Pakistan's Identity Crisis: Can it explain itself without India?

[Steppe Wolff]

It's the Thar desert that restricted geneflow between Pakistani and North India, regardless of distance. See how different North Africans and Sub-Saharan Africans look despite being on the same continent, thanks to the desert between them.

If skin color talks bother you so much why do you follow a religion that maintains and promotes caste system? Dumb hypocrites.

Indians hate their own skin colors. Dumb People.

 

[Maira La]

His name is Agnostic Indian though... just saying

Most upper caste Hindus are agnostic or atheist anyway. How many Brahmins do you think really believe monkey and elephant Gods exist?

Caste system, the backbone of Hinduism, is strictly maintained regardless of their faith in God(s).

 

[AgnosticIndian]

It's the Thar desert that restricted geneflow between Pakistani and North India, regardless of distance.

that's just untrue. it restricted neither geneflow nor cultural engagement. many Sindhis migrated out of Pakistan after after the partition, I doubt you'll be able to distinguish them from others in North India. you've probably seen a few Sindhis as Indians but failed to realize it. and the Thar desert theory doesn't even begin to apply for Punjab. there's nothing between Punjab and the gangetic plains.

follow a religion that maintains and promotes caste system? Dumb hypocrites.

I don't. I don't follow Brahminical Hinduism and any caste system.

Indians hate their own skin colors. Dumb People.

huh? who? I just see some Pakistanis calling Indians dark as an insult. not just colourism, it also comes off as self-hatred, yes. but you're the Pakistani calling yourself "Steppe Wolff", so your words kinda come of as projection.

 

[Steppe Wolff]

that's just untrue. it restricted neither geneflow nor cultural engagement. many Sindhis migrated out of Pakistan after after the partition, I doubt you'll be able to distinguish them from others in North India. you've probably seen a few Sindhis as Indians but failed to realize it. and the Thar desert theory doesn't even begin to apply for Punjab. there's nothing between Punjab and the gangetic plains.

I don't. I don't follow Brahminical Hinduism and any caste system.

huh? who? I just see some Pakistanis calling Indians dark as an insult. not just colourism, it also comes off as self-hatred, yes. but you're the Pakistani calling yourself "Steppe Wolff", so your words kinda come of as projection.

Nothing wrong with calling one's self "Steppe Wolff", especially if you are an ethnic Uzbek.
And, I have met enough of you lot. Self Hating of skin color is an Indian Trait. Just see how North Indians treat Tamils and other southerners.

 

[arjunk]

I don't know why North Indians act like they're snow white blond hair blue eyed white people when they're 1% fairer than South Indians and look the same to any non Indian. North Indians desperately try to sem2sem themselves with Pakistanis for some reason too. This inferiority complex is a result of their white skin worshipping caste system.

If I went to an Indian market people would think I'm a white tourist and try to scam me. That's how different I look from them and I am a native Sindhi. Every time I meet an Indian I tower over them too. There's literally no similarities, North Indians need to accept their skin colour and height and stop bullying their own countrymen.

Nothing wrong with calling one's self "Steppe Wolff", especially if you are an ethnic Uzbek.
And, I have met enough of you lot. Self Hating of skin color is an Indian Trait. Just see how North Indians treat Tamils and other southerners.

 

[The BrOkEn HeArT]

As a political unit it is federation of four [five] provinces and the name Pakistan itself is derived from the acronym of those provinces which are each clustered around a ethnic group.

View attachment 781580

View attachment 781581

The acronym 'PAKSTAN' was coined by Rehmat Ali in 1933 in his pamphlet 'NOW or NEVER'.


View attachment 781582

Now that covers the political frame of the state. At a geographic and historical level Pakistan is the latest appellation of the Indus Basin geography which has unbroken history going back to 7,000 years. This is the land that gave birth to name India. Indeed at dawn of history 'India' was the Indus Basin analogous to Pakistan. A good example is Alexnder's invasion of India. He never went to the India we know today and neither did he fight West Indians because both meanings as they are understood today dod not exist. It is the false use of two names on a historical continuum to give a incorrect rendering of facts. It is much like Romani Gyspies claming ancient Roman Empire was something to do with them and NOT the Italians because Italy did not exist then.

Indus River is almost 96% in Pakistan with tiny sliver in disputed J & K and another sliver in China. As much as Nile is to Egypt, Indus is to Pakistan - actually more because Egypt does not cover more than even 50% of nile with rest being in Sudan, Ethopia, Uganda etc.

Indians as are understood today ae a composite of Gangus of the Ganga basin and Aboriginal Dravids of the south with some admixture from our lands.

You try to manipulate your identity and change it each day even for next 1000s years, you will still find "ugly" INDIAN jeans in your blood.
I have a solution for Identity crisis, just tag yourself as "Indian" and move on.

 

[Steppe Wolff]

I don't know why North Indians act like they're snow white blond hair blue eyed white people when they're 1% fairer than South Indians and look the same to any non Indian. North Indians desperately try to sem2sem themselves with Pakistanis for some reason too. This inferiority complex is a result of their white skin worshipping caste system.

If I went to an Indian market people would think I'm a white tourist and try to scam me. That's how different I look from them and I am a native Sindhi. Every time I meet an Indian I tower over them too. There's literally no similarities, North Indians need to accept their skin colour and height and stop bullying their own countrymen.

In Canada, Sikhs don't even associate themselves with other Indians both North( UP, Biharis ) and South Indians, just because they don't look like same. These gangus smell bad with their hair oiled all the time.

Indians say they are same as us and how we are one people despite the fact, entire Western part of Pakistan doesn't share anything with them. Only thing similar is Punjabis on both sides and Punjabis are only 2 % of India.

 

[Maira La]

You try to manipulate your identity and change it each day even for next 1000s years, you will still find "ugly" INDIAN jeans in your blood.
I have a solution for Identity crisis, just tag yourself as "Indian" and move on.

You ganga/dravidian think an ancient Punjabi warrior Porus is your Dad and not the little Tamil man who gave birth to you. Who's the one with identity crisis?

 

[Steppe Wolff]

You try to manipulate your identity and change it each day even for next 1000s years, you will still find "ugly" INDIAN jeans in your blood.
I have a solution for Identity crisis, just tag yourself as "Indian" and move on.

INDIAN JEANS ? I think you wanted to write GENES but couldn't as your Gangu Brain doesn't has the capacity to even write a simple Word.

 

[The BrOkEn HeArT]

You ganga/dravidian think an ancient Punjabi warrior Porus is your Dad and not the little Tamil man who gave birth to you. Who's the one with identity crisis?

Indianess is vast. Your little brain of maddrasha can't unterstand it. I myself is Punjabi from Punjab. We are completely Indians. You will never find a single person in India who is suffering from identity crisis like Pakistanis does.
Because we know very well that India was and is a vast civilization with different genes, color and faces. Today's Pakistan was also part of it. But you got a duty to justify the making of Pakistan forgetting you real identity.

 

[Maira La]

Indianess is vast. Your little brain of maddrasha can't unterstand it. I myself is Punjabi from Punjab. We are completely Indians.

You look Indian because you are lower caste Punjabi, Chamar or Chuhra. You guys are recent migrants. Indus is vast, but you come from Ganga or Southern slums.

Real reason is distance from equator

It's Sahara desert. Deserts, mountains and seas can separate races.

 

[Maula Jatt]

Indianess is vast. Your little brain of maddrasha can't unterstand it. I myself is Punjabi from Punjab. We are completely Indians. You will never find a single person in India who is suffering from identity crisis like Pakistanis does.
Because we know very well that India was and is a vast civilization with different genes, color and faces. Today's Pakistan was also part of it. But you got a duty to justify the making of Pakistan forgetting you real identity.

Write a paragraph in Punjabi and I'll see your punjabiyat..
Go on let's see ...

Their are Turkic speaking Azeris in Iran who call themselves Iranian and not part of the Republic of Baku- hopefully you can get my point of different people groups living in a land where vast majority of them are way different than them but still associating with that that country - it happens

B- that's a continent, SC or whatever you wanna name it
But not a country- this is not how countries work

Next day if there's a country named Asia or Europe and they chimp themselves out that
Hey we are proud Europeans or Asians or Africans and we are a country

Cool do it but people will point it out don't throw tantrums

 

[Maira La]

People living close to equator are darker. For example east Asians of southern areas like Myanmar Philippines etc are darker and Mongol and Koreans are light skinned. Yemenis are darker than Saudis

Yemenis are darker because of admixture with migrants from the Horn of Africa. Otherwise they are same as Saudis.

Myanmar and Philippines people are darker because of admixture with Onge like people who were ancient adivasis of South East Easia. In Philippines they are called Negrito and the average Filipino has around 10-30% genes from Negritos.

 

[magra]

that's a continent, SC or whatever you wanna name it
But not a country- this is not how countries work

Tujhko mirchi lagi to mein kya karoon

 

[Maula Jatt]

Tujhko mirchi lagi to mein kya karoon

don't do anything - smoke an ounce to it
chill out and relax

I only said it because this "indianess" is used for "greater India" shit y'all pull
So naturally of course countries from rest of the SC will have something to say