What's new

Tesla’s semi-autonomous driving tech killed 11 people in the US in 12 months – report

beijingwalker

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 4, 2011
Messages
65,191
Reaction score
-55
Country
China
Location
China

Tesla’s semi-autonomous driving tech killed 11 people in the US in 12 months – report​

Tesla’s so-called ‘Autopilot’ and ‘Full Self-Driving’ assistance systems have been linked to more than 80 per cent of car crashes in the US which involved a vehicle using semi-autonomous technology, according to a landmark report.


Jordan Mulach
09:3019 June 2023

Tesla’s semi-autonomous driving tech killed 11 people in the US in 12 months – report

A US newspaper’s investigation into Tesla’s semi-autonomous driving technology has found the electric-car giant’s dodgy driver assistance systems were attributed to at least 11 fatal car crashes in less than a year – almost double the figure from the previous three years combined.

Earlier this week, respected newspaper The Washington Post published its report into car crashes in the US caused by semi-autonomous driving technology, using data reported to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) by auto-makers.

According to the report, since 2019 there have been 17 fatalities attributed to Tesla cars which were using semi-autonomous driving technology within 30 seconds of the crash.

While six fatalities were recorded between early 2019 and May 2022, The Washington Post reported the additional 11 deaths occurred in the following 11 months – an average of one road user killed per month.

In the US, Tesla offers three levels of advanced driver assistance systems to its customers – marketed as Autopilot, Enhanced Autopilot and Full Self-Driving.

Launched in 2015, ‘Autopilot’ is similar to a number of other semi-autonomous systems offered by car makers, providing ‘Level 2’ autonomous capabilities such as adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assistance.

‘Enhanced Autopilot’ claims to add functions such as automatic navigation, lane change and parking, while also allowing the car to be summoned by its owner.

In addition to Autopilot, ‘Full Self-Driving’ claims to add the ability to detect and stop for traffic signs and lights – meaning it can accelerate, stop, steer and park the car without human intervention.

The controversial Full Self-Driving system was released as a ‘beta’ service in September 2021, utilising real-time data gathered by Tesla’s customers on public roads to improve the system.

Full-Self Driving became publicly available – without approval from road safety regulators – to US owners of certain Tesla cars in November 2022 , though it was later recalled in February 2023 due to a fault which could cause the system to malfunction in certain situations.

All three of Tesla’s semi-autonomous driving systems require the driver to be attentive and keep their hands on the steering wheel in case they are required to respond to unforeseen scenarios or a failure of the technology.

NHTSA’s semi-autonomous car crash data does not detail which system was in use at the time of an incident, though Autopilot and Enhanced Autopilot have been the two most commonly used Tesla advanced driver assistance systems.

The Washington Post also found more than 90 per cent of crashes which were attributed to a vehicle being operated in its semi-autonomous driving mode had involved Tesla cars – however its reported figures do not line up with the data available on NHTSA’s website.

The publication reported Tesla cars were involved in 736 out of the 807 reported incidents between 2019 and mid-April 2023.

NHTSA data shows there have been 916 crashes between July 2021 and mid-April 2023 which meet the criteria.

Of the 916 incidents, 754 – or 82 per cent – of which were attributed to Tesla vehicles.

This represents a 10 per cent increase from NHTSA data collected between July 2021 and June 2022, which found Tesla vehicles accounted for 273 – or 70 per cent – of the 392 crashes in the 12-month period.

Since July 2021, Honda has been the second-most common car-maker in the NHTSA crash data with 108 reported incidents involving its semi-autonomous driving technology, followed by Subaru (23), Toyota (16) and BMW (eight).

 
NHTSA’s semi-autonomous car crash data does not detail which system was in use at the time of an incident, though Autopilot and Enhanced Autopilot have been the two most commonly used Tesla advanced driver assistance systems.

Correct, none have so far been attributed to the FSD BETA (Tesla's name for their street driving system)...all have been related to Autopilot (Tesla's name for their highway cruise control system).

Tesla Autopilot, new Advanced Autopilot & FSD compared​


It's amazing there is only 11 deaths with Autopilot considering many people are trusting it beyond its capabilities.
People stupidly falling asleep at the wheel on the highway while Autopilot is on.

Another highway Autopilot sleeper

Another highway Autopilot sleeper

Another highway Autopilot sleeper



Meanwhile...

Street driving with FSD BETA
 
Last edited:
It's amazing there is only 11 deaths with Autopilot considering many people are trusting it beyond its capabilities.
People stupidly falling asleep at the wheel on the highway while Autopilot is on.

thats the nature of the system , they must include mechanism to prevent driver from sleeping while auto pilot is engaged
 
They do..and people just spend alot of time figuring out hacks to get around it.

it seems they use a tactile sensor in steering wheel to detect if people are holding the wheel . wonder if it won't be better if they use an infrared sensor to see if somebody is holding the wheel
 
it seems they use a tactile sensor in steering wheel to detect if people are holding the wheel . wonder if it won't be better if they use an infrared sensor to see if somebody is holding the wheel

Then people would put a little heating element on the weight.

Tesla is constantly changing to get around hacks.

They now have resorted to using a camera with computer vision AI pointed at the driver. Things are just getting silly at the insane level they are taking to stop people from abusing the system. Back to the old adage "This is why we can't have good things..."

tesla-internal-camera.jpg

Note tiny camera in the plastic mount above rearview mirror.

May 13, 2023
 
Last edited:

Back
Top Bottom