Thread closed, but why?

[E-Python]

I registered here to thank the initiator of the thread "Makkah and Medina should be a separate state". and to share my opinion regarding the issue.


Why is the thread closed?

 

[Cherokee]

We are not on a defence forum to discuss/debate Balkanisation of any country . That will lead to offensive reply and counter troll threads and eventually Ban of Members . ( Suicide Troll ) .

 

[mb444]

If you read the posts in the thread it should be clear.... Assuming trolling stated so the moderators closed it down. Not sure why you would want to break up Saudi but as the above posters says it would have encouraged the crazies.... Me included!!!

 

[Windjammer]

I registered here to thank the initiator of the thread "Makkah and Medina should be a separate state". and to share my opinion regarding the issue.


Why is the thread closed?

Oh Bandu rey.....kitta khabor. ??...khoub balu ashun...

First introduce yourself in the "Members Introduction" section....so we could formerly welcome you.

 

[kobiraaz]

i just saw a twit by PDF - thread closed but why!

 

[Hyde]

I don't see any other thread created by you?

What thread are you talking about?

 

[E-Python]

We are not on a defence forum to discuss/debate Balkanisation of any country . That will lead to offensive reply and counter troll threads and eventually Ban of Members . ( Suicide Troll ) .

What makes us human being if we cannot discuss issues without being offensive? Just because an issue is provocative, we never discuss it? I just can't fathom why you wrote such.

I don't see any other thread created by you?

What thread are you talking about?

Zakii, I did not start the thread, but someone else did.

Oh Bandu rey.....kitta khabor. ??...khoub balu ashun...

First introduce yourself in the "Members Introduction" section....so we could formerly welcome you.

I will, Bondu.

 

[Hyde]

What makes us human being if we cannot discuss issues without being offensive? Just because an issue is provocative, we never discuss it? I just can't fathom why you wrote such.

Which thread are you talking about?

 

[Markus]

I registered here to thank the initiator of the thread "Makkah and Medina should be a separate state". and to share my opinion regarding the issue.


Why is the thread closed?

ARe you talking abt this thread?

http://www.defence.pk/forums/middle...ak-out-against-wanton-destruction-meccas.html

 

[Hyde]

I don't see any post from you anywhere else in the forum. Did you post from different account or what thread are you talking about? Please post the link

 

[E-Python]

Which thread are you talking about?

Thread "Makkah and Madina should be a separate state" initiated by Shahin Vatani. I am sorry I cannot share the link with you now.

 

[Hyde]

Thread "Makkah and Madina should be a separate state" initiated by Shahin Vatani. I am sorry I cannot share the link with you now.

That thread was closed for a valid reason. It was allowed to run for 7 pages and was heavily dominated by trolls and off topic discussion/rants.

You can still use the thank button to thank the thread starter but that thread is now history

 

[Skallagrim]

I don't see any post from you anywhere else in the forum. Did you post from different account or what thread are you talking about? Please post the link

http://www.defence.pk/forums/middle-east-africa/204632-makkah-should-separate-state.html

 

[Bhai Zakir]

I think religion based threads are not allowed here.

For god sake its a defense forum one should remember it its not a social networking website.