Should we Muslims Sacrifice Animals on Eid-al-Adha?

[Counter-Errorist]

None of the top beef consuming / cattle slaughtering countries are Muslim. Turkey isn't really an Islamic country.

 

[SilverKnights]

Delete this post.it is hurting my fundamental religious belief.

What an irony this cow shit eaters malnutrition Hindus are giving thoughts about animal sacrifice.

 

[Imran Khan]

we are liberal also but cant be this much stupid . saaly hamary gosht ke peechy pary hian

 

[Verve]

It is a form of Charity itself

> People Purchase animal far more than their market value from the poorer
> Butcher get paid handsomely for their services
> 1/3rd of meat goes to charity itself
> Hides of animal get donated and served a good cause

Is this thread not against forum rules?

 

[aamirzs]

We LOL ... On serious note this not only mentioned in Quran But Also in Bible and Torah.

Bible: Biblical narrative in Genesis 22. In the biblical narrative According to the Hebrew Bible, God commands Abraham to offer his son Isaac as a sacrifice.

Torah: In The Binding of Isaac chapter.

 

[Lincoln]

Yes, no question at all about it! It is farz to sacrifice an animal for those who can afford and are capable.

 

[IbnAbdullah]

Salaam

None of the top beef consuming / cattle slaughtering countries are Muslim. Turkey isn't really an Islamic country.

View attachment 658090

Turkey is as Muslim as many other Muslim countries.

 

[Leviza]

What a stupid logic is this ?
Mac Donald, Burger King , kfc etc slaughter million animals daily all over the world but no questions raised like this as the profit goes to already rich ppl

poor person sell his animals and slaughter house or person get some money on the days of Eid and all these stupid ppl have issues

 

[Iltutmish]

What a stupid logic is this ?
Mac Donald, Burger King , kfc etc slaughter million animals daily all over the world but no questions raised like this as the profit goes to already rich ppl

poor person sell his animals and slaughter house or person get some money on the days of Eid and all these stupid ppl have issues

IKR, in Germany there are indoor cattle farms in which the cows never see daylight. They are born in the farm and never get to go outside. Meat is very cheap in Germany and the government subsidies it. The animals are held in ugly conditions but everybody is fine with that.

But if we Muslims slaughter our cattle for religious reasons they go ape on us just because they hate Islam and its messages. 364 days they really don’t care and on our holiday they all become animal rights activists!

 

[TNT]

Seems the article is written by a stupid moron hindu a** licker. Does this idiot think animals are free or cheaper?? Ppl pay millions for a good bull and then sacrifice it and give its meat to the poor. Its due to Eid that each and every poor of the country gets to enjoy good meat for few days. Let alone the whole chain behind it and the economic benefit.

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Real sacrifice requires us to give up some of what is dear to us. Today, the most cherished possession is money, and people must be willing to part with some of it.



On Friday, July 31, 2020, over a billion and a half Muslims around the world, will be slaughtering millions of goats, camels, and cattle to carry out Abraham’s tradition of sacrificing the symbolic lamb.

Is there an alternative to the ritual of slaying animals on Eid Al-Adha, the festival of sacrifice? The answer is yes.

Rituals are the pathways to accomplish milestones of peace for oneself and with what surrounds one; life and environment. None of us can escape from the ceremonies. Each of us instinctively follows certain routines, from waking up to the time we go to sleep. Whether we shower, eat breakfast, go to the office, or gym, we follow the rituals.

The essence of Islam is to create cohesive societies where every human feels secure about his/her faith, race, religion, region, or ethnicity. It is time for Muslims to consider the essence of sacrifice rather than the ritual itself.

Real sacrifice requires us to give up some of what is dear to us. It is about parents going to sleep without food but feeding their kids; it is clothing their kids while waiting to get their own. In the case of extremities, we would instead get the bullet and save our loved ones, we are willing to rescue an individual from a freezing lake risking our own lives, and even strangers do that.

A thousand years ago, a man’s assets were made up of his goats, camels, and cattle. The ultimate sacrifice one would make was to give away his precious assets in gifts. Today, the most cherished possession is money, and people must be willing to part some of it to give the ability to the receiver to spend on his or her critical needs.

One of the examples set up for guidance was the test of Abraham’s faith, love, and devotion to God, which humans do routinely, “If you love me, you would do this for me.” A simple assurance would suffice, be it your fiancé, spouse, kids, siblings, or parents.

It was Abraham’s turn to face the command of God to sacrifice his son. Upon hearing this, he prepared to submit to God’s will and places his son on the block. Right at that moment, a lamb appears as an alternative. Then God revealed to Abraham that his “sacrifice” has already been fulfilled.

Also read: Why Indians Should Stick to Saying ‘Ramzaan Mubarak’, Not ‘Ramadan Kareem’

Does God want animals to be sacrificed?

Not at all. Qur’an, Al-Hajj 22:37 (The Pilgrimage) is clear:

“Never does their flesh reach God, and neither their blood. It is only your God-consciousness that reaches Him. It is to this end that we have made them subservient to your needs so that you might glorify God for all the guidance with which He has graced you. And give thou this glad tiding unto the doers of good.”

The act symbolises our willingness to give up a part of our bounties to strengthen and preserve the web of the universe and help those in need. We recognise that all blessings come from God, and we should open our hearts and share with others.

Eid being celebrated in Amritsar. Photo: PTI

What would you sacrifice instead?

It is customary for Muslims to sacrifice an animal on the day of the Hajj, a symbolic representation of Prophet Abraham’s act. What are our alternatives?

We can put that money to a different use that will do greater good like lending to a street hawker who can sell things from a cart and take care of his family or a single mom who can weave baskets or make sweaters to take care of her family. The beauty of this practice is you can make the same money repeatedly work for the common good. Muslims call it Sadaq-e-Jariah, which is continual giving.

Dr Nauman Anwar shares his view on the festivity:

“Sacrificing animals without making a public spectacle is still a good idea, as long as no wastage of the meat and hides occur. Many Muslim countries have a lot of poverty, and if the meat reaches the deserving population, it will help improve the nutritional status of the poor.

Let your single sacrifice multiply rather than the one-time sacrifice of animals. Prophet Muhammad had emphasised service to fellow humans as the highest service to God. Quran (4:152) says, if you are kind to your fellow humans, which is my creation, you will earn my grace regardless of your faith.

I am aware of the resistance from some Muslims. Still, the majority of Muslims are looking for alternatives to cope with COVID-19, animal rights activism, and the societal dynamics to keep harmony intact. I am also mindful of the Islamophobes who want to take advantage of the suggestions in this article. In a free and proud society of ours, no one should have the right to force others to comply to their demands without giving others the same power. Let us enjoy the God-given freedom to eat, drink, wear, and believe what brings us happiness. Let’s mind our own business.

Also read: A Growing Indifference Around the Festival of Eid Al-Fitr

Honouring police, firemen, and soldiers

Every day our police officers and firemen risk their own lives to protect ours, our freedom is protected by the men and women in the uniforms. I urge fellow Muslims to stop and salute every one of these men and women, honouring them for their love for humanity. Better yet, call the firemen, policemen, and let them know that as a Muslim you appreciate their sacrifice, and this festival is about appreciation for such sacrifice.

I did that in Louisville; within minutes, the officer had emailed the article to his fellow officers, appreciating the Muslims.

Prophet Muhammad had said the least you can do as a charity is to smile and appreciate the otherness of others.

Mike Ghouse is the founder and president of the Center for Pluralism. He is a speaker, thinker, community consultant, pluralist, activist, newsmaker, an interfaith wedding officiant and the author of the book American Muslim Agenda.


https://thewire.in/religion/muslims-eid-festival-islam-sacrifice-animals

Do you realise that we eat the animal that gets slaughtered? Some of it goes to people who can't afford a decent meal. It's not some sort of Aztec-style wasteful sacrificial killing to calm the storm god or something. It's a commemoration of the original quranic event involving Abraham (swt). By donating meat to the poor, Muslims sacrifice a portion of their wealth every time qurbani takes place.

Veggies may not like it on principle - fair enough, point taken - but it's no different to any other episode of meat eating. In fact, its charitable elements add value over regular episodes of meat eating.

The "sacrifice" element actually arises in the distribution of food to others.