Rise of Islamist seminaries is latest worry in Islamabad, Pakistan

[Zarvan]

Not the point, since I(and him) live amongst arabs(all kinds of them) we know better about them, arabs are often really slutty and their knowing of arabic doesnt affect how strict they are. The ONLY ONE SINGLE difference being strict pakistanis get their knowledge from weirdo mullahs and 'Islamic' pages on facebooks' chainmail pictures and viral 'Islamic' youtube videos, while arabs often get their knowledge from random books like Ibn kathir or Al Bukhari etc.
But the fact is, strictness is solely based on personal conviction, not how they're educated or how much they know.
I've never been to a madrassah, I read the Quran myself, i know some arabic, and read on the internet or in books - i feel much more satisfied that my guidance comes from Allah's blessing rather than corrupt munafiq mulllahs. The only way Pakistanis can succeed is if they ask for sincere guidance from Allah and not these bs seminaries


Nope, saudi doesnt have any Islamic law either

Saudi Arabia have more Islamic Laws than Pakistan but not complete Islamic Law

 

[Dil Pakistan]

From the very beginning I am trying to understand that …Pakistan came into existence in the name of Islam….But Still Pakistan is not implemented Islamic Sharia law…Like Arab countries ...Please help me to understand this.

To answer your questions:

1). No Islamic country (including Arab) has Sharia as its law. If there was Sharia, there would be no monarchies. What you see is a "system" that has been erected to keep "few" in power.

2). Why Pakistan has not implemented Sharia ? Because we are hypocrites and ruled by hypocrites.

 

[Zarvan]

Not the point, since I(and him) live amongst arabs(all kinds of them) we know better about them, arabs are often really slutty and their knowing of arabic doesnt affect how strict they are. The ONLY ONE SINGLE difference being strict pakistanis get their knowledge from weirdo mullahs and 'Islamic' pages on facebooks' chainmail pictures and viral 'Islamic' youtube videos, while arabs often get their knowledge from random books like Ibn kathir or Al Bukhari etc.
But the fact is, strictness is solely based on personal conviction, not how they're educated or how much they know.
I've never been to a madrassah, I read the Quran myself, i know some arabic, and read on the internet or in books - i feel much more satisfied that my guidance comes from Allah's blessing rather than corrupt munafiq mulllahs. The only way Pakistanis can succeed is if they ask for sincere guidance from Allah and not these bs seminaries


Nope, saudi doesnt have any Islamic law either

Sir Tafsir Ibn Katheer and Sahih Bukhari are not some random books they are tafseer and Sayings of HAZRAT MUHAMMAD SAW and we have to follow every order of HAZRAT MUHAMMAD SAW and Arabs know what they are reading and have better knowledge than most so called champions of Quran in South Asia

 

[Jango]

Whenever I visit Islamabad, a new madrassah has cropped up, and it has huge boundary walls, a intimidating structure, and some students with sticks standing outside and barricades.

There is a mushroom growth.

Either destroy all these fundo madrassas or get them under government control and introduce government syllabus and everything before another lal masjid happens.

 

[ice_man]

Mulim follow Islam then Why Don Pakistan follow Sharia law...?...Being a Muslim don you think So.

no problem i guess following Sharia law is not wrong AT ALL!

 

[Zarvan]

Whenever I visit Islamabad, a new madrassah has cropped up, and it has huge boundary walls, a intimidating structure, and some students with sticks standing outside and barricades.

There is a mushroom growth.

Either destroy all these fundo madrassas or get them under government control and introduce government syllabus and everything before another lal masjid happens.

Sir the day the government try to do this kind of funny business with these Madrassas another LAL MASJID will take place for sure and that will result in far more suicide bombings than LAL MASJID what government should do is improve school education make it free and also teach more syllabus of Islam in schools than which is taught in Madrassas

 

[Jango]

a hard hand has to be taken sometime.

 

[Zarvan]

a hard hand has to be taken sometime.

No if that Hard Hand results in Civil War and results in killing of hundred thousand people

 

[shree835]

no problem i guess following Sharia law is not wrong AT ALL!

You are looking confused… Don't you…??

 

[Pakistanisage]

From the very beginning I am trying to understand that …Pakistan came into existence in the name of Islam….But Still Pakistan is not implemented Islamic Sharia law…Like Arab countries ...Please help me to understand this.

Can you name an Arab country that has implemented SHARIA LAW ?

Stop talking about things you know nothing about.

Stop Trolling.

 

[saix]

How much control does the government have over what is taught in these seminaries?

 

[Uchiha]

Sir Tafsir Ibn Katheer and Sahih Bukhari are not some random books they are tafseer and Sayings of HAZRAT MUHAMMAD SAW and we have to follow every order of HAZRAT MUHAMMAD SAW and Arabs know what they are reading and have better knowledge than most so called champions of Quran in South Asia

South Asia? South Asians arent exactly the brightest of all muslims. In fact people in South Asia like sticking to old traditions (regardless right or wrong) compared to arabs. But arabs are more diverse and likely to change.
I understand we have to follow every order of the prophet SAW but alas, we don't have reliable evidence of what he said and what he didn't

 

[Zarvan]

South Asia? South Asians arent exactly the brightest of all muslims. In fact people in South Asia like sticking to old traditions (regardless right or wrong) compared to arabs. But arabs are more diverse and likely to change.
I understand we have to follow every order of the prophet SAW but alas, we don't have reliable evidence of what he said and what he didn't

Mr we have reliable evidence and Sir you can't follow most orders of Quran without following Hadees and Hadees are the most reliable thing with the Quran in this world only those who want to deny Quran say this

 

[Icewolf]

Mulim follow Islam then Why Don Pakistan follow Sharia law...?...Being a Muslim don you think So.

Sharia law was never popular in Pakistan... Only Mullahs want Sharia which is like 0.01% of the pop... Check out popularity of Jamaat-e-Islami now which used to be popular before

 

[Zarvan]

Sharia law was never popular in Pakistan... Only Mullahs want Sharia which is like 0.01% of the pop... Check out popularity of Jamaat-e-Islami now which used to be popular before

Mr according to all latest surveys more than 80 %Muslims want Shariah and you say only 0.001 % want Shariah and if you are a Muslim you have to follow Shariah other wise according to Quran you are doing kufr