President’s Arunachal visit irks China

[Fattyacids]

Next time Chinese minister visit Tibet, we should express our displeasure too

Tibet historically belonged to China for hundreds of years, AP was never part of any indian kingdoms, hence the need for Simla Accord between the Chinese and the British. There was no India yet.

 

[Roybot]

Meanwhile in Arunachal Pradesh, India

Meanwhile in Beijing, China.

 

[GR!FF!N]

Tibet historically belonged to China for hundreds of years, AP was never part of any indian kingdoms, hence the need for Simla Accord between the Chinese and the British. There was no India yet.

you should read about the Simla accord then.....

China rejected the Accord and their plenipotentiary, Ivan Chen, withdrew on 3 July 1914. The British and Tibetan plenipotentiaries then attached a note denying China any privileges under the Accord and sealed it as a bilateral agreement the same day.

Simla Accord (1914) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

so,no fuk was given to China even that day....

and a Chinese talking about Simla accord when they don't recognise Mcmohan line is hilarious....

now,if you really accept Mcmohan Line,then.....Give back Aksai Chin...

 

[asad71]

No, East Bengal, a part of Akhand Bharata.

E Bengal is the soul of Akhand Bangla-Bihar-Orissa.

 

[Fattyacids]

you should read about the Simla accord then.....

China rejected the Accord and their plenipotentiary, Ivan Chen, withdrew on 3 July 1914. The British and Tibetan plenipotentiaries then attached a note denying China any privileges under the Accord and sealed it as a bilateral agreement the same day.

Simla Accord (1914) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

so,no fuk was given to China even that day....

and a Chinese talking about Simla accord when they don't recognise Mcmohan line is hilarious....

now,if you really accept Mcmohan Line,then.....Give back Aksai Chin...

You post simply proved my point that AP never belonged to any Indian kingdoms. If it did, there wouldn't be a need for China and British to negotiate. India as a country didn't even existed then.

 

[[Bregs]]

AP is an integral part of India, and will always be so

 

[neehar]

China should take down this elephant called India if they don't understand that Arunachal Pradesh belongs to China. India should hand over that to China without any tussle otherwise our friend Dragon is powerful enough to destroy India in a day or two. China and Pakistan should attack India and annex all its land and throw it's people out if they will be able to survive. India will be our backyard in coming days. InshaAllah.

yeah as if they are waiting for ur permission.china has already complicated its position in its eastern front they have enough problems.they dont want to irk its other neighbors that'd be worst.

You post simply proved my point that AP never belonged to any Indian kingdoms. If it did, there wouldn't be a need for China and British to negotiate. India as a country didn't even existed then.

not everybody thinks like china looking some stupid ancient maps u see..its just that we dont want to look crazy.if we'd have thought the same then many independent countries today should be a part of india.so stop living in past and come to future.as of today arunachal pradesh is governed by india.and will remain so.

 

[GR!FF!N]

You post simply proved my point that AP never belonged to any Indian kingdoms. If it did, there wouldn't be a need for China and British to negotiate. India as a country didn't even existed then.

now now..lets start to learn how to study the maps,shall we???

the left most yellow part is Tawang,so called chinese Claim while Aksai Chin is in Kashmir(Noob,don't even know what logic you've to use,cause you've no bais of claim.its just like another 9 dotted line)...as per Arunachal Pradesh,until 1858,it was part of Ahom Kingdom,from Assam..unlike China,India was divided several kingdoms until 1947(even during British Rule,what Chibots don't know).its only during Integration of India,these kingdoms dissolved.unlike China,which simply grew exponentially by years under monarchy,claiming everything from Tibet,Mongolia,Xinjiang and others even Tawang from India(I wonder when was the last time China had boundary here),Indian Union built upon integration of homogeneous type of kingdoms.

 

[Fattyacids]

now now..lets start to learn how to study the maps,shall we???

the left most yellow part is Tawang,so called chinese Claim while Aksai Chin is in Kashmir(Noob,don't even know what logic you've to use,cause you've no bais of claim.its just like another 9 dotted line)...as per Arunachal Pradesh,until 1858,it was part of Ahom Kingdom,from Assam..unlike China,India was divided several kingdoms until 1947(even during British Rule,what Chibots don't know).its only during Integration of India,these kingdoms dissolved.unlike China,which simply grew exponentially by years under monarchy,claiming everything from Tibet,Mongolia,Xinjiang and others even Tawang from India(I wonder when was the last time China had boundary here),Indian Union built upon integration of homogeneous type of kingdoms.

A map drawn by Indian, which you took from India govt site???

You post proved me right, again!!

 

[GR!FF!N]

A map drawn by Indian, which you took from India govt site???
I can pull one from Chinese govt too.

you can provide a different Arunachal Pradesh's map from Chinese Govt Site??no wonder,a cheap copy of Indian map..

you missed the point troll.I only wanted to pointed out Tawang,only claim China have.but Tawang itself was handovered to India by Tibet in 1914 due to Shimla Accord.China has no other claim in Arunachal Pradesh.

 

[Ayush]

As if we care

 

[Fattyacids]

you can provide a different Arunachal Pradesh's map from Chinese Govt Site??no wonder,a cheap copy of Indian map..

you missed the point troll.I only wanted to pinted out Tawang,only claim China have.but Tawang itself was handovered to India by Tibet in 1914 due to Shimla Accord.China has no other claim in Arunachal Pradesh.

No, you missed the crux of the whole matter. The map is irrelevant to the fact that Tibet belongs to China back then, any treaty that is NOT rectified by China, naturally China will not recognized it. What's hard to understand?

 

[Dash]

No, you missed the crux of the whole matter. The map is irrelevant to the fact that Tibet belongs to China back then, any treaty that is NOT rectified by China, naturally China will not recognized it. What's hard to understand?

China is coming then to get it...is it?

Why are farting acid?, fattyacid..You can wish for whatever you are entitled to, the fact is that AP is with India and will remain with India, until then keep melting your bed with that acid of yours...

 

[Fattyacids]

China is coming then to get it...is it?

Why are farting acid?, fattyacid..You can wish for whatever you are entitled to, the fact is that AP is with India and will remain with India, until then keep melting your bed with that acid of yours...

It's perfectly fine if you're not capable of making an intellectual argument, but there's no need for personal attack.

 

[Pathan02]

It's perfectly fine if you're not capable of making an intellectual argument, but there's no need for personal attack.

From what I know the natives of Arunchal Pradesh are Hindu and Buddhist so wouldn't they have more in common with Indian culture. Also there doesn't seem to be any movement for a independent Arunchal Pradesh or a Chinese Arunchal Pradesh by the people so wouldn't it make more sense for it to remain part of India. I don't know much about the subject but I have quickly researched it.