What's new

Pakistan's Wazirstani refugees in Afghanistan

North Waziristan offensive: Anger and fear of refugees - BBC News

North Waziristan offensive: Anger and fear of refugees

By Shahzeb Jillani BBC News, Bannu
_75750004_75750003.jpg



The dusty, sun-baked main road in Bannu in north-west Pakistan is filled with overloaded vehicles arriving from North Waziristan.

Tens of thousands of families have been fleeing the Pakistani army bombardment of Taliban targets in the tribal area in the past few days.

Many have had to spend long hours in intense heat - often without any food or water - for security clearance to enter the town.

Officials say that, in the coming days, their numbers are expected to swell to about half a million.

"My family is still stuck back home. Some of my relatives have travelled on foot to arrive here," says Ghulam Rasool, a resident of the main town of Miranshah in North Waziristan. He's furious with the Pakistan army for launching its latest offensive.

_75749615_ghulam.png

Image caption Ghulam Rasool from Miranshah says the army offensive is hurting civilians
"The army is attacking our children with their missiles. Let them say they are helping us, but we will not take their help," he says angrily.

The army denies these charges, saying it's taking utmost care to target only militant hideouts to destroy their safe havens once and for all.

But many of those at the receiving end of this military operation told us they feel betrayed by the government for allegedly letting militants slip away before the start of the operation.

_75742544_75749794.jpg

Image caption Among those who fled the militant stronghold were a group of 500 Christians
_75742545_75749796.jpg

Image caption Some residents who have left have been given polio vaccinations
_75750276_75750011.jpg

Image caption Tens of thousands of people are on the move - destination unclear
_75749620_ramzan.jpg

Image caption Maulana Gul Ramzan had been mediating talks with the militants
"The militants left the towns of Mir Ali and Miranshah before the bombardment started," says Maulana Gul Ramzan.

Until last week, he was a member of the peace jirga in North Waziristan mediating talks between the army and the Pakistani Taliban.

Today, he's forced to seek refuge with a friend in Bannu. He says the operation is fuelling hatred for the army.

"What's the point of this military operation now? Who are they trying to kill? The Taliban militants, Uzbeks and Chechens? Most of them were already long gone!"

For more than a decade the world has viewed North Waziristan as a base for global jihadists, where the Pakistani military was accused of tolerating militants. But the tribal region is also home to a large civilian population, estimated to be between 550,000 and 700,000.

"I don't care for the Taliban, or the army," says Khalid Ahmed, a resident of Mir Ali. "As civilians, we have long been crushed by the two sides."

For its part, the government has set up a relief camp at Baka Khel, near Bannu. Journalists weren't allowed to go there. But by the government's own admission, few families have turned up there, citing a lack of basic facilities like food, water and sanitation at the remote facility.

_75567956_pak_tribal_areas_khyber_pakhtunkhwa_464map.gif


Many arriving families told us they plan to stay with friends or family in cities and towns across Pakistan. Some will have to find rented accommodation; others had no idea where they will end up, or for how long.

Among those on the move are tens of thousands of children, many of whom have never been vaccinated for infectious diseases like polio because of a Taliban-imposed ban. There are fears that the displacement could lead to the spread the disease, making Pakistan's struggle to contain polio even more difficult.

Health activists say that the latest crisis could be an opportunity to immunise children who were until now out of reach for health workers.

Indeed, as they arrive in Bannu, large numbers of children are being administered polio drops for the first time. But experts point out that for the vaccine to be effective, the children would need to be given the drops every few months for at least a year.

That may be very difficult as officials are unlikely to be able to keep track of all the displaced families as they move to resettle in cities and towns across Pakistan.

The military operation is still in its early days and an expected ground offensive is yet to begin.

So far, the military has managed to tightly control the war narrative. And it appears to enjoy broad political and public support.

But that could start to change if the fighting drags on and becomes too costly.

For now, the biggest challenge for North Waziristan's large displaced population is to find shelter and help rebuild their lives with some dignity.
 
.
They are our people and should be called back to Pakistan. They should he compensated and should be given a better life ( a promise made to FATA by us after zarb e azb).

The operation was very necessary and the success has been proven as attacks have went down drastically after operation zarb e azb. The army cannot be blamed here at all as the operation was the need of the hour and the givta ineptness and the ttp non serious attitude during talks pushed us into it.. We have 11 million IDPs to whom we have promised a better life, a better FATA and better representation and these refugees stand no different. We must bring them back to Pakistan and show them a great life before they are brainwashed and then used against us.

This makes development of FATA and integration all the more necessary and all the more important in the development aspect of zarb e azb. The operation on military scale has been a huge success but it's the development sector where the war will be won and closed.

We can't screw it up.

The winter will be harsh and our govt must be awake. They must provide then food and shelter and warm clothes. If the govt feels it can't then ask the people to donate. Do not abandon them.

This also makes it very necessary why the wester. Border must be blocked. These terrorists have been jumping borders and we cannot allow them to comeback.
 
. .
By terrorists I meant ttp and other banned outfits or monsters...
 
.
They shouldn't have harbored enemy combatants and should have avoided mischief ALL OVER THE PLACE. They wrote their own sad demise. Enough said.
This coming from you means a lot-since you are from the region. What percentage of the population have supported the taliban and brought this on themselves? Not all but many, I have met few maseeds and all of them all the time have a negative view of the army and a positive view of the Taliban. It is unfortunate but truth.
 
.
They shouldn't have harbored enemy combatants and should have avoided mischief ALL OVER THE PLACE. They wrote their own sad demise. Enough said.

Pakistan's security services should cleared out these militants long before they became a serious threat. This is the failure of Pakistan intelligence and security agencies and not the fault of these innocent people. Pakistan is also being blamed for harboring Talibans does that means all the Pakistanis are culpable ? Does the Paris attack means all the Muslims are militanats ? Don't generalize by blaming the civilian population of Waziristan. Its is another huge failure of the Pakistani security forces.
 
.
The bottom line is that the innocent Pakistani citizens are living in refugee camps in Afghanistan. Pakistan must bring back these refugees and settle them in safe areas with full compensation.



These are Pakistani citizens that escaped from the ruthless Pakistan Army action that did not distinguish between innocent civilians and the militants. First Pakistan Army ignores these militants for years then take action against them while innocent Pakistani civilians were made refugees in a foreign country.
Everyone with a keyboard thinks he is an intellectual, humanitarian, tactician, strategist, defence expert, diplomat, judge, jury and executioner, all in one. Generals are neither thick skulled neither unaware of the consequences. Hard times call for hard decisions. Choices are not black and white but different shades of grey. Yes I do agree that inherent discipline and non-mutinous atmosphere in Army can be a case of its own downfall. Individual personalities start to have direct effect on its working like the case of Gen Musharaf who allowed the TTP threat to fester, most Generals he gathered around himself could not muster enough courage to confront him.
Hind sight is 6/6. We have had direct onslaught of two world powers. We are lucky to be still alive though with massive bruises and bloodied nose. Look around and see. Few thousands as compared to millions of Iraqis , Syrians and Libyans. We are no different or special from them, the only difference is that we have an army that is keeping this idea of a nation alive against everything. If you still have a place to come back to when your foreign lands tell you you are not canadian or british enough for them you won't be hapless stateless man.
 
.
We have certain sayings in our language for Maseeds and Wazirs. I rather not get into them. Suffice to say, they got what was coming to them. If you ask me, they should get some more of the loving, they deserve it.

For rest of Pakistani's, don't lose sleep over their plight, they slept with the enemy and are paying for it. This is what should've happened long way back. Same should happen with MQM in Karachi. I have absolutely no sympathy for either old school criminals or criminals in suits (Altaf Bhai). After him, it should be turn of Patwari gang in Lahore.

This coming from you means a lot-since you are from the region. What percentage of the population have supported the taliban and brought this on themselves? Not all but many, I have met few maseeds and all of them all the time have a negative view of the army and a positive view of the Taliban. It is unfortunate but truth.
 
. .
Pakistan's security services should cleared out these militants long before they became a serious threat. This is the failure of Pakistan intelligence and security agencies and not the fault of these innocent people. Pakistan is also being blamed for harboring Talibans does that means all the Pakistanis are culpable ? Does the Paris attack means all the Muslims are militanats ? Don't generalize by blaming the civilian population of Waziristan. Its is another huge failure of the Pakistani security forces.
There is much more than what meets the eye. First of all civ population is to be blamed, why not? First rule of Guerilla warfare, the local populace has to be on your side. No guerrilla hit and run tactics flourish without local support. Intimidation does not work. Secondly to win a war against a power using the money from the same power will have consequences in a real world. Un fortunately real world is not an ideal place. If bigger powers create their own enemies to jump into conflict, smaller powers also have to create enemies to deflect from bigger conflicts.
 
.
We have certain sayings in our language for Maseeds and Wazirs. I rather not get into them. Suffice to say, they got what was coming to them. If you ask me, they should get some more of the loving, they deserve it.

For rest of Pakistani's, don't lose sleep over their plight, they slept with the enemy and are paying for it. This is what should've happened long way back. Same should happen with MQM in Karachi. I have absolutely no sympathy for either for old school criminals or criminals in suits (Altaf Bhai). After him, it should be turn of Patwari gang in Lahore.
I agree here. Altaf should be next on the list. I wish urdu speakers had such a unethnically motivated feeling of MQM or Karachi like you have for the tribal areas despite being from there. You are thinking of the country first and not of the ethnic group-or a select community or tribe and you have been very blunt-despite the fact that there is a possibility that you would be lumped or grouped or branded with these same people (Taliban) if it came to our urdu speaking drawing room conversations.

This is where Karachites fail very badly-having a national outlook. Our relatives have been supporting a mafia in Karachi for more than 30 years yet they blame their problems (problems that did not even exist until they started demanding extra rights and voting for MQM) on others. What have Karachites ever done for the country other than impose urdu on the rest? What have our forefathers done other than demanding extra rights while other communities particularly the rural sindhis and Balochs are suffering.

I agree that all of us should look within. And we will find the problems in our own mentality. I will celebrate when Altaf falls. Cheers.
 
. . . . .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom