Sing Vande Mataram or quit India: BJP to Muslim corporators

[ThinkLogically]

Thank you.

Our people sing "neeradum kadaluduyththa..." in TN gov functions,

Tamil nationalists sing "engal vaazvum ... " in some functions.

Yean daa vunaku saadharana paechu vaarthai yellam paesa theriyaatha? Parupaati papaya.

 

[xairhossi]

Southern darkies. Many are dalits and the most virulent lot. Though they will not admit to it online.

Bengalis can be a pain too. But in the current pecking order, a long way down.

The really militant Hindus from the north and west. You will not hear them. You'll be clashing swords and choppers with them when the time comes ...

These internet studs are a joke. Guys like this Dinesh especially. Laugh it off.

Nahh, Hindu nationalism developed in Bengal in the late 19th and early 20th century, by Bengali figures like Swami Viveknanda etc. This was after the British used to look down upon and revile the " Bengali Babus" as they called them while praising the Punjabis, Pathans, Sikhs etc. so they developed Hindu nationalism with a focus on " Vedic or Aryan" identity. Ironically, the British used to call the people of the North-West as Aryan derived or something while the Bengalis/Central Indians/South Indians were called aboriginal Dravidian or whatever.

 

[adil_minhas]

Nahh, Hindu nationalism developed in Bengal in the late 19th and early 20th century, by Bengali figures like Swami Viveknanda etc. This was after the British used to look down upon and revile the " Bengali Babus" as they called them while praising the Punjabis, Pathans, Sikhs etc. so they developed Hindu nationalism with a focus on " Vedic or Aryan" identity. Ironically, the British used to call the people of the North-West as Aryan derived or something while the Bengalis/Central Indians/South Indians were called aboriginal Dravidian or whatever.

Thanks for the lesson in history.

I'm telling you what it is today.

Kudos.

 

[xairhossi]

He He He. Shows how shallow your knowledge is.

Tagore did not write Vande Mataram. It was written by another bengali Bankim Chandra Chatterjee. Tagore wrote our National Anthem Jana Gana Mana

However that does not prove that Bengalis are Hindutva Followers. The exact opposite is the case

Bengal is one state where BJP has never been in power - Ever

It was ruled by leftists for decades and now ruled by Mamta Bannerjee. Both are as opposed the BJP and Hindutva as possible

If Bengalis were pro Hindutva at some point of time BJP would have formed the govt or atleast won a good no of seats.

In 2016 elections to state assembly BJP won a grand total of 3 seats out of 295. This was the best performance of BJP ever. Its previous avatar Bharatiya Jana Sangh had won 9 seats at its best performance.

http://www.oneindia.com/kolkata/bjp-wins-highest-tally-in-bengal-since-bjs-in-1952-2103277.html

Bengalis consider themselves as "Intellectuals" and Liberals. They are total opposite of Hindutva

So what is happening is Hindutva Revivalism not Bengali Revivalism

I never said Tagore wrote Vande Mataram, read it carefully. I said Tagore was a Hindu nationalist and Bengali and so was the writer of the Vande Matram, not that Tagore was the writer. And Hindu nationalism originated in Bengal, created by Bengalis to counter their " Bengali Babu" image and to try and appear as some sort of macho "Vedic Aryan warriors"

 

[A.A. Khan]

Extremely sad and painful to see, Indian muslim looks rudderless, leaderless. All these topi drama jokers Owaisis and Azam Khans are self-serving opportunists.

170-180+ million muslims is not a 'community', equivalent or more than the populations of France, Germany and Spain combined. Its a nation. Same issues, same events being repeated on a cycle with same intentions as 1937-1939.
The more I read about the systematic persecution of muslims in india today, I went back to re-read the Pirpur Report (1939) on the Congress rule 1937-39, same things same issues and in most places more worse conditions than at that time
"I have declared on numerous occasions that we Mussalmans are a nation [not a community or minority] but when in my letter to Mr. Gandhi recently I made this statement, he said all his hopes on Hindu-Muslim Unity had been dashed.The question is what are the hopes of Mr. Gandhi and what does he mean by Hindu-Muslim Unity? Mr. Gandhi's hope is to subjugate and vassalise the Muslims under a Hindu raj. I have resisted it with all the power at any commandand, therefore, I am condemned as the worst Mussalman in the country........ It was no use depending upon anybody. We must depend upon ourselves... I appeal to you to put your shoulders together and work with the Muslim League. Stand firm as one solid block of steel, go on organizing our people, training them, disciplining them. They are with us..... Organize the muslims, bring them all together, train them, drill them, and make of them one of the most wonderful political army that india has ever seen and we will soon reach the goal of freedom. " M.A. Jinnah, Aligarh March 6 1940

 

[saurav jha]

Yes. Mine.

no my friend. your land is saudi arebia. this is Hindustan. land of Hindus.

 

[hussain0216]

Extremely sad and painful to see, Indian muslim looks rudderless, leaderless. All these topi drama jokers Owaisis and Azam Khans are self-serving opportunists.

170-180+ million muslims is not a 'community', equivalent or more than the populations of France, Germany and Spain combined. Its a nation. Same issues, same events being repeated on a cycle with same intentions as 1937-1939.
The more I read about the systematic persecution of muslims in india today, I went back to re-read the Pirpur Report (1939) on the Congress rule 1937-39, same things same issues and in most places more worse conditions than at that time
"I have declared on numerous occasions that we Mussalmans are a nation [not a community or minority] but when in my letter to Mr. Gandhi recently I made this statement, he said all his hopes on Hindu-Muslim Unity had been dashed.The question is what are the hopes of Mr. Gandhi and what does he mean by Hindu-Muslim Unity? Mr. Gandhi's hope is to subjugate and vassalise the Muslims under a Hindu raj. I have resisted it with all the power at any commandand, therefore, I am condemned as the worst Mussalman in the country........ It was no use depending upon anybody. We must depend upon ourselves... I appeal to you to put your shoulders together and work with the Muslim League. Stand firm as one solid block of steel, go on organizing our people, training them, disciplining them. They are with us..... Organize the muslims, bring them all together, train them, drill them, and make of them one of the most wonderful political army that india has ever seen and we will soon reach the goal of freedom. " M.A. Jinnah, Aligarh March 6 1940

Jinnah was a genius

no my friend. your land is saudi arebia. this is Hindustan. land of Hindus.

You have to partition hindustan o indian muslims can have a safe state

 

[saurav jha]

You have to partition hindustan o indian muslims can have a safe state

this is not Gandhi's India. we will kill anyone who tries to divide our country. we will kill 200 million people to keep our country united.

 

[hussain0216]

this is not Gandhi's India. we will kill anyone who tries to divide our country. we will kill 200 million people to keep our country united.

200 million will be enough to fight back

When you have isolated small villages and towns they can be attacked, but muslims in numbers of a few million plus can defend themselves and this will be the basis of Partition

Kashmir will also cede totally as they can see the Hindutva slide

And you have Pakistan to support and supply weapons to the defenseless indian muslims

 

[adil_minhas]

no my friend. your land is saudi arebia. this is Hindustan. land of Hindus.

Ok. Bigger off now. Corpses await your gentle passion.

 

[AKD]

200 million will be enough to fight back

When you have isolated small villages and towns they can be attacked, but muslims in numbers of a few million plus can defend themselves and this will be the basis of Partition

Kashmir will also cede totally as they can see the Hindutva slide

And you have Pakistan to support and supply weapons to the defenseless indian muslims

In 1999 and 2002 Muslims couldn't save themselves from stick and sword holding hindus...
What they will do now???
Beg for mercy again?

 

[hussain0216]

In 1999 and 2002 Muslims couldn't save themselves from stick and sword holding hindus...
What they will do now???
Beg for mercy again?

They were unarmed and heavily outnumbered

But 200 million is enough numbers to defend their core and partition india

 

[AKD]

They were unarmed and heavily outnumbered

But 200 million is enough numbers to defend their core and partition india

If They can't handle villagers with sticks how they are going to handle army???
I believe they would be first to run away or surrender

 

[Mangus Ortus Novem]

Improvisation you mean? I guess as a mirasi you are more adept with that talent. I defer to your superior knowledge on the subject.

What is 'mirasi', if do not minding translating in English. Thanks!

 

[saurav jha]

Ok. Bigger off now. Corpses await your gentle passion.

ok