 55 posts and have a long long way to go to prove your credentials. You claim you're an economist, then it should be easy for you to compare both russia and india, economy-wise and military-wise. Go compare and come back with hardcore facts. And just as a starting reference point, compare the gold reserves each country holds, then oil production, gold production, arms production and exports...............


My dear, I can tell you what will happen to Gold prices to the accuracy of some of the best analysts in the world, I am a Gold trader & you are asking comparison.

If you search my real name in google you will know my credentials. I am not interested to beat the drum, who I am to get mileage. What's the purpose of your request. What are you trying to imply. Explain why & I will make it easy for you.
 
Last edited:
Uncle ji. Because you ridiculed Russia and Putin in your post and portrayed India to be stronger than Russia.

Moreover, let's hear your take on GOLD. What's your Gold Outlook in the short, medium and long term? Let's see whether you're really an economist or just another wanna-be fako rat on PDF.
 
Uncle ji. Because you ridiculed Russia and Putin in your post and portrayed India to be stronger than Russia.

Good, that's easier. Putin is very emotional leader. He does try to dominate people with his comments & acts. That doesn't make a country strong.

Russian economy is dependent on oil, natural gas & defence exports. Their major revenue comes from these products. I gave explanation of what's oil prices in my previous post if you read properly. It's around 45 $ now as we speak. Oil producing countries don't make anything if oil trades below 50$. And if it comes below 40, all oil producing countries will have major hit on its economy. Venezuela is one country mostly depending on oil income. It's in the verge of collapse, which I already mentioned.

India was a major contributor to Russian economy due to its billions of dollars worth arms purchase. Till 2012 their arms exports has year on year made increments. From 2013 their total Arms exports value has started to go negative. One of the major reasons is India. Last year in-spite of our decreased reliance on Russia we still bought near 7 billion $ worth of arms. Even after diverting our funds to other markets still our 10% arms purchase will not even match what Pakistan can purchase. So still they wont risk offering too much to Pakistan, since that also Russia will lose.

You need money to feed the economy, which is being choked today for Russia. If their arms industry exports come down, their arms manufacturers are in big threat. That's reason Russia is running helter skelter finding customers. They are even compromising their security concerns & selling arms to China, since they have the money.

They didn't have money to risk in Brahmos, so gave that technology to India to enhance it, since India is more trustworthy & reliable than China. Same goes with Su 30 fighters. But they have been dictating for the PAK FA & 5th Gen fighters. They even keep our engineers outside in many key areas, that's very insulting for Indians, since the amt we are investing is billions & they are benefiting both ways, one is free development & procurement at cheaper prices, since our cost of production is much much cheaper.

So economy is not about how much weapons or reserves you have. You also need money to sustain a war. At today's position, Russia can't afford a big full scale war, which can go more than 5-6 months. They will be doomed.

When Putin makes statement, we will sell latest technology to Pakistan is just to taunt India, since we have agreement that they will not sell same thing which they sold to us. So it's blackmailing, because India is shifting its major of its defense budget to Israel, France, America & others & they are treating us with great respect.
 
Last edited:
Good, that's easier. Putin is very emotional leader. He does try to dominate people with his comments & acts. That doesn't make a country strong.

Russian economy is dependent on oil, natural gas & defence exports. Their major revenue comes from these products. I gave explanation of what's oil prices in my previous post if you read properly. It's around 45 $ now as we speak. Oil producing countries don't make anything if oil trades below 50$. And if it comes below 40, all oil producing countries will have major hit on its economy. Venezuela is one country mostly depending on oil income. It's in the verge of collapse, which I already mentioned.

India was a major contributor to Russian economy due to its billions of dollars worth arms purchase. Till 2012 their arms exports has year on year made increments. From 2013 their total Arms exports value has started to go negative. One of the major reasons is India. Last year in-spite of our decreased reliance on Russia we still bought near 7 billion $ worth of arms. Even after diverting our funds to other markets still our 10% arms purchase will not even match what Pakistan can purchase. So still they wont risk offering too much to Pakistan, since that also Russia will lose.

You need money to feed the economy, which is being choked today for Russia. If their arms industry exports come down, their arms manufacturers are in big threat. That's reason Russia is running helter skelter finding customers. They are even compromising their security concerns & selling arms to China, since they have the money.

They didn't have money to risk in Brahmos, so gave that technology to India to enhance it, since India is more trustworthy & reliable than China. Same goes with Su 30 fighters. But they have been dictating for the PAK FA & 5th Gen fighters. They even keep our engineers outside in many key areas, that's very insulting for Indians, since the amt we are investing is billions & they are benefiting both ways, one is free development & procurement at cheaper prices, since our cost of production is much much cheaper.

So economy is not about how much weapons or reserves you have. You also need money to sustain a war. At today's position, Russia can't afford a big full scale war, which can go more than 5-6 months. They will be doomed.
What sort of an economist are you. You're using generalised statements and not quoting any economic indicators / facts. Your'e a farse. A Fako.

LET ME MAKE IT SIMPLE FOR YOU:

COMPARE RUSSIAN ECONOMY WITH INDIAN ECONOMY.

= = = =

Can't compare? Here's an eye-opener for you. Read it and spend a few sleepless nights.

http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/India/Russia/Economy
 
One can make an argument Muslim are an oppressed people, but the Russians? Who is exactly oppressing them? The US? If so, how?
It has already been answered in the article so you better read the article again.
 
What sort of an economist are you. You're using generalised statements and not quoting any economic indicators / facts. Your'e a farse. A Fako.

LET ME MAKE IT SIMPLE FOR YOU:

COMPARE RUSSIAN ECONOMY WITH INDIAN ECONOMY.

= = = =

Can't compare? Here's an eye-opener for you. Read it and spend a few sleepless nights.

http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/India/Russia/Economy

You have forgotten there is sanctions on it's Crimea, Ukraine ventures. It may be hard for someone to explain, when someone doesn't understand basics.





Have you seen the Russian financial market & Ruble crash after the Crimea adventure. It used to be 1:2 with Indian Rupee. Today the values are almost same. Manufacturing is majorly hit since lay offs & unemployment is increasing
 
Last edited:
You have forgotten there is sanctions on it's Crimea, Ukraine ventures. It may be hard for someone to explain, when someone doesn't understand basics.





Have you seen the Russian financial market & Ruble crash after the Crimea adventure. It used to be 1:2 with Indian Rupee. Today the values are almost same. Manufacturing is majorly hit since lay offs & unemployment is increasing
Assume that I am a Chartered Accountant with an MPhil in Economics and then, humour me. But stick to facts and figures.
 

Apart from the hit in oil & Arms industry. Russia is not getting any FDI into its countries.

 
And here, use facts and figures from this neutral link http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/India/Russia/Economy


You're not an economist. You're a FAKO. buzz off looser.

Ha Ha Ha, Your posts show, who's dumb here. If you really understood world economics, you will know Russia is in a economic crunch. If you don't know that, it proves you know nothing, since that's basics. I have tried to explain in simple words what's economics. You come with some crap link. You don't need such figures to explain a layman. I very well understand these figures. Most people wont understand these figures & how it works.

Somebody who actually understands economics will know you are a fool.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_economy

If facts & figures is what you need, kindly go through the above link. Let me get back from work & will help you with more facts if you need.

Current world economic league table of largest economies in the world by GDP and share of global economic growth

Kindly Read this section mentioned above in the link to make a fool of yourself -
 
Last edited:
One can make an argument Muslim are an oppressed people, but the Russians? Who is exactly oppressing them? The US? If so, how?

read, follow current affairs, or ask learned people around you
 
Well, with the chaos around middle east, the isolated Putin is definitely trying to find new support & most important finance. All his desperate ploys to bring down America's superpower status & its influence has failed. BRICS was putin's brainchild, but America has put it in the back burner by creating some internal chaos in Brazil, hammering oil prices down to keep Russia's economy under wraps, stirring tension in South China Sea to deviate China & pulling India aboard as its ally.

Lower oil prices will hurt many countries badly like Saudi, Iran, UAE, Iraq, Qatar, Nigeria, etc. The oil prices need to go above 60 $ & stay there for a long time for Russia to come out & play. If it's below 50 it will have no proper blood supply. Hammering it below 40 will choke Russia & most oil dependent country. Venezuela is one example.

So Russia is no more a power. In-fact Modi is given more importance in any world leaders meet, which infuriates Putin. He keeps sulking seeing every leader gather aroound Modi & not many people bothered to talk to him. The reason is, Russia has nothing to offer, except its weapons, which America, France, Germany, Israel & many other players have better variety & quality. Gone are those days when people bow down to Russia & America. America knows how to play the game, it tilts its power & influence to the countries which suits their interests. So even the tilt to India is America's need more than India. Putin's engagements with countries are more a dictating & bossy nature. The day the Russians start having countries behind it, it can regain back its power. Putin's actions are more emotional than a well planned one.


Russia may try to get influence from Saudi, Iran, Turkey & may be UAE, Qatar. These countries have money. Pakistan has nothing to offer to Russia. So it will be among the last consideration. They only give some statements to irk India, when we don't give importance to them like before. America is giving technology & advanced weaponry without making us to beg. Though we have been & are loyal to Russia, the hardships they give when we need their help is at times annoying. Putin never acknowledged we are sustaining their economy with our billions of dollars pumped in every year. They cannot boss or show superiority in friendship, just because they have high technology. Russia never gave the due regard & appreciation we needed for giving our billions of dollars for decades.

Modi's master move to look west was for quite a few reasons.

Russia wont come to our help if China attacks us.& China has be making incursions to its will & Russia doesn't utter a word. The increasing bullying & threat of China has gone to an extent of safeguarding our pride. It was high time somebody taught China a lesson.

Russia has been blackmailing not to go to America or west even threatening it will supply arms to Pakistan. Thank fully Modi took some risky steps & didn't buckle down like most previous leaders.

In-spite of having good reserves & having the power of fishing with carrots, we sat with our billions of dollars just keeping Russia happy. As Modi announced, we are looking for other markets, there is mad rush & push to catch the bait. This has changed the very influence & Image of India. Modi has smartly maneuvered the real power we possess & used politics to become a regional power. Modi has clearly sent a statement to Putin, Money talks & Bullshit walks.


If this above speech would have been given by an Indian, there would have been protest, riots & terrorists going insane over India.

Anyway we still have high regards for Russia & will remain it's friend. Russia slowly displaying desperation looking for friends & money.
lol outdated analysis......this is the latest situation.

Shift in Russia-Turkey-USA relationship within an year.
G20 conference.



‘We are all Muslims’
September 05, 2016/ 1 Comment
Gen (r) Mirza Aslam Beg


The Russian President while talking to our President at Tashkent recently, said “we are all Muslims” meaning thereby that, we all have a common “tormentor” who, during the last three decades, has destroyed more than half a dozen Muslim countries, killing over two million of them. Now it has turned towards Russia to destroy its economy, by imposing unwarranted sanctions’ and blocking the oil supply life-lines. Thus the Muslims and the Russians are the oppressed people, with a common cause, to stand together, to fight the evil of global barbarity.

Thus a new conflict spectrum is now developing, determining the contours of the global geo-strategic order. It is similar to the Cold War order of the past, but is different in its dimensions as it pulls and gravitate towards it almost all the geo-economic centers of power of the world, masked by US Pivot to Asia Strategy. Thus the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) has been forged to counter Chinese rising economic and military power, which challenges US hegemony in the Indo-Pacific region. The non-aligned India has signed the Logistic Exchange Memorandum of Agreement (LEMOA) with Washington on 29 August 2016, which provides facilities to the armed forces of the two countries to operate from either country military bases. India never allowed foreign powers to operate from its military bases, yet it now accepts a complete shift from non-alignment. India now is one of the biggest buyers of advanced weaponry and USA is equally a big vendor. It is a marriage of convenience, with USA expected to sell military hardware worth over 150 billion dollars in the near future. India is dreaming to become a super-power of the world with more than 600 million Indians living below the poverty line.

The Americans lost their longest war in Afghanistan despite the support from NATO and the allies with combat troops, armed with most modern weapon technology. They do no accept defeat as the Soviets did in 1989. They lack the grace to accept the reality and are engaged in conspiracies and deceit to prevent the establishment of the Islamic State in Afghanistan, under the Taliban. Now they have formed US-India-Afghanistan Partnership (UIAP) to stabilise Ashraf Ghani’s government tottering on its feet. They are destined to lose, because they have failed to understand the Afghans, who are fighting their war of liberation for the last thirty five years, defending their ideology, their values and traditions. The Americans and the allies have challenged their ideology, ignoring the logic of the Chinese saying, “Do not take-on the revolutionaries, unless you have an ideology, stronger than theirs.” And there is no ideology, stronger than the ideology of Islam, embraced by the Afghans.

The specter of US-India-Afghanistan Partnership (UIAP) thus has prompted the Russians, the Chinese and the Pakistanis, to form a regional alliance, also to be joined by Iran, now disenchanted with the Americans, after the nuclear deal. Iran has already allowed the Russians to use their Hamadan Airbase against the Syrian rebels. Afghan Taliban have developed good relations with Russia, China and Iran and have not drifted away from Pakistan either, despite Pakistan joining against them as a coalition partner of USA, in war against Afghanistan. Mullah Omar reminded Pakistan in very clear terms “you have joined our enemy in their war on us, yet we regard you as friends, because our national interests and destiny are linked.” His words provide the logic to Pakistan to join the regional alliance of Russia, China, Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan (RCPIA) to counter the machinations of LEMOA and UIAP and restore balance in the region. In my article, titled “Afghanistan after Mullah Omar” I wrote last year:

“The cross-currents of interests of the Global powers and regional countries make the Afghan situation more complex. The American and their coalition partners want Afghanistan destabilised, so that the emerging coalition of Russia, China, Pakistan and Iran does not materialize, and the China-Pakistan-Economic Corridor (CPEC) benefits, do not extend beyond Pakistan. India is particularly perturbed about the impact of CPEC, on the Khalistan Movement in Punjab and the freedom movement in Kashmir, because both the regions and the movements complement each other, and find themselves deprived of the economic benefits of the CPEC, so long as Pakistan does not grant the ‘Most Favoured Nation Status’ to India, whose ‘Look North Policy’ thus would remain unrealised. An intriguing situation indeed, which could undermine the geo-political realities of the region.”

The geo-political realities of the region beckon Pakistan, to shake-off American baggage and accept Putins offer of joining the ranks and files of the oppressed Muslim world, as partners in distress, to share Putins vision for overcoming the logic of conflict in tomorrows world.
Gen (r) Mirza Aslam Beg
The writer is a former COAS, Pakistan. He can be reached at friendsfoundation@live.co.uk
http://nation.com.pk/columns/05-Sep-2016/we-are-all-muslims
wonderful article.... @Irfan Baloch @araz @The Eagle @Sarge @Horus @Arsalan
 
Last edited:

Back
Top Bottom