What's new

Pukhtoons first and Sikh later

ajpirzada

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 4, 2008
Messages
6,011
Reaction score
11
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Pukhtoons first and Sikh later

Friday, May 15, 2009
By Kamal Siddiqi

HASAN ABDAL: The Gurdwara Panja Sahib, located in Hasan Abdal, has so far received 340 displaced families from places as far away as Swat and Malakand. Many of those who turned up at the Gurdwara fled their homes with only their clothes on their back.

Dr Ashok, a six-foot-tall man hailing from the Pir Baba village in Buner, said he decided to leave his home when there was a lull in fighting. “We headed for Hasan Abdal, because this is the only place we know,” he added.

While children play in the courtyard of the Gurdwara and women wash their clothes in the water channel down below, Dr Suran Singh of the Pak-Sikh Gurdwara Parbandhan Committee worries about how to cater for the growing number of arrivals. Dr Singh, a homeopathic doctor, left his clinic in Buner and fled with his six family members packed in his small Suzuki on April 28. Back home, he was an elected member of the local council. Since his arrival in Hasan Abdal, he has taken charge as spokesman and chief organiser of the group. He said the only thing people wanted now was to go home.

Many people are still left behind in the troubled areas. The fighting on the main highway has discouraged them from travelling and there is hope that they will come once there is a break in the curfew and fighting. Dr Singh said in many ways, the Sikhs had been lucky to have a place to come to. “Many of our Muslim neighbours and friends have ended up in tents,” he said, adding that the reason why most had fled was because of fear of shelling.

When asked about the Jiziya tax that the Taliban were believed to have imposed on the Sikhs living in areas controlled by the militants, Dr Singh said these reports were untrue. “I have not been approached.

In fact, the Taliban came to my area on April 4 and for almost a month, we lived under their control. We only fled when the fighting intensified.” However, others said they had indeed heard of the tax. “I know families in Tirah who were told to pay,” said one young man. Others said the Taliban had held some Sikhs against their will and imposed a levy on the community. One man said the Taliban confiscated the homes of the people who fled rather than paid the tax.

Most of the Sikh families which arrived in Hasan Abdal left behind a family member; many of them in the areas which were under intense firing and shelling. Others closed their homes, shops, clinics and offices and moved out.

Many worry about their family members back home. Others said they fear the worst once they get back. Almost all of the men and women from the Sikh community, who arrived from the troubled areas, are educated and from middle-income backgrounds. Most of them speak Pushto fluently and feel at home in the wider Pukhtoon community.

Some worry that their properties would be targeted and looted once the violence dies down. Others hope and pray that they get the opportunity to rebuild their homes and lives. One sign that their stay at Hasan Abdal would be longer than expected is that the children are being offered admission in the school adjoining the Gurdwara.

Some Sikh women are already spending time at the school teaching for a few hours. They said this helped release their stress. As the capacity of the Gurdwara to accommodate people reaches its limit, the Sikhs have started to rent places around the town. But rentals have also gone up, given the unexpected demand. Locals also worry that the arrival of so many Sikh families may upset the ethnic balance of the little town.

Manzoor Bhatti, the caretaker of the Gurdwara, belongs to the Evacuee Trust Property Board. He said the Sikhs, many of whom are professional doctors and engineers, were happy to run their own affairs. So far, both the government and the United Nations have helped with the supplies.

However, to sustain such a large number over a longer period would be difficult. He said he was hoping for the best. This optimism is shared by people like Sandeep Kumar, a student of the Edward’s College in Peshawar. He said his family never migrated to India after partition, “because the Muslims in our area begged us to stay on.” Now, however, “we have been forced out by the extremists, not our neighbours.”

Asked to comment on the offer to migrate to India, Dr Suran Singh said with a smile: “We are Pakhtoons first and Sikhs later. These times are troubling for all the Pakhtoons, not just the Pakistani Sikhs. We need to fight this challenge together.” This is a sentiment shared by many of the people, who have taken refuge in the Gurdwara.
Pukhtoons first and Sikh later
 
. .
No surprise why any Indian decided not to comment on this one.
 
.
No surprise why any Indian decided not to comment on this one.

Comment on what? That Sikhs are patriotic and don't let their religion come in the way of the greater good? We already know that :)

And about pakhtun first, sikh later, pakistani first, pakhtun later but muslim first, pakistani later etc etc have been debated to death on other threads.
 
.
No surprise why any Indian decided not to comment on this one.

Hold your horses.

My opinion is:fantastic. I totally agree with them. But do all Pakistanis think the same way?

Similarly for Indian Muslims. Indians first, Muslims a long and distant second. That is essentially the ideal India strives for, can't say the same for Pakistan.
 
.
I hope they can return home soon and live in peace amazing they have loyalty to their home even after they suffered so much we should be grateful to them for this and do even more to protect them.
I'm surprised i thought religion would come before your ethnic group for sikhs just like it's supposed to be for muslims(though it isn't) looks like the pukthoon pride goes is in sikhs too like all pukhtoons.
 
.
they are a very proud race in general but pashtoons are extremely hospitable and would consider them theyre own which is why i think the sikhs consider themselves pashtoon first sikh later i wonder have any of the members met a pashto speakin sikh
 
.
most CHINESE ARE BUDDHISTS SO WOULD THEY COME TO INDIA IF THEY HAVE TROUBLES IN CHINA ...TELLING SIKHS AS INDIANS IS PURE INJUSTICE .....:hitwall:
 
. .
what are u smoking wat r u trying to say

WATCH UR LANGUAGE ....if you dont have anything to post about the topic then refrain from doing so

sikhs live all over the world ..so do budhists ...hindus and muslims ....just because he has some problems in that country would you ask him weather he would consider moving to the place of his religions origin ...asking such a question by the reporter shows how much he sees them as his countrymen
 
.
from the looks of it ur post had nothing to do with the topic and stop trying to be so politically correct their safety comes first. no its because if they are in danger it would be suitable to move them to a place where they are the large majority, if they are getting threats from the general population then its not safe but as it is they have been treated as their own and are facing the same dangers as everyone else
 
.
WATCH UR LANGUAGE ....if you dont have anything to post about the topic then refrain from doing so

sikhs live all over the world ..so do budhists ...hindus and muslims ....just because he has some problems in that country would you ask him weather he would consider moving to the place of his religions origin ...asking such a question by the reporter shows how much he sees them as his countrymen

so now u blame the reporter. gud one. he asked the question in light of reports floatin in ur media that sikhs in pakistan want to come to india.
and its not about pathan first, sikh first, muslim first, pakistani first, but its all about ones character, loyalty and what he considers to be his soil.
 
Last edited:
.
I just hope we can all live in peace & friendship soon ! this blood shed is enough no body is first & second we should all be equal and live among each other i really do pray for that day to come soon inshallah!
 
.
I just hope we can all live in peace & friendship soon ! this blood shed is enough no body is first & second we should all be equal and live among each other i really do pray for that day to come soon inshallah!

inshAllah:pakistan:
 
.
so now u blame the reporter. gud one. he asked the question in light of reports floatin in ur media that sikhs in pakistan want to come to india.
and its not about pathan first, sikh first, muslim first, pakistani first, but its all about ones character, loyalty and what he considers to be his soil.

whom else did i blame in the first place ..and why do you wish to support him ...how do you feel when someone asks you weather you are smoking in reply to your very first post ...please stop it ....indian reporter stated that right ...how much weight does it carry ..not as much as a FORMER PRESIDENT RIGHT(refering to musharraf) ...be kind to me and expect the same kind of treatment from me too

:cheers:
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom