What's new

Pakistan’s path of denial.

Perceptron

BANNED
Joined
Oct 3, 2010
Messages
834
Reaction score
0
Pakistan’s path of denial
By:Ali Rizvi
151.jpg

Pakistan’s future seems uncertain, especially in these volatile times when the threat of an economic wipeout is looming on the horizon. The most worrying part in this sordid tale of incompetence, corruption, nepotism, black marketeering, cartelisation, monopolies is that Pakistanis seem to have a 10-second memory span. It’s very easy to wipeout our memory. Suicide blast in Lahore kills 30; memory wipes out in one week. Policemen gang rape a woman for months; memory wipes out in two days. Load shedding making lives miserable, memory wipes out as soon as load shedding stops. We are an indifferent nation. There will be no revolution in Pakistan; we all have the collective memory span of a gold fish.

So if any of you feel the Arab spring will come to Pakistan, you’re mistaken; because just four days ago, on 23rd October 2011, a father of two burnt himself alive in front of the parliament. Raja Khan from Sindh doused himself with kerosene and set himself alight. He was taken to the hospital with 95 per cent burns and died on Monday. He left a letter that said he was responsible for his death; he had taken this decision because he was fed up with his financial condition, he wrote that he was leaving behind two children and the government should take care of them. Surprisingly though, the day after his death was not declared a public holiday. On closer inspection I found out that he did not have the Bhutto DNA in his bloodstream, or even if he did, he did not carry the name. Had his name been Raja Khan Bhutto, the next day would have been declared a public holiday. Why, you ask? Well, because we can.

I don’t know how Bhutto, the man who came to power campaigning for workers rights, championing their cause, must have felt in his grave when a man killed himself because a democratic government which came to power on his legacy failed to provide their workers sustenance. Sustenance you ask? I’m sure a daily wage earner can survive on boiled rocks for breakfast, lunch and supper when the government declares a public holiday.

All is well. We are embarking on a path of prosperity where each and every one of us will be able to promise a bright future to our coming generations. We hear this rhetoric day in and day out from our worthy politicians. All will be well I’m sure, if these same policy makers instead of continuing with their vulgar borrowing binge from the State Bank of Pakistan introduce some tax reforms by widening the tax base. That makes more sense. It’s the logical way to raise money; through taxes. It will ensure that the rupee remains stable. All will be well, if instead of distributing Rs40 billion through Benazir income support programme, a paltry amount by our government’s standards is allocated to create employment opportunities for the people of Pakistan, for promoting industry, for attracting investment. Maybe, just maybe, today Raja Khan would have lived had the powers that be, instead of patronising their vote bank by distributing cash cheques worked on creating employment for the youth.

In the last four years Pakistan’s public debt has increased by more than Rs5.7 trillion – it took 60 years for it to reach Rs4.8 trillion – capita income growth rate is 0.3 per cent, a reason why investment has decreased to its lowest level in the last 40 years. Economic mismanagement and inflation, coupled with minimal employment opportunities, is strangulating our middle class.

We are on a path to oblivion while our innocent people continue with their lives of indifference, waiting for a revolution to take place, as they sip on their cups of tea while the screams of people like Raja are buried deep within the ashes of our own sins, our own apathy.
 
.
Nothing to do with current events or social issues
 
.
I disagree with the writer entirely on this issue. I feel that the ability to forget is what's keeping us alive. If we had taken each of our problem and started moping over it, we would have been wiped out as early as 2005. Our ability to move on is what has allowed us to absorb 3 large scale disasters, hundreds of terrorist attacks, sustained international pressure, rampart corruption, hyper-inflation and a dysfunctional government without breaking down.
Let's take the writer's own example. A woman was raped for months by police. They are apprehended, tried, awarded 14 years rigorous imprisonment and left to languish in jails. The woman is relocated, given psychiatric help and monetary compensation by police. Problem done and solved.
If moping about it would help me go back in time and stop the incident from ever occurring then someone hand me a dozen tissue boxes because I'm going on a mission to mope. If not, then it makes no sense in blowing it out of proportions.
 
.
Besides post No 3 I feel the ' tipping point' is yet far away.
 
.
The problem is not merely moping about it, but working on the root cause of every problem that Pakistan is facing. What are the people doing about the daily bombs going off ? What are people doing about Loadshedding ? What are people doing about incidents that leads to a public suicide in front of the Parliament no less ? What are people doing about the massive debt incurred by the state ? It is this that the writer is concerned about. The seeming indifference of brushing every problem under the rug, waiting for a bigger one to arrive, and then another one, and then another, until the fragility will cause an Arab spring like situation is what the author is trying to highlight.
 
.
The problem is not merely moping about it, but working on the root cause of every problem that Pakistan is facing. What are the people doing about the daily bombs going off ? What are people doing about Loadshedding ? What are people doing about incidents that leads to a public suicide in front of the Parliament no less ? What are people doing about the massive debt incurred by the state ? It is this that the writer is concerned about. The seeming indifference of brushing every problem under the rug, waiting for a bigger one to arrive, and then another one, and then another, until the fragility will cause an Arab spring like situation is what the author is trying to highlight.


Our version of Arab Sping is already in place, we are the leading nation when it comes to self criticism when its due, be it army, clergy, judiciary, feudalism and corruption, nothing is sacred and off the table.

Who do you think the writer is? Is he not stating the obvious? How is it brushing the issue under the carpet? The difference of opinion is only in the argument on how strongly we see it and what we hold important. My view is as good as the writer and we both have to live with that.

We don’t brush the things under the rug but you do when you fail to acknowledge that such issues are not country specific. The current problem is skewed exponentially due to the ongoing war on terror. Before joining this war back in 2000 we were doing just fine. But there comes a time in a nation when its clogged arteries need a thorough cleaning. Nothing to gloat about and be smug about it if its happening to us it can happen to you too, even the most humane and best welfare states of Scandinavia are not free for this, case in point the Norwegian massacre.

(ok I changed my original text if you are so insecure, happy now?)
 
. .
There are daily bomb blasts going off in India as well, you celebrated your Diwali with blackouts, everything you said happens in India everyday. So please, let Pakistanis handle their own situation, & you look after yourself.
I knew you cannot refrain from bringing India in, but do it in threads meant specifically where you already have schadenfreude. Bringing India to a Pakistan-centric bucket list of problems does not make away with Pakistan's problem list. Post reported for unnecessary diversion from topic.
 
.
No matter what, Pakistan won't collapse, China will support Pakistan at any cost.

The collapse of Pakistan means the end of China's journey for superpower. Do you really think China will allow this to happen?

If we couldn't become the superpower, then we could only be perished forever.

Do you think China was saying this for fun? But keep in mind we are warning against the most powerful country in the World!!!

http://www.defence.pk/forums/strate...you-will-messing-beijing-china-warns-usa.html
 
.
There are daily bomb blasts going off in India as well, you celebrated your Diwali with blackouts, everything you said happens in India everyday. So please, let Pakistanis handle their own situation, & you look after yourself.

Stick to the topic which is pakistan in denial written by a pakistani. Lol at the bolded part, practice what you preach ;)
 
.
No matter what, Pakistan won't collapse, China will support Pakistan at any cost.

The collapse of Pakistan means the end of China's journey for superpower. Do you really think China will allow this to happen?

If we couldn't become the superpower, then we could only be perished forever.

Do you think China was saying this for fun? But keep in mind we are warning against the most powerful country in the World!!!

http://www.defence.pk/forums/strate...you-will-messing-beijing-china-warns-usa.html

Thanks dude, we appreciate China's support but Pakistan should not depend on others to fix our problems.

In fact, foreign support often gets siphoned off by the corrupt oligarchy which is the very cause of these problems in the first place. It is a domestic issue that Pakistani society needs to solve internally.

Chinese support would be welcome in the sense of preventing opportunistic countries from trying to take advantage of any mass civil disturbance inside Pakistan.
 
.
No matter what, Pakistan won't collapse, China will support Pakistan at any cost.

The collapse of Pakistan means the end of China's journey for superpower. Do you really think China will allow this to happen?

If we couldn't become the superpower, then we could only be perished forever.

Do you think China was saying this for fun? But keep in mind we are warning against the most powerful country in the World!!!

http://www.defence.pk/forums/strate...you-will-messing-beijing-china-warns-usa.html

I won't get into the "Will Pakistan Collapse" debate.
What I'm curious to know is how is China's super power status attached to Pakistan's fate?
 
.
No matter what, Pakistan won't collapse, China will support Pakistan at any cost.

The collapse of Pakistan means the end of China's journey for superpower. Do you really think China will allow this to happen?

If we couldn't become the superpower, then we could only be perished forever.

Do you think China was saying this for fun? But keep in mind we are warning against the most powerful country in the World!!!

http://www.defence.pk/forums/strate...you-will-messing-beijing-china-warns-usa.html
let me refute you point by point .
How will china support Pakistan ?. they have already refused to give PAK financial help or to bail Pakistan out of debt.

china journey to becoming a superpower has nothing to do with Pakistan . in no way is Pakistan contributing towards it .

china is china , nothing will ever perish ( even if its super power ambitions are not met.)

if you did not intervien in any of Pakistan's war before, what makes you think you will now? :)
 
.
let me refute you point by point .
How will china support Pakistan ?. they have already refused to give PAK financial help or to bail Pakistan out of debt.

china journey to becoming a superpower has nothing to do with Pakistan . in no way is Pakistan contributing towards it .

china is china , nothing will ever perish ( even if its super power ambitions are not met.)

if you did not intervien in any of Pakistan's war before, what makes you think you will now? :)

They didnt help us finicially well that the best thing they did to us coz they know if they do all the money will go in to swiss accounts and there is nothing for the people in it .SO they offered doing many project for us for free. by free i mean we will pay whenever we like but chinese will do the work and invest on our GOVT behalf.

Yes China's journey is related to Paksitan , Y do u think Russian attacked Afghanistan on the first place to gain access to the warm water so is the case with china.

And about the intervention at that time China was nothing compare to US of A or Russia so it was fool of them to come in between two superpower and get crushed for nothing.but now the situation is very different ,China has alot say how in the international community now.Plus It might not directly jump in to the battle but it can help us back handedly by providing information about India.

PS : What i think is creation of Pakistan was a miracle and it has been protected by Allah(S.W.T) since then and inshaallah it will remain till the end of the World. Many termites came and many went but it is still standing there.
 
.
They didnt help us finicially well that the best thing they did to us coz they know if they do all the money will go in to swiss accounts and there is nothing for the people in it .SO they offered doing many project for us for free. by free i mean we will pay whenever we like but chinese will do the work and invest on our GOVT behalf.

Yes China's journey is related to Paksitan , Y do u think Russian attacked Afghanistan on the first place to gain access to the warm water so is the case with china.

And about the intervention at that time China was nothing compare to US of A or Russia so it was fool of them to come in between two superpower and get crushed for nothing.but now the situation is very different ,China has alot say how in the international community now.Plus It might not directly jump in to the battle but it can help us back handedly by providing information about India.

PS : What i think is creation of Pakistan was a miracle and it has been protected by Allah(S.W.T) since then and inshaallah it will remain till the end of the World. Many termites came and many went but it is still standing there.

if you believe the did a good thing by not helping you financially, why is it you leaders repeatedly ask for financial help from china ? if they were to do any service for you then they should have built industries and infrastructure in Pakistan to make it a self sustaining model. which never happened .
the Russian attacking Afghanistan to gain access to warm water is understandable . why do the Chinese need it .? none of their ports are cold water ones..

but my dear chap the danger you face is not from India at the moment . its from the US . you think they will go to war for you? or help you in it?
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom