What's new

Superjet accident darkens Russia's aviation dreams

harpoon

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jan 30, 2007
Messages
9,419
Reaction score
-1
Country
India
Location
Oman
MOSCOW: The loss of the new Superjet 100 in Indonesia has dealt a heavy blow to the Russian aviation industry which hoped the first new civilian aircraft built in post-Soviet Russia would improve its image.

The Superjet 100, developed by legendary Russian planemaker Sukhoi, first took to the skies in 2008 and only started commercial flights last year in what officials hoped would mark a turnaround for the industry.

Russian aviation is still shadowed by stereotypes of oddly-shaped and disaster-prone Soviet planes but the Superjet was a brand new project aimed at presenting a gleaming new image of Russian technical prowess to the world.

In a horrific irony, the accident happened when the plane was performing a test flight in Jakarta for guests including foreign aviation executives while on its first tour of Asia to drum up more orders in the region.

"This tragic accident represents a further setback to the ambitious Russian civilian aerospace industry," Fitch Ratings said, adding that it expected orders would be negatively hit in the short term.

"Over the past decade the Russian state has invested heavily in the sector in the hope of re-establishing the country as a global technology and high-end manufacturing leader," it said.

The plane is intended to replace the Tupolev 134, the workhorse of Soviet short-haul aviation, which was involved in several disasters in the last decade and which many airlines such as Aeroflot have now withdrawn from service.

The Russian government has championed the $1 billion Superjet project, wooing Italian industrial giant Finmeccanica to take a stake, and, whatever the cause of the incident, this support is likely to remain strong.

"What has happened will definitely slow down the programme and cause some reputational damage," the director of the Centre for Strategic Analysis and Technology Ruslan Pukhov told the Izvestia daily.

"But the programme is not going to come to a halt. And the Superjet is still going to be sold both on the domestic and foreign markets."

Just over half a dozen Superjets are currently flying commercially, mostly for Aeroflot on short-haul routes such as from Moscow to Minsk and from Moscow to Nizhny Novgorod but also for Armenian carrier Armavia.

It was Armavia that made the first commercial flight on a Superjet in 2011, shortly followed by Aeroflot, which now mainly operates Airbus and Boeing jets after ditching the Tupolev.

In a sign of its commitment to the Superjet, Aeroflot announced it was flying its fleet of planes on a normal schedule.

Sukhoi has inked in recent months a 12-jet sale to Italy's Blue Panorama Airlines and a 15-plane deal with Mexico's Interjet as well as an agreement to sell 12 planes to Indonesian regional carrier PT Sky Aviation.

Fitch said that while a total of 170 orders have been placed, the numbers purchased remain short of the programme break-even point. Further orders outside the (former Sovier Union) are vital to its success."

"We are still hoping that the incident in Jakarta will not have an influence on Superjet orders," an official from the Russian Industry and Trade Ministry told the Vedomosti daily.

The loss of the plane has sent shockwaves through the Russian aviation industry, with press reports saying the pilot Alexander Yablontsev was hugely experienced and was considered Sukhoi's leading test pilot for the Superjet.

The Superjet project is a joint venture between Sukhoi and Italy's Alenia Aeronautica, which is part of Italy's partially state-owned Finmeccanica.

Alenia owns 25% plus one share of Sukhoi Civil Aircraft, the Sukhoi unit developing the jet, as well as 51% of Superjet International, which is handling sales of the aircraft.


_________________________________________________________________________

Hope Sukhoi could bounce back from this tragedy.
 
.
I am not sure a 100 percent but is not india's and china's civilian aircraft ambitions based largely on Russian technologies?
 
. .
there was no fault with the jet so i HOPE it shouldn't affects the sale.

i read an article and it said that pilot was flying around 3000m and he requested to drop down to 1600m or so. the volcanic mountain was in the area which was over 2000m tall.

human error was the cause of the incident.
unless they find something later on..
 
.
Sukhoi will bounce back from this setback and come back more stronger. This will be valuable lesson in the learning curve.
 
.
Feel sad about the guests on board :(
RIP to all victims.
Hope it's just human error only
 
.
I am not sure a 100 percent but is not india's and china's civilian aircraft ambitions based largely on Russian technologies?
india has delusions. China has its own civilian aircraft industry. Our Y-20 heavy transport is entering service next year.
 
. .
Accidents happen to anyone.
We do not know if this was an accident. In aviation, the initial call is 'mishap' or 'incident'. Not 'disaster' or 'catastrophe' or anything so hyperbolic and emotional. But simply 'mishap'. Then after proper investigations are done, it may be further detailed as 'accident' or a 'design flaw' or a 'manufacturing defect'. It is too early to tell at this time.
 
.
Hate to say it... but I think China's Y-20 will be more reliable and cost effective.
 
.
Russians have to take some time to refurbish its outdated tech in all fields.

Russian plane accidents has topped the world for how many years? It's not even news today. This is not including those tragedies among Russian air force with all sorts of covering stories, which are unknown to the world.

RIP to those lost in the down.
 
.
Hate to say it... but I think China's Y-20 will be more reliable and cost effective.

Y-20 is a military aircraft.

Also, Russia doesn't have a great record when it comes to commercial aircraft safety.

But as far as this tragic incident is concerned, I think it's too early to conclude anything right now.
 
.
Y-20 is a military aircraft.

Also, Russia doesn't have a great record when it comes to commercial aircraft safety.

But as far as this tragic incident is concerned, I think it's too early to conclude anything right now.

I disagree. Compared to the number of aircrafts they operate, they have a low accident rate when compared to western ones..but Russians suffer from bad press all the time.
 
.
I disagree. Compared to the number of aircrafts they operate, they have a low accident rate when compared to western ones..but Russians suffer from bad press all the time.

To be more specific, I wasn't referring to military aviation safety.

I specifically mentioned commercial aviation. And Russia's air safety is below international standards.

Russia and the former Soviet republics combined for one of the world's worst air-traffic safety records last year, with a total accident rate almost three times the world average, according to the International Air Transport Association.

IATA said in December that global airline safety rates had improved in 2011 but that the rate had risen in Russia and the CIS group of former Soviet republics.

Gunther Matschnigg, IATA senior vice-president for safety, said a key problem in Russia was that pilots and ground technicians were having to adapt to a growing number of a highly sophisticated aircraft.

He said Russian aviation officials and political leaders had accepted that pilot training needed rapid improvement.
Russian plane crash kills 31, exposes safety record | Reuters

Safety*

The top priority is always safety. Russia’s hull loss rate for Western-built aircraft shows no hull losses in 2009 and 2010. The record was broken this year, with one tragic accident that claimed five lives. IATA’s Operational Safety Audit (IOSA)has helped with this tremendous improvement. From just a few years ago, when Russia had one of the highest hull loss rates in the world, today the thirteen biggest Russian airlines are on the registry, including of course all nine IATA members. None of these carriers has had a fatal accident in the last three years.

But safety remains an issue, with three accidents this year with Russian-built aircraft, and nine last year. We have standards within IOSA for modern Russian aircraft, which comply with the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) standards, and we encourage FATA—the Federal Air Transport Authority - to move quickly to deal with aircraft still in service that do not comply with ICAO’s standards.

Charges

I have also come to Moscow with a strong appeal for Russia to adopt global standards for airport and air navigation charges. For various historical reasons
Russia charges foreign carriers more to use airports and air navigation services than it does Russian carriers. Now it’s time to stop this practice and focus on cost efficiency, with effective economic regulation, and equal charges for all carriers.

This can be achieved through more open consultation between airlines, and both FATA and the State Air Traffic Management Corporation. The more that they understand airlines’ needs, the better we will be able to plan for top-class cost efficient services.
Press Conference, Moscow
Press Conference, Moscow

That's all from IATA. Not me or the Western press.
 
. .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom