Pakistani Experts Admit Chabbar Port Will Dilute Gwader Potential

[Storm Force]

Key highlights from both vedios from PAKISTANIS

Gwader will remain a CPEC corridor for transit of Chinease energy and goods predominately

Indian Chabbar port will Give India Iran & USA access to Afghnistan BUT also a ,much shorter route than Gwader to Central Asia & Russia

India has BACKING OF USA

TOTAL INVESTMENT could rise to $20 billion over next 10 - 15 years.

The Chabbar Port gurantees India Gas supplies AND huge access to central ASIA not JUST AFGHNISTAN.

Chabbar Port is a strategy that has FULL USA SUPPORT AND BACKING

 

[Storm Force]

 

[mikkix]

US is supporting Iran covertly and overtly supporting Ksa. US have no plans to de stabilize shia state as it is in US interest to allow Shia state to rule sunnis which can start civil war in all middleeast and that is what US is doing and that is what happening now since Iraq war.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Why can't Chabahar just be India and Iran expanding trade opportunities instead of doing in Gwadar? Why do we have to be doing in Gwadar? Why can't the partners in Gwadar be trying to build prosperity for their people? What's wrong with that? I didn't think much of that until Kaptaan's mind-jolting report, but now it's different. India needs twenty Gwadars, to bring about a genuine turn in the economy, and we could link those up to a whole arc of countries from Vietnam to China to Central Asia. Think of India as an enormous dock sticking into the Indian Ocean instead of a jagged fence of mountains keeping everybody out.

 

[somebozo]

UAE and Jebel Ali will retain their importance.
Gawader retain its importance.

Chahbar may glow in dark if it continues to meddle with Saudi Arabia and launching missiles.

 

[hussain0216]

Key highlights from both vedios from PAKISTANIS

Gwader will remain a CPEC corridor for transit of Chinease energy and goods predominately

Indian Chabbar port will Give India Iran & USA access to Afghnistan BUT also a ,much shorter route than Gwader to Central Asia & Russia

India has BACKING OF USA

TOTAL INVESTMENT could rise to $20 billion over next 10 - 15 years.

The Chabbar Port gurantees India Gas supplies AND huge access to central ASIA not JUST AFGHNISTAN.

Chabbar Port is a strategy that has FULL USA SUPPORT AND BACKING

Sure it will

Because India has so much top class stuff to sell?

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

These are not experts, just random *** people that are brought by crapshoot media outlets to dramatically over-blow minor specks and earn themselves more viewership and ratings from a confused and insecure people.

 

[Jungibaaz]

Chabahar and Gwadar are not in competition in much ways that I can see. Just because they're close to one another, operate in the same region and are funded/built by adversaries. Their purposes are different, Pakistan could really use another port like Gwadar, and it just so happens that it provides a nice trade access route to the Middle East and China. Either Chabahar or Gwadar could be used to grant access to trade via ports to Central Asia and Afghanistan too. Other than that, there isn't much to discuss.

Gwadar ought not to worry India at all, it's meant for Pakistan's purposes and has little to no relevance to them, and Chabahar is no business of ours either. OP as for CPEC, please don't confuse ~$50 billion investments, loans and partnerships intended for use all over Pakistan as the same thing as Gwadar and an addition to trade routes. You don't need that much money to build a port, the vast majority of these funds are for development elsewhere in Pakistan. We're still suffering an energy crisis and will have even higher demand as we develop, our infrastructure is in a horrifically bad state and costs the economy a fortune. CPEC is mainly meant for that purpose, as well as some other projects underway in science research and agriculture.

Long story short:

Gwadar isn't all of CPEC, and CPEC is only about Pakistan and China, Chabahar doesn't need to have much to do with Gwadar, and it certainly doesn't have anything to do with wider CPEC portfolio.

Please don't take Pakistani media seriously on these matters, they're only good for over-analysing domestic politics, they can't be relied upon for assessing CPEC or anything else.

As for Afghanistan, the US has always been looking for supply routes to Afghanistan to sustain their occupation and to sustain an unsustainable Afghan government. Chabahar isn't really a game changer that matters at this stage, their war is lost and they know it. Finding a way to bypass Pakistan won't be winning that war, and Iran isn't always on the friendliest terms with the US either, both potential routes aren't ideal for the US.

 

[hussain0216]

Indian Chabbar port

It's an Iranian port where India has only been allowed to develop two berths, Iran has vowed that Pakistani security is paramount and they will keep India on a leash

Indian Chabbar port will Give India Iran & USA access to Afghnistan

Why would Iran need access to Afghanistan through chabahar?
As tensions rise between the U.S/Israel and Iran on numerous issues why would they start sending their military equipment through Iran an avowed enemy making Iran Kashmir kingmaker in Afghanistan

much shorter route than Gwader to Central Asia & Russia

Shorter for who? Not for India its longer

The Chabbar Port gurantees India Gas supplies

Why does India need chabahar for gas supplies from Iran?

AND huge access to central ASIA not JUST AFGHNISTAN.

To supply what? What is central asia so eager to buy, what are India's must have product that China can't make cheaper or better?

India has BACKING OF USA

Chabbar Port is a strategy that has FULL USA SUPPORT AND BACKING

You said that twice is blessing from white master so important?



Honestly we are good in Pakistan, we have our plans we want nothing to do with India and will give it no access to or through Pakistan, India can this take whatever route suits it away from us.
Afghanistan has been a headache for too long let it go its way

 

[Verve]

These two are "experts"?

 

[Big Tank]

lol look at these experts :3 I wonder why do these CIA Paid experts just come out with their information when Iran and Pakistan try to improve their ties.

 

[-blitzkrieg-]

Key highlights from both vedios from PAKISTANIS

Gwader will remain a CPEC corridor for transit of Chinease energy and goods predominately

Indian Chabbar port will Give India Iran & USA access to Afghnistan BUT also a ,much shorter route than Gwader to Central Asia & Russia

India has BACKING OF USA

TOTAL INVESTMENT could rise to $20 billion over next 10 - 15 years.

The Chabbar Port gurantees India Gas supplies AND huge access to central ASIA not JUST AFGHNISTAN.

Chabbar Port is a strategy that has FULL USA SUPPORT AND BACKING

Why are you hell bent on proving that chahbahar is a pain for us..
Its not dear..get over it.. And it looks funny now how you are desperate in proving something that doesnt exist.

For the first video when they say Central Asia, they are referring to the two states Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan.Both can not trade with Pakistan via Afghan land route because of the situation in Southern Afghanistan not because Pakistani route is longer or anything or because of emergence of Chabahar. A deep seaport like Gwadar right next to Chabahar would definitely attracts both nations and Chabahar alone can be insufficient so why not share load between the two ports. India and its cargo can stick to Chahbahar though .
The other three states namely Kazakhistan,Kyrgizstan and Tajikistan are actually in the midst of developing a route through Pakistan and very much want their trade to go through Pakistan.Tajikistan is the latest to join the agreement. Its called QTTA Quadrilateral Traffic in Transit Agreement.

http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00K24C.pdf

The second video, that guy is only there to make sure we show people we have 'freedom of speech' in our country.

 

[Zarvan]

Key highlights from both vedios from PAKISTANIS

Gwader will remain a CPEC corridor for transit of Chinease energy and goods predominately

Indian Chabbar port will Give India Iran & USA access to Afghnistan BUT also a ,much shorter route than Gwader to Central Asia & Russia

India has BACKING OF USA

TOTAL INVESTMENT could rise to $20 billion over next 10 - 15 years.

The Chabbar Port gurantees India Gas supplies AND huge access to central ASIA not JUST AFGHNISTAN.

Chabbar Port is a strategy that has FULL USA SUPPORT AND BACKING

We give a dam about Chabbar and no it won't dilute CPEC in fact it doesn't even come close to doing that biggest reason is location janab. You can't reach central Asia without going through Afghanistan and we all know what is going on in Afghanistan so please Chabbar port will do thinga

 

[MultaniGuy]

Bullshit.

Gwadar is for CPEC.

Chabahar port will not dilute Gwadar ports's usefulness.

 

[AZ1]

Experts one is current pcb chairman. Its good keep the dream alive of chabahar.