What's new

The wailing wall of Israel-Pakistan

King Solomon

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 6, 2011
Messages
2,990
Reaction score
0
The wailing wall of Israel

The wailing wall of Israel – The Express Tribune Blog

P.S. An article describing a pakistani's experience in Israel

524970_415608005139028_356535017712994_1205559_1334751573_n.jpg

(different photo as the original could not be linked)

Israel was not the garrison state it was branded to be in the media. No scary atmosphere. No guns totting policemen. No siren-blazing police cars buzzing around; as commonly seen in London. PHOTO: REUTERS

Perhaps we have all heard the oft repeated joke; when an American tourist came to Israel with the intention of visiting the Kotel (the Wailing Wall) but he forgot what it was called. When he stepped into a taxi, he said to the driver,

Can you please take me to the place where all Jews cry? Do you know where this is?

The taxi driver answered,

Beseder – I’ll take you there.

And he drove him straight to the taxation office!

When I stepped outside the Easy Jet terminal on Tel Aviv International Airport, I felt chills travelling down my spine. They were partly due to the baggage of history being a British Pakistani entering Israel, perhaps the most hated place on earth in Pakistan, its ideological twin; and mainly, it was the weather.

Tel Aviv was almost bordering zero degrees with strong winds that made it feel even worse; I had left London basking in glorious sunshine that resembled more of spring than fall.

However my racing heart started calming down when we entered the modern airport building. It all looked like the usual business day. There were passengers trolling their luggage and scurrying around. The airport staff was amicable and polite. We were showered with smiles, which was quite unusual for immigration staff at an international airport.

Quite importantly, there were no armed policemen around; compared to the British airport we flew from.

Gradually I noticed my group members, mostly senior British Pakistani businessmen, easing up which might sound a little odd, us being in Israel and all.

Our next few days in Israel were spent on a rollercoaster.

We had been travelling, attending meetings, speaking at receptions, engaging in discussions and waiting for the most coveted moment of our lives; offering Friday prayers at al Aqsa Mosque which is one of the three holiest places in Islam.

My trip to Israel was myth-shattering in several ways.

Israel was not the garrison state it was branded to be in the media. No scary atmosphere. No guns totting policemen. No siren-blazing police cars buzzing around; as commonly seen in London.

Surprisingly enough, Israeli chefs at the Grand Beech Hotel, when they figured out my Pakistani roots, knew how to prepare the big spicy mother of omelettes for the hectic day ahead.

Amongst many of my discoveries, I found out that Zionism had a separate existence from Judaism. This, I found out, when two orthodox Jews criticised Israeli atrocities on my flight from London to Tel Aviv. I was also kind of shocked when I heard from a senior retired air force officer ’what America blundered by creating a jihadi industry in Afghanistan and Pakistan; Israelis floundered by supporting Hamas against al Fatah’.

I met Israeli businessmen who whined about Israel’s isolation in the global fraternity due to its Zionist movers and shakers.

We were invited by the Federation of the Israeli Chamber of Commerce and Industry to look into its technologically advanced market economy.

Being the 24th largest economy in the world, and ranking 17th among 187 world nations on the UN Human Development Index, Israel’s economy also ranks 17th amongst the world’s most economically developed nations.

I was shocked when a senior Israeli businessman mentioned that the leading Israeli manufacturer of tankers, aircraft refuelers, fire fighting trucks, armoured vehicles and special purpose trailers, Hatehof Ltd., provided Pakistan’s Air Force with military equipment under a clandestine contract through Turkey; which was used in the much acclaimed JF Thunder aircraft. An Israeli press television aired a similar broadcast as well.

As the trip was organised from a business perspective, we missed the chance of visiting Palestinian areas, particularly the Gaza Strip. When I contrasted the developed State of Israel with underprivileged areas of the Palestinian territory, the Israelis claimed that they had handed control to Palestinian authorities who wanted to keep it as it is to showcase their miseries.

They also blamed rampant corruption in Palestinian authorities as another source of underdevelopment. The construction of the wall to isolate Palestinian areas from Israeli areas, an act of raising barriers, in the 21st century, in which humanity claims to have come a long way from since demolition of the Berlin Wall, however, does raise questions;

I roamed Jerusalem donning a keffiyeh; a traditional Arab headdress fashioned from square cotton; a scarf made popular by Yasser Arafat.

Past the Wailing Wall, I saw two fully armed Israeli soldiers in an alert position for the first time and stopped there to recollect ourselves. As a memento, we took a photograph of the contradictory scene that captured us.

The photograph shows the three faces cracking wide grins, holding guns with barrels that reached the ground; a weird mix of guns and roses.

It made me wonder if roses will have conquered guns by the time I make my next visit to the Holy Land; which, I thought, was definitely spacious enough to accommodate all Abrahamic faiths.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Personally, I have been to a family trip in Israel and I can attest that Israel is fully on par with any developed country in the world.
 
. .
One of the comments below
Okay, let me tell you MY experience at Ben Gurion airport as a young British Pakistani woman. Interrogated for nine hours, detained for 48 hours, treated like a terrorist when I’m not even an activist, and finally deported back to London. I don’t know where in Israel you have been and/or if you had your eyes shut the whole time but let me tell you about how racist they are.

My friend who is half Palestinian, half American was arrested in Tel Aviv because she was wearing a hijab.
Not to mention the deplorable treatment of Africans from Sudan and Eritrea because they are black.

People think that most Israelis are “liberal”, trust me, they’re not. Also go into the open air prison Toaha, also known as the West Bank. See how Palestinians are treated.

And should I give you a history lesson into how many Palestinians live in refugee camps and cannot get back their OWN land because of racist Israel.

Another comment reads
So you had a lovely time in Israel. Good for you! Now let’s bring on the contradictions.

Arabs and non-Jews are actually quite openly discriminated against at Israeli airports. There is a racial discrimination policy that is not even covered under the thin veneer of ”random” checks used by the U.S to pull us brown people apart. You would have encountered different treatment as a tourist. That is a guarantee.

In Israel, racial profiling doesn't warrant debate, or apologies - Haaretz Daily Newspaper | Israel News
BBC News | Middle East | El Al charged with race discrimination

”Israel was not the garrison state it was branded to be in the media. No scary atmosphere. No guns totting policemen. No siren-blazing police cars buzzing around; as commonly seen in London.”

Not a garrison state? I suppose that’s why Israel has enforced conscription at age 18? No scary atmosphere? Been to East Jerusalem where Arabs live in constant fear over their houses being seized by Jewish settlers under flimsy pretences? ”The secular-religious gap was also present when students were faced with the question of whether Arabs should be eligible to run for office in the Knesset. While 82 percent of those with religious tendencies answered in the negative, 47 percent of secular teens agreed. In total, 56 percent said Arabs should be denied this right altogether.” – Poll: Half of Israeli high schoolers oppose equal rights for Arabs - Haaretz Daily Newspaper | Israel News
Ah lovely Israel.

It’s tourists like you that go into conflict zones with zero knowledge of the issues and write uninformed pieces that don’t need venues on intellectual sites like this. ET, please publish this comment. I hope your next visitor to Israel will have at least some knowledge of Israel before visiting.

Yet another.
We hate Israel for what it does to Palestinians in the form of naval blockade and embargoes, throwing them out of their homes and occupying them. And for killing innocent young babies. Come on you know they do that! And by the way, many Jews hate Israel and it’s policies against Palestinians

Yet one more
I’m Palestinian and I just read this! I’m really disgusted that this “business man” got wooed into some fancy business trip around the touristy parts of Jerusalem. My mother can never see Jerusalem because she was expelled from her land along with the rest of our family. We are now refugees in Jordan. When you talk about Israel being your friend, look how they treat anyone who isn’t Ashkenazi Jews from Europe. Check out these articles:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/24/opinion/not-all-israeli-citizens-are-equal.html?_r=1&smid=fb-share
And this: Africans attacked in Tel Aviv protest; MKs: ‘infiltrators’ are cancer

A politician referred to African migrants in Tel Aviv as “cancer”! This isn’t just my opinion as a Palestinian but it’s a fact!!

Same Palestinian commenter
@ Maddy, did you know that there are so many Christian Palestinians who are treated like animals as well? This is not a war of Islam vs Judaism. It’s about human rights and that Israel stole our land.

Same Palestinian commenter
@ Maddy, did you know that there are so many Christian Palestinians who are treated like animals as well? This is not a war of Islam vs Judaism. It’s about human rights and that Israel stole our land.

Oh my god I can’t believe some of the comments on this about Israel being the friend and how this article is a friggin eye opener! Do some research first! Israel is the only country in the world that bases migration to the country on religion. Only if you’re Jewish can you have the legal right to live there. Is that alone not discriminating?? And even between Israeli society there is a hierarchy of discrimination. Ashkenazi Jews from Europe including Russia are at the top. Then Orthodox. Black, Ethiopian Jews are at the bottom of the ladder. They get treated like dirt. And should I mention Palestinians? Ethnically cleansed? Why didn’t you go to East Jerusalem or the West Bank? See “liberal’ Israel there? Checkpoints everywhere. Not to mention the huge apartheid wall that is three times bigger than the Berlin wall was. Human rights come before your stupid business trip. I seriously think you went to apartheid Israel blind.

Read this above.

Oh my god I can’t believe some of the comments on this about Israel being the friend and how this article is a friggin eye opener! Do some research first! Israel is the only country in the world that bases migration to the country on religion. Only if you’re Jewish can you have the legal right to live there. Is that alone not discriminating?? And even between Israeli society there is a hierarchy of discrimination. Ashkenazi Jews from Europe including Russia are at the top. Then Orthodox. Black, Ethiopian Jews are at the bottom of the ladder. They get treated like dirt. And should I mention Palestinians? Ethnically cleansed? Why didn’t you go to East Jerusalem or the West Bank? See “liberal’ Israel there? Checkpoints everywhere. Not to mention the huge apartheid wall that is three times bigger than the Berlin wall was. Human rights come before your stupid business trip. I seriously think you went to apartheid Israel blind.

Read this above.

If a Jewish American business man came to Pakistan and only visited cosmopolitan cities like Islamabad and Karachi, and only visited the nice areas, he would think everything is fine in Pakistan and that women and non-Muslims are treated equally.

In fact if a Christian from America visited and prayed at a church here in Pakistan, he would think Pakistan is an egalitarian society too, but that isn’t the whole picture.

You would find the truth if you visited the rural parts Pakistan and the dangerous Northwestern parts of Pakistan, and see how women and non-Muslims are treated.

Same way you would only the truth if you visited east Jerusalem or the Gaza strip and the west bank.

There are good and bad places everywhere, I mean if you visited Manhattan or Florida you would think America is great, but then if you visit Alabama, it would be a different story.
Same thing India and every country.

If we believed the writer then why south africa confrence called them most Racist nation in the world??? palestineans thrown out on gun points in jerusalem by civilized israelis most often????
and please visit palestine next time if u get some time or may be scare off to they not gonna give u visa again …. and when u say truth about something its not hate its a fact.
 
. .
Israel gets targeted by lot of country and image is completely distorted. They are friends of India and care a lot about them
 
.
Israel... I can't judge because I've never been there...

But... Express Tribune has been known notoriously for it's propoganda and anti-Pak articles.
 
.
OP (King Solomon) has different identities and different personalities selling drugs. Is he Arab or Kazakhstani or now Jewish?

:disagree:

Israel... I can't judge because I've never been there...

But... Express Tribune has been known notoriously for it's propoganda and anti-Pak articles.

Yeah, i have noticed lately too.

Express Tribune reporters and editors seemed happy while Pakistan is in difficult moment today in current wars.

http://www.defence.pk/forums/members-club/173027-express-tribune-negative-propaganda.html
 
.
.
good essay.

Thanks for sharing.

For ordinary Pakistanis, Israel is a distant country that has never threatened Pakistan, or damaged us in any way.

So the hype and propaganda by the Mullahs and Ayatullahs is just that. Propaganda.

Israelis turn out to be good company whenever Pakistanis meet them. We share food sense and cultural sense much more than many others such as Chinese, or Koreans.

I hope such articles will lessen the number of jingoistic anti-Israeli nut cases in Pakistan.


peace,


p.s. Israeli-Palestinian issue has been on for almost 100 years, so as a Pakistani I cannot do much about it. My view of Israel has to be based on multiple factors.
 
.
If a Jewish American business man came to Pakistan and only visited cosmopolitan cities like Islamabad and Karachi, and only visited the nice areas, he would think everything is fine in Pakistan -
Doubtful. Pakistanis in those cities still whisper that they are afraid that if they voice pro-Israel sentiments they will have their throats slit within the hour.

PakProud, it's amazing how you ignore the article to focus on the comments. It's as if you find it completely irrefutable but don't want people to think about that.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom