IbnAbdullah
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2018
- Messages
- 1,584
- Reaction score
- 9
- Country
- Location
Aoa
I actually wasn't talking about the Islamic past or Pakistani past, it was a general comment about the pride we (as in people) sometimes feel for the achievements of those before us.
We are always selective about the history we choose.
Muslims boast about the conquests of the Rashidun Caliphate or maybe about Salahudin Ayubi, but we seldom celebrate the loss of spain or the loss of Jerusalem to the crusaders in the first place.
The Persians may talk about their great empires in the past but seldom do they talk about all the time Persia was conquered and ruled for centuries by others.
The Ottomans will talk about the exploits of Suleman the Magnificent but not talk as enthusiastically about the internal causes that led to its weakness.
The Pakistanis mostly look at history through shared belief (so Muslims are counted as our predecessors) instead of using biological or regional identity.
The point is, history is viewed with heavily tinted glasses of our modern world.
Just as in the movie 300 the Spartans became freedom loving, civilized and honourable alpha white males fighting the barbaric hordes of the eastern tyrants, the figures and events of our choice, in whatever history we chose for ourself, become substitutes for our ideals.
---
The fact is that the greatness of the past got us to wherever it is that we are and not one bit further.
No matter how great the Empire of Darius was or how splendidly powerful the Achaemenid Empire was, today the power centers of the world are far away. Today the Persians are not increased in relevance in anyway by the collective greatness of its past.
The past of Persia has brought it to wherever it is today, and not one bit further.
That is not limited to Persia, rather applies equally to all others. We are a continuation of our histories, and our present came from our past. So our present is as great as our past allowed us.
Point was - no matter how great our chosen predecessors were, what matters more is where we currently are and where we are headed as a people.
History is great for learning, but being proud of something you didn't do seems a tad strange to me.
...
Your glorious past was a nightmare not only for the others but for Muslims too you pray that never comeback again your best bet is democracy but at the good hands not corrupted ones
I actually wasn't talking about the Islamic past or Pakistani past, it was a general comment about the pride we (as in people) sometimes feel for the achievements of those before us.
We are always selective about the history we choose.
Muslims boast about the conquests of the Rashidun Caliphate or maybe about Salahudin Ayubi, but we seldom celebrate the loss of spain or the loss of Jerusalem to the crusaders in the first place.
The Persians may talk about their great empires in the past but seldom do they talk about all the time Persia was conquered and ruled for centuries by others.
The Ottomans will talk about the exploits of Suleman the Magnificent but not talk as enthusiastically about the internal causes that led to its weakness.
The Pakistanis mostly look at history through shared belief (so Muslims are counted as our predecessors) instead of using biological or regional identity.
The point is, history is viewed with heavily tinted glasses of our modern world.
Just as in the movie 300 the Spartans became freedom loving, civilized and honourable alpha white males fighting the barbaric hordes of the eastern tyrants, the figures and events of our choice, in whatever history we chose for ourself, become substitutes for our ideals.
---
The fact is that the greatness of the past got us to wherever it is that we are and not one bit further.
No matter how great the Empire of Darius was or how splendidly powerful the Achaemenid Empire was, today the power centers of the world are far away. Today the Persians are not increased in relevance in anyway by the collective greatness of its past.
The past of Persia has brought it to wherever it is today, and not one bit further.
That is not limited to Persia, rather applies equally to all others. We are a continuation of our histories, and our present came from our past. So our present is as great as our past allowed us.
Point was - no matter how great our chosen predecessors were, what matters more is where we currently are and where we are headed as a people.
History is great for learning, but being proud of something you didn't do seems a tad strange to me.
...
Last edited: