Consider the following: If one considers Islam as a religion for all times to come, then it must be capable of change to keep itself relevant. Not the basics of course, but the application of those basic must remain flexible, otherwise it fossilizes itself into gradual irrelevance. For example, how would a Muslim fast on the poles or in orbit? Clearly, the old interpretations of sehri and iftari timings can not hold true.
Similarly, Islam is only what Muslims do. There can be no separating the actions of its followers from the motivation provided by the religion.
I would no problem accepting your pontification were it not for the fact that religious threads and material have been long tolerated and indeed promoted if they are of the approved variety. Witness the posts by
@revol in the Member's section, and the plethora of Ramadan threads soon to come. Indeed, there are several title holders who enforce the same tyranny of strangulating thought that permeates throughout the Muslim world today, with similar consequences.
Or perhaps I can expect you to enforce the same rule with equal effectiveness when I point out religious threads and posts here?