What's new

Panama leak Case Proceedings - JIT Report, News, Updates And Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.
Like you say, It has become clear in recent days that the original 5 member bench had given an interim order and the actual judgement was postponed till JIT implementation bench concluded its hearings.

Based on Judges comments in memory, the three implementation bench judges would have started preparing, deliberating and writing implementation bench recommendations immediately for the original five judges bench.

After the recommendations are prepared, the five member bench shall deliberate on those recommendations and write the final judgment.

The two earlier dissenting judges may well stick with their earlier judgements and may or may not add further (along those lines) their own findings based on implementation bench judges recommendations. I think at least Justice Khosa will add further if not both.

The three JIT judges obviously would have arrived at their findings too.

The judges may concur/ oppose according to their findings and arrive at a unanimous or majority verdict.

Justice Khosa and or other justices shall then write their findings/notes in the concluding judgement like in the interim order and Justice Khosa shall announce the final verdict.

It's just a not too wild guess based on how the media reported about the earlier interim order, I may be totally wrong but to me it appears to be a time consuming endeavour in itself.

May be if there is broad based consensus, I wish, we may yet get a verdict sooner rather than later.

I still think that it will be atleast 4-1 in favour of DQ if not unanimous, in sha Allah, and onwards to trial courts, NAB and EC according to criminal court or institutional proceedings requirements.

Above is the actual post on the subject of 3 or 5 member bench.
 
Pata nahi kiun..lekin mujhe lag raha hai ke agar is week verdict aaraha hai tu phir short order hi hoga... Itni jaldi detailed verdict nahi aasakta...itnay baray case main...jahan bhtt kuch discuss karna ho.. JIT report main hi itni saari cheezein aa chuki hain... Kher ...short order hi aajaye tu bhtt hai ...
 
Umer chema ko icij nay profile ki hadd tak bilawaja motabir bana dala hay...kashif wali video maen to bilkul chawal sabit kar raha hay khud apnay aap ko.

He's saying the other 2 judges are irrelevant, reflecting Geo tv policy to keep general public confused.

Then biggest joke is his comment that dissenting judgements are not part of our SC culture. Shows that he has been doing investigative journalism related to SC while he is completely unawares of SC judgement history.

Buddy its a laughing matter indeed.

Is maashray ne 70 saal laga diye hai Sadiq o Ameen ko sirf define krne me.

Pehle British aye they thoday laws dediye.
Ab Chinese aenge or corruption pe apni saza denge.

Chinese are smarter still, they won't bother us much with laws. They must have seen the coalition supply trucks run through Pakistan virtually free and would have kicked themselves for not realizing whats sitting next door to them...
 
Pata nahi kiun..lekin mujhe lag raha hai ke agar is week verdict aaraha hai tu phir short order hi hoga... Itni jaldi detailed verdict nahi aasakta...itnay baray case main...jahan bhtt kuch discuss karna ho.. JIT report main hi itni saari cheezein aa chuki hain... Kher ...short order hi aajaye tu bhtt hai ...

The judges have already penned down their reasoning. All the have to do is fit the new evidence with that. It's not a long process.

Coming to the discussion about 3/5 bench: it was an "order of the Court" and not "judgment of the Court." That means it's not final. A judgment is final. And order is always interim.
 
There is no room for neutrals now, sides have been picked

Yes, one is either with Pakistan & Pakistani Public or against.

Those against and neutral will both pay the price. InshaAllah.

if verdict will be announced on thursday then it's notification will come tomorrow .... let's see

Some time in August .. SC will take a month or more.
 
Yes, one is either with Pakistan & Pakistani Public or against.

Those against and neutral will both pay the price. InshaAllah.



Some time in August .. SC will take a month or more.

Ideally short order should arrive soon.
Otherwise it will become political and then its of no use this push towards transparency.
 
Some time in August .. SC will take a month or more.

maybe looking at current crisis in country judges might have decided to give short order .... possibility of short order is there Sir ... detailed verdict will follow
 
Ideally short order should arrive soon.
Otherwise it will become political and then its of no use this push towards transparency.

'Ideally' ... :-)

I will pangrah-pao'ing if a short order disqualifies NS ... and I don't know how to. So that'll be first, for the first.
 
Bhai I understand that... but that sort of system can work in countries that have strict checks and balances even in the States, Donald Trump has put his friends and family members in his cabinet. What is to prevent a future Pakistani president from putting his phoopoo, khala ka beta as minister?

Checks and balances are required in any system.

Presidential Democracy is the need. A few candidates vetted by all institutions thoroughly and then public elects one.

And it is good that IK is being probed by the current pro-NS CJP. If he comes out clean, he will make a very strong leader of the country with a high moral authority.
 
Dr Dhabardhoos: Verdict is week a sakta hai. Saray sources yea hi keh rahy hain

Phir tu is week aana mushkil hai.... Waisy tu Ch Ghulam Hussain bhi keh rqhay hian.. Is se lag raha hai ke is week waqayi aasakta hai.. Lekin ab jo dr dhabardoos ne bhi keh diy tu ab dar lag raha hai .... Dr dhabardoos k kehnay se lag raha k ab tu nahi aayega is week
 
And it is good that IK is being probed by the current pro-NS CJP. If he comes out clean, he will make a very strong leader of the country with a high moral authority.

Agreed. I don't know why PTI worry too much that CJP will surely dq IK.

It is like Asad Umer said, if you are clean then you don't have to worry about the courts.

ECP on the other hand is entirely another game but there is SC after that so if there is hanky panky in ECP then not too much to worry after all and may even backfire in the long run.
 
Ch Ghulam Hussain again saying today tht by tomorrow evening, supplementary cause list will come and decision will come either on Thursday or Friday.. I would like decision to come on Friday, not Thursday.. Because NS will be in Maldives till Thursday.. If he gets disqualified and if by any chance, SC puts him on ECL...agar woh Maldives main hua tu kahin woh waheen se kahin aur hi na bhaag jaye....Pak wapis aaye hi na?

Esa ho jay to maza aa jay.

Wo bhi kia hi din hoga jub esy ticker chalen gy hr channel pr....
Nawaz sharif ko na ehl qarar de dia gya h....
and next...
Nawaz sharif ne waten wapis any se inkar kr dia h or Maldive m siasi panah ki darkhuwast jama krwa di hy.

usky baad har channel Noonies ko dhondhy ga or wo kahin nazar nahin aain gy comments k liay.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom