Qasba ali Garh killings 1986

[Sinnerman108]

While I am deeply saddened about the loss of Urdu people during that operation,

We must not forget the historic oppression by Urdu Spanking People since 1948,

And the brutal oppression since 1983 by Urdu people.

Why it is that Sindh's major city aka Karachi has been ethnically cleansed of top posts all thanks to Urdu Spanking people.

Can you ever imagine Lahore without Punjabis in the top posts, Peshawar without Pathans in the top posts, and Quetta without Balochis without top posts in politics, admin, judiciary, etc. etc.

No.

But my friends my community has wiped out the native Sindhi population from top jobs in the city.

And

then so many of us sit together, eat Pulao, and blame Sindhis and other ethnicities for all the $hit. .


Sadly.

Agreed.

I think the roots of KHI problem go back to before Islamabad was made Pakistan's capital.
I believe the sense of hostility took birth at that time amongst the local ethnic groups against the migrants.
It is logical to assume that this hostility was due to deprivation.
The deprivation may have been due to the fact that the migrant population was possibly better educated and more skilled than the local options.
However the migrant population did use it's advantage in education and skill (1947 - 1960s) and systematically cleansed all positions of power from locals.

There is a cultural aspect to the problem as well, which I do not want to discuss at this moment.

 

[W.11]

Agreed.

I think the roots of KHI problem go back to before Islamabad was made Pakistan's capital.
I believe the sense of hostility took birth at that time amongst the local ethnic groups against the migrants.
It is logical to assume that this hostility was due to deprivation.
The deprivation may have been due to the fact that the migrant population was possibly better educated and more skilled than the local options.
However the migrant population did use it's advantage in education and skill (1947 - 1960s) and systematically cleansed all positions of power from locals.

There is a cultural aspect to the problem as well, which I do not want to discuss at this moment.

can you be more specific, what do you mean by local and what do you mean by migrants

i don't want to be racist and ethnic biased because i love my country more than these pity things which divides the nation

 

[Viking 63]

My heart goes out to those poor souls who lost their lives, to women who lost their Honor by these Barbarians from the North !! Qasba Aligarh victims have never received justice !! I know who are these people but right now this forums rules are keep me from saying things. ! I can say a lot about Punjabis and Pathans !! I was never an racist or communal but I learned how others behave how they look at you . MQM is the result of same Bigotary which is open and practised like religion in Pakistan.

No one has forgotten about this Massacre not in Karachi and I can promise that payback time is coming soon !!!!
MQM ZINDABAD !!!!!!!!!!!

 

[FaujHistorian]

My heart goes out to those poor souls who lost their lives, to women who lost their Honor by these Barbarians from the North !! Qasba Aligarh victims have never received justice !! I know who are these people but right now this forums rules are keep me from saying things. ! I can say a lot about Punjabis and Pathans !! I was never an racist or communal but I learned how others behave how they look at you . MQM is the result of same Bigotary which is open and practised like religion in Pakistan.

No one has forgotten about this Massacre not in Karachi and I can promise that payback time is coming soon !!!!
MQM ZINDABAD !!!!!!!!!!!

You sound very similar to the goons of TTP and others you hate.

What a waste of being in Canada and having a privilige to live in an enlightened society .

Because your talk is just like a 2-bit terrorist.

 

[W.11]

You sound very similar to the goons of TTP and others you hate.

What a waste of being in Canada and having a privilige to live in an enlightened society .

Because your talk is just like a 2-bit terrorist.

can you shed some light on this please

 

[FaujHistorian]

Agreed.

I think the roots of KHI problem go back to before Islamabad was made Pakistan's capital.
I believe the sense of hostility took birth at that time amongst the local ethnic groups against the migrants.
It is logical to assume that this hostility was due to deprivation.
The deprivation may have been due to the fact that the migrant population was possibly better educated and more skilled than the local options.
However the migrant population did use it's advantage in education and skill (1947 - 1960s) and systematically cleansed all positions of power from locals.

There is a cultural aspect to the problem as well, which I do not want to discuss at this moment.

UPiets and Biharis migrated to both W. Pakistan and E. Pakistan from 1948 to 1950s under government quota schemes.

It is unfortunate to see that in both the places we were utterly hated group due to our tribal and prejudiced attitudes towards local Sindhi and Bengali culture.

peace

can you shed some light on this please

Anyone raising slogans of Murda wa Qatil Movement (MQM) while talking about killings by other ethnic groups is?

Yeah

Tell me

He is ???


just a hypocrite at best.


Thank you

 

[W.11]

Anyone raising slogans of Murda wa Qatil Movement (MQM) while talking about killings by other ethnic groups is?

Yeah

Tell me

He is ???


just a hypocrite at best.


Thank you

please remain on the point and answer my question


i have one more question from you when you finish giving answer to my previous question

 

[FaujHistorian]

please remain on the point and answer my question


i have one more question from you when you finish giving answer to my previous question

Please post your interpretation of specific event/questions and we can discuss.

Cut and paste job is no good.


Thank you

can you be more specific, what do you mean by local and what do you mean by migrants

i don't want to be racist and ethnic biased because i love my country more than these pity things which divides the nation

You question like Clinton asking $tupid question when accused of doing hanky phanky with Monica

Clinton said --- Define sex

hahahah


hahahaahh

 

[Viking 63]

You sound very similar to the goons of TTP and others you hate.

What a waste of being in Canada and having a privilige to live in an enlightened society .

Because your talk is just like a 2-bit terrorist.

And you sound typically of all what I hate with a passion ""An Hypocrite"" You may be on wrong path and side of history. Yes I live in Canada but what do you know about this country and its so called perception of enlightened society. you call your self FuijiHistorian but one who has very shallow depth on things and issues specially on domestic ground realities in Pakistan. You would have never equated me with TTP goons had you understood the meaning of my post. It was written with severe restraint, and I also have seen the kind of Restraint shown and excercised by so called brave army of PAKISTAN
in 1992 Karachi operations.!!! AND on personal note please rest assured that me living in Canada is not a waste in any way. My success both personally ,professionally, and Materially and not to mention spiritually is something you and your likes can only dream off !!!!

 

[W.11]

Please post your interpretation of specific event/questions and we can discuss.

Cut and paste job is no good.


Thank you

i just want your analysis on the news piece, why are you diverting the discussion again and again

if you don't like to comment on it, just say it i wont bother you again!

You question like Clinton asking $tupid question when accused of doing hanky phanky with Monica

Clinton said --- Define sex

hahahah


hahahaahh

am i guilty or accused of some thing? my dear lord?

 

[FaujHistorian]

...My success both personally ,professionally, and Materially and not to mention spiritually is something you and your likes can only dream off !!!!

OK

Now you have injected this me-me-me-me thingy so I have to respond. Why are you making this personal?


Please keep it on the level of ideas. Thank you.

So let me with due respect add,

It is a shame that with material success, spirituality went out of the door for many die hard fanboyz of the fatso and now

So many are raising slogans

of

Murda wa Qatil Movement (MQM) as if Altaf Mota Chor is a reincarnation of Jesus (Nauzbilla).

Running away from Karachi's killing fields instead of facing the terrible situation here is what?

Bigora pun

But that's OK and understandable.


However the way Altaf Mota chor is

raising slogans for the Murdas and Qatils

is a sure sign of

utter depravity at least spiritually.


But so many will never understand

Summun bukmun is nothing new.

Has happened in the past all the times. Heck by Murda Movement's definition, Hitler and Nazis would be very enlightened! spiritually!.

What a shame

i just want your analysis on the news piece, ?

Then do your homework, express your OWN views on the news piece. Cut and paste is a high schooler's method, Should not be yours

Thank you

 

[W.11]

Then do your homework, express your OWN views on the news piece. Cut and paste is a high schooler's method, Should not be yours

Thank you

you are more senior than me,

i have asked to bestow

your divine knowledge onto me,

i know nothing im empty vessel,

you are think tank,

you think more,

curse more, so please,

now without wasting my time,

i need some knowledge

from you

 

[FaujHistorian]

...

i need some knowledge

from you

Then please write down your questions,

Give me some view. If I agree with your views re: these questions. Great. I'll say so.

But you should know that if I disagree, I'll let you know too.

So

What are your questions/opinions?


Thank you

p..s I am ignoring your sarcasm as I really want to see what you can bring to the table (in addition to the cut and past thingy).

 

[Viking 63]

OK

Now you have injected this me-me-me-me thingy so I have to respond. Why are you making this personal?


Please keep it on the level of ideas. Thank you.

So let me with due respect add,

It is a shame that with material success, spirituality went out of the door for many die hard fanboyz of the fatso and now

So many are raising slogans

of

Murda wa Qatil Movement (MQM) as if Altaf Mota Chor is a reincarnation of Jesus (Nauzbilla).

Running away from Karachi's killing fields instead of facing the terrible situation here is what?

Bigora pun

But that's OK and understandable.


However the way Altaf Mota chor is

raising slogans for the Murdas and Qatils

is a sure sign of

utter depravity at least spiritually.


But so many will never understand

Summun bukmun is nothing new.

Has happened in the past all the times. Heck by Murda Movement's definition, Hitler and Nazis would be very enlightened! spiritually!.

What a shame



Then do your homework, express your OWN views on the news piece. Cut and paste is a high schooler's method, Should not be yours

Thank you

You are definatly not from Karachi or grew up during 70.80,90s had you been we will not be having this discussion If you are actually part of this website think tank and I really hope for the sake of it that you are not, I have not come across someone so naïve almost to the point of utter stupidity !! It is not Altaf Hussain as person but his movement we all adhere to. No one is immortal he will die one day just like you me and others. But the movement goes on and fight continues, I don't live in color world but iam fully aware of what ills Pakistani society.
And yes Hitler and Nazis were a very enlightened group spiritually under their own Garp of being righteous and correct as it was part of their Third Reich manifesto, ""Aryan and Martial Race"" but it will be very difficult for you to understand, just like your ANCESTORS FROM some remote village of Punjab or Frontier did, and showed their true delight of spirituality by death,destruction and PILLAGE IN EAST PAKISTAN,BALUCHISTAN,AND KARACHI !!!
So do not tell me about what's right and wrong because it is just this prejudiced and Bigatory which you so enthusiastically practice that I stand in your way and will till I die !!!!

 

[Sinnerman108]

@FaujHistorian

He won't stop, he had a predefined notion which he is not willing to put to test.
He wants to hear only what he believes and will refuse to understand anything else.