What's new

The Water Wars Myth: India, China and the Brahmaputra

I was talking about the record rainfall they've received in the last CY2022. On June 17th 2022, Mawsynram set a new record by receiving 1003.6 mm in a span of 24 hours which has now become its highest single day record for the month of June and for its all time single day record beating its former record of 944.7 mm on June 7th 1966.



The annual mean temperature in the NE state has increased by only 0.59 degrees Celsius in the last 60 years and you're portraying it as if they've turned into a Sahara desert 🤣

There are shortfalls of rainwater now over the time period do you understand how bad that is? Yet you're posting about last year's rainfall!
India's so called 'wettest' state has seen it's rainfall share fall.
Feel free to deny your own experts. I know the truth hurts so this must be your way to make yourself feel better i.e. deny it all.:enjoy:

Next you stated that minor changes in temperature are not a problem which again shows your lack of scientific understanding.. Fractional changes in temperature cause devastating results on the earth's fragile ecosystem.


Here educate yourself;

Whether you agree with the consensus or not, there's no denying that even a small change in temperature can have enormous consequences.

Temperature plays an important part in shaping weather patterns, guiding the life cycle of various organisms and maintaining ocean levels. Shifting the temperature a couple of degrees can throw an entire ecosystem into chaos.



Today, the temperature shift is going in the other direction – with global temperatures already 1 C (1.8 F) higher than before the industrial era, and local, sometimes devastating, extremes occurring around the world.

New research has found that extreme heat waves, those that don’t just break records but shatter them, become more common when temperatures change rapidly.

These serve as a warning to governments to redouble their efforts to limit warming to 1.5 C (2.7 F), relative to the 20th-century average,
while also investing in the development and deployment of technologies that filter greenhouse gases out of the atmosphere.


Five and a half degrees Fahrenheit. It may not sound like much—perhaps the difference between wearing a sweater and not wearing one on an early-spring day. But for the world in which we live—which climate experts project will be at least 5.7 degrees Fahrenheit warmer by 2100, relative to pre-industrial levels (1850–1900), should global emissions continue on their current path—this small rise will have grave consequences. These impacts are already becoming apparent for every ecosystem and living thing, including us.


Here they discuss how a 5.7 degrees fahrenheit is massive and you are dismissing an actual rise of 0.59 Celsius lol!! :woot:

For northeast and east India, IMD’s normal rainfall calculated for the period from 1961 to 2010 was 1,410.4 mm which came down to 1,367.3 mm in the 1971 to 2020 period(Is it that low according to your calculations? I don't think so)
During the last year’s monsoon between June 1 and June 23, Meghalaya has recorded 150% excess rains, followed by Assam 83% and Arunachal Pradesh 25% excess rain. Northeast India used to receive large amounts or rain and comparatively it still does because the normal here is very high but we are seeing that the quantum of rainfall is increasing along the west coast now

@waz Now it has been proved once again that 🇨🇳 holding of Brahmaputra water is much lower than what it is generally perceived

That's a great reduction and your experts are sounding the alarm. You lack a complete understanding of how ecosystems work and review the numbers in a nominal way.
In 1861, Cherrapunji, known to locals as Sohra, created a world record with 22,987mm of rainfall in a year.

More than 150 years later, and experiencing an average annual rainfall of 11,430mm, it is still the second wettest place in the world.

However, the current rainfall in Cherrapunji, located in Meghalaya state, is just one third of what it was in the 1970s.

Residents blame events beyond their control for the problems they face – the place is hotter, drier and shorter of water than even before. :what:


“We never had very large forests around Cherrapunji. Those that were there were sacred to us and we did not cut a branch,” says Millergrace Symlieh, a senior member of the Sohra Science Society.

“We are affected by what’s happening all over the world,” he told Al Jazeera.

Even Chadhuri’s “normal average” of 11,000mm of annual rain is a far cry from the 1970s, when Cherrapunji got almost double that amount of annual rainfall.


In 1974, Cherrapunji experienced 24,555mm of annual rain, a world record.

So at about 8,000mm to 9,000mm, the present average is only about a third of the town’s annual rainfall compared with only 40 years ago.
Meanwhile, her sister Mimi complains that rainfall is now very erratic.

The neighbouring state of Assam was once, and perhaps still is ,famous for its destructive floods caused by rivers like the Brahmaputra.

But for the past two years, during the late winter and summer months, half of its 28 districts have suffered drought.



Oh dear this was back in 2016 and the situation is far worse now.

Your posts remind me of this;

1*BU57RnJoFGfiZq3d7sgxYQ.jpeg
 
Last edited:
.
All water collected in China and flows in the rivers of Chinese land are rightfully Chinese water for China to use, no consultation with any country needed, no exception, period.
 
.
please teach this wonderful lesson to your iron brother pakistan, why is your iron brother bickering about indus water treaty, they should learn from you. as you say
All water collected in China and flows in the rivers of Chinese land are rightfully Chinese water for China to use, no consultation with any country needed, no exception, period.
All water collected in India and flows in the rivers of Indian land are rightfully Indian water for India to use, no consultation with any country needed, no exception, period.
 
.
please teach this wonderful lesson to your iron brother pakistan, why is your iron brother bickering about indus water treaty, they should learn from you. as you say

All water collected in India and flows in the rivers of Indian land are rightfully Indian water for India to use, no consultation with any country needed, no exception, period.
That is esp true between China and India.
 
.
Please, Be my guest, only rivers that flow from China to India are
  • Satluj (this river gets enough rainwater in india that it can fulfil india's need, the best the chinese can do is cause a flooding, which can be dealt with, because we already have enough Dams on this river with more on the way)
  • Jadh Ganga (The valley of Jadh Ganga is claimed by China,[1] though the whole extent of Jadh Ganga is administered by India.)
  • Ghaghara (most of its water orignates in nepal and uttarakhand, its basin is shared between india and nepal, due to its geography for the most part it can not be dammed in tibet)
  • Koshi (again same case, most of its water orignates in nepal from small tributries and due to its geography, for the most part this river can not be dammed in tibet)
  • Indus ( the best the you can do is cause a flash flooding, in kashmir, but that too would be very difficult)
  • Torsa (not a very major river, flows from tibet to bhutan to india then to bangladesh, we will be just fine even without this water but if need be it can be easily dammed in both bhutan and india and to deal with any chinese misadventure)
  • Gandaki (it doesn't even contribute that much in india additionally due to its geography, for the most part it can not be dammed in tibet,)
  • Brahmaputra (70% of its water orignates in india's arunanchal pradesh and assam, best china can do here is cause a flasf flood, and we are builing dams to deal with it,)
Conclusion only 3 (bramhaputra, indus, satulaj) can be weaponised against india, and that too not very effectively due to geographical constrains.
China is not using rivers as weapons against India, I am just saying China has the right to use water flows inside China that also find downstreams in India.
 
.
China is not using rivers as weapons against India, I am just saying China has the right to use water flows inside China that also find downstreams in India.
China doesn't use its nuclear weapons too but that doesn't mean it can't, having the ability to do something is different from actually doing that. China is not using rivers as weapons against India but it can and by taking steps like not sharing hydrological data annually and excessively damming rivers that go in india disregarding india's concerns, china has made itself very clear, that it will not back down from using water as a strategic tool

And if you want to use water that is rightfully yours, be my guest, but please teach this lesson to your iron brother too, as for India we don't care (only 3 major rivers flowing in india source their water from tibet), you can do whatever you want with your water, but please do so under international rules and laws.
 
Last edited:
.
Please be my guest, but please teach this lesson to your iron brother too, as for India we don't care (only 3 major rivers flowing in india source their water from tibet), you can do whatever you want with your water, but please do so under international rules and laws.
What do yo mean by international rules and laws ? Do you mean China is not using water upstreams in Tibet lawfully ? China can use water flows in China at its will. We are discussing water issue between China and India here, why do you have to drag in Pakistan in conversation, its beween you two.
 
.
China doesn't use its nuclear weapons too but that doesn't mean it can't, having the ability to do something is different from actually doing that. China is not using rivers as weapons against India but it can and by taking steps like not sharing hydrological data annually and excessively damming rivers that go in india disregarding india's concerns, china has made itself very clear, that it will not back down from using water as a strategic tool

And if you want to use water that is rightfully yours, be my guest, but please teach this lesson to your iron brother too, as for India we don't care (only 3 major rivers flowing in india source their water from tibet), you can do whatever you want with your water, but please do so under international rules and laws.
What are you talking nonsense. So, you want China to stop building dams in Tibet becos they could be used in the time of war ? What do you think you are asking China to do is to stop any developments in China so you Indians can feel totally safe, what a nonsense delusional unreal demand you are asking, who the fk do you Indians think you are to make such foolish demands. On the other hand, by the same logic, why dont you Indians stop building nukes since they can be used against China in time of war and therefore threaten China ?

India is asking for unreasonable weather info of the rivers from China, China has given India the reasonable data of the rivers.
 
Last edited:
.
Dumb Indians!

China is building dams in Tibet to

1) Generate electricity needed for the PLA to invade India

2) Flood India by releasing water as needed to drown the Indian military
With this much IQ you should be the right person to help out your Government from the current economic problem.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom