What's new

Secular Kerala in Action

We can call Kerala "The Land of Child Marriages"

Going by the logic of people supporting this retrograde move "it will be OK for them if USA approves child marriages because US is leading the world in all kind of statistics".

Funny people! Can't call the spade a spade.

Apart from few fundamentalist , nobody is supporting this move.

It was a bad move but with good intentions .

But due to the internal politics of kerala , instead of cancelling the wrong circular they will now issue a new one correcting the old one.
 
Apart from few fundamentalist , nobody is supporting this move.

It was a bad move but with good intentions .

But due to the internal politics of kerala , instead of cancelling the wrong circular they will now issue a new one correcting the old one.

There is an old saying ...........the path to Hell is paved with Good Intentions.

.........that was for people who were confused where 'gods own country' was heading :devil:
 
This is also happening in my secular Kerala!!

Muslim women protest stand of religious leaders

Reducing marriage age of Muslim girls a retrograde step’

In an unprecedented protest programme at Mananchira here on Saturday, a group of Muslim women burned the All-India Sunni Jam-Iyyathul Ulema general secretary Kanthapuram A.P. Aboobacker Musalyar in effigy for his recent comments in support of reducing the legal marriage age for Muslim women.

NO ALLEGIANCE

The women who do not owe allegiance to any party or organisation said that they were forced to protest after the many regressive comments from Muslim organisations and clerics supporting the recent circular to legalise marriage of Muslim girls who had completed 16.

FIRST TIME

This was perhaps the first time that a group of women from the community was protesting against their community leaders, they said.

Mr. Kanthapuram had on Friday said that girls should be married off by the time they are 16 to prevent them from going wayward. The Jamaat-e-Islami said that it was not right to fix the age for marriage in a democratic country like India.K. Alikutti Musaliar, general secretary of the EK Group, had said that girls who had reached physical maturity could be married off.A newspaper owing allegiance to the AP Sunni group had published all their comments on Saturday, which led to the protest. “The stand taken by these clerics and leaders is not just against Muslim society but against the whole of humanity. They are trying to see women as pieces of flesh and not as independent citizens. Marriage at such an age will curtail the mental growth of girls. It is also an age when they should be gaining better education and widening their horizon,” said V.P. Rajeena, one of the protesters.

CRITICISED

They criticised the United Democratic Front Government for acting according to the diktats of religious organisations.

CHILD MARRIAGE

“The circular was issued keeping in mind the interests of a few people in the community. This is nothing less than allowing child marriage and will only tarnish the image of the community as a whole. There should be strong opposition to such trends which will only help in taking the Muslim society many centuries backward. This community leaders should withdraw their comments and apologise to the people of Kerala,” said A. Seenath, another protester.

Muslim women protest stand of religious leaders - The Hindu
 
With a 98% literacy for women, they certainly took their time to make their voice heard.

Not sure what being secular has got to do with this. This protest was clearly by group of Muslim women . how does that make it secular ? :lol: ..... where the hell were the Hindu and Christian women ? :angel: ..... grasping at straws ?
 
That literacy status is a big bogus.

when one goes to kerala,they ll figure this out for themselves.
 
Gulf money fueling Muslim extremism in Kerala; IUML grows more militant to take on other radical islamist parties

Kerala's Muslims have prospered largely thanks to the Gulf Boom, but over the past four decades the phenomenon has also led to an apparent spurt in extremist tendencies among the minority community, throwing up yet another paradox in a state known for paradoxes.

Every time the chief Muslim party, Indian Union Muslim League (IUML), flexes its political muscles and seeks more representation in the Congress-led government, the focus shifts to 'radical Islam'. None other than the state Congress president, Ramesh Chennithala, recently accused the recalcitrant ally of being a "liability".

The IUML, which has 20 MLAs and five ministers in the 140-member assembly, has often come under attack - even from defence minister AK Antony - for using its "bargaining power" in a minority government to secure ministerial and other administrative perks. The party has come under sharp criticism for nominating a former long-time security guard of industries minister and IUML leader P K Kunhalikutty as the regional passport officer of Malappuram :omghaha: - the CBI has initiated a probe into irregularities in issuing passports by this former gunman, K Abdul Rasheed, whose "out of turn" appointment itself had generated controversy. It has also been demanding bifurcation of the Muslim majority district of Malappuram to gain an additional Lok Sabha seat in the 2014 general elections.

The IUML, according to renowned historian MGS Narayanan, who was a chairman of the Indian Council for Historical Research (ICHR), used to be a "relatively secular party like the Congress". Lately, however, he says, it has been trying to outwit radical elements such as the Popular Front of India (PFI) through its constant "pro-Muslim posturing", and in the process contributing to polarisation along communal lines in the country's most literate state. The state's self-government department, held by IUML, had issued a circular that legalised marriages of Muslim women in the age group of 16 to 18 and men below 21. In the face of protests, the circular was amended.

Last year, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had listed Kerala - a state that economists such as Professor Amartya Sen and others have used as a case study to highlight the paradox of high social indicators despite low growth - along with the likes of J&K and Assam that are seeing a spurt in extremist religious fervour.

Indoctrination, Identity

A major chunk of the estimated 60,000 crore in remittances that Kerala receives is contributed by Muslim migrants and Malappuram tops the list of beneficiaries among all its 14 districts. The Muslims, who form more than a quarter of Kerala's total population, are not only more economically advanced but also politically more powerful compared with the Muslims in the other states. Among all communities in the state, only Muslims have positive population growth - something that has prompted the Church to discreetly encourage more than two children per family. :sick: :tdown:

Narayanan contends that "indoctrination of Muslim youths follows a pattern". "These labourers and others who go to the Gulf get into this trap and once indoctrinated, they return committed to the cause of Islam, ready to spend money or devote time and energy into what they call religious activities," he says, emphasising that Hindu organisations, too, are flush with funds from overseas donors.now

"Saudi" money, love jihad

The real problem now, says a senior state police officer, is the growing "extremist" tendencies among Muslim youths. "It is leading to a major law-and-order situation in the state known for its progressive edge," he adds, asking not to be named.

Narayanan points out, "Both - Hindu extremist and Islamic fundamentalism - grow on each other." Emphasising that "madrassas are mushrooming and are the breeding grounds for potential jihadis", he says such childhood training results in a person building a wall against other religions.

Even as various Islamist recruits have been charged with wooing girls from other religions in an effort to convert them, senior PFI leader EM Abdurahman dismisses charges of "love jihad" "It is absolutely false and it is just a creation of rightwing elements," he says. "Muslims are now aware of their identity and are proud of it. Unfortunately, this prosperity has invited jealously from right-wing sections and vested interests," he said.

Dangerous Politics

In certain pockets in north Kerala, CPM cadres have joined hands with those in the BJP to take on what they call "threat from Islamist forces such as PFI". :angel: While Narayanan calls this "a very dangerous trend", Abdurahman downplays it, saying, "People of northern Kerala are very emotional compared with those down south. This is true of all cadres, including those in the CPM, RSS and our own." For his part, Narayanan blames the CPM in the state for encouraging radical Islamic elements so as to corner votes and batter the IUML. "That strategy has misfired in the state, causing this deep polarisation," he says. Abdurahman disagrees: "The CPM, I would say, isn't doing enough to safeguard the rights of the minorities as it should have."

The PFI was accused by the central agencies of being involved in creating bulk SMSes that led to the exodus of Northeasterners from Bangalore last year. Earlier, the PFI had come under scanner on several occasions over various communal clashes across Kerala. Political leaders, especially those from the CPM, have charged the PFI with double standards. "Organisations such as this (PFI) are engaged in nefarious activities. If Kerala isn't as progressive as it used to be, it is because of outfits like the PFI," CPM politburo member and former home minister Kodiyeri Balakrishnan told ET, citing the hand-chopping incident of a teacher on charges of "blasphemy against Prophet Mohammed". The PFI has denied any wrongdoing.

However, political observers such as MG Radhakrishnan, a senior journalist based in Thiruvananthapuram, offer a slightly different view. "The kind of radicalisation among Muslims in Kerala isn't the militant kind," he says, adding that Muslims in the state are now more prosperous and more conscious of their identity. "This is why you see more burkhas and skull caps on the roads. Militant Islamism in Kerala is a major hype. There are many odd incidents, but I see it as a natural phenomenon. When communities rise out of long years of poverty and transform into a new mode, there is always this kind of perception. They are rediscovering their identity. Reading too much into it is a mistake," he says. Radhakrishnan adds that the Muslims who were among the lower sections of Kerala society take special pride in their identity once they become rich. "There is nothing unusual about it," he says, adding that many of them are highly successful businessmen and serial entrepreneurs. "It is radicalism, but it is non-militant radicalism," he says.
 
Kerala’s riches & rapes

Kerala is supposed to be a socialist paradise with the best social and gender indicators, frowning on economic growth and globalisation. But a look at the latest crime data suggests that even Kerala's image as a civilised paradise for women is much exaggerated.

Of all states, Kerala has the highest crime rate of 455.8 per lakh people, over twice the national rate of 196.7 (see table). India's crime capital is Kochi (817.9) followed by Kollam (637.3). :angel:

Now, crimes are underreported in India, especially in the north. So, Kerala's high crime figures represent, in part, proper recording of crimes. Even so, the figures look uncomfortably high.

Crimes Against Women

Kerala has the highest female-male ratio (1084:1000 against the national 940:1000) and the highest female literacy rate (92%). This is attributed to a historical lead in education, matrilineality and enlightened gender attitudes.

Yet crimes against women in Kerala are shockingly high. The rape rate in Kerala (2.9) is almost one and a half times the national rate (2.1). The rate of assault on women with intent to outrage their modesty is 10.7 in Kerala, thrice as high as the national average (3.7). The rate of insults related to the modesty of women is 1.4, against the national 0.8.

Kerala does far better than India overall in dowry deaths: its rate 0.1 against the national 0.7. Yet cruelty to women comes in at the rate of 15 per lakh population, almost double the national 8.8.

The highest rates for cruelty are in two other Marxist strongholds — Tripura (23.4) and Bengal (21.9). Can this be attributed entirely to Marxist transparency in reporting? Nobody will believe the very low rate of 3.7 in Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, who are clearly guilty of gross under-reporting.

Kerala has a relatively low rate of murder and theft, but its cheating rate is almost double the national average. It is the champion in criminal rioting (31.4 against the national 6.2). This may explain the state's extraordinarily high rate of criminal hurt (60.7 against the national 27.7) and arson (1.6 against 1.0). We need more research on these subjects.

Crime data are an additional reason to rethink the famed Kerala model of socialist development. For decades, Amartya Sen and Mahbub ul Haq (creator of the Human Development Index) lavished praise on Kerala for achieving high social indicators through government intervention while being poor and growing slowly. New research shows this to be substantially illusory.

Rethinking the Model

Despite land reform and Marxist pretensions, the state is virtually the most unequal in India (with a Gini coefficient of 0.392 against the national 0.336). True, it has the highest Human Development Index, life expectancy and literacy, and the lowest fertility and infant mortality rate. But these have not arisen by emphasising welfare over GDP or economic growth.

Kerala has been among the richest five states (measured by per capita income) since 1980-81. It has the highest per capita spend in rural and urban areas. It is among the fastest-growing states, with a peak growth rate of 10.4% in 2007-08. This owes a lot to rising remittances from overseas Keralites, which now account for 32% of state GDP. So, Kerala's high social indicators are correlated not with poverty or lack of economic growth, but with rising Mammonisation.

Markets, Not Marx

Its leaders mouth anti-globalisation slogans, yet its economy represents a triumph of globalisation through remittances and exports of agricultural goods. Land reform may have helped, yet Kerala's rice yields are lower than in neighbouring Tamil Nadu. Kerala is very lucky in its agroclimate: it is the only state that gets copious rains from both the South West and North East monsoons.

This enables it to specialise in plantation crops — coconuts, arecanuts, cashew, rubber, tea coffee, spices — yielding up to 10 times the income per acre as rice.

Kerala has since Roman times been among India's most globalised states, exporting spices and other farm products. Its high Muslim population is explained by the influence of trade with the Gulf, not Islamic conquest (as in North India).

Kerala's early lead in education began under enlightened maharajas in the 1800s, supplemented by Christian missionaries and Nair and Ezhava movements. Kerala has the highest proportion of students in private rural schools (53%). Its educational success is based on private, not state provision (though the state finances private schools).

In health, Kerala has the highest private spending. In 2004-05, private health spending in Kerala wasRs 2,663 per capita, more than double that of its nearest rival Punjab (Rs 1,112).

By contrast, public health spending per capita in Kerala was just Rs 280. :lol: In sum, Kerala is not a success of welfare socialism. Rather, it is a success of globalisation, private provision of education and health, and rapid economic growth — along with the associated high inequality. And high crime.
 
I hope the 'secular' Indians read all the 3 articles.....

Kerala debate: It's crime data does tell a grim story

A fortnight ago, I wrote that Kerala, contrary to its reputation, was not a welfarist socialist paradise with low crime and excellent treatment of women. In fact, its development model had used globalisation and private provision of education to achieve rapid GDP growth, along with associated inequality and rising crime.

The column attracted a storm of comments. Many people expressed outrage over my table showing Kerala with the highest crime rate among states, and unexpectedly high rates of crimes against women. :P

Critics claimed that Kerala's rates looked high entirely because its police were more honest in recording crimes. Sorry, but that's too facile an excuse. As I said last fortnight, better reporting is certainly part of the story, but not the whole story. The state's own crime data show a terrible deterioration over time. The rate of all crimes per-lakh population has risen steadily from 230.5 in 1990 to 294.1 in 1997 and 455.8 in 2012.

This virtual doubling over 22 years cannot be attributed to galloping honesty in Kerala: it had superior crime reporting compared with other states even in 1990. Back in 1990, Kerala's crime rate was only the eight-highest among states.


In 2012, it was clear No. 1. While crime reportage is grossly incomplete in all states, especially in the Hindi belt, there is no reason at all to think that the differentials between states have widened greatly. Indeed, governance in states such as Bihar, Odisha, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh has greatly improved in the last decade, so reportage has probably become much more honest there.

Safer, But Only Relatively

Similar logic applies to data on crimes against women. Surely, Kerala is more honest in reporting these crimes than many northern states and women there feel relatively safe.

Even so, I said in my last column, I am uncomfortable that Kerala's rates are rising fast, and sometimes overtaking the national average. Kerala's rate of rapes per-lakh population has quadrupled: up from 0.7 in 1990 to 1.9 in 1997 and 2.9 in 2012. In 1990, Kerala's rape rate was well below the national average of 1.2 but, by 2012, its rate was far above the national average of 2.1.

It has deteriorated in relation to other states as well as its own historical record. Detailed data on crimes against women is not available for 1990, but is available for 1997. Between 1997 and 2012, the rate of female molestation in Kerala went up from 5.0 per lakh to 10.7; of sexual harassment from 0.2 to 1.4; and of cruelty by husbands and relatives from 5.3 to 15.

The gap between Kerala's rates and the national average has worsened hugely. This worsening should make everybody uncomfortable, whatever the data problems may be. Some critics point out that rape rates globally are far higher than in India. Wikipedia says rapes perlakh population in 2010 were 63.5 in Sweden, 28.8 in the UK and 27.3 in the US.
India's recorded rate is just 2.1, and Kerala's is 2.9. But it is plain silly to conclude from this that Kerala is 20 times safer than Sweden or 10 times safer than the US. Rape reportage is very incomplete even in the US, and extremely incomplete in Kerala and all Indian states. All surveys show that the bulk of rapes are committed by relatives, friends and others who know the victim, and in Indian society, such incidents are swept under the carpet. Anecdotal evidence suggests that Kochi is safer for girls than Delhi, but is it really 10 times safer than London?

Make it God's Own State

During 1997-2012, Kerala's crime rate per-lakh population worsened for riots (from 20.6 to 31.4), criminal hurt (from 56.3 to 60.7), cheating (from 7.5 to 13.4) and arson (from 1.2 to 1.6).

However, there was improvement in the rate of murder (from 1.4 to 1.1) and theft (from 12.7 to 11.7). That's a silver lining, but not reason for ignoring the dark cloud. Instead of simply expressing outrage at the crime data I have collected, the people of Kerala should ask themselves what's going wrong, and what the remedies are.
 

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom