Sikhs and Kashmiris Demand Indian Exit from Punjab and J&K

[mahesh.]

and do you really think that those Sikh are allowed to protest in india ??
do you even remember what your govt do in Operation blue star ?

Do you think protesting on streets in India is hard. We have hundred of street protests every day.

 

[rockstar08]

Few Nutbags, backed by foreign mercenaries, don't represent us... We are not divided, we are united. For us India is Khalistan, Sikhs Land of Pure.

obviously a sikh who is living in india , consider his land a holy ...
but what my point is that , i dont think india will allow a big protest in favor of khalistan ,
at least those sikh who are not in favor of that Operation , and they still have memories when the Genocide of Sikhs, breaks out after indra assassination

Do you think protesting on streets in India is hard. We have hundred of street protests every day.

no i dont think so , but there is something that those sikhs fear about ? may the memories from the aftermath of indra killing

 

[mahesh.]

no i dont think so , but there is something that those sikhs fear about ? may the memories from the aftermath of indra killing

Sir , think practically. You think the brave men from Punjab are afraid of some thing. Even a beggar in India is not afraid of anything to protest. There is no such thing as fear. They do not protest because Khalistan movement does not sell in India. They will not have support from any political parties, social activists, or any media group. Because Sikhs are not persecuted . They are one of richest communities in India. One single incident does not take away facts. There may some kind of jingoism, and feeling to be a Sikh in youth or children. But that disappears once you become aware of things going on in country.

 

[paritosh]

Pure sikh is khalistani sikh jatt (provided he was kept save from desperate biharans) Khalis mean pure.

That single statement is the reason why Pakistan and Bangladesh are happily not together and we have online discussions about possible secession sentiments in India which still holds together as a country in spite of having the world's largest diversity and a plethora of problems.
The day Pakistanis stop seeing other people as 'baniya', 'bhaiya', 'kufr', 'ahmdiya', 'shia', 'mohajir'... will be the day all your problems will become a lot more bearable.
India is not the perfect country, but take a leaf out of our book in terms of tolerance.

 

[Parul]

i told you that i have see in Documentary , i can provide the link of that Documentary if you want

To learn about Khalistan, I've seen Documentaries & sharing it's links is of no use...

obviously a sikh who is living in india , consider his land a holy ...
but what my point is that , i dont think india will allow a big protest in favor of khalistan ,
at least those sikh who are not in favor of that Operation , and they still have memories when the Genocide of Sikhs, breaks out after indra assassination

Their is only one nutbag political party who favors Kahlista & they don't have any support in Punjab. I've seen them chanting Khalistan Zindabad at Golden Temple. This was even reported in Print and Electronic Media. This prooves they are allowed to protest. The problem is only handful of nutbags take these nutbags seriously.

I support Operation Blue Star, as Terrorist Bhindrawale and his supporters desecrated the Goden Temple by bringing in AK 47's, turning it into Fortress & what not.....Indian Army did the right thing by assassinating those thugs...

Yes, we still have dark memories of 84 genocide. It's dark chapter in Indian History. At present, we are well integrated in to India...Most of us have forgotten or trying to forget those black days, so that we can lead a prosperous life..

 

[rockstar08]

Sir , think practically. You think the brave men from Punjab are afraid of some thing. Even a beggar in India is not afraid of anything to protest. There is no such thing as fear. They do not protest because Khalistan movement does not sell in India. They will not have support from any political parties, social activists, or any media group. Because Sikhs are not persecuted . They are one of richest communities in India. One single incident does not take away facts. There may some kind of jingoism, and feeling to be a Sikh in youth or children. But that disappears once you become aware of things going on in country.

Sir first you are telling me to think Piratically than you are saying such rubbish ?
do i have to remind you that what happen to sikhs after the Indra killing ??

 

[mahesh.]

obviously a sikh who is living in india , consider his land a holy ...
but what my point is that , i dont think india will allow a big protest in favor of khalistan ,
at least those sikh who are not in favor of that Operation , and they still have memories when the Genocide of Sikhs, breaks out after indra assassination

The difference is killing of Sikhs during Indira Gandhi assassination was purely political. Some nut bag politicians and their supporters did that to gain some thing politically but not from any hatred towards sikhs.

 

[Parul]

That single statement is the reason why Pakistan and Bangladesh are happily not together and we have online discussions about possible secession sentiments in India which still holds together as a country in spite of having the world's largest diversity and a plethora of problems.
The day Pakistanis stop seeing other people as 'baniya', 'bhaiya', 'kufr', 'ahmdiya', 'shia', 'mohajir'... will be the day all your problems will become a lot more bearable.
India is not the perfect country, but take a leaf out of our book in terms of tolerance.

He is a Multiple ID troll, Ignore him & don't waste your energy on him.

The difference is killing of Sikhs during Indira Gandhi assassination was purely political. Some nut bag politicians and their supporters did that to gain some thing politically but not from any hatred towards sikhs.

The Secularism which is played between Hindus & Muslims these days, was played with us by Nehru, Fake Gandhi's and Congress Party.

 

[suresh1773]

Sir first you are telling me to think Piratically than you are saying such rubbish ?
do i have to remind you that what happen to sikhs after the Indra killing ??

It happened in 1984,but in Pakistan every year is like 1984.what about the attack on Hazaras.shias,Ahmediyas. I have read recently that Sri Lanka refused asylum to Pakistani Christians & Ahmediyas

 

[rockstar08]

To learn about Khalistan, I've seen Documentaries & sharing it's links is of no use...



Their is only one nutbag political party who favors Kahlista & they don't have any support in Punjab. I've seen them chanting Khalistan Zindabad at Golden Temple. This was even reported in Print and Electronic Media. This prooves they are allowed to protest. The problem is only handful of nutbags take these nutbags seriously.

I support Operation Blue Star, as Terrorist Bhindrawale and his supporters desecrated the Goden Temple by bringing in AK 47's, turning it into Fortress & what not.....Indian Army did the right thing by assassinating those thugs...

Yes, we still have dark memories of 84 genocide. It's dark chapter in Indian History. At present, we are well integrated in to India...Most of us have forgotten or trying to forget those black days, so that we can lead a prosperous life..

the operation puts a huge impact on a regular sikh life , and the aftermath, of indra killing make sure that there wont be any more voice heard in streets of India

 

[mahesh.]

Sir first you are telling me to think Piratically than you are saying such rubbish ?
do i have to remind you that what happen to sikhs after the Indra killing ??

Which part of it is rubbish to you. Could you quote. There is no hatred towards Sikhs in general public. I do agree there is hatred among Muslims and Hindu, but thats not in the case of Sikhs.

The one after Indiara was not from public or government but political leaders and supporters who want to show some thing once Indira was murdered.

 

[paritosh]

obviously a sikh who is living in india , consider his land a holy ...
but what my point is that , i dont think india will allow a big protest in favor of khalistan ,
at least those sikh who are not in favor of that Operation , and they still have memories when the Genocide of Sikhs, breaks out after indra assassination



no i dont think so , but there is something that those sikhs fear about ? may the memories from the aftermath of indra killing

you are right partly, Indian sikhs obviously are still angry at least about how what happened was handled. However, people revert back to other more basal pursuits and re-integrate into the society if after the big crash (read '84) there is a comprehensive lull period.
The fact of the matter is that Sikhs in India are respected. They contribute more than most communities in almost every sphere. This is the greatest success of them being a part of this country. When a secessionist movement starts reaping the fruits of their labour, the reason to secede appears more alien with time.
People below the mason-dixon line would still talk about the "lost cause" with melancholy, but would they want to act upon it?
I dont think so.

 

[mahesh.]

the operation puts a huge impact on a regular sikh life

Could you quote any article claiming impact on Sikh regular life.

 

[rockstar08]

Which part of it is rubbish to you. Could you quote. There is no hatred towards Sikhs in general public. I do agree there is hatred among Muslims and Hindu, but thats not in the case of Sikhs.

The one after Indiara was not from public or government but political leaders and supporters who want to show some thing once Indira was murdered.

not everyone is free to protest in India

 

[Etilla]

the operation puts a huge impact on a regular sikh life , and the aftermath, of indra killing make sure that there wont be any more voice heard in streets of India

Not true at all. Thats not the ground reality.