Sensitive Data of Indian Navy’s Scorpene Class Submarines Leaked

[50cent]

Cool down guys there is no war happening so no problem drink coke and take no tension watch videos on YouTube

 

[PARIKRAMA]

they have received major portion of payment

Not yet bro.. most of the payments are delayed and on hold due to project delay and not meeting the milestones... If Idnia does cancel and freeze it out, DCNS stands to lose more than 50% + of its dues and the reputation loss will be much more..

 

[GuardianRED]

Not yet bro.. most of the payments are delayed and on hold due to project delay and not meeting the milestones... If Idnia does cancel and freeze it out, DCNS stands to lose more than 50% + of its dues and the reputation loss will be much more..

Why are we worried abt DCNS, when the IN will stand to loose much MORE! If they cancel the deal or something crazy !

 

[Shankranthi]

Not yet bro.. most of the payments are delayed and on hold due to project delay and not meeting the milestones... If Idnia does cancel and freeze it out, DCNS stands to lose more than 50% + of its dues and the reputation loss will be much more..

Now all we have to do is spend another 9 Billion $ buying Rafale and pray that they do not leak too much information about that .

Literally on a Wing and a Prayer.

 

[PARIKRAMA]

Why are we worried abt DCNS, when the IN will stand to loose much MORE! If they cancel the deal or something crazy !

If we dont take any action also its a bigger issue.. Unless of course we stuck some bargain and get something else from DCNS for free in lieu of continuing the contract of 6 scorpenes..

This will turn out to be a corporate arm twisting scenario.. DM MP will not let such a chance go.. Either there will be some serious action or some additional things shared by France /DCNS to all aggrieved parties - India and Australia both to salvage their respective deal /potential contract and do damage control

 

[SirHatesALot]

Yeah buy French

 

[Shankranthi]

If we dont take any action also its a bigger issue.. Unless of course we stuck some bargain and get something else from DCNS for free in lieu of continuing the contract of 6 scorpenes..

This will turn out to be a corporate arm twisting scenario.. DM MP will not let such a chance go.. Either there will be some serious action or some additional things shared by France /DCNS to all aggrieved parties - India and Australia both to salvage their respective deal /potential contract and do damage control

If IN still wants to work with DCS after this then they must be word class morons.

DM MP and Ajit Doval have their work cut out. So much for "strategic partnership". Modi with Egg on his face. Solar Alliance in a pickle.

This is not going to end well for anyone.

 

[GuardianRED]

If we dont take any action also its a bigger issue.. Unless of course we stuck some bargain and get something else from DCNS for free in lieu of continuing the contract of 6 scorpenes..

This will turn out to be a corporate arm twisting scenario.. DM MP will not let such a chance go.. Either there will be some serious action or some additional things shared by France /DCNS to all aggrieved parties - India and Australia both to salvage their respective deal /potential contract and do damage control

That is an excellent reply.

Just hope that the DM doesn't do An Anthony or some opposition party plays the bofors or Agustawestland card and cries Corruption and Scam!

If IN still wants to work with DCS after this then they must be word class morons.

DM MP and Ajit Doval have their work cut out. So much for "strategic partnership". Modi with Egg on his face. Solar Alliance in a pickle.

This is not going to end well for anyone.

What do you expect them to do? Cancel and blacklisted them? and then wait another 10 -20yrs to open another sub line and build a new sub fleet?

 

[Shankranthi]

That is an excellent reply.

Just hope that the DM doesn't do An Anthony or some opposition party plays the bofors or Agustawestland card and cries Corruption and Scam!

Are you Crazy ? This is WORSE than Bofors.

The opposition will have a field day with this. What ever Modi / DM MP does, its a Lose lose situation.

At this point we can neither spit them out nor swallow it. We can only hope that we do not choke to death.

What do you expect them to do? Cancel and blacklisted them? and then wait another 10 -20yrs to open another sub line and build a new sub fleet?

This is Catch 22 situation.

We have landed in a mess. We stand to lose either way. There is no way of getting out of this without smelling of $hit.

 

[GuardianRED]

Are you Crazy ? This is WORSE than Bofors.

The opposition will have a field day with this. What ever Modi / DM MP does, its a Lose lose situation.

At this point we can neither spit them out nor swallow it. We can only hope that we do not choke to death.

How is this worst than bofors ? Is this a Scam? is there any middle men? all this is a security leak!

Are you Crazy ? This is WORSE than Bofors.

The opposition will have a field day with this. What ever Modi / DM MP does, its a Lose lose situation.

At this point we can neither spit them out nor swallow it. We can only hope that we do not choke to death.



This is Catch 22 situation.

We have landed in a mess. We stand to lose either way. There is no way of getting out of this without smelling of $hit.

Do u know whats a Catch 22 situation IS ?? This isn't one of them!

 

[Blue Marlin]

Couple of things

Not leaked but stolen by French Naval Officer/contractor for monetary gain as mentioned in article. That is why Australia and USA are concerned. If Scorpene info can be stolen then what else?

DCNS will loose lot of potential business including the giant Australian contract, so they are trying to deflect blame to India as Indian contract is done and they have received major portion of payment. So nothing to loose there as India is already stuck with them as all six scorpenes are under different stages of construction/induction.

well in that case i feel more has been leaked. you go all in or dont go in at all.
could be the usa still trying to push the aussies to japan. they lobbied them to choose japan. remember this contract is huge and still not signed for. so they can easily say no to france and say hello japan.

 

[Shankranthi]

How is this worst than bofors ? Is this a Scam? is there any middle men? all this is a security leak!

Do u know whats a Catch 22 situation IS ?? This isn't one of them!

If we continue to do business with them them it will smells of corruption and anti national activity.

If we refuse to do business with them it means HUGE Financial loss and loss to IN submarine fleet.

It is a classic Catch 22 situation.

All this while the solar alliance and Rafale deal hanging in balance.

The worse part is that this leak could very well have been done by US or China or Russia to screw up India so that we do not get too close to France.

Let me rephrase that. Its a Lose Lose Lose situation because France could not keep its $hit together. This is what happens when you enter into a bad marriage. Everybody is unhappy.

 

[GuardianRED]

If we continue to do business with them them it will smells of corruption and anti national activity.

If we refuse to do business with them it means HUGE Financial loss and loss to IN submarine fleet.

It is a classic Catch 22 situation.

All this while the solar alliance and Rafale deal hanging in balance.

huh??? where is the financial loss?

Where is the corruption?? where is the anti national activity?

and NO u still don't know what is a Catch 22 situation and how can this be CLASSIC?

 

[Shankranthi]

huh??? where is the financial loss?

Where is the corruption?? where is the anti national activity?

and NO u still don't know what is a Catch 22 situation and how can this be CLASSIC?

Its opportunity cost you idiot. The delay in Scorpene has already cost IN much.

Now that we have spent a fortune in learning how to build a scorpene, we find out its operational effectiveness has been reduced by half due to sensitive leaks.

So now if we spend more money building more scorpene, it means we are only getting half the worth for All the money.

So whatever choice we make now it is going to smell like corruption and opposition can make the claim either way.

 

[PARIKRAMA]

@Abingdonboy @Nilgiri - in here..