What's new

Singapore PM: Japan should admit mistake, China and Korea should stop repeatedly asking for apology

Joined
Jun 22, 2013
Messages
3,180
Reaction score
-45
Country
Singapore
Location
Singapore
Lee urges Japan to come clean on WWII atrocities | The Japan Times

Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong has urged Japan to admit to its misdeeds from World War II so it can play a more active role in the region.

“Japan needs to acknowledge past wrongs, and Japanese public opinion needs to be more forthright in rejecting the more outrageous interpretations of history by right-wing academics and politicians,”

“Japan has already expressed remorse or apologies for the war in general terms,” he said. “But on specific issues like the ‘comfort women’ and the Nanjing Massacre, its positions have been less unequivocal.”

He observed that even though this year is the 70th anniversary of the end of WWII, it “continues to cast a shadow over relations between the old adversaries, in particular between Japan and its neighbors China and Korea.”

“After 70 years, it is past the time to put this history behind us properly, like the Europeans have done. This requires statesmanship and largeness of spirit on both sides.”

While Beijing and Seoul do not think Tokyo has done enough to atone for the suffering caused by its aggression, Lee urged them to “accept Japan’s acknowledgements and not demand that Japan apologize over and over again.”

“The history of the war should not be used to put Japan on the defensive or to perpetuate enmities to future generations,” he said. “Such a reconciliation will also help Japan to become a normal country if it wishes to be.”


n-singapore-a-20150531-870x827.jpg
 
.
and he should mind his own business.
(BTW Japanese army killed almost 10,000 indians during WW2)
 
. .
“The history of the war should not be used to put Japan on the defensive or to perpetuate enmities to future generations,” he said. “Such a reconciliation will also help Japan to become a normal country if it wishes to be.”


Pertinent and true!!
 
.
220px-Subhas_Chandra_Bose.jpg


Netaji is mostly responsible, not Japan.

Indian biggest hero Netaji killed the 10,000 of your guys and you guys still lick him up till this days.
no regrets about it...netaji was a true patriot, even todays indian army follow the the legacy of netajis INA rather than brits and sings their marching song...
 
.
no regrets about it...netaji was a true patriot, even todays indian army follow the the legacy of netajis INA rather than brits and sings their marching song...


The INA was a true anti colonialist force and the very manifestation of Indian pro independence movement against British colonial yoke. Their ranks fought nobly and honorably.
 
.
Japan alrealy missed the opportunity of properly apologising long ago.
Every 10th anniversary only bring more pressure on Japan.
Even if Japan apologised now, it will not have any meaning.
 
.
The INA was a true anti colonialist force and the very manifestation of Indian pro independence movement against British colonial yoke. Their ranks fought nobly and honorably.
true..some 30 thousand troops marching against 4 million strong british indian army and strongest empire on earth was never meant for victory..it was just an spark which netaji thought will convert into fire...and it will..as the kamikaze use to say .." i have no regrets ".
 
.
true..some 30 thousand troops marching against 4 million strong british indian army and strongest empire on earth was never meant for victory..it was just an spark which netaji thought will convert into fire...and it will..as the kamikaze use to say .." i have no regrets ".

The honor of their fight will live on for eternity, and one can say they helped to spark the ultimate collapse of British empire in Indian Subcontinent.

Japan alrealy missed the opportunity of properly apologising long ago.
Every 10th anniversary only bring more pressure on Japan.
Even if Japan apologised now, it will not have any meaning.

You don't know that. Besides we've been apologizing now through bilateral framework. Your own country , Malaysia, recently signed a strategic partnership with Japan this week when Najib visited Tokyo. :)

:)

Merdeka! Jepang Malaysia!
 
.
and he should mind his own business.
(BTW Japanese army killed almost 10,000 indians during WW2)

And you should mind your own. He is in Asia Pacific, and his recommendations were very good, depicting the scene as it is.

@Nihonjin1051 My friend, I was disappointed that you upvoted this. Especially when Japan is essentially taking exactly the reverse stance. It is going all across the region, and not minding its own business.

And anyways my friend, it would be wise to follow Lee Hsien Loong's words.

Also, what views do you personally hold about the Nanjing Massacre?

Pertinent and true!!

Only you missed the first part completely. To get a society wide apology for Nanjing and comfort women. And a pointed apology, for these issues.

Japan alrealy missed the opportunity of properly apologising long ago.
Every 10th anniversary only bring more pressure on Japan.
Even if Japan apologised now, it will not have any meaning.

No. It will. It is never too late. Only the apology should be nation wide, felt by the society, and honest. It must also not skirt any issue.

You don't know that. Besides we've been apologizing now through bilateral framework. Your own country , Malaysia, recently signed a strategic partnership with Japan this week when Najib visited Tokyo. :)

:)

Merdeka! Jepang Malaysia!


Apology to Malaysia doesn't mean much. More than 95% of all damage and hurt was done to the people of Korea and China. It is they who need an apology and a honest one at that. Not the general rhetoric of Murayama statement, where half of the LDP is turning over ambiguous at even that mild thing.

A point blank, direct recognition of horrors. The location that would be most suitable will be Abe at the Nanjing Massacre Memorial.
 
. .
While Beijing and Seoul do not think Tokyo has done enough to atone for the suffering caused by its aggression, Lee urged them to “accept Japan’s acknowledgements and not demand that Japan apologize over and over again.”

Lee's 'advice' presupposes that Japan has indeed made acknowledgments, and that our forgiveness should be conditional on such acknowledgments being made. In reality though, I don't foresee Japan making such acknowledgments anytime in the near future. In practice, Lee's 'advice' makes only nominal, symbolic recommendations towards China and S. Korea, and but actually operates as a unilateral demand towards Japan.
 
.
Why should Japan apologize?

Because it did gory horrific genocidal rampage?

Because its two closest neighbors, and even @Nihonjin1051 would agree, its brothers, cultural, spiritual, can't get over the memories of that rampage?

Because it would like to actually have good relations with its two neighbors, and get along?

Because it would eventually like to integrate into some sort of East Asian Market and Alliance, so that they can kick *** together, and not be easily used as tools to contain each other?
 
.
This thread, by coincidence or by design, is exactly the same as # @48 of my posting on this thread: Singapore Prime Minister Encourages U.S. Role in Asia | Page 4
except, as I have pointed out in # 48 that Lee have missed out the red wordings

“Japan has already expressed remorse or apologies for the war in general terms,” he said. “But on specific issues like the ‘comfort women’ and the Nanjing Massacre, its positions have been less unequivocal.” (edit: and Chemical weapons the Unit 731: Unit 731 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia ; imperial money etc)

Talking is cheap. We want to see actions on the part of the Japanese.
 
.
You don't know that. Besides we've been apologizing now through bilateral framework. Your own country , Malaysia, recently signed a strategic partnership with Japan this week when Najib visited Tokyo. :)

:)

Merdeka! Jepang Malaysia!

Every single word of Japan official "Regret" has to be approved by your parliament. If your PM as much as used the wrong word, he will be in trouble.
That's how sincere Japan "Regret" is.

Jepang is Indonesian. Malay is Jepun.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom