The Decline Of Bengali Hindus

[Bilal9]

First, Bangladeshis are NOT Bengalis.

Second, Bangladeshis do not speak Bengali, they speak a hotchpotch of rustic Bengali with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert languages.

Third, Bangladeshis do not follow Bengali culture, they follow a hotchpotch of some Bengali culture with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert culture.

Kolkata is the only epicenter of genuine, classy Bengali language, culture, literature, music, movies, and art....all things that define a true Bengali.

Thank you.

Trying a bit of trolling - eh?

Not a lot here will take your bait, I'm afraid.

'Kolkata' can't be a center of Bengali-anything if its daily 'rooti-ruji' is provided by outsiders and non-Bengalis. They will (and are) dictating your culture. Good luck with your future.

If you are a bong - then you'll know the meaning of 'Apobhrashto' - which is what your comments are. In Bangladesh we all know Sanskrit words but don't use them in daily usage. Probably a lot more in literary circles than in Calcutta. Ask any chetona-wallah here.

By the way the word is 'hodgepodge'. You need a lesson in English too - it seems.

Hindu Bengalis becoming extinct...
That is news?

Marwari der jonnei Tao tike ache era Kolkata te. Malda Dinajpur Murshidabad er moddhye amader. Ar kichudin er opekkha. Era sudhu Ekta jinish pare. Musolman der arale ghrina ar shamne polayon.

I've heard about a lot of areas in Kolkata where they would not even rent to Muslims. Some have banded together to drive out Muslim renters. Is this true? This is amazing to me in 2018.

 

[AfrazulMandal]

I've heard about a lot of areas in Kolkata where they would not even rent to Muslims. Some have banded together to drive out Muslim renters. Is this true? This is amazing to me in 2018.

Obviously. Otherwise why do you think we have Muslim localities?

But in general, the opposite happens more. One beef shop and the Hindus in nearby blocks all sell their homes and leave. LOL.

There was a plan for W Bengal, BD, NE states and Arakan to become one state in 1947. This would have been best solution for the sub-continent

I oppose it.

In a century if not half, all of India will see a permanent demographic shift. Any further division initiated by us will lead to rest of the non Muslims banding together.

First, Bangladeshis are NOT Bengalis.

Second, Bangladeshis do not speak Bengali, they speak a hotchpotch of rustic Bengali with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert languages.

Third, Bangladeshis do not follow Bengali culture, they follow a hotchpotch of some Bengali culture with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert culture.

Kolkata is the only epicenter of genuine, classy Bengali language, culture, literature, music, movies, and art....all things that define a true Bengali.

Thank you.

What you call Bengali culture is actually just 18th century inspired Hindu culture. The people of Bangladesh have proved by their HDI indicators etc that they are doing better without it.
May be - just may be the people their prefer a more pious way of life than Holi color playing molesting, sati doing one.

If you are a bong - then you'll know the meaning of 'Apobhrashto' - which is what your comments are. In Bangladesh we all know Sanskrit words but don't use them in daily usage. Probably a lot more in literary circles than in Calcutta. Ask any chetona-wallah here.

Cultures evolve.

Hindu odhyushito somaje Sanskrit makes sense. Otherwise why should a modern society stick with a dead language? Arabic influence nie onek Hindu bangali nak shitkoy. Keno? So many countries speak the tongue. How many speak in Sanskrit?

 

[Kandari-Hushiyaar]

First, Bangladeshis are NOT Bengalis.

Second, Bangladeshis do not speak Bengali, they speak a hotchpotch of rustic Bengali with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert languages.

Third, Bangladeshis do not follow Bengali culture, they follow a hotchpotch of some Bengali culture with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert culture.

Kolkata is the only epicenter of genuine, classy Bengali language, culture, literature, music, movies, and art....all things that define a true Bengali.

Thank you.

First The Majority Bengalis in today's world are from Bangladesh. The world understands Bangladesh by the word "Bengali" . Kolkata neither have a flag nor freedom.

Second, Bengali language has always been rustic until some Kolkata centric so called bhadrolok of 19th century tried to imitate the control of Sanskrit Byakaran. Charyapad the most ancient bengali literature is considered the language of common rustic people.

Third, Bangladesh being the majority Bengali will dictate how Bangla culture will look like in future. Islamic or Hindu - It belongs to us, our choice.

Fourth, Bengalis are only 58% of Kolkata as stated in the OP. Gone are the days you trying to indicate. It is the epicenter of Marwari Colony now.

 

[Nilgiri]

Cmon, he clarified to me about this, this is from back when I was new

Just pointing it out to you what his inherent default nature is

 

[Species]

First, Bangladeshis are NOT Bengalis.

Second, Bangladeshis do not speak Bengali, they speak a hotchpotch of rustic Bengali with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert languages.

Third, Bangladeshis do not follow Bengali culture, they follow a hotchpotch of some Bengali culture with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert culture.

Kolkata is the only epicenter of genuine, classy Bengali language, culture, literature, music, movies, and art....all things that define a true Bengali.

Thank you.

Keep telling that to yourself if that makes you sleep well.

 

[AfrazulMandal]

First The Majority Bengalis in today's world are from Bangladesh. The world understands Bangladesh by the word "Bengali" . Kolkata neither have a flag nor freedom.

Second, Bengali language was always been rustic until some Kolkata centric so called bhadrolok of 19th century tried to imitate the control of Sanskrit Byakaran. Charyapad the most ancient bengali literature is considered the language of common rustic people.

Third, Bangladesh being the majority Bengali will dictate how Bangla culture will look like in future. Islamic or Hindu - It belongs to us, our choice.

Fourth, Bengalis are only 58% of Kolkata as stated in the OP. Gone are the days you trying to indicate. It is the epicenter of Marwari Colony now.

Slightly incorrect.

Bengali culture as we know it is itself decadent. It is basically Hindu.
Muslims in Bangladesh has progressed ONLY because it had slowly replaced it with what Hindus mock as Arabization.
Same with us in West bengal. Do we teach our kids about Iswar Chandra Vidyasagar? Hell no.

Keep telling that to yourself if that makes you sleep well.

My point is let Bengali Hindus be proud about 'their' Bengali. Bengali Hindus will either soon be extinct or be forced to live elsewhere.
We who remain will get to decide what Bengali is then.it may be Arabized. It may be this or that. But it will be ours. Kind of like how kashmiri Muslims got a chance to define Kashmiriat after the kashmiri Hindus left on their own. Similarly Bengali Muslims will have our own time in the sun.

Fourth, Bengalis are only 58% of Kolkata as stated in the OP. Gone are the days you trying to indicate. It is the epicenter of Marwari Colony now.

Bengali Hindus are 58 pc. There are some 30 pc Muslims and we are increasing while they are not.

 

[DarkPrince]

First, Bangladeshis are NOT Bengalis.

Second, Bangladeshis do not speak Bengali, they speak a hotchpotch of rustic Bengali with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert languages.

Third, Bangladeshis do not follow Bengali culture, they follow a hotchpotch of some Bengali culture with a large cocktail of Middle Eastern desert culture.

Kolkata is the only epicenter of genuine, classy Bengali language, culture, literature, music, movies, and art....all things that define a true Bengali.

Thank you.

You are not fully wrong. But define me Bengali culture? You mean idolatry ?

To me Bengali means who is a native to Bengal and speaks Bengali. That's it

Not interested in dhuti bindi wearing culture.

 

[Kandari-Hushiyaar]

Slightly incorrect.

Bengali culture as we know it is itself decadent. It is basically Hindu.

It is not. " Bengali " originated as the language of Buddhists during Pala empire. Sena Hindu dynasty tried to smother it by Promoting Sanskrit, Just like BJP does with Hindi. Then Muslim Sultans aggressively promoted Bengali which is the prime reason we speak Bengali today.
I do not find any "Hindu" in it. Just because Ford William college was situated in a Hindu majority area and it influenced Modern Bengali literature ---- Bengali culture doesnot become entirely " Hindu "

 

[dray / Rain Man]

In a century if not half, all of India will see a permanent demographic shift. Any further division initiated by us will lead to rest of the non Muslims banding together.

My point is let Bengali Hindus be proud about 'their' Bengali. Bengali Hindus will either soon be extinct or be forced to live elsewhere.
We who remain will get to decide what Bengali is then.it may be Arabized. It may be this or that. But it will be ours. Kind of like how kashmiri Muslims got a chance to define Kashmiriat after the kashmiri Hindus left on their own. Similarly Bengali Muslims will have our own time in the sun.

Not sure whether you are a delusional Bangladeshi troll or a delusional Muslim from West Bengal, but do note this; either you will die with your fantasies, or you will die trying.

 

[AfrazulMandal]

Not sure whether you are a delusional Bangladeshi troll or a delusional Muslim from West Bengal, but do note this; either you will die with your fantasies, or you will die trying.

Maldar aam khan.

Jadavpur e parle dekha korben.

 

[dray / Rain Man]

Maldar aam khan.

Jadavpur e parle dekha korben.

You are not of any importance for me to waste my time meeting you, you will survive as long as you keep your dreams as dreams.

 

[itsanufy]

Many Indians posing here as Bangladeshis too (false-flaggers). Try to initiate and carry on a conversation in Bengali then, ধরা খেয়ে যাবে|

I've thought about starting a thread with each 'Indian-sycophant' Bangladeshi poster to ask about how much 'Bangladeshi' Bangla they really know....

You don't know what we will find out.



I know - Bengali Hindus made a wrong choice unfortunately. That - and the targeted atrocities toward Hindus before 1971 did not help.

Look at how many Hindus that migrated to West Bengal have now started to come back home to Bangladesh. Wasn't the promised land of milk and honey at all, as they found out.

Speachless, day by day new Bangladeshis are coming..

Hindu Bengalis becoming extinct...
That is news?

Marwari der jonnei Tao tike ache era Kolkata te. Malda Dinajpur Murshidabad er moddhye amader. Ar kichudin er opekkha. Era sudhu Ekta jinish pare. Musolman der arale ghrina ar shamne polayon.

Most of the Fruit sellers in my area in Kolkata are Bangladeshis. Just saying.

First The Majority Bengalis in today's world are from Bangladesh. The world understands Bangladesh by the word "Bengali" . Kolkata neither have a flag nor freedom.

Second, Bengali language has always been rustic until some Kolkata centric so called bhadrolok of 19th century tried to imitate the control of Sanskrit Byakaran. Charyapad the most ancient bengali literature is considered the language of common rustic people.

Third, Bangladesh being the majority Bengali will dictate how Bangla culture will look like in future. Islamic or Hindu - It belongs to us, our choice.

Fourth, Bengalis are only 58% of Kolkata as stated in the OP. Gone are the days you trying to indicate. It is the epicenter of Marwari Colony now.

1. Its Bangladeshi and Bangali
2. Wrong, Charyapada was written in an Abahatta that was the common ancestor of Bengali, Assamese, Odia and Maithili. All of them consider it as their oldest form.
'Ka a Turubara Panchabi Dal A
Chanchal chitte Poitha Kal a'
Can a commoner understand the meaning. It was song of Buddhist Tantric or Vajrayana tradition.
3. That will emerge two diff culture, one Bangladeshi and another Bangali.
4. Marwaris are moving out of Kolkata to Mumbai which is economic epicenter now. It is Oriyas and Biharis which are non Bengali majority. But for your information still Hindi is not taught in West Bengal schools. We do speak a proper Bengali devoid of English words, we never say friend but bondhu or not five thousand but pach hazar.

You are not fully wrong. But define me Bengali culture? You mean idolatry ?

To me Bengali means who is a native to Bengal and speaks Bengali. That's it

Not interested in dhuti bindi wearing culture.

I have noticed here multiple time people are renouncing dhoti by saying its not part of Bengali culture.
Do you want some muslim names who were famous for dhoti who shaped the Bengali language and culture?

 

[AUSTERLITZ]

Bangladeshis are fake bengalis who follow a medieval arab tribal warlord with nothing to do with us or this land. The poor bangladeshis polevault over here and crowd our slums and create muslim ghettos by themselves.Bangladeshi cricket fans are acknowledged world over as the worst behaved jokers which is why even sri lankans who never liked us supported us and humiliated you .Bangladeshis have a chip on their shoulder,suffering from a little guy complex because they can never really be significant on the world stage and will always be just puppets in hands of greater powers as was proved in rohingya crisis when 'warrior' bengali muslims peed in their pants against tiny myanmar.If its was not for indian army they wouldn't even exist and would have been exterminated in 1971 and enslaved by punjabis and pathans,but their envy and communal hatred is deep.Jamati types in summary suffer from at once -identity crisis , envy ,communal hatred and inferiority complex.

 

[Black_cats]

Bangladeshis are fake bengalis who follow a medieval arab tribal warlord with nothing to do with us or this land. The poor bangladeshis polevault over here and crowd our slums and create muslim ghettos by themselves.Bangladeshi cricket fans are acknowledged world over as the worst behaved jokers which is why even sri lankans who never liked us supported us and humiliated you .Bangladeshis have a chip on their shoulder,suffering from a little guy complex because they can never really be significant on the world stage and will always be just puppets in hands of greater powers as was proved in rohingya crisis when 'warrior' bengali muslims peed in their pants against tiny myanmar.If its was not for indian army they wouldn't even exist and would have been exterminated in 1971 and enslaved by punjabis and pathans,but their envy and communal hatred is deep.Jamati types in summary suffer from at once -identity crisis , envy ,communal hatred and inferiority complex.

When and how you have become PDF think tank analyst kids?

@WebMaster do you have any criteria for selecting PDF Think Tank? Please read the post.

 

[Flynn Swagmire]

Bangladeshis are fake bengalis who follow a medieval arab tribal warlord with nothing to do with us or this land. The poor bangladeshis polevault over here and crowd our slums and create muslim ghettos by themselves.Bangladeshi cricket fans are acknowledged world over as the worst behaved jokers which is why even sri lankans who never liked us supported us and humiliated you .Bangladeshis have a chip on their shoulder,suffering from a little guy complex because they can never really be significant on the world stage and will always be just puppets in hands of greater powers as was proved in rohingya crisis when 'warrior' bengali muslims peed in their pants against tiny myanmar.If its was not for indian army they wouldn't even exist and would have been exterminated in 1971 and enslaved by punjabis and pathans,but their envy and communal hatred is deep.Jamati types in summary suffer from at once -identity crisis , envy ,communal hatred and inferiority complex.

Patience! We are very good at it...