Society, Women and Behashti Zewar

[Secur]

you can read Thanvi the way you like.

Hell no Maulana Thanvi didn't write vague predictions like Nostradamus. He states what he envisions or advises, very clearly.

 

[FaujHistorian]

Hell no Maulana Thanvi didn't write vague predictions like Nostradamus. He states what he envisions or advises, very clearly.

off course.

That is the definition of religious education. Knowledge is not bound by any such considerations, and education is better defined as the pursuit of knowledge.

Oh baba.

How many among Pakistani women (sometimes more than 60%) in higher education are obeying your or Thanvi's interpretation?

If someone tells a university educated married/grown up women today that she must know not to cheat or lie.

Is that religious education or moral or modern?

Take your pick please.

 

[VCheng]

How many among Pakistani women (sometimes more than 60%) in higher education are obeying your or Thanvi's interpretation?

A better question to ask is what percentage of the total number of women actually make it to a university? The vast majority still fall under the same retrogressive mentality as that espoused by books like BZ.

 

[FaujHistorian]

A better question to ask is what percentage of the total number of women actually make it to a university? The vast majority still fall under the same retrogressive mentality as that espoused by books like BZ.

look bhai jaan

I am talking about women who can read and understand and thus get impacted by the BZ.

Hope you understand now.

 

[VCheng]

look bhai jaan

I am talking about women who can read and understand and thus get impacted by the BZ.

Hope you understand now.

You mean women with a pre-12th grade education? The numbers still remain horrible. Besides to be affected by BZ, they do not have to read it themselves, but merely be in a household where BZ thinking holds, reinforced by patriarchal and matriarchal authority.

 

[FaujHistorian]

You mean women with a pre-12th grade education? The numbers still remain horrible. Besides to be affected by BZ, they do not have to read it themselves, but merely be in a household where BZ thinking holds, reinforced by patriarchal and matriarchal authority.

[HASHTAG]#227[/HASHTAG]

Thank you

 

[VCheng]

[HASHTAG]#227[/HASHTAG]

Thank you

What about it? The point is that merely looking at university going women is misleading, since the effect on all women is what is important.

 

[FaujHistorian]

What about it? The point is that merely looking at university going women is misleading, since the effect on all women is what is important.

So no answer.

 

[VCheng]

So no answer.

Answered correctly, with your disingenuity exposed.

 

[FaujHistorian]

Answered correctly, with your disingenuity exposed.

??????

 

[VCheng]

Has anybody read this book that might be relevant to the present thread?

A Gift for Muslim Women (Tohfae Khawateen)

ISBN: 8171013759
Author: Maulana Ashiq Elahi Madani
Publisher: Idara Publishers
Pages: 931 Binding: Hardback

"After Bahishti Zewar, this is the fist concise and most detailed book the subject of which is women and their problems. The work is beneficial for all though it is addressed particularly to women. Special effort has been made to compile the traditions originally reported by women, and problems too are those connected with women. However, as necessary, Ahadith reported by men have also been included. There are also disputations because the purpose is to counsel and guide. The chapters are arranged somewhat as follows. First there is the Book of Faith, Kitab ul Iman, then, Ablution and Bath, Sala’t, Zaka’t, Fasting, Hajj, Virtues of al Quran, Remembrance and Prayers, Marriage, Divorce, Bringing up children, etc."