Falconless
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 13, 2020
- Messages
- 1,547
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
@mods this thread has become a sub-sectarian dick measuring contest.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Don't try to jump around with your tail caught in the trap. On the matter of demolishing a mosque, both Barelvis and Deobandis have the same views.
Ah. Blame it on Jews as well when you are at it.Insha Allah this Qadiyani wet dream will never come to pass.
Tell this to Saudi Government about Kaaba and let me know what they say, try that gimmick in badshahi Mosque or Faisal Masjid and tell me what happens next.In case you don't know, Mosques belongs to no one, not even the government. Within the mosque, the diktats and writ of the government do not hold. Only Allah's Law applies inside a mosque.
there is another way too sir
i was grown up a small town where there is almost every sect and many hindus too . all i see in my childhood we was not learn hate and secterianism as elders did not teach is .
we go hindu marriages
we go ashoura jaloos and eat drink
we go rajbis
and we go to milaad shareef and 11ween shareef too .
this sectarian issue is 1400 years old no Pakistani not all of us can solve it . all we can do try to teach our kids not to discriminate hate and have say bad to any faith . just live with it in peace . do not give them identity like deobandi brlvi shia sunni teach them we are muslims and everyone have own way to pray to god but we all worship same god
ohh man even my family was deobandi i love so much of sufism but since thsi tlp and labbaik started i have washed my hands from them .
As for the mosque, I, for one, do not agree with the SC decision. But the law of the land has to be followed in any case. Those inciting rebellion against the state on this matter are guilty of trying to spread Fasad Fil Arz and if things spiral out of control and lives are lost, their punishment is very clear, at least as per the Holy Qur'an
@CriticalThought You said that praying behind a Deobandi Imam is your right (Well i wouldn't force you to pray behind non deobandi Imam) but please tell me how you guys do Hajj? Do you stand behind Imam e Kaaba or ask for a deobandi Imam e Kaaba?
Khan sb you are spot on. However sectarianism in this country has reached to new level which is absent in my other muslim countries. In Pakistan, you cannot be called a true muslim by your sect unless you call another sect non muslim. Our identity of being a muslim is not based on our acts rather slogans of hate towards others.
Unfortunately, Pakistan has given a lot of unnecessary space to sectarian agendas and it is making this country suffer.
thank you for enlighten we will InshAllah change lahores name to khadim-abad or rizvi-abad
Ah. Blame it on Jews as well when you are at it.
Tell this to Saudi Government about Kaaba and let me know what they say, try that gimmick in badshahi Mosque or Faisal Masjid and tell me what happens next.
Aray yar with azizabad wil need nine zero who would want “the mendak “ in a peaceful place .. another thought says why not both burqina azizi and fat toad can live toghether peacefullyAnd change the Islamabad as Azizabad on name of Maulana Abdul Aziz of Lal masjid for such day and night struggle & sacrifices.
We are largely in agreement here, except I am maintaining that current 'Law of the Land' is that there IS no law in this land, and this is the incompetence of multiple governments and a situation that is ripe for trouble. When such a situation arises, it is the enemies of State and Islam who start talking about Imposing the Writ of State. Those are exactly the terrorist, fasaadi elements.
This would literally be the biggest development to happen in Pakistan. Not them J-10Cs, not CPEC, but fixing these brainwashed people's minds. I see no hope for Pakistan if this, or something similar, is not done.There should be fewer places of worship but of a higher quality building and Imams who are vetted. There should be an Imam register managed by the government and they must pass the "I am not a TLP/sectarian/political activist" test.
Who knows in how many shacks, youtube brainwashed imams are preaching so they can finally say to themselves "I am an important person in life, people listen to me".
And you know controversy is what these folk thrive on, they want the attention. They want the opportunity to make a big deal, it feeds their delusions of importance. Lal Masjid is a perfect example of this.
You need to understand your demography, when an English guy red pills he might become a racist, or ultra nationalist. An American guy red pills and they might become a Trump supporter or become a follower of QAnon. In Germany he might become a nazi revivalist. In Japan, he might kill himself when he realises the futility of an overworked, under-stimulated Tokyo life. In Syria he might become ISIS.
Even on this forum you can tell the aggressive and triggered ones,
Do you see what I mean? In every society there is a section of people who red pill and think they know the truth.
Unfortunately in Pakistan as it is Islam dominated, the red pill usually leads them down the extremist path and in a unregulated place like Pakistan these fantasies become violent because the terrorist organisations understood this early on and used it as a tool to destabilize and curated the content to lead these people down this path.
Taking law into one's own hands on the pretext of poor governance / ineffectiveness of law enforcement etc. can never be justified. We are a functioning state and this kind of attitude will only lead towards anarchy and Fasad. Writ of the state has to be established in any case, but unwarranted use of power is highly inadvisable. This matter could have been easily resolved by providing compensation/alternate land to shift the mosque (or by allotting alternate space for the public park) .. It was KMC after all that allowed that mosque to be built there (and stay there for 25 years) .. .. Yes, there are some enemies of the state (and religion) who want unrest and violence. And those enemies include the Mullahs who are inciting rebellion and bloodshed.
Now here is the real kicker. Case law is also part of law and Supreme Court's decision basically adds to the body of law in Pakistan. So far, the SC seems quite open to the prospect of providing an alternate piece of land, and as my OP suggests, I am of the opinion that this opportunity should be grasped so we can finally obtain a legalized piece of land. It would even more brilliant if the government simply legalizes the exact same piece of land. That would be quite smart and forward thinking on the part of the government. And this is the very premise of this thread. Of course, my personal opinions are void if they contradict the Fatwa from Muftian-e-Kiraam.
BUT, the question needs to be asked: in allocating an alternate piece of land, do the Supreme Court and Government realize that a mosque is for all eternity? This very important point needs to be addressed and acknowledged by these authorities as well.
We maybe entitled to our opinions regarding law/judgements but it is The Supreme Court of Pakistan that is the Court of ultimate appeal and final arbiter of deciding all civil and criminal disputes and interpreting the law and the Constitution.
We do agree on what should have happened ... But we disagree on what should happen next as the SC judgement is not what we had wished for. Picking up arms against the state or threatening the state to submit is no solution in my opinion
Taking law into one's own hands on the pretext of poor governance / ineffectiveness of law enforcement etc. can never be justified. We are a functioning state and this kind of attitude will only lead towards anarchy and Fasad. Writ of the state has to be established in any case, but unwarranted use of force is highly inadvisable. This matter could have been easily resolved by providing compensation/alternate land to shift the mosque (or by allotting alternate space for the public park) .. It was KMC after all that allowed that mosque to be built there (and stay there for 25 years) .. .. Yes, there are some enemies of the state (and religion) who want unrest and violence. And those enemies include the Mullahs who are inciting rebellion and bloodshed.