What's new

Featured Project Azm: Pakistan's Ambitious Quest to Develop 5th Generation Military Technologies.

.
Hi,

This is a defence forum---and not a " truth forum ". There is information and there is dis-information.

As a patriotic pakistani---it is my duty to sabotage the enemy's assessment of my country's warfare capabilities and equipment---and I believe that I have done well on that front by providing information or giving out misleading information over the years as the need was---.

Some believe that at a certain time the enemy was shocked to find things otherwise---. I am proud to have been of my minor assistance to my motherland. God bless pakistan. Pakistan zindabad.


Oh my god what a warped character ?! Now you have been boasting that you have been spreading false reports and FAKED news here for years ... I really wonder what you are looking for in an international forum and it only proved my decision to ban you at the SDF for all that BS you posted.

In fact it is trolling at the worst level I ever witnessed in a forum since years.
 
.
Hi,

This is a defence forum---and not a " truth forum ". There is information and there is dis-information.

As a patriotic pakistani---it is my duty to sabotage the enemy's assessment of my country's warfare capabilities and equipment---and I believe that I have done well on that front by providing information or giving out misleading information over the years as the need was---.

Some believe that at a certain time the enemy was shocked to find things otherwise---. I am proud to have been of my minor assistance to my motherland. God bless pakistan. Pakistan zindabad.


First, you finally admit to talking BS, deliberately. Second, you're delusional in your self grandiose belief that the "enemies of Pakistan" would even take someone like you or this forum seriously or as a valid source of reliable information. Cognitive dissonance at its clearest example.
 
.
What makes a spy "Jewish"? Does he have a crooked nose and is circumcised? Why would any "spy" worth his salt come on a forum like this for reliable "inside secrets"?! The stupidity of some of these posts beggars belief, but it's what I've come to expect of Ilk who have a certain cognitive dissonance.

Hi,

His name---you did not even know that---! And you come out swinging on the forum.

Where do you think spies get their information from---.

You are just a child---ain't you.

This forum---or any other forum---amongst many other places where GOSSIP runs hard---children of military officers---parents who cannot keep secrets and children who are ready to spill them to look important---.

So many times the secrets have been leaked here on this forum and decisions made by other nations to counter them.

Please allow me to say---no disrespect---you are not very intelligent if you did not know that.

And posters like DEINO---who's questions are always nagging---like a tip of a sharp knife---cutting you---poking you---small insults---large insults---trying real hard---.

Degrading pakistan at every step of financially not being capable---calling pakistan a beggar nation multiple time on sino def forum ( why does the webmaster has this guy on this forum he can better answer that question ).

You disappointed me more with your comments---I was surprised at the lack of understanding the core issue---.
 
Last edited:
.
First, you finally admit to talking BS, deliberately. Second, you're delusional in your self grandiose belief that the "enemies of Pakistan" would even take someone like you or this forum seriously or as a valid source of reliable information. Cognitive dissonance at its clearest example.


Hi,

Son---it is okay to insult me---but learn something.

Always remember ELIA COHEN.
 
Last edited:
.
....
And posters like DEINO---who's questions are always nagging---like a tip of a sharp knife---cutting you---poking you---small insults---large insults---trying real hard---.
...


OMG :crazy:... would you please so kind and contact the secret service you are speaking of and give them a hint where to find me?
At least by now, no secret service contacted me nor do I stand on the paylist of such an organisation, but if I'm indeed such a good spy like you always portray me, then I'm sure they must be interested in this nasty nagging and insulting German teacherman. :smitten:
 
.
The only thing you've succeeded in is proving that you are a jahil equus asinus.

Hi,

I thank you very much for the blessing that you have endowed upon me.

May the enemies of pakistan think the same way as you do---Pakistan Zindabad.

And I am really really grateful for the title ASINUS---always serving the master without thanks.
 
. .
Oh my god what a warped character ?! Now you have been boasting that you have been spreading false reports and FAKED news here for years ... I really wonder what you are looking for in an international forum and it only proved my decision to ban you at the SDF for all that BS you posted.

In fact it is trolling at the worst level I ever witnessed in a forum since years.
you both I value for your participation despite differing views

please make peace
 
.
Thanks for your kind and honest reply and I cab assure you I'm in no way offended by your post. In fact as I noted, I know my limitations and they are surely undeniable. I can only hope the same in return, it was never my intention to offend you nor Pakistan.

As such I'm eager for any further input and advice from you and if it is off-topic, we shall continue via PM.

Kind regards and best,
Andreas

Thank you so much for the positive rating. As I said, despite the apparent anger underlying intend was positive in a sense that I wanted to defend the actual truth.

@Irfan Baloch
I will reply your insightful post and yes you are right on many things. You have far more experience and know much more than I do. Please have no hard feelings. There was absolutely no intention to degrade anyone. My response was just out of nationalism. i just responded based on my emotions at that time. I meant no disrespect. I try not to but sometimes I slip and make a emotions driven mistake.

I have some deadlines so for a while I won't come here on this forum and but when I will, I will say few things still sticking to the topic of project azm but on the general institutional mindset that indeed had negative effect on lots of things including impeding development of advanced science and technology. I will reply your post. For now i will be off of this forum for a while. Take good care.
 
Last edited:
. .
Thank you so much for the positive rating. As I said, despite the apparent anger underlying intend was positive in a sense that I wanted to defend the actual truth.

Deino I do know far more about Pakistan's actual capabilities. That is just true. Also stereotypical view of Pakistanis sometime leads to wrong projections of Pakistan's capabilities. Pakistanis are euro-asian people Deino. Vewing them as some permanently incompetent people does not reflect the actual reality. Some Pakistani themselves view whole Pakistan in low light (but that's come from their own poor self image which they project on the whole country Pakistan).

A Pakistani neuro-surgeon does as good in America as his/her fellow Americans. They can do the same in Pakistan given the right environment.

I have deadline and need to send 3 papers for publication (I am one of co-authors) and can't write much now. But I assure you that when I will have time, I will demonstrate that now Pakistani researchers can already not just design and analyze but can synthesize at the chemistry level many of those technologies that are critical for advanced stealth fighters.

Say If they want certain properties for non-stealth applications in nano-composites (or general composites), Pakistanis can get it done. If Pakistan wants to produce for stealth applications, they can get it done. Graphene or Carbon-nano tube based and so on all can be done. In a conservative country Pakistan where girls don't study much and yet even women are now synthesizing from the basic chemistry level advanced ( and I mean very advanced) nanocomposities with the properties they seek. As an example, here is a PhD thesis by a Pakistan girl (I think I given that above before):

Fabrication of graphene metal nano composite and its applications

This Pakistani girl used the same co-precipitation methods that were used to produce several key stealth related components of F-35 including RAM. Such things can be done now in Pakistan. Pakistani girls have even produced PhD dissertations in nonlinear analysis including specialist topics such as set-valued optimization methods (One of the key but highly advanced abstract sciences required for so many advanced engineering applications including optimization for stealth design). Such things never happened in the past. But now things are different. If girls are now doing PhDs on such complex topics, producing most complex high tech research, realize, Pakistani men are way way ahead of Pakistani girls.

Plus 10,000's are studying overseas who can be recruited if there is a need (many send/funded by Pakistani military to begin with).

Other very modern approaches such as chemical plating for expanded Graphite metallization and so on can be done by Pakistanis as they please.

In short As I said in my earlier post (which was deleted but still exists in Quots of others) that Pakistan can now produce any composites or RAM with any desired properties. There is no need to steal or copy anyone.

Addition of a large number of civilian experienced and young with fresh PhD in specialized topics has revolutionized Pakistan military's ability to do almost anything, if they can fund it.

PAF has a large number of very capable engineers who have specialist expertise in stealth, aerodynamics, structures and so on.

Money is now slowing them down wherever they are slow. Money is also needed to gain experience cause with the money you can research more and learn more and increase your expertise level.

Nonetheless Pakistan is willing to spend money at least for project AZM so if they need to perfect some technique, or gain more experience in some area, they will do it.

In any event, as agreed, i won't interfere in your posts.

But in the future i will highlight more advanced capabilities of Pakistan as far as stealth aircraft engineering is concerned. Furthermore there are a large number of Pakistani researchers around the world available to Pakistan most of whom would love to be part of such project of national importance.

Trust me, If they have trouble with some extreme technical problem, they have fellow Pakistani researchers somewhere who they can contact and ask for help.

These fellow Pakistanis researchers have developed high degree of expertise through their own hard work. They know what is going on even in the "so called classified domains". For example, even though S-500 of Russian has not even made it yet, and they already know what exactly russian did to optimize space-time characteristics of radar waveforms to do enhanced detection of stealth vehicle including enhancements to utilize bistatic and multi-static detection/tracking strategies.

The point is information is very hard to hide if you have people who who have high degree of technical expertise and are determine to get it. One can analyze their research, the topics they are funding (russian funding, DARPA Funding etc.) to figure out what exactly they intend to produce and at what level of technology they will produce it and how they will do it. One can replicate the research or better still build upon it and create even more advanced results.

Just the topic name is enough to analyze a lot. Pakistani can do all of that. This "tracking" of advanced western, russian, or someone's else's research is required since some of its finds its way into india. Pakistanis are now learning to do just that right now using informal global networks (e.g. researchers/colleagues interacting with each other across the planet). But one day, hopefully they will do it formally.

Thanks to Chinese who are so liberal that they even openly not just publish the most classified research, they bloody even publish whole books on them. Chinese have totally liberalized even the most sophisticated technological research even at component level analysis. This pleasant Chinese openness is now spreading to other regions. For example now even russian are doing the same. Europe is being forced to do the same since one can then collaborate and/or let others do some hard work.

The point is there is nothing hidden or secret anymore. Pakistan has people who can understand all this. Time have changed now. Past monopoly on advanced science and technology is rapidly going out of existence.

As Pakistan's economy improves in coming years, even the most complex project will be added to the already growing list (e.g. Nuclear submarine). That's the new world order now where increasingly countries like Pakistan decide what they will do for their freedom.

@Irfan Baloch
I will reply your insightful post and yes you are right on many things. You have far more experience and know much more than I do. Please have no hard feelings. There was absolutely no intention to degrade anyone. My response was just out of nationalism. i just responded based on my emotions at that time. I meant no disrespect. I try not to but sometimes I slip and make a emotions driven mistake.

I have some deadlines so for a while I won't come here on this forum and but when I will, I will say few things still sticking to the topic of project azm but on the general institutional mindset that indeed had negative effect on lots of things including impeding development of advanced science and technology. I will reply your post. For now i will be off of this forum for a while. Take good care.

DSir,

You have spoken too much---. There was no need for this---.
 
Last edited:
.
I will watch it Insha-Allah tomorrow.

I want to add that Pakistani military has ONE way information flow policy. Meaning let's say some Pakistani goes to Pakistan who has some specific expertise. They will only ask what he knows. They will never tell him what they will do with the information or mathematical framework he suggested for a certain sub-problem. He would never know the whole problem or even part of the whole project. A sincere Pakistani would never ask for any classified information in the first place.

Things are discussed at the fundamental physics and mathematical level only like a university researcher which is absolutely safe. NOT at an actual sub-system, product, or project level. Even government researcher in American nuclear facilities such as los alamos work with researchers outside of their institution working only at the fundamental physics or mathematical level and implementing it away for an actual design in secrecy.

The point is classified information always remain classified. Pakistan is very good at it.

Even US needs outside researchers (contrary to common beliefs). For example for F-35 Lockheed martin had severe difficulty in synthesizing multi-sensor detection and tracking algorithms based on random finite sets (a topic in stochastic geometry). They struggled with it for nearly two decades. So they went around the world seeking "more smarter researchers who could solve the problem for them" and they found two Vietnamese brothers who finally gave them various solutions after more than a decade of research. The most general solution called Generalized labeled multi-Bernoulli filter was eventually implemented as part of F-35's multi-sensor fusion suit.

Yes I implemented it myself in C++ (combined with distributed sensor fusion framework that me and some colleagues are working on) then discussed it with fellow Pakistanis back home.

The point is discussing fundamental physics keeps a lot of things secret but even Lockheed martin had to work with academics to get more complex work done by outsiders. Its the nature of complex engineering.
Instead making the process of evolution complex we should be striving to simplify and also instead of applying boundaries initially (not sure what we are at) remove unnecessary shackles and boundaries. Even the most complex of problems can be dismantled into simpler tasks.
We have tendency of getting tied up with a lot of mumbo jumbo and then later on give up and try to import technology and expertise... Keep it small, simple and iterative. If someone can talk a lot technical terms does not mean he/she is the smartest..
My two cents.
 
.
Physicists have a famous saying: all cows are round. You start from there and apply perturbation theory. Although I don't have a very indepth knowledge of Maxwell's equations, I will hazard a guess and say you will start with the parameters of the flow when the aircraft is intact, and then setup a perturbation to progressively reach closer to the final system.


You read a highly technical response that went straight above your head like a bouncer. Mr Deino needs to be shown his place in the pecking order. Yes, we have a lot of ordinary Pakistanis who cannot express themselves, cannot reason about advanced topics. But to ritualistically degrade them and to use the word Pakistanis when doing that, it is humiliating for those Pakistanis who actually know what they are talking about.
Who gets to judge whether their claims to be that are actually so and not just plain loghorrea or self aggrandizing BS?

But then, when we have people who think Khadim Rizvi has greater merit than a true humanitarian such as Edhi.. I’d say let the delusions be. @Deino has much much better validation of his knowledge and research from verified people rather than self fellatio 1’s and 0’s.
Oh my god what a warped character ?! Now you have been boasting that you have been spreading false reports and FAKED news here for years ... I really wonder what you are looking for in an international forum and it only proved my decision to ban you at the SDF for all that BS you posted.

In fact it is trolling at the worst level I ever witnessed in a forum since years.
With “assistance “ like that - lets be glad its selling Peterbilt Trucks and not actually involved in actual assistance.
 
.
I will watch it Insha-Allah tomorrow.

I want to add that Pakistani military has ONE way information flow policy. Meaning let's say some Pakistani goes to Pakistan who has some specific expertise. They will only ask what he knows. They will never tell him what they will do with the information or mathematical framework he suggested for a certain sub-problem. He would never know the whole problem or even part of the whole project. A sincere Pakistani would never ask for any classified information in the first place.

Things are discussed at the fundamental physics and mathematical level only like a university researcher which is absolutely safe. NOT at an actual sub-system, product, or project level. Even government researcher in American nuclear facilities such as los alamos work with researchers outside of their institution working only at the fundamental physics or mathematical level and implementing it away for an actual design in secrecy.

The point is classified information always remain classified. Pakistan is very good at it.

Even US needs outside researchers (contrary to common beliefs). For example for F-35 Lockheed martin had severe difficulty in synthesizing multi-sensor detection and tracking algorithms based on random finite sets (a topic in stochastic geometry). They struggled with it for nearly two decades. So they went around the world seeking "more smarter researchers who could solve the problem for them" and they found two Vietnamese brothers who finally gave them various solutions after more than a decade of research. The most general solution called Generalized labeled multi-Bernoulli filter was eventually implemented as part of F-35's multi-sensor fusion suit.

Yes I implemented it myself in C++ (combined with distributed sensor fusion framework that me and some colleagues are working on) then discussed it with fellow Pakistanis back home.

The point is discussing fundamental physics keeps a lot of things secret but even Lockheed martin had to work with academics to get more complex work done by outsiders. Its the nature of complex engineering.
Unless the entire culture of Pakistan R&D did a 180 in 9 years(kudos if it did) , there are still key limitations within the cultural aspect of it that also hamper R&D although change is happening.

The biggest limitation is the transfer of authority to actual SME’s in the subject and honest Project management. It doesn’t matter whether the SME is military or civilian.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom