What's new

'URI attack', Whose responsibility/Accountability ?

What according to you is the core issue???

The very "K word" you do not want us to mention.

My take is "and then came Modi govt and our enemies decided to fuel sectarian violence in Kashmir". It's easy when you have a Hindu party at the Center...you know. :)

So your enemies sent all those fanatics to lynch beef eaters? :disagree:

Even the hard core Indians accept this time problems in Indian held Kashmir are purely domestic.

It is not "enemies of India" who elected those hindu fanatics in the center. So for once take responsibility instead of searching faults elsewhere.
 
.
It is not "enemies of India" who elected those hindu fanatics in the center.
Not again.:tsk:
People in Kashmir also elected the so called "Hindu fanatics". Lolz
PDP formed a govt in the state with bjp's support. Remember?
Issues in Kashmir are not domestic. Too many coincidences force me to doubt that someone's been adding fuel to fire.

Okay now...we are going nowhere with this discussion.
 
. .
BBC last night had a very good discussion on Kashmir issue.

it was on their world service for 1 hour on radio; you may want to listen to it with a panel from both sides.
 
.
One question from side, once again.

Keep it clean guys, I know from last 4-5 days lot of useless trolling going on here.

Whose responsibility or rather the question should have been who should be accountable for the Uri attack ?

Every time we start blaming Pakistan for such attacks, I know Pakistan allows anti-India elements inside their territory for their so called "Good Terrorism". But was the army ill equipped or did somebody tied their hands ? Since the attacks there are only 2 parties are blamed for the attack, at least on Twitter & news media :

1. Pakistan whole country.
2. Indian Govt for tying the hands of Army.

But according to me the real responsibility of the attack should have been of the top Army personnel who are assigned the job of deciding the plans of defending the army camps or the LOC.

I respect the level of professionalism shown by the Armed forces and their non-interference in countries internal/political affairs is commendable, unlike our neighbours we can proudly say that "Our State has an Army" rather than "Our Army has a State".

But still, do you all think that the Army just got away very easily in between all this chaos created by the Media & the Government ?

My Ans : I think there should be a mechanism created within the Army or may be by the SC regarding the accountability of Armed forces.

@waz , @WAJsal Sirji try to keep it clean, and your suggestions are welcome too.

@PARIKRAMA
@Abingdonboy @anant_s @Taygibay @Picdelamirand-oil @Vergennes @randomradio @Ankit Kumar 002 @MilSpec @Koovie @Echo_419 @Dash @hellfire @ito @SR-91 @AMCA @DesiGuy1403 @ranjeet @hellfire @fsayed @SpArK @AUSTERLITZ @nair @proud_indian @Roybot @jbgt90 @Sergi @Water Car Engineer @dadeechi @kurup @Rain Man @kaykay @Joe Shearer @Tshering22 @Dandpatta @danger007 @Didact @Soumitra @SrNair @TejasMk3@jbgt90 @ranjeet @4GTejasBVR @The_Showstopper @guest11 @egodoc222 @Nilgiri @SarthakGanguly @Omega007 @GURU DUTT @HariPrasad @JanjaWeed @litefire @AMCA @Perpendicular @Spectre @litefire @AMCA @Perpendicular @Ryuzaki @CorporateAffairs @GR!FF!N @migflug @Levina @SvenSvensonov @-xXx- @Perpendicular @proud_indian @Mustang06 @Param @Local_Legend @Ali Zadi @hellfire @egodoc222 @CorporateAffairs @Major Shaitan Singh @jha @SmilingBuddha @#hydra# @danish_vij @[Bregs] @Skillrex @Hephaestus @SR-91 @Techy @litefire @R!CK @zebra7 @dev_moh @DesiGuy1403 @itachii @nik141993 @Marxist @Glorino @noksss @jbgt90 @Skull and Bones @Crixus @others

If there is someone who should be held accountable he is the commanding officer of the base. Under his watch people entered and killed army personnel.
 
. .
Where is he these days??? Yerwada Jail???
question your agency .

BSF caught him while crossing the fence in border i posted the news...
I am not Special investigation office...you are asking Id card from me...:lol::lol::lol::lol:

Don't worry parrot is speaking...
He was crossing loc in short and jersey ok great . case solved .
 
.
Implicating Pakistan without evidence actually exposes India as a blame gamer and trying to divert the world's attention from Kashmir.
 
. .
Blanket statements made by twitteratis.


If not anything this attack exposed the way our army treats its soldiers, at the bottom of the ladder I meant.


Yes.


Well... that's not true.



Just being honest here. I'm done cribbing about Pakistan (elsewhere).
India must take responsibility for itself.
Be assured I will be voiceferous about the elements within Pakistan which want to see my country splintered.
But India must realise putting your house in order also means fixing responsibility for slipping up.
IAF And Indian Army Asked To Pin-Point Personnel Responsible For Pathankot Airbase, Uri Brigade And Nagrota Attacks
The Indian Air Force (IAF) is resubmitting its Court-of-Inquiry findings into the Pathankot Airbase terror-attack. It will now pin-point officers and their lapses. And, the Indian Army too has been asked to point lapses of officers in the probe on Uri Brigade and Nagrota terror - attack, top sources have told Huffington Post India.

This comes after Manohar Parrikar, who recently quit as Defence Minister, asked the Army and the IAF to point at specifics, top government sources have told Huffington Post India.

"Very rarely" does the government send such advice, former Vice-Chief of the Indian Air Force, Air Marshal P K Barbora said. "Very rarely" does the government send such advice, former Vice-Chief of the Indian Air Force, Air Marshal P K Barbora said. Findings of the forces are generally accepted, he said.

In a first of its kind attack, Pakistan-based Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM) terrorists entered the Pathankot air base on the 2 January, 2016. The Pathankot airbase is a forward airbase. Fighter jets and attack helicopters are positioned at the base. At least 4 terrorists and 8 soldiers were killed in the operation that ended on 5 January.

Just a week before this terror-attack, Prime Minister Narendra Modi took a bold step and had visited Lahore on 25 December, 2015 when returning from Kabul. India-Pakistan relations that then showed signs of revival suffered a major blow because of the attack.

Nine months later, on 18 September, four terrorists stormed the Army's 12th Infantry Brigade located close to the India- Pakistan boundary along the 1972 agreed Line of Control (LoC) in Uri in Jammu and Kashmir. At least 19 soldiers lost their lives, and several others were injured in the attack. In retaliation, Indian commandos crossed the LoC to kill an unknown number of terrorists and Pakistan army soldiers, and destroyed as many as seven terror launch pads and Pakistan army facilities. India –Pakistan relations went into a deep freeze.

Soon after on 29 November, 2016, three Pakistan based terrorist impersonating as policemen attacked the Nagrota based 166 Field Regiment of the Army. Nine soldiers including two officers were killed in the attack.

The officer commanding Pathankot airbase during the attack, Air Commodore J S Dhamoon, was removed from command and shifted to Delhi months after the attack. Similarly, Brigadier K Somashankar, commander of the 12th Brigade, too was removed in what appeared to be a damage control exercise. "The officers were removed, but no one was scalped for lapses, and that is what the government is asking for," a top Ministry of Defence Official told Huffington Post India, on conditions of anonymity.

"The officers were removed, but no was scalped for lapses, and that is what the government is asking for," a top Ministry of Defence Official told Huffington Post India, on conditions of anonymity.

One of the two commanding officers, for instance, was then cleared for a prestigious course considered necessary for promotion to the next rank – i.e. Air-Vice Marshal or Major General. The Court-of-Inquiry findings into the two attacks, subsequently submitted to the Government, didn't fix responsibility.

Top sources confirmed that the Western Air Command that supervises the Pathankot air base is sending the Court-of-Inquiry back with a fresh set findings that fixes responsibility.

The Western Air Command that supervises the Pathankot air base is sending the Court-of -Inquiry back with a fresh set findings that fixes responsibility.

The Indian Air Force, India Army and Ministry of Defence did not respond to the queries of the Huffington Post India.
http://www.huffingtonpost.in/2017/0...n-point-personnel-responsible-for_a_22030203/
Sorry, didn't want to create fresh thread, so posted in relevant thread.
 
.
The officer commanding Pathankot airbase during the attack, Air Commodore J S Dhamoon, was removed from command and shifted to Delhi months after the attack. Similarly, Brigadier K Somashankar, commander of the 12th Brigade, too was removed in what appeared to be a damage control exercise. "The officers were removed, but no one was scalped for lapses, and that is what the government is asking for," a top Ministry of Defence Official to

Thanks for the article.
C of I, or otherwise court of enquiry,is pretty powerless and biased towards the senior officers. But for the laxity shown at the Uri Air Force base and at the border senior officers must be taken to task.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom