What's new

PISA maths score a sign of Malay progress in Singapore

Mista

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 9, 2016
Messages
4,567
Reaction score
10
Country
Singapore
Location
Singapore
It is first time Malay students here have surpassed global average

Malay students in Singapore have achieved a historic first by outperforming the average international student in mathematics, the latest Programme for International Student Assessment (Pisa) results show.

As for reading and science, the students' scores are on a par with those of their counterparts in the countries of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), which includes the United States, the United Kingdom and China.

The laudable maths score was disclosed by Minister-in-charge of Muslim Affairs Masagos Zulkifli in an interview with local media on the progress made by the Malay/ Muslim community this year. It was held on Dec 17 at the Environment Building in Scotts Road.

Mr Masagos, who is also the Minister for the Environment and Water Resources, said: "This is the first time the Malay community has surpassed the OECD average."

He made the point when he was setting out the various successes of the Muslim community, particularly how it was excelling in three key areas: competence, character and citizenry.

The maths feat was used to illuminate competence.

Overall, however, Singapore students were second to China's in the Pisa study, which covers maths, science and reading. Done every three years, the study tests how well students apply knowledge and skills as well as solve problems.

On citizenry, Mr Masagos noted that while many Muslim minorities around the world struggle to be both good Muslims and good citizens, "we don't find that in Singapore".

He cited how in June, Singapore mosques and Malay/Muslim organisations like Mendaki signed a commitment to safeguard religious harmony in the wake of growing inter-ethnic tensions across the globe.

A total of 250 religious organisations here had pledged to build strong bonds across religions. "As diverse as we are, we know that diversity is something that works, especially in Singapore," he said.

On character, he held up the high volunteerism rate in the community. In the past year, more than 1,400 Muslims, including professionals such as lawyers and accountants, have volunteered in various M3 initiatives.

3 GROWING AREAS OF SUCCESS
M3 is a collaboration among three institutions to improve how they help uplift the less well-off in their community. The trio are the Islamic Religious Council of Singapore (Muis), self-help group Mendaki and the People's Association Malay Activity Executive Committees Council (Mesra).

The M3 initiatives are categorised under three areas of focus.
The first, led by Senior Parliamentary Secretary for Social and Family Development and Education Faishal Ibrahim, aims to provide support for marriage, parenthood and early childhood development.

Its initiatives have been well received, said Mr Masagos. One of them is the Marital First Responders programme, which has trained 128 mosque leaders as well as religious and community leaders to provide basic marriage support to couples. It was launched in March.

Another is the Bersamamu marriage preparation course in which the person solemnising the union engages and journeys with a couple through the first two years of marriage. Since its launch in July, more than 2,500 couples have completed the course.

The second focus area lends a hand to vulnerable people and their families. Led by Senior Parliamentary Secretary for Home Affairs and Health Amrin Amin, more than 320 volunteers, including religious counsellors, have been recruited to support inmates and former inmates under the Family and Inmates Through-care Assistance Haven initiative.

The third is dedicated to empowering youth.

Jurong GRC MP Rahayu Mahzam is building a network of mentors under a structured programme "to address the whole spectrum of youth needs, from the lowest end where youth need mentoring because they are at risk... to the very highest end for people who can do better because they have a network of professionals they can rely on", Mr Masagos said.

More than 500 mentors have been recruited to mentor youth aged 14 to 16, and over 100 of these teens have been identified for pilot projects.

Praising the youth achievements, he noted that the number of students who received the Anugerah Mendaki award for attaining first class honours has increased 10-fold, from seven to 70 in the last 10 years.

But in uplifting the community, the important role of community institutions is paramount, said Mr Masagos. He dug into history to make his point, quoting founding Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew's opening speech at the 1982 Mendaki Congress.

The late Mr Lee had said government-run schemes on their own cannot achieve the results of Mendaki, a "voluntary, spontaneous effort by Malay/Muslims to help themselves".

He added: "You (Mendaki) can better succeed because you will be more effective with the Malay/Muslim parents than the government school teachers and principals. You can reach them through their hearts, not simply their minds."


NEW YEAR, NEW PROGRAMMES
Next year, M3 will launch CiptaSama@M3, an initiative that aims to include the community in co-creating policy changes with the Government.
Also, the findings on how Muis can better develop religious teachers professionally will be released by the Committee on Future Asatizah next year.

The committee is led by Senior Minister of State for Defence and Foreign Affairs Maliki Osman.

Mr Masagos said that in future, the M3 agencies will work with community stakeholders to reach out directly to eligible children and families. "Right now, we are scaling up the programmes. The next stage must be targeting," he added.

"The real outcome we want is to move the needle. That means not only to do programmes and be effective for those who come to the programme, but also to reach out in a targeted manner to those who really need the programme - and make a difference."

He added: "If you look at the areas where we have been successful, they really are important building blocks upon which we can do even better."

https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/pisa-maths-score-a-sign-of-malay-progress-says-masagos
 
.
Malaysia education minister are terrible especially Maslee. Keep following Finland method like hire extra staff. Extra staff to reduce workload have little or no impact on education excellence in the latest PISA studies. Malays worship west too much, look east my ***. He did meaningless changes like changing white shoe to black shoe.
 
.
are malays have to be muslims in singapore?
 
.
are malays have to be muslims in singapore?

Screenshot (1524).png
Screenshot (1525).png
Screenshot (1526).png
 
.
Malay students in Singapore have achieved a historic first by outperforming the average international student in mathematics, the latest Programme for International Student Assessment (Pisa) results show.

As for reading and science, the students' scores are on a par with those of their counterparts in the countries of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD).

Mr Masagos, who is also the Minister for the Environment and Water Resources, said: "This is the first time the Malay community has surpassed the OECD average."

East Asian countries generally do well academically because of our family culture of placing importance on education. But our education system is doing not bad even for minorities from other cultures.

primary1005.jpg


c2_0.png


It's great to see improving educational standards among our minority and letting them stand on their own, and now they are as good as other OECD students.

Self-reliance is more effective and sustainable than affirmative actions which has created minority entitlement and dependency like in the US or in Malaysia.
 
.
Last edited:
.
Disappointed at Indian minority’s results. They generally do well in US and UK, despite indian minority being initially poor in the UK. I wonder what’s failing them in Singapore.
 
.
If some Vietnamese people, like San Diu ethnic minority, who speak a Cantonese dialect, move to Singapore, will they be registered as ethnic Chinese or others

They are native Cantonese speakers, (pop. 200k, in areas near Hanoi) but seem different culturally to other Hoa groups in Vietnam.
I believe it is up to the people to declare themselves as "Chinese" or "Others" on their own will when they fill in their data on registration form.

Disappointed at Indian minority’s results. They generally do well in US and UK, despite indian minority being initially poor in the UK. I wonder what’s failing them in Singapore.
It is the priorities undertake by different communities from the past to recent years. Ethnic Chinese families traditionally placed high priority on education, way above politics, religions etc. Indians placed high priority in personal and family social status and religion above education, while the Malays pay much attention to religion.

But as with the title of this thread and its content, Singaporeans today are different from their forefathers. Malays and Indians are catching up well in educations now.
 
Last edited:
.
If some Vietnamese people, like San Diu ethnic minority, who speak a Cantonese dialect, move to Singapore, will they be registered as ethnic Chinese or others

They are native Cantonese speakers, (pop. 200k, in areas near Hanoi) but seem different culturally to other Hoa groups in Vietnam.
It is said this guy is the decendent of Veitnamese immigrant. I wonder if he is from same group you said.

fj.jpg
aeffaf2e-9a08-4c96-b6be-60aa94a5070e.jpeg
 
.
It is said this guy is the decendent of Veitnamese immigrant. I wonder if he is from same group you said.

View attachment 595390 View attachment 595391

I do not know that he was from Vietnam. Very few Vietnamese care or know anything about him, although Hong Kong protest has been up in recent social media (his name, in Vietnamese, is Hoang Chi Phong. You can google to find)
 
.
Disappointed at Indian minority’s results. They generally do well in US and UK, despite indian minority being initially poor in the UK. I wonder what’s failing them in Singapore.

I don't think the Indian minority are failing in Singapore as compared to the US and the UK.

A reminder that Singapore outperforms both the US and the UK in PISA, by far.

pisa-2018.png


Ethnic Indians in Singapore may very well be performing as well as, or even better than ethnic Indians in the US/UK academically. Just because they are behind ethnic Chinese in Singapore doesn't mean they are failing; the mean is higher in Singapore.
 
.
It is said this guy is the decendent of Veitnamese immigrant. I wonder if he is from same group you said.

View attachment 595390 View attachment 595391

Sorry to burst your bubble, that guy is said to have ancestry in Guangdong. His surname is Wong, if he have has any Vietnamese ancestry, his surname would be spelled "Vang" or "Huang", Wong denoted that his ancestry is from Central Eastern China, near modern day Henan province.

In fact, there are not too many Hong Konger are descendant from Vietnamese ancestry, unless they were migrated before 1950. After 1950, Hong Kong have remove the "Touch Base" policy which automatically grant people residence once they arrive in Hong Kong island by any means. After Vietnam war and Sino-Vietnam border conflict. Vietnamese refugee were not allow to settle in Hong Kong, unless they are very rich (which qualify for migration program) but if those refugee are rich, they would go on to US or Canada or Australia instead of staying in Hong Kong.

It is estimated 92% (or 6.3 millions) of all Hong Konger have ancestry trace back to China, Vietnamese ancestry is less than 10,000.
 
.
Among top 10 ranking, seven are in East Asia and have traditions traced to Confucius (孔夫子).
What the old wise man said:-
c1.png
c2.png
c3.png
c4.png
c5.png
c6.png
c7.png
c8.png
c9.png
 
.
I believe it is up to the people to declare themselves as "Chinese" or "Others" on their own will when they fill in their data on registration form.
Even if they do not speak Chinese? As I know, San Diu people now speak mostly Vietnamese.


The footage is about San Diu people living near Tam Dao mountain, 60km from Hanoi.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Diu_people (the definition in Wikipedia is confused whether they belong to Yao or Hoa ethnic minorities). How do you think?
 
.
Even if they do not speak Chinese? As I know, San Diu people now speak mostly Vietnamese.


The footage is about San Diu people living near Tam Dao mountain, 60km from Hanoi.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Diu_people (the definition in Wikipedia is confused whether they belong to Yao or Hoa ethnic minorities). How do you think?
They should identify themselves as Vietnamese since they speak Vietnamese and live in Vietnam. Cantonese is a dialect, and can be spoken by people of different nationalities.
 
.

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom