al-Hasani
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2013
- Messages
- 14,060
- Reaction score
- 43
- Country
- Location
The region of 'palestine' was indeed sparsely populated due to its inhospitable nature and mostly infertile lands (back then)
The Ottomans brought in many Jews to the region and it was because of this that region started to bloom and attracted Arab migrants for work.
What we do know is that Jews had lived in that region and land for millennia, before Islam and 'palestinians'. Not only lived, but governed. Something 'palestinians' have never done.
Israel is one of the most heavily excavated lands in the world with international dig teams - I ask you Hasani, why are there no 'palestinian' artefacts? why is there nothing that points to these people? a clay mug? coins? something that points to them as a people?
There is nothing for them. There is plenty for Israelis and Jews. Plenty for Christians and Romans. Nothing for 'palestinians'. Nothing.
I'm not allowed to post links yet, but your map is way off.
If you look at pre-1946 mandate of 'palestine' - you will see what I'm talking about.
The Jews were actually supposed to get more land than they got.
Anyway, it's all academic. They waged war and lost.
What? Palestine was never deserted. Look at the historical censuses. Sure it had a much smaller population than today but which country of the world had NOT that? Iraq had a population the size of 1.5 million 150 years ago for instance.
What? Most of what is now Palestine was majority Muslim and Arab for the past many centuries. Well for the past 1400 years or so.
Oh, that's a lame logic and fallacy. How many "Saudi Arabian" artifacts can you find? I mean from the past 82 years? Yet the people that are now called Saudi Arabians are the same that once inhabited the ancient Semitic civilizations found on the Arabian Peninsula and the ME. For instance the 5000 year old Dilmun Civilization in the Eastern Province or the Nabateans etc.
There are no Israeli artifacts either with that kind of logic.
Yet the Palestinians who are hybrids of various Semitic people, mostly Canaanites and Arabs, have no historical presence in what is now Palestine? That is obviously complete and utter nonsense. For starters the Canaanites are as native as they can be (predate the Semitic Hebrews) and the Arabs themselves have had a nearly 2500 year old presence in what is now Levant. In fact there is a consensus that the Arab homeland is found between Levant and the Western Arabian Peninsula. At least the language points that out.
Anyway all this is history.
If you claim that Palestine was deserted until the Palestinians supposedly started migrating into Palestine and later were followed by Jewish migrants from all backgrounds and all corners of the world then that land was up for grapes for anyone. Using that logic.
The Palestinians just came first.
Because it is inevitable that the Jews who came from outside of Palestine are less native to what is now Palestine than the actual Palestinians that you are busy portraying as "outsiders". At least genetic studies confirm this.
Anyway simple logic should tell anyone that the regular Ashkenazi Jew who lived in Germany, Poland, Ukraine, Romania, Russia etc. for close to 1000 years cannot have more ties to Israel than the people who actually lived there since forever and who just mixed with new or local Semitic populations.
Yet nobody here disputes that SOME Jews indeed have ancestral ties to what is now Israel the point is just that it cannot be the majority unless you show me genetic tests that say the opposite.
So you cannot use history here.
The point is that a dumb Zionist by the name @Solomon2 is trying to spread propaganda here in this thread.
Apparently Jordan, who already welcomed MILLIONS of Palestinians and assimilated them into their society is oppressing the Palestinians for not being willing to welcome millions more. Yet what would that mean? Yes, that would mean that the Palestinians would be going out of Palestine and Israel and why should they be doing that? You and other Zionists want us to absorb Palestinians so they can forget everything about their land, country and struggle. So you can win the demographical battle now when you cannot erase Palestine or Palestinians.
Then you are trying to do life as difficult as possible for them so they can migrate to Egypt and Jordan. Because what does a few Palestinians mean when there are nearly 450 million Arabs in this world? For the regular Israeli they are just Arabs.
The title of this thread should be "Why is Zionist Israel forcing the native Palestinians out of their homeland in order to make other Arab countries assimilate them so the European, African etc. Jewish migrants can keep all of Palestine for themselves and built new illegal settlements"
Palestinians never had any struggle against other Arabs. If not for us Arabs Palestine would not have existed today.
Whatever struggle the Palestinian people and nation face today is SOLELY due to the Zionist crimes and the aftereffects of that.
Thus this thread is a massive Zionist lie and joke. But anyway one cannot be surprised when the author is a self-confessed American Zionist.
@Hazzy997
Can you believe this thread?
@WebMaster
You should really read my posts and this whole discussion. I don't know why this propaganda thread by a self-confessed American Zionist is not closed?
@al-Hasani
Great posts Hasani.
Ignore this Zionist terrorist idiot who's trying to push the same old bs we Arabs know well about Palestine being deserted and Jews just came to buy land.
Before WW1 Jewish population was small, under 4% of the population. Nobody had a problem with Jews who had lived there peacefully, obviously after enormous waves of illegal immigration was when Arab population began to decrease in Palestinian land significantly.
He's trying to imply a few thousand Jews were living peacefully on land they purchased until aggressor arabs forced them to take over the country and suddenly become the majority. At the same time he's trying to give himself a right to land by implying all of historic Palestine is Jewish whether we like it or not and they 'took back' what they consider their land through force and other methods.
This guy and his comrades are the most pathetic people with their old arguments when they're telling us in our face that they disregard the native population and seized the land they believe is there's either way so what's the point of debating with idiots who say either way illegally or immorally our card we play is that it's all our land because a few thousand years ago Jews colonized Canaan. As if life started three thousand years ago.
I will voice this propaganda attempt and all the nonsense/lies spread here among the moderators. This is beyond ridiculous. Reversed history and falsifications.
Last edited: