What's new

To Be A Muslim In India This Eid

Tameem

BANNED
Joined
Jan 27, 2008
Messages
4,468
Reaction score
-22
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
SEEMA MUSTAFA
Tuesday, September 13,2016

NEW DELHI: Mohammad Akhlaq was dragged out of his tenement in Dadri by a mob of Gau Rakshaks and beaten to death for allegedly eating beef. His son barely survived and was in hospital for weeks. His wife and children were screaming with terror, unable to get help and unable to prevent the frenzied mob.

This Eid, Akhlaq's family, charged with consuming beef, have a long legal battle ahead of them. Terrified out of their wits this family has been running from pillar to post, not just for justice for Akhlaq, but for their own security. They have been threatened, abused despite the trauma, and now the impoverished family has been dragged to the courts on an alleged forensic laboratory report that claims that the meat, that the mob insisted was taken from their home, was indeed beef. This is after the first forensic reports of similar meat samples verified that it was not beef.

In Hyderabad, a senior BJP lawmaker T.Raja Singh threatened violence if oxen were sacrificed on Eid. He warned the Telangana government to ensure the ban was imposed strictly.

This, even as the poor briyani vendors in Mewat, Haryana, remained on the run fearing action as rumours spread that samples seized from their stalls had tested positive for “beef”. In this sleepy Haryana town, the police turned into cow vigilantes, swooped down on the impoverished vendors, and spread terror as the youth ran fearing indiscriminate arrests. In the midst of this a mob attacked a Muslim home in a Mewat village and raped the girls, including a 14 year old, and killed a couple by tying them and beating them to death.

In Muzaffarnagar, a large number of Muslims displaced in the 2013 communal violence that tore through the villages in what was a first for the area, remain in camps. These internally displaced persons have been unable to return to their vilages, as the attackers were neighbours, as were those who raped their women. Terrified, and still facing abuse, these families live in terrible conditions in these camps infested with snakes, and with no sanitation, electricity or even potable drinking water. For three years they have been living in inhuman conditions, with tears pouring down at the mention of the homes where they had lived for generations, but can no longer return to.

In Kairana, again a bustling town, local BJP leaders spread the rumour of Hindu migration as a result of which the minorities are now terrified, and scared of reprisal by mobs. The state government stepped in on this issue for a change, and hence it was prevented from reaching new levels of violence although locally the terror remains.

Overarching is Kashmir, India’s only Muslim majority state. The state is stepping up the offensive with the Army returning to villages and districts it had left over a decade and more ago. At the time of writing this, a senior retired government official from Kashmir called, very agitated, that the forces were going into homes in the rural areas and firing pellet guns inside at the families. People are being arrested, taken away in action reminiscent of the 1990’s when enforced disappearances had hit almost every Kashmiri home. This is now the apprehension amongst the elders of Kashmir, even as the young are bent on giving up their lives for what they perceive to be their rights.

Drones and helicopters fly over Kashmir on Eid day even as one writes. Strict curfew keeps people at home, with internet and communication services suspended.

New Delhi, in line with the approach of centralising its slogan of nationalism around the ‘anti-national’ Kashmiri (and now also the Muslims in other parts of India), has decided to force an offensive for as long as it takes. The visit of the All Party Parliamentary delegation has been dismissed by the government as an aberration, with the hard line continuing in Kashmir. More so as the state has been placed since Independence in the national security paradigm, and not in the space of democratic rights and justice. Kashmir, thus, allows the government to build its ‘nationalism’ constituency by juxtaposing the Kashmiris as a national security threat.

Muslims in India thus, today, are being effectively projected as the crux of the definition of anti-nationals and terrorists embodied in the persona of the Kashmiri:-

anti-Hindu for being beef eaters with the current campaign actually intended to make the Indian Muslim synonymous with beef, when exactly the opposite is true;

anti-India and pro-Pakistan (this applies to Kashmiris and all other Muslims as well);

And all on the verge of joining the Islamic State.

There is no counter narrative, given the political opposition’s collapse in the face of the right wing onslaught. The Muslims have no organisation, no leadership except of the Muslim Personal Law Board kind, diminishing political support, with rights and justice playing a poor second to vote bank politics. The isolation is nearing completion.

http://www.thecitizen.in/index.php/NewsDetail/index/2/8705/To-Be-A-Muslim-In-India-This-Eid

Welcome to Modified India!
 
Last edited:
.
SEEMA MUSTAFA
Tuesday, September 13,2016

NEW DELHI: Mohammad Akhlaq was dragged out of his tenement in Dadri by a mob of Gau Rakshaks and beaten to death for allegedly eating beef. His son barely survived and was in hospital for weeks. His wife and children were screaming with terror, unable to get help and unable to prevent the frenzied mob.

This Eid, Akhlaq's family, charged with consuming beef, have a long legal battle ahead of them. Terrified out of their wits this family has been running from pillar to post, not just for justice for Akhlaq, but for their own security. They have been threatened, abused despite the trauma, and now the impoverished family has been dragged to the courts on an alleged forensic laboratory report that claims that the meat, that the mob insisted was taken from their home, was indeed beef. This is after the first forensic reports of similar meat samples verified that it was not beef.

In Hyderabad, a senior BJP lawmaker T.Raja Singh threatened violence if oxen were sacrificed on Eid. He warned the Telangana government to ensure the ban was imposed strictly.

This, even as the poor briyani vendors in Mewat, Haryana, remained on the run fearing action as rumours spread that samples seized from their stalls had tested positive for “beef”. In this sleepy Haryana town, the police turned into cow vigilantes, swooped down on the impoverished vendors, and spread terror as the youth ran fearing indiscriminate arrests. In the midst of this a mob attacked a Muslim home in a Mewat village and raped the girls, including a 14 year old, and killed a couple by tying them and beating them to death.

In Muzaffarnagar, a large number of Muslims displaced in the 2013 communal violence that tore through the villages in what was a first for the area, remain in camps. These internally displaced persons have been unable to return to their vilages, as the attackers were neighbours, as were those who raped their women. Terrified, and still facing abuse, these families live in terrible conditions in these camps infested with snakes, and with no sanitation, electricity or even potable drinking water. For three years they have been living in inhuman conditions, with tears pouring down at the mention of the homes where they had lived for generations, but can no longer return to.

In Kairana, again a bustling town, local BJP leaders spread the rumour of Hindu migration as a result of which the minorities are now terrified, and scared of reprisal by mobs. The state government stepped in on this issue for a change, and hence it was prevented from reaching new levels of violence although locally the terror remains.

Overarching is Kashmir, India’s only Muslim majority state. The state is stepping up the offensive with the Army returning to villages and districts it had left over a decade and more ago. At the time of writing this, a senior retired government official from Kashmir called, very agitated, that the forces were going into homes in the rural areas and firing pellet guns inside at the families. People are being arrested, taken away in action reminiscent of the 1990’s when enforced disappearances had hit almost every Kashmiri home. This is now the apprehension amongst the elders of Kashmir, even as the young are bent on giving up their lives for what they perceive to be their rights.

Drones and helicopters fly over Kashmir on Eid day even as one writes. Strict curfew keeps people at home, with internet and communication services suspended.

New Delhi, in line with the approach of centralising its slogan of nationalism around the ‘anti-national’ Kashmiri (and now also the Muslims in other parts of India), has decided to force an offensive for as long as it takes. The visit of the All Party Parliamentary delegation has been dismissed by the government as an aberration, with the hard line continuing in Kashmir. More so as the state has been placed since Independence in the national security paradigm, and not in the space of democratic rights and justice. Kashmir, thus, allows the government to build its ‘nationalism’ constituency by juxtaposing the Kashmiris as a national security threat.

Muslims in India thus, today, are being effectively projected as the crux of the definition of anti-nationals and terrorists embodied in the persona of the Kashmiri:-

anti-Hindu for being beef eaters with the current campaign actually intended to make the Indian Muslim synonymous with beef, when exactly the opposite is true;

anti-India and pro-Pakistan (this applies to Kashmiris and all other Muslims as well);

And all on the verge of joining the Islamic State.

There is no counter narrative, given the political opposition’s collapse in the face of the right wing onslaught. The Muslims have no organisation, no leadership except of the Muslim Personal Law Board kind, diminishing political support, with rights and justice playing a poor second to vote bank politics. The isolation is nearing completion.

http://www.thecitizen.in/index.php/NewsDetail/index/2/8705/To-Be-A-Muslim-In-India-This-Eid

Despite being a BJP supporter I must admit the violence against Muslims particularly in relation to the beef issue has gone out of control recently. The beef vigilantes are soon going to emerge as a threat for Hindus as well whom they suspect to have eaten beef.

I am a bit dissapointed with the way BJP has handled this. I was hoping that Modi would be extra cautious not to allow such incidents considering the kind of allegations that were made against him earlier.

Communal violence was always there in India but it seems to have become more common lately. Almost every 3rd day there is some news. Has to stop if India is to succeed and reach the level of economic success we desire.

Btw, why are Pakistanis on this forum so concerned about India's internal matters ? 28 people were blown to bits in a terror attack there yesterday. I hardly find anyone here talking about it.
 
.
So sad, really!

What can we say?

They chose to live in India under fanatic hindus, now sadly they will have to face the consequences!

Btw, why are Pakistanis on this forum so concerned about India's internal matters ? 28 people were blown to bits in a terror attack there yesterday. I hardly find anyone here talking about it.

We know, we are the victim of Indian sponsored cross-border terrorism, but to compare this with systematic govt support to fanatic hindus for killing and torturing minorities is quite pathetic!
 
.
We know, we are the victim of Indian sponsored cross-border terrorism, but to compare this with systematic govt support to fanatic hindus for killing and torturing minorities is quite pathetic!

If you wish to focus on religious violence in India and brush aside the murder of 28 Pakistanis in religious violence as an Indian conspiracy then that is your prerogative. It's your issue. But be rest assured, things will not improve for your country if you don't set your priorities right. We have our issues, you have yours. Better we focus on our own.
 
.
If you wish to focus on religious violence in India and brush aside the murder of 28 Pakistanis in religious violence as an Indian conspiracy then that is your prerogative. It's your issue. But be rest assured, things will not improve for your country if you don't set your priorities right. We have our issues, you have yours. Better we focus on our own.

Terrorism is a global problem. The focus is now shifting from foot soldiers to their sponsors. India being the major sponsor of cross-border terrorism in the region for more than half a century can not hide behind the victim card forever.

So now lets come back to the topic at hand: Letting your fanatics kill minorities under full govt protection is something quite different. Because here is no one else, but you your own govt is protecting those fanatics. This is called state terrorism against minorities
 
.
Terrorism is a global problem. The focus is now shifting from foot soldiers to their sponsors. India being the major sponsor of cross-border terrorism in the region for more than half a century can not hide behind the victim card forever.

So now lets come back to the topic at hand: Letting your fanatics kill minorities under full govt protection is something quite different. Because here is no one else, but you your own govt is protecting those fanatics. This is called state terrorism against minorities

So when religious fanatics kill people in your country including the few minorities that you have left, it's all fine but when religious fanatics kill people in India it is worth discussing. Your hypocrisy is too blatant for you to be taken seriously.

As for the recent anti-minority incidents, all the perpetrators have been arrested and are under trial. They don't become state sponsored just because you say so.I'll give you a perfect example of state sponsored terrorism on minorities - It is called a Blasphemy Law and we don't have any such non-sense in India. Besides, it's India's internal issue. Keep out.

As for my opinion on the violence, I have already made it in my first post on this thread.
 
.
As for the recent anti-minority incidents, all the perpetrators have been arrested and are under trial. They don't become state sponsored just because you say so.

You make a mass murderer your PM, who was banned to enter any Western countries for his role in massacre of minorities. His companions get all other powerful positions in the govt.

And you still questioning state sponsorship of fanatic hindus in India?
 
. . .
Despite being a BJP supporter I must admit the violence against Muslims particularly in relation to the beef issue has gone out of control recently. The beef vigilantes are soon going to emerge as a threat for Hindus as well whom they suspect to have eaten beef.

I am a bit dissapointed with the way BJP has handled this. I was hoping that Modi would be extra cautious not to allow such incidents considering the kind of allegations that were made against him earlier.

Communal violence was always there in India but it seems to have become more common lately. Almost every 3rd day there is some news. Has to stop if India is to succeed and reach the level of economic success we desire.

Btw, why are Pakistanis on this forum so concerned about India's internal matters ? 28 people were blown to bits in a terror attack there yesterday. I hardly find anyone here talking about it.
true,
however it was the same guy after all who was responsible of gujrat genocide so expecting much was futile anyway. Still, it would have been much better if things where handled properly. As you said, this is all getting out of control and is likely to come back and haunt those who did nothing despite the power to do something!!
 
.
true,
however it was the same guy after all who was responsible of gujrat genocide so expecting much was futile anyway. Still, it would have been much better if things where handled properly. As you said, this is all getting out of control and is likely to come back and haunt those who did nothing despite the power to do something!!

Agree with your latter point except for your reference to Gujarat.

It wasn't a genocide- 790 Muslims and 254 Hindus were killed.Genocide required much bigger numbers. Kind of like what Pakistan did in Bangladesh in 1971. If it was a genocide, it was a genocide for both Hindus and Muslims. Secondly, there is nothing to show that Modi was responsible. You can't say he was responsible just because he was the CM then. You can accuse him of incompetence but not complicity without any proof.

You make a mass murderer your PM, who was banned to enter any Western countries for his role in massacre of minorities. His companions get all other powerful positions in the govt.

And you still questioning state sponsorship of fanatic hindus in India?

There is not a single court in India or outside or related to the UN that has found him to be as you call "a mass murderer". He doesn't become a mass murderer just because you say it. Your words and judgement count for Nothing. Zilch.

As for Western countries, it was only US and UK which imposed a visa ban on him. There are dozens of other countries in the West. Check the map. Even the ban imposed by US and UK was only to appease some Muslims' sentiments and not based on any ruling by any Court of law in India or abroad or in UN.

These recent incidents of beef related violence are anything but state sponsored. People have been immediately arrested. They wouldn't be arrested if this was state sponsored. BJP and Modi know damn well that this will hurt them in the next elections. Though more could and should be done to prevent such attacks.
 
.
Despite being a BJP supporter I must admit the violence against Muslims particularly in relation to the beef issue has gone out of control recently. The beef vigilantes are soon going to emerge as a threat for Hindus as well whom they suspect to have eaten beef.

I am a bit dissapointed with the way BJP has handled this. I was hoping that Modi would be extra cautious not to allow such incidents considering the kind of allegations that were made against him earlier.

Communal violence was always there in India but it seems to have become more common lately. Almost every 3rd day there is some news. Has to stop if India is to succeed and reach the level of economic success we desire.

Btw, why are Pakistanis on this forum so concerned about India's internal matters ? 28 people were blown to bits in a terror attack there yesterday. I hardly find anyone here talking about it.
If they continue this way I am sure they will be sent packing in next elections. Fact is some overzealous borderlines have convinced themselves that Modi was elected on religious consideration. Thats the reason why they end up indulging in such activities thinking that will shore up their support. Elements in modi govt should be quite aware that the elections were on national agenda and states still have a long way in accepting them.

However good our economic growth is ppl will not be pleased with environment of chaos & unruly mob run the show.
 
.
SEEMA MUSTAFA
Tuesday, September 13,2016

NEW DELHI: Mohammad Akhlaq was dragged out of his tenement in Dadri by a mob of Gau Rakshaks and beaten to death for allegedly eating beef. His son barely survived and was in hospital for weeks. His wife and children were screaming with terror, unable to get help and unable to prevent the frenzied mob.

This Eid, Akhlaq's family, charged with consuming beef, have a long legal battle ahead of them. Terrified out of their wits this family has been running from pillar to post, not just for justice for Akhlaq, but for their own security. They have been threatened, abused despite the trauma, and now the impoverished family has been dragged to the courts on an alleged forensic laboratory report that claims that the meat, that the mob insisted was taken from their home, was indeed beef. This is after the first forensic reports of similar meat samples verified that it was not beef.

In Hyderabad, a senior BJP lawmaker T.Raja Singh threatened violence if oxen were sacrificed on Eid. He warned the Telangana government to ensure the ban was imposed strictly.

This, even as the poor briyani vendors in Mewat, Haryana, remained on the run fearing action as rumours spread that samples seized from their stalls had tested positive for “beef”. In this sleepy Haryana town, the police turned into cow vigilantes, swooped down on the impoverished vendors, and spread terror as the youth ran fearing indiscriminate arrests. In the midst of this a mob attacked a Muslim home in a Mewat village and raped the girls, including a 14 year old, and killed a couple by tying them and beating them to death.

In Muzaffarnagar, a large number of Muslims displaced in the 2013 communal violence that tore through the villages in what was a first for the area, remain in camps. These internally displaced persons have been unable to return to their vilages, as the attackers were neighbours, as were those who raped their women. Terrified, and still facing abuse, these families live in terrible conditions in these camps infested with snakes, and with no sanitation, electricity or even potable drinking water. For three years they have been living in inhuman conditions, with tears pouring down at the mention of the homes where they had lived for generations, but can no longer return to.

In Kairana, again a bustling town, local BJP leaders spread the rumour of Hindu migration as a result of which the minorities are now terrified, and scared of reprisal by mobs. The state government stepped in on this issue for a change, and hence it was prevented from reaching new levels of violence although locally the terror remains.

Overarching is Kashmir, India’s only Muslim majority state. The state is stepping up the offensive with the Army returning to villages and districts it had left over a decade and more ago. At the time of writing this, a senior retired government official from Kashmir called, very agitated, that the forces were going into homes in the rural areas and firing pellet guns inside at the families. People are being arrested, taken away in action reminiscent of the 1990’s when enforced disappearances had hit almost every Kashmiri home. This is now the apprehension amongst the elders of Kashmir, even as the young are bent on giving up their lives for what they perceive to be their rights.

Drones and helicopters fly over Kashmir on Eid day even as one writes. Strict curfew keeps people at home, with internet and communication services suspended.

New Delhi, in line with the approach of centralising its slogan of nationalism around the ‘anti-national’ Kashmiri (and now also the Muslims in other parts of India), has decided to force an offensive for as long as it takes. The visit of the All Party Parliamentary delegation has been dismissed by the government as an aberration, with the hard line continuing in Kashmir. More so as the state has been placed since Independence in the national security paradigm, and not in the space of democratic rights and justice. Kashmir, thus, allows the government to build its ‘nationalism’ constituency by juxtaposing the Kashmiris as a national security threat.

Muslims in India thus, today, are being effectively projected as the crux of the definition of anti-nationals and terrorists embodied in the persona of the Kashmiri:-

anti-Hindu for being beef eaters with the current campaign actually intended to make the Indian Muslim synonymous with beef, when exactly the opposite is true;

anti-India and pro-Pakistan (this applies to Kashmiris and all other Muslims as well);

And all on the verge of joining the Islamic State.

There is no counter narrative, given the political opposition’s collapse in the face of the right wing onslaught. The Muslims have no organisation, no leadership except of the Muslim Personal Law Board kind, diminishing political support, with rights and justice playing a poor second to vote bank politics. The isolation is nearing completion.

http://www.thecitizen.in/index.php/NewsDetail/index/2/8705/To-Be-A-Muslim-In-India-This-Eid

Welcome to Modified India!

When Muslims voted for the Muslim League in 1946 they buried their political future.
Note - I did not say Pakistan. They voted for the Muslim League leaders without understanding the consequences of their actions.

Actions have consequences
 
. .
I am just sorry and sad for them...I wish they realise their rights and stand for it otherwise the fanatic hindu will kill each one of them.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom