What's new

Pakistani/Indian Muslim Letter to the British PM 1919

Hakan

RETIRED INTL MOD
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
6,274
Reaction score
39
Country
Turkey
Location
Canada
download (1)e.jpg
On January 5, 1919, Indian Muslims living in Britain gave the then prime minister Lloyd George a memorandum regarding the occupation of the Ottoman Empire.

Indian Muslims living in Britain expressed their deep concern and anger to the British prime minister Lloyd George on January 5, 1919, after the capital of the Ottoman Empire, Istanbul, was occupied by allied forces led by Britain.

On October 30, 1918, the Ottoman Empire left itself at the mercy of the Allied States when it was left with no choice but to sign the Mudros Armistice.

When the news reached southern Asia, the Indian Muslims, who were known for their love of the Ottomans and the Caliph, immediately got to work in preparation for the Paris Peace Conference, which was scheduled to take place on January 18, 1919, in order to discuss new developments in the war.

Thirteen days before the conference, Indian Muslims living in Britain sent Prime Minister Lloyd George a memorandum warning that Ottoman sovereignty over the Turkish nations will never be destroyed.

The memorandum also stated that the Ottomans had never willingly entered the war, and that they were pushed into it by the British and the French to fight against Russia. They also rejected claims that the Turks were treating ethnic Armenians and Greek prisoners badly, saying that it was in fact them who were guilty of atrocities against Turks. At the same time, they mentioned that as a condition of Islam, the Ottoman state had always treated minorities well, and that they had always honored agreements with Europe. Moreover, the memorandum claimed that the Ottoman state had always been more civilized that Europe in the past.

Stating their demands, the Indian Muslims said in the memorandum that Istanbul was an Islamic city and should thus remain an Islamic city. They rejected the caliphate of Sharif Hussein, who declared himself as the caliph of all Muslims after he declared the independence of the Arabian Hejaz from the Ottomans, stating that the caliphate still belonged to the Ottomans. Additionally, they instructed Europe to ensure the safety of Muslims in the Balkans and to recognize the sovereignty and independence of the Turks. Should Europe not recognize the same rights given to Christians who left the Ottoman Empire to the Muslims, the entire Muslim world would become enraged, they warned. The Indian Muslims also tried to influence public opinion by publishing articles in the press.

While the British demonstrated that they were not open for compromise in this issue, the campaign of the Indian Muslims only grew stronger. Muslims in India started a movement for the caliphate, which even Mahatma Gandhi winded up supporting. A delegation was sent from India to meet with Lloyd George just before the Treaty of Sevres. Following a negative response from the British prime minister, the delegation met representatives of France and Italy.

The hard work of the Indian Muslims in the international arena, as well as the support they gave to the Turkish people throughout their national struggle for independence, will always stand as a monument to the eternal friendship between these two great communities of the Muslim world.
TreatyOfSevres_(corrected).PNG
The Ottoman memorandum of Indian Muslims to the British PM | Historical Events | Worldbulletin News
 
The Muslims in undivided India were enraged at the European Powers who were ready to carve out the Ottoman Empire between themselves. This gave the British Government some pause as they feared a Mutiny by the 100 million strong Muslim Population of the Sub-Continent.
 
good for ottoman to receive support but what do Indian muslims got to do with ottomans?
btw Indian muslims wanted the caliphate to survive which luckily for turks did not.
 
Why would South Asian Muslims care about the Ottoman Empire?

Probably because the Ottoman Sultan was the Caliph of Islam & the Ottoman Empire was the last remaining Muslim Empire in the world & Muslims generally are & were considerably more so then (before the advent of the concept of a Nation-State becoming widespread) strong proponents of Muslim Unity, though like all romanticized notions, Muslims were the first to depart from it & continue to do so even if the average Muslim does feel a bond with his fellow Muslim wherever he maybe !
 
Probably because the Ottoman Sultan was the Caliph of Islam & the Ottoman Empire was the last remaining Muslim Empire in the world & Muslims generally are & were considerably more so then (before the advent of the concept of a Nation-State becoming widespread) strong proponents of Muslim Unity, though like all romanticized notions, Muslims were the first to depart from it & continue to do so even if the average Muslim does feel a bond with his fellow Muslim wherever he maybe !
I understand that, but I find it a bit odd that during the rebellion against British colonialism that they where more concerned with something quite far away from them.
 
It was a great letter to British and also having a great discussion on it.
 
I understand that, but I find it a bit odd that during the rebellion against British colonialism that they where more concerned with something quite far away from them.

I suppose the coincidence of the First World War, a growing sense of their Muslim Identity & heightened political participation sparked those Pan-Islamic fraternal ties that most Muslims have, even the Nationalistic ones !

But the Khilafat Movement wasn't necessarily the brightest conception of the Muslims of British India - the failed migrations to Afghanistan was testament to that !

But the sentiments of terrible restlessness & despondency that had been growing in Muslims since the fall of the Mughal Empire perhaps reached its peak when Muslims saw that the Last Remaining Muslim Empire - the Ottoman Empire was being dealt with in the manner that it was & the Office of the Caliphate would be treated ever so unceremoniously after the War with the Ottoman Empire being broken up into bits & pieces called 'protectorates' or 'mandates' as if it were a piece of meat !

Besides at that point in time the early 1920s I presume, the efforts towards full independence from the British hadn't really been taken as a widely accepted idea by the British Indians so maybe the fight against Colonialism wasn't so much as a Rebellion as it was a Civilized Agitation for greater Rights !
 
I suppose the coincidence of the First World War, a growing sense of their Muslim Identity & heightened political participation sparked those Pan-Islamic fraternal ties that most Muslims have, even the Nationalistic ones !

But the Khilafat Movement wasn't necessarily the brightest conception of the Muslims of British India - the failed migrations to Afghanistan was testament to that !

But the sentiments of terrible restlessness & despondency that had been growing in Muslims since the fall of the Mughal Empire perhaps reached its peak when Muslims saw that the Last Remaining Muslim Empire - the Ottoman Empire was being dealt with in the manner that it was & the Office of the Caliphate would be treated ever so unceremoniously after the War with the Ottoman Empire being broken up into bits & pieces called 'protectorates' or 'mandates' as if it were a piece of meat !

Besides at that point in time the early 1920s I presume, the efforts towards full independence from the British hadn't really been taken as a widely accepted idea by the British Indians so maybe the fight against Colonialism wasn't so much as a Rebellion as it was a Civilized Agitation for greater Rights !
Very interesting, Muslims seem like incredibly united people!
 

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Military Forum Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom