What's new

Right decision to go ahead with Russia trip, says FM Qureshi

Right decision to go ahead with Russia trip, says FM Qureshi

Dawn.com Published February 25, 2022 - Updated 11 minutes ago

Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi gestures while addressing the members of the media in Islamabad on February 25. — AFP

Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi gestures while addressing the members of the media in Islamabad on February 25. — AFP

Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi asserted on Friday that the government's decision to go ahead with the recently concluded Moscow visit was correct, explaining that there had been a shift in the country's foreign policy towards geoeconomics, which warranted progress on regional connectivity.

"If we have to move towards geoeconomics, a natural conclusion for this [to happen] is to make progress on [developing] regional connectivity [with] Afghanistan and beyond Afghanistan into Central Asian republics. And if we have to move towards regional connectivity, then Russia has an historical role ... in this region," he said while addressing a press conference in Islamabad.

"Russia being onboard will fortify our [shift in] focus towards geoeconomic regional connectivity."
The foreign minister said this and several other factors were considered before it was decided to go ahead with the Moscow visit.
"We went ahead and I am convinced after this visit that we did the right thing in going ahead," he added.

The visit coincided with escalating tensions between Russia and the West as the former launched an operation in neighbouring Ukraine.
The timing of the visit has been questioned but top Pakistani government officials termed it one of the rarest opportunities for the energy-starved country to make headway in energy and regional connectivity.
Addressing the matter, Qureshi told media persons the before Prime Minister Imran Khan left for Moscow along with a delegation of ministers, he had presided over a meeting to analyse the evolving conflict.
He said the current foreign secretary and four former foreign secretaries, former ambassadors, including those who served in Moscow, and other senior officials were present at the meeting.

"We consulted [them], we weighed pros and cons and then decided the way forward accordingly," the foreign minister said, dispelling the impression that the decision to visit Moscow was not well thought out.
He emphasised the importance of "collective wisdom" in this regard, saying that he had been inviting former ambassadors and foreign secretaries for consultation and advice after assuming the role of foreign minister.
"Institutional memory is of good use and we should benefit from experience," he said. "Using this collective wisdom, we concluded that the solid rationale for consolidation of our bilateral relations with Russia should not be lost sight of. In light of this, we decided to keep our plan for the visit unchanged."

The foreign minister further said the objective of the visit was to "maximise the diplomatic space for Pakistan".
He described the visit as "satisfactory" and said, "I believe we made the right decision. Our diplomatic space has increased."
Moreover, Qureshi said, the government saw the visit as an opportunity to take Russia into confidence on the issue of Afghanistan and the evolving situation in South Asia, particularly with regards to Indian-occupied Kashmir.
"We saw [...] it as an important opportunity that should not be squandered."

In apparent criticism of rival opposition parties, he said he saw some tweets during the visit by individuals who were "panicking".
Refusing to name anyone, he said their tweets expressed worry. "But my prime minister, on the other hand, did not seem perturbed and was confident."

Qureshi said one of the reasons behind this could be that PM Imran did not have accounts or assets in any Western capital.

'US contacted Pakistan before Moscow visit'​

He revealed that the US administration had made a "high-level" contact with Pakistan before the Moscow visit.
Using a catchword used by anchorperson Waseem Badami, Qureshi added: "They (the US) asked us a masoomana (innocent) question and we gave them a respectful reply."
When asked to elaborate further, he said the US conveyed its perspective and Pakistan communicated its point view, as well as the objective and background of the visit.
"And as I said, [the plan for the visit] remained unchanged."

'Will not be part of any camp'​

Qureshi referred to a statement by PM Imran, wherein the premier said Pakistan did not want to be in a position that implied that it was part of a certain camp.
"In view of past experiences, we have made this big decision not to be part of any camp politics," the foreign minister reiterated.
"We will move forward with what is in the interest of Pakistan. Period. This is our focus, this is our priority, and we are moving forward in line with this [philosophy]," he said, adding that today, Pakistan was broadly engaged and had good relations with all major powers of the world.

