Shed 'Gandhigiri' approach with Pakistan, Afghan scholars urge India.

[Thəorətic Muslim]

You know what Iran did to Afghan refugees during the Afghan National War? They put them in Refugee camps and put barbed wire around it. And said "If you want to move around in Iran, you will need a visa." <---- Great idea.

You know what Pakistan did? We let them go were ever they wanted. <---- Bad Idea.

Afghan "Scholars" talk big, If the Pakistan Govt had any balls they would have closed down every transit route to Afghanistan and demanded Karzai suck their b@lls if he wants them open again.

 

[Baby Leone]

selective vision or blindness to see from a birds eye view is not my problem, but yours. So go ahead. let INDIANs address our problem and let the Pakistanis address their problem.

Teach the same to ur illiterate, cheap & frustrated country man who are hell obessed with Pakistan........

 

[zip]

First develop bilateral ties .. Develop your economy .. Develop your defence ..then think about rest

 

[Secur]

I am astonished to learn that Indians even today consider some Afghanis as " Scholars "

Where are those " Mad Mullahs " , " Extremist " , " 0 IQ Cavemen " and " Talibunnies " ?

P.S A piece of **** written to satisfy Indians by pathetic journalist who must learn to get a life ...

We haven't signed no agreement with India to deal with us peacefully or leniently ... I dont even know where these " so called scholars " get the idea that India deals with Pakistan with " Gandhigiri " approach ...

I will love to see these ungrateful Afghanis after 2014 when NATO will leave their country ...

If they love India so much , then they must ask every Afghan refugee to migrate to India ... The Wagah border can be opened for them

 

[Paan Singh]

I am astonished to learn that Indians even today consider some Afghanis as " Scholars "

Where are those " Mad Mullahs " , " Extremist " , " 0 IQ Cavemen " and " Talibunnies " ?

P.S A piece of **** written to satisfy Indians by pathetic journalist who must learn to get a life ...

We haven't signed no agreement with India to deal with us peacefully or leniently ... I dont even know where these " so called scholars " get the idea that India deals with Pakistan with " Gandhigiri " approach ...

I will love to see these ungrateful Afghanis after 2014 when NATO will leave their country ...

If they love India so much , then they must ask every Afghan refugee to migrate to India ... The Wagah border can be opened

for them

why they should go to india??its you who make the a-stan as training yard for terrorist..ask hamid gul like guys
and it was you,who brought mujahids from all over world to fight in their country
it was you who were ready to led nato in region
it was you who asked for dollars and few weapons in exchange of the U.S war in region..

and still sending supplies

why they should torn india??why not pakistan who have done blunders by involving them in this fight

and regarding to U.S with drawal..i will wait for day when they will go

underground hangars of aircraft storage,biggest embassies in a-stan....and caspian sea resources in region..tell something else.

so those who says,every thing will be ok after 2014,will have to wait for 10 -15 yrs more

 

[ashokdeiva]

Teach the same to ur illiterate, cheap & frustrated country man who are hell obessed with Pakistan........

thats not my job, there are people on both sides of the border who are obsessed with each other and I can not do any thing about that because they do seldom question before arriving at a decision and you are one among them when you first replied to my post in this thread, you showed how much you hate the Hindus when you said that all sects are RSS, Sivasena etc, when i mentioned the people of my nation with out discriminating any one.

 

[Infinite]

Perhaps these scholars can give same advice to Karzai
http://www.defence.pk/forums/strate...children-dead-rampage-kills-16-civilians.html Serves them right.

 

[StormShadow]

They are NOT unwanted.

* on topic , we didn't beg India to deal Pakistan with Gandhigeeri , we are ready to take you head on , always have , always will.

Yes...you will be ready to take head on with countries which follow "gandhigiri" with Pakistan. But I dunno what happens to this pride and patriotism in dealing with countries showing "dadagiri" with pakistan? [YES...i'm talking about 28 pak soldiers killed by US/NATO, unilateral raids, Raymond Davis , Drones etc etc]

 

[Sinnerman108]

What a load of crap !

The only GANDHIGIRI that should be abolished is by Pakistan to these "persian influenced" northern Afghans.

Let them take back their refugees.
Let them grow their own food
Let them get their own oil.
Stop them from selling stuff in Pakistan without paying customs.
Stop letting them steal cars etc from Pakistan and taking them to Afghanistan.
Stop them from selling drugs in Pakistan
Stop them from selling weapons in Pakistan.
Stop them from running prostitution rings here

and the we will think of equality.

 

[Karachiite]

Why not just kick out the millions of Afghan trash living in Pakistan illegally and on refugee status. Pakistan should give them to India since Afghanistan and India are such great friend. While were at it seal the Afg-Pak border and mine it as well.

If only Pakistan treated Afghanistan like Iran treats them. Iran keeps the Afghan refugees in secluded camps while Afghans in Pakistan are allowed to do whatever they want. The drug and weapon problem in Pakistan started thanks to Afghanistan.

 

[Bhairava]

I wish that these afghan "scholars" would urge "major power" india to take the 4 million unwanted afghan refugees sitting in Pakistan too.

. Pakistan should give them to India since Afghanistan and India are such great friend..

Well we did not interfere in their country's internal affairs in the name of jehad and basically destroyed them once again in the name of strategic depth...did we ?

 

[Tshering22]

What a man! He's more worried about us than our scumbag politicians. And very truly said, dear Afghan buddy. 'Gandhigiri' is the worst form of human perversion one can imagine... to run away with tail tucked between legs when injustice is being done. No wonder with Gandhians leading our nation, we have come down to that terrible situation today.

And thank goodness that loony was snuffed by Godse. If Gandhi and his cowardly principles had stayed for 2 more years alive, India would have become the size of Sri Lanka (as a legendary red-capped man keeps talking )

 

[Rafi]

What a man! He's more worried about us than our scumbag politicians. And very truly said, dear Afghan buddy. 'Gandhigiri' is the worst form of human perversion one can imagine... to run away with tail tucked between legs when injustice is being done. No wonder with Gandhians leading our nation, we have come down to that terrible situation today.

And thank goodness that loony was snuffed by Godse. If Gandhi and his cowardly principles had stayed for 2 more years alive, India would have become the size of Sri Lanka (as a legendary red-capped man keeps talking )

LoL this guy is justifying the murder of Gandhi where are the indian lovers of the "fakir" -

 

[Areesh]

"Balance of power in the South Asian region has shifted long back. India has advanced economically as well as militarily far more than Pakistan. But I don't understand why India is still in the early 80s mentality," said Haroun M. Mir, a US educated Afghanistan analyst who was an aide to the late Ahmad Shah Massoud, Afghanistan's former defence minister

Fake Maulvi. Typical case of Amreeka walai Maulana.

 

[Shapur]

You know what Iran did to Afghan refugees during the Afghan National War? They put them in Refugee camps and put barbed wire around it. And said "If you want to move around in Iran, you will need a visa." <---- Great idea.

You know what Pakistan did? We let them go were ever they wanted. <---- Bad Idea.

Afghan "Scholars" talk big, If the Pakistan Govt had any balls they would have closed down every transit route to Afghanistan and demanded Karzai suck their b@lls if he wants them open again.

Funniest sh1t I have heard. Pakistan nor Afghanistan has any control over the border except a few major entry routes. This is a long border over 1000 km and its impossible to patrol it. Forget patroling most pakistani or Afghan troops can't even enter those areas. These areas are controlled by Tribal Lashkar (militia) and the Taliban. NO one can close that border, the Tribes simply won't allow it. That's one of the main reasons why the British left these areas autonomous. As the Durand Line Treaty confirms, these areas are outside the jurisdiction of Pakistan and Pakistani army has no right being there.

As regards to the rest of your post about the difference between the Pakistani and Iranian approach to refugees. The Iran is a much more controlled centralized and closed state unlike Pakistan. The pakistani security services are corrupt and with a few dollars you can buy them off.