Religious Freedom in Islamic Countries- can u plz explain this?

[KS]

I think you assume Muslim countries are like India where HISTORIC mosques are burned down , becasue some pujari burried some idol in sand and claimed he found it there

Mind ur words mister .
Dont step into waters that are unknown to u.....
For u that mosque is historical ..but for me that temple or idol is religious and so much much more important than history.

 

[sparklingway]

All religions dislike the free market when it comes to faith. No religion, absolutely none appreciates another faith group proselytizing in their backyard.

Reactions are different. Some in tolerant societies are forced to accept the other groups nibbing in the backyard and recruiting faithfuls. Others in countries with medieval and tribal norms use force and threats.

 

[ice_man]

Is it possible to build a temple in saudi ?

is it possible to build a mosque in VATICAN???

well to be honest there must be a church in DAMAM but non of them are official they are in the US ARMY cantonment!

 

[Agnostic_Indian]

All religions dislike the free market when it comes to faith. No religion, absolutely none appreciates another faith group proselytizing in their backyard.

Excatly....and all i am waiting is for a change.....

 

[sparklingway]

is it possible to build a mosque in VATICAN???

Saudi Arabia is 1.88 million times bigger than the Vatican.

You should have directed it towards a highly catholic country.

PS: Muslims can visit the Vatican but non-Muslims cannot visit Mecca.

 

[Agnostic_Indian]

is it possible to build a mosque in VATICAN???

Is the answer a NO..?

 

[Spring Onion]

Mind ur words mister .
Dont step into waters that are unknown to u.....
For u that mosque is historical ..but for me that temple or idol is religious and so much much more important than history.

Hindus failed to prove that it was idols worship place.

The fanatic Hindus burnt Babri Mosque, not only that but we have seen they also burnt Christians alive for the reason that they converted from Hinduism and were preaching Christianity.

 

[Spring Onion]

Saudi Arabia is 1.88 million times bigger than the Vatican.

You should have directed it towards a highly catholic country.

PS: Muslims can visit the Vatican but non-Muslims cannot visit Mecca.

Saudi is not the entire Muslim world


Secondly why would Non-Muslims visit Khana Kaba ??? Its not a tourist spot neither a place to carry on your hobby of clicking. Isnt it a worship place ?


On the other hand you can see the city no harm in that

 

[sparklingway]

Saudi is not the entire Muslim world


Secondly why would Non-Muslims visit Khana Kaba ??? Its not a tourist spot neither a place to carry on your hobby of clicking. Isnt it a worship place ?


On the other hand you can see the city no harm in that

I commented on the merits of his argument and did not form my own. Therefore, I need not reply. However, your argument about tourism falls apart since non-Muslims cannot enter the city at all. Visiting the Ka'aba is a whole different thing. I hope you've seen the road sign with "Muslims Only" and exit for non-Muslims before Mecca.

 

[humanfirst]

@jana
We have also seen hindus evicted from village because a child drank from mosque and christians murdered on fake blasphemy charges(just this month).All these are isolated incidents like the killing of christian missionary in india and we are ashamed of it.And babri masjid demolition was another shameful act did by the perception that emporer had demolished a temple Another isolated incident.Dont try to derail the topic by bringing isolated incidents

 

[Spring Onion]

I commented on the merits of his argument and did not form my own. Therefore, I need not reply. However, your argument about tourism falls apart since non-Muslims cannot enter the city at all. Visiting the Ka'aba is a whole different thing. I hope you've seen the road sign with "Muslims Only" and exit for non-Muslims before Mecca.

What is there in the city which the tourists will see? And how many Non-Muslims actually visit Saudia for tourism or for entering Ka,aba to be more simple ???


I do not know the reason Saudis give for not allowing non-Muslims, but logically i dont think so any logic why any Hindu or Jew would like to visit Kaaba.


On the other hand we know that Non-Muslims (kuffar) were allowed in the era of Khilaft-e-Rashda as Hazrat Omar you used to listen to complaints of Jews against Muslim rulers (governors) in different areas, during Hajj.

 

[notsuperstitious]

I think there is freedom to propagate other religion in most most muslim countries(Except saudi)I have seen indian christian missionaries who work in indonesia(biggest muslim country by population),UAE etc

UAE does not allow any non muslim to propagate.

Indonesia is NOT a muslim country, its muslim majority.

Hindus failed to prove that it was idols worship place.

The fanatic Hindus burnt Babri Mosque, not only that but we have seen they also burnt Christians alive for the reason that they converted from Hinduism and were preaching Christianity.

Criminal activities and state sanctioned discrimination are not exactly comparable, except for those who support state sanctioned discrimination and are merely looking for a justification. Criminal activities in Muslim countries, including Pakistan, are not being debated here.

 

[Spring Onion]

@jana
We have also seen hindus evicted from village because a child drank from mosque and christians murdered on fake blasphemy charges(just this month).All these are isolated incidents like the killing of christian missionary in india and we are ashamed of it.And babri masjid demolition was another shameful act did by the perception that emporer had demolished a temple Another isolated incident.Dont try to derail the topic by bringing isolated incidents

And we debated and condemned that. It was just one acceptional case where barbaric Feduls did that in Sindh. Sindh is still under practices of Hinduism prevalent in interior. The Muslim Feudal lords have adopted many discriminatory Hindu rituals.

On the other hand the practice of not eating in the same plat of even sit together with a low cast Hindu in Hinudism is still prevalent, this untouchable practice is there despite passage of thousands of Years.

And you can not call it isolated incident. The killing of Chrisitians not on few numbers but in thousands in orrisa can not be called isolated incident.


As far as misuse of blasphemy laws in our country than its not limited to non-Muslims, as many Muslims have been killed using this law which is unfortunate and should be changed.

 

[sparklingway]

What is there in the city which the tourists will see? And how many Non-Muslims actually visit Saudia for tourism or for entering Ka,aba to be more simple ???

That is not an argument but rather a justification for something you seem to be confused about yourself. Say the Pope restricts all non-catholics from entering the Vatican. I guess most people will be battering that point all the time.

Just saying.

I do not know the reason Saudis give for not allowing non-Muslims, but logically i dont think so any logic why any Hindu or Jew would like to visit Kaaba.

Check 9:28. Also, Mecca is bigger than just Ka'aba now. "Not having any reason to visit" should follow that they will not be present. A complete ban on entry is a different thing. Apologizing with something that simply is illogical and discriminatory is pretty wrong.

 

[notsuperstitious]

And you can not call it isolated incident. The killing of Chrisitians not on few numbers but in thousands in orrisa can not be called isolated incident.

You are a supposed reporter but in Ahmed Qureshi mould. Prove with neutral links that thousands were killed in Orissa or shut up.