pakistan won kishan ganga dam case

[Imran Khan]

This



This is what Google translation says-

Hague (ICRC) International Court of Justice were occupied Kashmir sapphire emanating from the Indian River dam "Biharis " stance against the construction of the dam, while recognizing that India has directed design changes . , India , Pakistan interests against the dayzyn by Kishan Ganga Dam srua was the Pakistan raised objections , but India not care about them which was squarely Pakistan this case the International Court of Justice was . global court Feb 2013 ءmynas case which was decided in favor of India against Pakistan had requested the review . court granted review of the decision to recognize the object was issued against India . decision before the court interim order India had stopped the construction of the dam . objections raised by Pakistan that India is violating the Indus Water Treaty Kishan Ganga Dam , the water under the Treaty of Pakistan hold India to be Kishan Ganga Dam but also the water of Neelum River Pakistan will go into the dam which damage can occur. Indians started in 2007 that the dam was completed in 2016 .

What ???

ye to meri english se bhi aik dam mast hai yaar

another pak news site report it same

بھارت کو شکست ،پاکستان نے عالمی عدالت میں کشن گنگا ڈیم کا مقدمہ جیت لیا
1 views
ہیگ(قدرت نیوز)عالمی عدالت انصاف نے مقبوضہ کشمیر سے نکلنے والے دریا ئے نیلم پر بھارتی ڈیم ’’کشن گنگا‘‘کی تعمیر کے خلاف پاکستانی موقف تسلیم کرتے ہوئے بھارت کو اس ڈیم کا ڈیزائن تبدل کرنے کی ہدایت کر دی ہے۔ بھارت نے پاکستانی مفادات کے منافی ڈایزئن بنا کر کشن گنگا ڈیم کی تعمیر سروع کی تھی جس پر پاکستان نے اعتراضات اٹھائے تھے لیکن بھارت نے ان کی پرواہ نہیں کی تھی جس پے پاکستان یہ مقدمہ عالمی عدالتِ انصاف میں لے گیا تھا۔عالمی عدالت نے فروری 2013ء4 میں اس کیس کا فیصلہ بھارت کے حق میں دیا تھا جس کے خلاف پاکستان نے نظر ثانی کی درخواست کی تھی۔عدالت نے نظر ثانی کی درخواست منظور کرتے ہوئے پاکستانی اعتراض تسلیم کر کے فیصلہ بھارت کے خلاف صادر کر دیا۔فیصلہ سے قبل عدالت نے عبوری حکم کے تحت بھارت نے ڈیم کی تعمیر کا کام روک دیا تھا۔پاکستان نے اعتراض اٹھایا تھا کہ بھارت کا کشن گنگا ڈیم سندھ طاس معاہدے کی خلاف ورزی ہے ،اس معاہدے کے تحت بھارت پاکستانکا پانی نہیں روک لیکن کشن گنگا ڈیم بننے سے دریائے نیلم کا پانی بھی اس ڈیم میں چلا جائے گا جس سے پاکستان کو نقصان ہو سکتا ہے۔بھارت نے یہ ڈیم 2007ء4 میں شروع کیاتھا جو 2016ء4 میں مکمل ہونا تھ

- See more at: بھارت کو شکست ،پاکستان نے عالمی عدالت میں کشن گنگا ڈیم کا مقدمہ جیت لیا | Daily Qudrat Quetta / Karachi / islamabad / pakistan

 

[Always Neutral]

Kishanganga dam will affect Neelum Jhelum project Pakistan Lastupdate:- Sat, 21 Dec 2013 18:30:00 GMT GreaterKashmir.com

Islamabad, Dec 20: The construction of the Kishanganga dam by India in Jammu and Kashmir will result in 14 percent decrease in the flow of water for Pakistan's Neelum-Jhelum hydroelectric project, the Pakistan Senate was informed.
Pakistan's Petroleum and Natural Resources Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi, on behalf of water and power minister, told the senate Thursday that the Indian project would reduce energy generation of Pakistan's hydroelectric project by 13 percent or 700 million units, The Nation reported Friday.
Abbasi said India was constructing the Kishanganga hydroelectric project in Jammu and Kashmir. The gross capacity of the reservoir is 18.80 million cubic metres or 14,900 acre feet with dead storage of 8,755 acre feet.
He said the water of river Kishanganga is to be diverted through a 23-km-long tunnel to produce 330 megawatts of power.
He said the water would join the Wullar Lake after power generation and ultimately flow down through the Jhelum river to Muzaffarabad.
The petroleum and natural resources minister said the International Court of Arbitration would announce its verdict on the Kishanganga hydroelectric project by the end of December.
He added that India was allowed to construct run-of-river hydroelectric plants and limited storage works on the Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab rivers within the limits of design criteria provided in the relevant provisions of the Indus Waters Treaty of 1960.
The minister said all the dams constructed by India on Pakistan's rivers like Indus, Jhelum and Chenab so far are run-of-river hydroelectric plants, which do not involve any consumption of water and, therefore, no reduction in flow of water coming to Pakistan has been noticed or was likely to occur on account of the dams constructed for hydropower generation.
He said India was bound to provide detailed information and design data regarding the proposed projects.
In February this year, the International Court of Arbitration at The Hague ruled in favour of India's position on the diversion of Kishanganga water, setting aside objections by Pakistan that had halted work on the 330 megawatt Kishanganga hydel project in Jammu and Kashmir.
Islamabad took New Delhi to the court of arbitration in 2010, disrupting Indian plans to divert water from the Kishanganga into the Bona Madmati Nallah.
Islamabad said the diversion violated provisions of the Indus Waters Treaty of 1960, a claim that India refuted.

 

[W.11]

Kishanganga dam will affect Neelum Jhelum project Pakistan Lastupdate:- Sat, 21 Dec 2013 18:30:00 GMT GreaterKashmir.com

Islamabad, Dec 20: The construction of the Kishanganga dam by India in Jammu and Kashmir will result in 14 percent decrease in the flow of water for Pakistan's Neelum-Jhelum hydroelectric project, the Pakistan Senate was informed.
Pakistan's Petroleum and Natural Resources Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi, on behalf of water and power minister, told the senate Thursday that the Indian project would reduce energy generation of Pakistan's hydroelectric project by 13 percent or 700 million units, The Nation reported Friday.
Abbasi said India was constructing the Kishanganga hydroelectric project in Jammu and Kashmir. The gross capacity of the reservoir is 18.80 million cubic metres or 14,900 acre feet with dead storage of 8,755 acre feet.
He said the water of river Kishanganga is to be diverted through a 23-km-long tunnel to produce 330 megawatts of power.
He said the water would join the Wullar Lake after power generation and ultimately flow down through the Jhelum river to Muzaffarabad.
The petroleum and natural resources minister said the International Court of Arbitration would announce its verdict on the Kishanganga hydroelectric project by the end of December.
He added that India was allowed to construct run-of-river hydroelectric plants and limited storage works on the Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab rivers within the limits of design criteria provided in the relevant provisions of the Indus Waters Treaty of 1960.
The minister said all the dams constructed by India on Pakistan's rivers like Indus, Jhelum and Chenab so far are run-of-river hydroelectric plants, which do not involve any consumption of water and, therefore, no reduction in flow of water coming to Pakistan has been noticed or was likely to occur on account of the dams constructed for hydropower generation.
He said India was bound to provide detailed information and design data regarding the proposed projects.
In February this year, the International Court of Arbitration at The Hague ruled in favour of India's position on the diversion of Kishanganga water, setting aside objections by Pakistan that had halted work on the 330 megawatt Kishanganga hydel project in Jammu and Kashmir.
Islamabad took New Delhi to the court of arbitration in 2010, disrupting Indian plans to divert water from the Kishanganga into the Bona Madmati Nallah.
Islamabad said the diversion violated provisions of the Indus Waters Treaty of 1960, a claim that India refuted.

The petroleum and natural resources minister said the International Court of Arbitration would announce its verdict on the Kishanganga hydroelectric project by the end of December.

 

[livingdead]

The petroleum and natural resources minister said the International Court of Arbitration would announce its verdict on the Kishanganga hydroelectric project by the end of December.

in feb both sides claimed victory... lets see what happens this time...

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

The petroleum and natural resources minister said the International Court of Arbitration would announce its verdict on the Kishanganga hydroelectric project by the end of December.

Which means the verdict isn't out yet. How come Pakistani media knows the verdict before the judges even announce it ?

Btw, the partial award announced in February by the ICA at Hague was already in India's favour since it allowed India to construct the dam although with minimal water diversion from the rivers. The only question remaining to be answered was, how much water India could divert in the final award.

 

[W.11]

in feb both sides claimed victory... lets see what happens this time...

i think this happened

https://twitter.com/x/status/414116369806802944

https://twitter.com/x/status/414052636044693504

https://twitter.com/x/status/414114080543084545

 

[Devil Soul]

Good news..

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

i think this happened

https://twitter.com/x/status/414116369806802944

https://twitter.com/x/status/414052636044693504

https://twitter.com/x/status/414114080543084545

Even if we believe these tweets , it means India is still building the dam and Pakistan will still lose water. The only consolation for Pakistan is that they managed to stop India from getting the design for the dam that India wanted.

Good consolation prize but certainly not a victory.

 

[W.11]

Even if we believe these tweets , it means India is still building the dam and Pakistan will still lose water. The only consolation for Pakistan is that they managed to stop India from getting the design for the dam that India wanted.

Good consolation prize but certainly not a victory.

i think pakistan achieved what it was aiming for

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

i think pakistan achieved what it was aiming for

dil ko khush rakhne ke liye ghalib yeh khayal accha hai ...

Pakistan sought to stop India from making the dam or at least prevent India from diverting water from rivers. If India gets to do both and the only change is in the design of the dam , then mubahrak ho aisi victory aapko

Anyway , I will still wait for the final verdict from neutral sources.

 

[livingdead]

i think pakistan achieved what it was aiming for

what was the aim.. delay the dam and force cost overrun on India.. then yes you succeeded..

 

[bandit]

well yes its conformed india won in ICJ pakistan submit review petition and pakistan won case now

and now no more review petition


bana dam hum uncle sam ko bulaty hain wo ajkal india per bharak raha hai phly hi

Aisa nahi ho sakta kaliya, ab to Jang hogi.

Mujhe to Kishan-Ganga ke pani mai hi daru peeni hai

 

[lightoftruth]

initial attempt from pakistan was to stop diverting - which was failled

then to stop construction-again failed

now wants design changes - verdict pending

quite a victory if they get.

 

[W.11]

what was the aim.. delay the dam and force cost overrun on India.. then yes you succeeded..

thats for technicians to decide what benefit pakistan got i think we both have no first hand knowledge of this

 

[Chronos]

No such thing. We've been honoring the Indus Waters treaty so far.

Under the IWT, Pakistan has exclusive use of the western rivers Jhelum, Chenab and Indus but with some stipulations for development of projects on these rivers in India. Since Kishanganga River is a tributary of the Jhelum River, India cannot build conventional Hydel Projects(with water storage capability) on this river.

Kishanganga dam is a run-of-the-river Hydel project, meaning little or no water storage provisions are provided. India reduced the height of the dam from 98m to 37m bowing to the directives of the Permanent Court of Arbitration at The Hague.

I don't know what the latest verdict is, but no major News website has reported anything on it so far.

I have a quote from Mian Nawaz Sharif

"Yindoo Baniyas, up to their usual dirty tricks invoked their pagan god Varuna (peace be not upon them) to build kishenganga dam.

We had notified ICJ of this, but the sitting panel, consisting of Yahoodi judges and drinking from the chalice of the blood of palestinian children found in India's favor.

Jazakallah! Inshallah! we said, we will appeal this to ICJ. The god fearing sons of ICJ (no Women allowed) have now found the judgement in favor of us, the sons of the land of the pure.

And now, Ghazwa E Hind will move forward and Inshallah our new dam, Jazakallah Dam will be built on the Delhi Red fort to stop the tears of the weak willed yindoo baniyas from reaching our borders.

Jazakallah!"

=D