Should Pakistan do Surgical Strikes in IOK?

[TheTallGuy]

In other words you are saying that we have accepted the ground reality and shall go through motions... thats what this hypothesis boils down to.

If such be case then the need to keep such a large army/airforce/navy/security apparatus become unnecessary... and we should move to BD model... a subserviant state under the GangaDaesh Sphere of Influence.

Interesting! This would suit NarcoLeague and PeePeeLeague very well...

However, if your hypothesis is correct then why do a 27the Feb in such fanfare and broad daylight to after announcing #WeShallSurpriseYou ..?

Afterall, it was a dead AgentCrow and a few trees. Why respond and have ganga loose 8 fighter jets as per your consistent contention?

Waiting Game!

Good things to those who wait!!!

Let us allow Time to unfold mysteries.​

Sir Jee, on the contrary i was trying to highlight that what is planned is quite different from previous indo-Pak examples. clearly out of the box thinking is required.
You will understand i would request to a historic example PLA intervention 1951 Korea how was it done with what capability that force hold. try to go through there arms and the structure.

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

Sir Jee, on the contrary i was trying to highlight that what is planned is quite different from previous indo-Pak examples. clearly out of the box thinking is required.
You will understand i would request to a historic example PLA intervention 1951 Korea how was it done with what capability that force hold. try to go through there arms and the structure.

“Victory has no alternatives” - General Douglas MacArthur. Won in WW2 in the Pacific Theater only to get sacked over a stalemated (losing considering the US standing with NK treating the USA) Korean War

 

[Adam_Khan]

Interesting propaganda tool.


Perhaps you need to re-read what I wrote without the blinders on. I've asked for a debate on the pros and cons. Only a dimwit would imagine I'm saying that the entire Kashmir problem will be solved by surgical strikes.


Pak has been cool and calm since 1947. Some fellows here pretending we are a lion after a prey, waiting for 70 years "for the right time". This fantasy narrative only feeds everyone some Kool Aid and is basically a dishonest narrative.

Only a dimwit would actually ask such a nonsensical question in the first place buddy,it's not kid's play doing surgical strikes inorder to liberate a large swathe of territory. Only way out is diplomacy not war,if war was the solution to Kashmir problem then by now it would have been a part of Pakistan.

Peace

 

[Armchair]

Only a dimwit would actually ask such a nonsensical question in the first place buddy,it's not kid's play doing surgical strikes inorder to liberate a large swathe of territory. Only way out is diplomacy not war,if war was the solution to Kashmir problem then by now it would have been a part of Pakistan.

Peace

Only a dimwit would imagine we are talking about liberating Kashmir with a surgical strike. Please read the thread again or ask someone who understands English to read it for you.
Peace be upon you too.

Sir Jee, i have some possible scenarios why its so calm. existential threat if there is then why in current picture military ops are not apparent which should have been apparent. why go far in past 2008 PAF was flying over cities armed and ready, after 14th Feb till 26th Feb you have witnessed how much movement was there resolve was very much apparent.

what is the difference now?

These are some common sense reasons i come up with
1. Political Leadership has decided that war is out of the question. This is will be treated as diplomatically as its been treated for last 70 years.
2. Military has not enough confidence to reach the desire goals or they have not yet given the set of goals that is required to be fulfilled. again due to reason 1.
3. They are waiting for something which will give them excuse to execute the required task with 24-48 hours prep time after the go-head is given.(But for this they required heavies to move out which is not apparent..at all!)
4.The counter to point 3. Does india Plans to move ahead? which would have been apparent with there force mobilization. if they had any plans to invade Azad Kashmir...again we would have seen a very hot CFL. i believe india will not attack Pakistan they will keep the pressure and smile when out pressure Pakistan Rush In!

Share you input please.

Sirji asa hein ke present force capacity se hum full scale war execute nehin kar sakte.

If we begin to see conscription and massive arms buys, that would be when we have chosen a military solution.

Unless we are quietly getting supplied from up north.

The most logical military solution is a full scale war. Indian military is stuck in Kashmir. Keep them stuck there and invade where they are weakest. Along South Punjab, hariana, rajestan and gujarat. Grab as much land here as possible. Then trade it for Kashmir.

For this to happen we need conscription and at least 200k more soldiers. Let me share a map of such a scenario

 

[untitled]

The revocation of the status of Kashmir is actually an insight into the Hindutva mind regarding what it plans to do with Muslims of South Asia.
This gives us an excellent opportunity to restart our nuclear weapons testing programme and fine tune it even further. India not to be outdone is likely going to follow suit. This will increase tensions in the region even further. Now the international community will be forced to do more than issue mere statements to diffuse the situation

 

[Armchair]

Hammer and anvil pattern

 

[R Wing]

Only feasible option is to reinforce and arm Kashmiri freedom fighters, to raise the armed struggle against India, to a new level. This would open up new scenarios, which can then be manipulated, to achieve freedom of Kashmir.

This is THE only way.

 

[War Thunder]

We have experienced that kind of operation in Kargil, Our foreign ministries always so weak, we don't have any super power support for that kind of operation, when u run ur country on others money then learn to live on low profile.

"Super power" support?

The smell of ignorance in your comment is a bit too strong.
Whose support do you need besides the only power there is, was, and always will be?

Cowardice and weakness makes girlies out of men, and we have a bit too many who fear humans and not their Creator. And that is exactly why you folk suffer and get humiliated time and again.