Pakistan's Service Rifle (G-3, Type-56) Replacement Competition 2016.

[Zarvan]

No i was asking wasn't it the BERN that was closest to FN SCAR till last week? What changed sir?
Also what makes you say that ONLY FN SCAR will go through to, what you call, round 2

Not close to FN SCAR but among the 5 Guns we are testing it's on 2nd Position.

 

[Arsalan]

Not close to FN SCAR but among the 5 Guns we are testing it's on 2nd Position.

and you are saying now that HK 414 is "closer" to FN SCAR then CZ BERN 805?

also;

Also what makes you say that ONLY FN SCAR will go through to, what you call, round 2

 

[Zarvan]

and you are saying now that HK 414 is "closer" to FN SCAR then CZ BERN 805?

also;

Janab what I am saying is pretty clear. Stop confusing things. FN SCAR is great Gun and the 5 Guns which we currently are testing FN SCAR is the best. CZ-806 is good Gun but doesn't come close to FN SCAR but it's better than other 3 Guns being tested by Pakistan. Now if we are going to test 4 to 5 new Guns in round II along with FN SCAR than in entire world I can only see HK-417 which may come close to FN SCAR in performance in all aspects.

 

[Arsalan]

Janab what I am saying is pretty clear. Stop confusing things. FN SCAR is great Gun and the 5 Guns which we currently are testing FN SCAR is the best. CZ-806 is good Gun but doesn't come close to FN SCAR but it's better than other 3 Guns being tested by Pakistan. Now if we are going to test 4 to 5 new Guns in round II along with FN SCAR than in entire world I can only see HK-417 which may come close to FN SCAR in performance in all aspects.

Oh bahi I am sorry. As I have mentioned time and time again, I have NOTHING against you, nothing personal. You have been here for around 5 years now, I am aware of your contributions here. So I am sorry, AGAIN, if you feel I am getting to you.

My only disagreement with you here on this topic and may be some other topics like this is about exaggeration. There are a few things, especially when it comes to our military that can be confirmed only with time. Making things SOUND like otherwise is something that miss lead people. You are know that we, the members are not paid to come here right? The only reason for all of us being here is because we want to learn about things. That is the reason I am always careful while claiming things. I do not want to mislead people and what I know about you, you won’t either want to do any such thing. For this, I just request that we do not announce things so that they SOUND as facts while they are just our own feelings or analysis.

As for the last post, I was curious what makes you think that ONLY FN SCAR will go through to what you call round 2? I mean, why isn’t it possible that two or even three guns are tested again along with two or three new ones? There is apparently no reason for that to happen so I won’t say that with any surety.

I hope you understand what I am trying to say

Have a good day!

 

[F.O.X]

Nothing is confirmed yet.

 

[ali_raza]

Nothing is confirmed yet.

plz confirm it then sir

 

[F.O.X]

plz confirm it then sir

not that simple

 

[Zarvan]

not that simple

not that simple

Well can you at least tell that Gun from these 5 Guns being tested will be selected or we may bring more Guns for testing

 

[Skaði]

. Now if we are going to test 4 to 5 new Guns in round II along with FN SCAR than in entire world I can only see HK-417 which may come close to FN SCAR in performance in all aspects.

No, you're comparing dissimilar guns. FN-SCAR is an assault rifle and behaves like one. It has semi and full-auto and controllable recoil. It's light, compact and easy to maneuver in tight spaces.

The HK-417, which I had the pleasure of using during my time in the RNoAF during aerial shoots, is a battle rifle and is typically used as a designated marksman rifle:

While both have longer or shorter barrels depending on the requirements on the individual military's, the HK-417 is less suited to assault duties due to a heavier recoil and a higher weight, which drags on a soldier.

The HK-417 is used as a long-range precision weapon, as fits its traits:

Even when using a smaller barrel, it's still better for DMR duties, as opposed to SCAR which is best as an assault rifle and has a secondary DMR capability with the Mod 20 configuration:

The two guns share the same round, but one is better for assault duties and is an assault rifle. The other is best as a DMR and is a battle rifle.

They aren't really comparable. HK-417 is a straight improvement over the G3 (AG3 here), as the G3 was also a battle rifle:

But SCAR would be a shift away from the battle rifle type in Pakistani service and a move towards a more conventional setup for infantry units, as it's an assault rifle.

 

[Bratva]

Wesay yaar, Halway ka naam lai kai mujhay aap nai akhrot ka halwa yaad karwa dia. Pata nahi ab Karachi sai kon kab aye ga. Oh, aur wo khopray wala bhi!

Humara phada ho jaye gaaa... Sohn Halvaaa >>>>>>> Khopray Shopray

 

[ali_raza]

Humara phada ho jaye gaaa... Sohn Halvaaa >>>>>>> Khopray Shopray

me khila du ga sir apko multan ka special hafiz ka sohn halwa.ap bas news nikalo

 

[Amaa'n]

am i too late to join the party????

Weapons are out of PoF again --- and send back for second round to Kharian---- now what is in the round 2 is very unclear ----
but that is what has been said on chats --- you guys ask me questions at the wrong time

 

[Zarvan]

am i too late to join the party????

Weapons are out of PoF again --- and send back for second round to Kharian---- now what is in the round 2 is very unclear ----
but that is what has been said on chats --- you guys ask me questions at the wrong time

Our friend claimed that FN SCAR H has won the trials. He has made some funny claims before ,although I wanted him to be right this time. But still we wanted to get it confirmed or denied by you so thanks for the answer. @Tipu7 @Sulman Badshah

Humara phada ho jaye gaaa... Sohn Halvaaa >>>>>>> Khopray Shopray

I prefer Sohan Halwa and than Gajar ka Halwa but unfortunately we would have to wait for that because trials are still going on.

 

[ali_raza]

hi

 

[ali_raza]

no one can post something new