Poverty of the biggest democracy

[Span]

With this huge population, problems are obvious.

This is what most people fail to see. Glad you did.

 

[Ahmad Masood]

This article is pure horse shit !!

do you think this 8% does not include Gujarat or other BJP ruled states ?

Most of the numbers will talk about a whole country and not about a particular state.

 

[GreenFalcon]

@Manticore i would like you to look at the Original post. does it seriously deserve a positive rating just because it narrates what pleases someone ( especially Modi bashing ) ???

Just because you don't like the thread doesn't make it 'Negative'

 

[Ahmad Masood]

This is what most people fail to see. Glad you did.

Don't take me wrong for posting this but Russell Peters came up with something interesting about that. Its not my views but just to have fun;

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

Just because you don't like the thread doesn't make it 'Negative'

It is not about liking or disliking.

Its about Rating System, which unfortunately is been misused rapidly by some members. like you i also have an opinion and i shared it with the concerned staff member.

 

[steelseries779]

India Developing, but still a long way to go

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

India Developing, but still a long way to go

A very long way !!

 

[chhota bheem]

Take it easy kid , ..... You are just having comprehension issues , nothing else ...

Here is what I said : "In fact thousands of SMEs have closed down during Modi's tenure in Gujarat" ...


Arvind Kejriwal , while announcing his candidature from Varanasi constituency in Uttar Pradesh had claimed that over 60,000 SME units have closed down in Gujarat . He said SMEs in Gujarat are in the pathetic state, and are closed down. He even shot an “open” letter to Narendra Modi in which he asked:

In the last 10 years almost two-third small industries have shut down in Gujarat. We found that in a small place like Mehsana alone 140 of the 187 small industrial units have shut down. under such circumstances, what is your model of development? Will you shut down all small, medium industries in the country and handover industry in the country select business houses?

One day later , A senior state government official , said that at least nine per cent of SMEs, registered before 2010, have closed down operations.

There are close to 300,000 registered SMEs in Gujarat, according to the Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry (Assocham). However, close to 95 per cent of SMEs are unregistered.

“At least nine per cent of SMEs have closed down their operations in Gujarat. This is according to a survey conducted by the Central government for the period between 2007 and 2012,” said D J Pandian, additional chief secretary, Industries and Mines department, government of Gujarat. He was speaking to mediapersons on the sidelines of a seminar “Funding SME’s Unlocking the Growth Potential” organised by Assocham here.

He, though, specified “I don’t know the exact number of SMEs that have shut down their operations.” .......

And between 2002 and 2007, 12 per cent of SMEs had shut down operations in the state. ......

No doubt that Kejriwal is right that the entry of Tatas, Birlas, Ambanis and Adanis in Gujarat will lead to exit of existing SMEs ....

“It was during the Modi regime that the Adanis’ turnover increased from Rs 3,000 crore to Rs 47,000 crore between 2001 and 2013,” Kejariwal said.



But then again , it is not your fault . You guys have been brainwashed by your media . Modi is a hardcore follower of cronie capitalism . Corporates love Modi as he goes easy on their audacious policies and the same corporates control news media today....

Dont get me wrong but what you do is,google it and copy paste lots of stuff with out understanding it,not because you cannot understand it but not spending enought time understanding it.
To put it in a simple way,you know x+y=2,but you cant relate when someone
says y=2-x

 

[Koovie]

My friend my own country Pakistan is not doing wonders in this regard but I can tell you even CIA is also running some anti Modi
campaign. The World Factbook

COUNTRY POPULATION BELOW POVERTY LINE(%)

India 29.8% (2010 est.)

You must do something to stop this BULLSHIT.

These numbers are over four years old, and the article the OP posted is communist BS

 

[surya kiran]

@Aeronaut pls move to south asia section

 

[M. Sarmad]

Take it easy old man.If you are quoting someone post the source,puhlease!!.
Seriously your argument was based on Kejriwal and a senior state government official statement .So the the GoI's Ministry Of Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises Annual Report is a piece of garbage according to you.

Stop embarrassing yourself my friend . Additional chief secretary, Industries and Mines department, government of Gujarat , and a senior politician ( who has served as Chief Minister of Delhi and as a Joint Commissioner in the Income Tax Department) are far more credible than (mostly) illiterate Hindutava activists and Cyber Hindus , I believe .........

And here is the Final report of Ministry of Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises, Government of India Fourth All India Census of Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises 2006-2007 : Registered Sector
Edition : April, 2011


which says that 12.15 % of enterprises have been closed down in Gujarat :

And from the link you posted :

These figures are however higher than the claims by made by Gujarat government in response to the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leader Arvind Kejriwal's allegation on the rampant closure of MSME units in Gujarat. The state government had claimed on Thursday that the rate of closure of MSME units was just five percent in March 2012

Now who is lying ?? Kejriwal ? the govt official ... or the Narendra Modi govt. ??? Or may be it is you !!

Read my posts carefully and try to understand what I am saying , and you need to try much harder my friend , if you are serious in giving a rebuttal !!

Dont get me wrong but what you do is,google it and copy paste lots of stuff with out understanding it,not because you cannot understand it but not spending enought time understanding it.
To put it in a simple way,you know x+y=2,but you cant relate when someone
says y=2-x

No my friend , You got it wrong . I don`t have that much time to waste . I have been a member of different socialist groups for a few years now , and there are a lot of progressive Indian members too (mostly professionals in their forties and fifties) ... So I get to learn a lot from them . Amateur Indian teenagers / cyber warriors on PDF (or anywhere else) know nothing . But unfortunately , educated and progressive people in India (and Pakistan) form insignificant minority and as they say , democracy is a system in which people are counted merely , their opinions are not weighed ...

@Manticore i would like you to look at the Original post. does it seriously deserve a positive rating just because it narrates what pleases someone ( especially Modi bashing ) ???

My dear friend , Lal Khan (the author of this article) is a leading Trotskyist analyst (Only if you know what that means) . This thread is not meant for bashing Modi or India , but exposing capitalism ........ 94 % of your country fellows have net assets worth less than 10 k USD (worse than Africa) ... The rich are growing richer and the poor are getting poorer ........ But then again , you don`t represent the 94 % most probably , So you are not concerned ...... We need to change this attitude ..... Poverty and Exploitation are the main problems being faced by the people of Sub Continent today .....

 

[cloud_9]

And from the link you posted :




Now who is lying ?? Kejriwal ? the govt official ... or the Narendra Modi govt. ??? Or may be it is you !!

Read my posts carefully and try to understand what I am saying , and you need to try much harder my friend , if you are serious in giving a rebuttal !!

Please get a table for the last 10 years and calculate the growth rate or maybe look for CAGR for MSME in Gujarat.Well I'm pretty sure you went through that report (looking at the above screenshot) and you probably know the whole story.

Did you have a closure figure for India during 2012.I mean if you want to take a dig at Modi,look for the closure numbers for 2007 as they will surely be high.

No my friend , You got it wrong . I don`t have that much time to waste . I have been a member of different socialist groups for a few years now , and there are a lot of progressive Indian members too (mostly professionals in their forties and fifties) ... So I get to learn a lot from them . Amateur Indian teenagers / cyber warriors on PDF (or anywhere else) know nothing . But unfortunately , educated and progressive people in India (and Pakistan) form insignificant minority and as they say , democracy is a system in which people are counted merely , their opinions are not weighed ...

Professionals ?? Educated?? Progressive?? Who believe in what Kejriwal says and can't collect some data and form an opinion.

I'm happy to be a part of the majority.


Sayonara

 

[M. Sarmad]

Please get a table for the last 10 years and calculate the growth rate or maybe look for CAGR for MSME in Gujarat.Well I'm pretty sure you went through that report (looking at the above screenshot) and you probably know the whole story.
Did you have a closure figure for India during 2012.I mean if you want to take a dig at Modi,look for the closure numbers for 2007 as they will surely be high.

AFAIK The latest census conducted on Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) is the Fourth All India Census of MSME with reference year 2006-07.(the one I mentioned) The data was collected till 2009, results of which were published in 2011-12 ...... Until the next census is conducted , this FINAL report remains the authentic most account of MSMEs closures in India .. Correct me if I am wrong ..

Closure figures for India during 2012 remain unclear . Kejriwal may have used a little bit exaggerated figures , but Gujarat govt. is surely lying ... The figures can`t be that low !! It is a part of false propaganda done by Modi govt. with the help of corporate Media , that has won him a nationwide majority .....

 

[ni8mare]

AFAIK The latest census conducted on Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) is the Fourth All India Census of MSME with reference year 2006-07.(the one I mentioned) The data was collected till 2009, results of which were published in 2011-12 ...... Until the next census is conducted , this FINAL report remains the authentic most account of MSMEs closures in India .. Correct me if I am wrong ..

Closure figures for India during 2012 remain unclear . Kejriwal may have used a little bit exaggerated figures , but Gujarat govt. is surely lying ... The figures can`t be that low !! It is a part of false propaganda done by Modi govt. with the help of corporate Media , that has won him a nationwide majority .....

so what is your problems? SME are getting closed in india not in pakistan. why worry?
let be there be unrest in india , which will be our problems why you showing your crocodile tears?