In response to a question whether PM Imran's visit to Moscow did not give the impression that Pakistan was backing Russia in the ongoing conflict, Qureshi said it depended on how one viewed things.
"We are not part of any camp politics and we don't intend to be," he added.

The foreign minster said Pakistan had paid a huge price for being part of camp politics, adding that it would "maintain ties with all". In this connection, he gave the example of Germany, where he said he would visit soon.
Today, Qureshi said, Pakistan was presenting its stance before the world in a self-respecting manner.
"There is newness in our foreign policy and Pakistan is moving towards a self-respecting and independent foreign policy," he said. "We have shifted our focus from geopolitics to geoeconomics in light of past experiences."

Stance on Ukraine situation​

To a question about whether PM Imran had made any offer to Russian President Vladimir Putin to mediate between Russia and Ukraine, the foreign minister said both leaders presented their stance on the matter in the meeting.
But, he said, the visit was not planned keeping in view the situation in Ukarine.
"It was being planned for a long time," Qureshi said, outlining multiple occasions of bilateral engagement with Russia. "This bilateral visit was planned in that context," he added.

However, he said, since a situation had arisen, "we presented our stance on the matter and heard theirs."
The foreign minister said PM Imran had spoken about the issue at an "appropriate time and place", stressing that it should be resolved through diplomacy.

"Because when a country or region engages in a military conflict, it results in a loss for all, especially developing countries," Qureshi said, adding that the results of the Russia-Ukraine conflict were already appearing in the shape of rising oil prices.
He called for exercising restraint and said there was still a possibility of resolving the issue through diplomatic efforts.
In response to a question, he said Pakistan had diplomatic ties with Ukraine and "we give importance to them."
Moreover, he said, "Our military ties with Russia are improving."

Assistance to citizens in Ukraine​

The foreign minister assured that authorities in Pakistan were in touch with Pakistan's embassy in the Ukrainian capital, Kyiv.
He said he had a detailed phone conversationwith Pakistan's ambassador to Ukraine before the press conference.
The minister said clear directives were also issued to Pakistan's embassy in Kyiv for ensuring the safety of the country's diaspora in Ukraine before the Moscow visit.

Moreover, he said, there were around 3,000 Pakistani students in Ukraine and the embassy had been contacted to ensure that they were moved to safe areas and eventually sent back home.
"We are in constant touch with them," he said, adding that in order to facilitate the student's evacuation, Pakistan's embassy had been shifted from Kyiv to Ternopil.

He dismissed reports that a Pakistani student had been killed in Ukraine.
"I spoke to the ambassador and he told me that all our children are safe so far," the minister said, expressing the hope that their evacuation would be completed soon. "Their anxiety is understandable and we will provide them all the help they need."

Recap of the visit​

Qureshi began his speech with a round up of the visit, saying that the meeting between PM Imran and President Putin lasted for around three-and-a-half hours.

He said both leaders exchanged views on the improvement in and positive trajectory of ties between Pakistan and Russia over the past few years. Moreover, he said, regional matters, especially the situation in Afghanistan and the security and stability of South Asia, were discussed.

"PM Imran took him (Putin) into confidence over occupied Kashmir and shared Pakistan's stance on the matter," he added.

He said energy cooperation was also discussed in the meeting, with particular focus on Pakistan Stream gas pipeline, as well as the rising trend of Islamophobia.
When asked about the progress on the building of Pakistan Stream gas pipeline, which is being constructed in collaboration with Russia, Qureshi said there was agreement on most matters and there would be discussion on remaining issues next month.
"We hope that it will be completed soon," he added.

Qureshi further told media persons that Russia's Deputy Prime Minister Alexander Novak and Energy Minister Nikolay Shulginov called on PM Imran and discussed bilateral trade and investment opportunities.
Energy cooperation was also discussed with them, he said, adding that Pakistan had expressed interest in purchasing gas from Russia through a long-term government-to-government arrangement.

He said it was proposed that the gas pipeline between Russia and Uzbekistan be extended to Pakistan via Afghanistan.
The minister added that Russia had also expressed interest on the establishment of a liquified natural gas terminal in Gwadar.
He said PM Imran and other ministers had also addressed a forum of Russian and Pakistani businessmen and discussed opportunities for cooperative arrangement in the future.

"We also discussed ways to remove procedural bottlenecks in trade and economic linkages," added.
The foreign minister termed the discussion productive, adding that several businessmen had indicated interest in participating in a investment conference that would be organised in Islamabad in March.

PM Imran also visited Moscow's central mosque and met its grand mufti during the visit, he said.
The minister then shared some of the salient features from a statement issued by the Foreign Office after the visit.
When asked about opposition parties approaching Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf's allies, he said they may hold as many meetings as they want. "It does not affect us."
The foreign minister announce that he would visit Ghotki tomorrow where he would respond to the opposition.
 
.
. . .
My naive views:
  • Pak very much has decided her future course of actions, which requires a close association with the Sino-Russo axis
  • Without Russia no connectivity to the Central Asia
  • Without Russia no gas from the Central Asia
  • Russian cooperation is required to make Afghanistan viable and feasible
  • Etc.
 
. .
Yes but the other camp will say so will USA/Biden.
I say they've used us when it's suited them otherwise sanctions and more sanctions.

If the other camp says so - ask them how many times Biden has called or spoken to IK. Biden's failure / refusal to engage with Pakistan gives the Pak government the perfect excuse to engage with Russia. They can't blame you when they themselves refuse to engage with you.
 
.
If the other camp says so - ask them how many times Biden has called or spoken to IK. Biden's failure / refusal to engage with Pakistan gives the Pak government the perfect excuse to engage with Russia. They can't blame you when they themselves refuse to engage with you.
Totally agree brother
 
.
In some way, I'd say that the Russians used Imran Khan to send a message to India. The timing can't be entirely a coincidence :unsure:
 
. .
It is difficult to say whether it was the right or wrong move but one thing that no one can deny is that this visit will never be forgotten.

A visit on any other day of the year would have been ignored by everyone, but as it would happen, the visit happened on the day of the invasion and because of that, it became major news in every capital of the world from Washington to Beijing.

I think one thing that a lot of people forget is that it is more important to be relevant than to be liked. Being powerful requires having powerful enemies. There will be a lot of countries who will hate Pakistan for this but that is the price that you pay for being bold and being relevant. There are very few leaders out there who would have the balls to stay in Moscow during a Russian invasion of Ukraine in what is arguably one of the most decisive moments in the post-WWII era.

This visit was the clearest, most unmistakable signal that could be sent to the West that any illusions of Pakistani loyalty to Europe and America are over. It is as clear as it gets and ultimately that is a good thing. Sometimes a clean break to end a bad relationship is better than dragging it on for years. Pakistan had been looking for a moment exactly like this to end the US-Pakistan era of broken promises once and for all and we finally made good on that word.

For Pakistan, there are no illusions here. Russia is far more important to Pakistan than Ukraine has been or ever will be. Russia is a global power, whether they are sanctioned or not does not matter. Look at Iran, every kind of sanction that exists has been put on them, but it hasn't worked. Iran is the most powerful in the country today by a significant margin. There was a time in the past that America vowed never to negotiate with Iran, but today, not only America but all of their allies have been forced to the table in Vienna to deal with the consequences of their arrogance.

Russia will remember Pakistan being there during the good and bad times and that matters. The world is filled with countries who can backstab you at any moment and it is more important than ever to have allies who will actually stick by you when everyone else runs away. Biden has snubbed Pakistan at every turn and every opportunity. There is no lost love for them. They are reaping what they sowed.

As for Putin, imagine how valuable his time was during the day of the invasion, a once in a several decades type event that Russia has prepared for years, since the end of the Cold War. NATO has been dreading this day for decades. Russia has been waiting for this day for decades. You cannot put a price on how valuable Putin's time would have been during this day. The time and insight that Pakistan got by observing Putin at war, up close, inside the Kremlin itself, how Putin launches an invasion of Ukraine from inside the Kremlin is the kind of stuff that money cannot buy. Now imagine that on what some people would describe as one of the most important days of Putin's entire career, he gave several hours of his time just to talk with Imran Khan.

I could not have imagined or made something like this up, sometimes reality is stranger than fiction. If you had told me one month ago that Imran Khan would be inside the Kremlin on the day Putin invades Ukraine I would never have believed it. You cannot put a price on opportunities like this, IK was the only foreign leader in the Kremlin on that day. Xi Jinping would have killed for an opportunity like this. Imran Khan would be the only leader in the world who actually knows how Putin reacted to the initial hours of the invasion and what his mood was like. Some day he will write a book and reveal the secrets that only he knew. No amount of US intelligence from the best of CIA and MI6 will be as good as what ISI and Pakistan knows by being inside the Kremlin itself during the invasion. People always underestimate the ISI and that has always been a losing bet. The information gained during black swan events like this influences intelligence calculations and the results of those calculations creates a trajectory that can last for decades in the future. Russia wants Pakistan to be on the same page as them and that is why Pakistan was in Moscow when it mattered.

There are only 2 countries in the world who knew what was really going on inside the Kremlin during the invasion: Russia and Pakistan. Putin is an ex-KGB for a reason, if he wants Pakistan to be on his side, he knew how to make it happen and he did. It speaks volumes that he sees Pakistan as important enough to be given time during the height of his power. Pakistan will become ever more relevant going forward and Russia knows that, Putin wants the west to have no ambiguity that Russia is on our side. It will no doubt become a big problem for Pakistan's adversaries but that is to the benefit of both Pakistan and Russia. There was certainly a period where there was nothing to show for languishing Pakistan-Russia ties other than some exchange of pleasantries but surely those days are over and now the real foundations for future cooperation will be laid.

If you expect someone to back you up during your difficult times, then you must back them up when it is their difficult times. If we ever expect Russia's help when the time comes to take back Kashmir, then it is no surprise that we would have to follow through on the visit to Moscow regardless of whatever optics that brings. Anybody can be Russia's friend during the good times, it is those who stand by Russia during their difficult times that Moscow will remember. Money can buy favors but not loyalty. Only trust.
 
Last edited:
. .
I think in India this day will go down as a once a decade, conspiracy type major black swan event with the likes of the Zia plane crash and Benazir assassination. The real truth will probably never be known. This visit was planned long in advance and surprised many. Who knows how long this visit was actually in the works. Only Putin, Imran Khan and the people closest to them will really know what actually happened inside the Kremlin on the day of the invasion. If there were any doubts about ISI being a premier intelligence agency, they can be laid to rest.
 
.
I think in India this day will go down as a once a decade, conspiracy type major black swan event with the likes of the Zia plane crash and Benazir assassination. The real truth will probably never be known. This visit was planned long in advance and surprised many. Who knows how long this visit was actually in the works. Only Putin, Imran Khan and the people closest to them will really know what actually happened inside the Kremlin on the day of the invasion. If there were any doubts about ISI being a premier intelligence agency, they can be laid to rest.
Nothing you said makes sense and it has little to no connection with your last statement, it's all just words creating hype

A diplomatic meet is not how you measure the capabilities or competency of an intelligence agency

ISI is definitely overrated
 
.
Nothing you said makes sense and it has little to no connection with your last statement, it's all just words creating hype

A diplomatic meet is not how you measure the capabilities or competency of an intelligence agency

ISI is definitely overrated

A "diplomatic meet" as you would have it would would have happened on any other day of the year, not on the day of the actual invasion. As for ISI, they definitely have some cards left to play.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom