Pakistan proposes Muslim Blue Berets for Afghanistan

[twoplustwoisfour]

its not dividing its keeping in view the ground realities. Tell me why India sends Muslim ambassador to some Muslim countries or Muslim orgs? why some countries before sending their envoys to Muslim countries advice and train them with regard to cultural, religious sensitivities.

Sure, train them with regard to cultural, religious sensitivities. I have no problem there. But that does not mean that a non-muslim should not have a say in afghan peace keeping force. Those two are completely different.

So hindus, sikhs in Indian army are religious soldiers too?


you are just further insulting name of Indian army by posting with this id lolzz


so BD peacekeepers on UN missions are religious soldiers too?

Don't undermine your intelligence. An Indian soldier is an Indian soldier and a Bangladeshi soldier is a Bangladeshi soldier. They are not defined by their religion. But that is exactly what YOU are trying to do. YOU are separating people in the name of religion and it is WE who are opposing that.

 

[Developereo]

Did Pakistan check with Malaysia, Indonesia and Bangladesh before "volunteering" their forces? Do they want their kids dying in Afghanistan possibly fighting fellow Muslims to achieve NATO/India's objectives?

Is this yet another idiotic blunder by our perpetually clueless "diplomats"?

 

[IndianArmy]

The Afghanistanis dont need what is motive of NATO. if they cared by now NATO/US invaders would have been succeeded.

ANA is considered mostly tilted towards one side so obviously might not be acceptable to all sides in Afghanistan. still if its capable of carrying out the job we have no issue but so far the supreme leader above this ANA aka Karzai doesnt see this capability in ANA and has been requesting staying of NATO/US which is considered hostile outsider invaders

Afghanistan does not have any choice, It cannot Go beyond NATO and UN as there is no other force Which can Overcome the service they have been doing with the amount of Infrastructure and Manpower The organizations have... Next ANA is Not yet capable which the US admits, US also admits , when it leaves the afghan Soil it will make the ANA capable enough to defend, If It dosent, UNPKF can Take over, But certainly not a Religious UNPKF

since you came up with bharti lies as always that this force is meant to loot Afghan resources so back your bharti BS with logic here and prove it how they will loot?

Since You counter the Bharti Lies as always without any prior notice to what the bharti says its almost evident you are desperate to prove something but Fail to do so.... How do u say they would not loot?? For me saying they loot is quite Evident from the Statement passed by pakistan to urge the presence of a Muslim UNPKF in afghanistan after 90% of the work is accomplished by NATO and UN...

2. why cant they loot because only an idiot can think of looting something which is not yet been TAPPED lolzz so you can think they arent this idiot

Most certainly, only an Idiot can think so, Thats why I am Relating it to Pakistan...How can Pakistan think Like that??

its not dividing its keeping in view the ground realities. Tell me why India sends Muslim ambassador to some Muslim countries or Muslim orgs? why some countries before sending their envoys to Muslim countries advice and train them with regard to cultural, religious sensitivities.

Muslims are a Part of our society and they have every right to write IFS and Its Coincidence that they end up Going to muslim countries, how many Indian muslim ambassador do u know who are ambassadors to muslim countries??

So what is your problem with BD, Indonesia in this force ??

Absolutely non, as long as they are a part of UNPKF, not a Religious UNPKF....

secondly what 90% work has been done by NATO/UN in Afghanistan so far? other than destruction chaos and blood shed.

They have been successful in Doing everything which a Normal force couldnt and cannot... Bloodshed and Violence are a Part of any major military movement,....

if you dont know about anything their then dont open your mouth

You Being a Journalist are Not the Only one who is supposed to Open mouth, there are several others too Who can, Who are you to Stop me??

So hindus, sikhs in Indian army are religious soldiers too?

There Lies the Difference, They are "Indian Army" Not a Neutral "Muslim force" or a "Sikh force"

you are just further insulting name of Indian army by posting with this id lolzz

Indian army doesnt need a Brand value, it Cares Non for what you think of it...

so BD peacekeepers on UN missions are religious soldiers too?

There is an absolute difference between "UNPKF" and Forming a Religious team Out of UNPKF

 

[mjnaushad]

There are around 200 countries in the world, out of which I am guessing less than 50 would be muslim. Out of the rest of 150, do you think we cannot even find 5 to 10 neutral countries?

I don't have problem with Muslim neutral countries.... You guys have... So you give us suggestions.... Thats how things go... By talking reasonably....

And as you know the traffic on site include some high class news channels.... They might like the idea and we also become part of bringing peace in Afghanistan.

 

[IndianArmy]

I don't have problem with Muslim neutral countries.... You guys have... So you give us suggestions.... Thats how things go... By talking reasonably....

And as you know the traffic on site include some high class news channels.... They might like the idea and we also become part of bringing peace in Afghanistan.

We are not against Muslim Force sir.... But the Very Idea Of drawing Muslims From UNPKF.... Why Not We all can sit and Talk about this , and Make a team Comprising of All the Asian Countries?? Wouldnt that be more better?? It will not only solve the Afghan Problem, but it will Bring the Asian Countries more closer and Powerful....

 

[Spring Onion]

we have no intention of sending troops in afghanistan. US asked us to send troops before and we rightly refused it, there is no need to change that policy now.

Tell this to your bharti members who are desperate to include india .

The Indian hindus once again proved that anything Muslim even in another country is unacceptable to them.

 

[Spring Onion]

We are not against Muslim Force sir.... But the Very Idea Of drawing Muslims From UNPKF.... Why Not We all can sit and Talk about this , and Make a team Comprising of All the Asian Countries?? Wouldnt that be more better?? It will not only solve the Afghan Problem, but it will Bring the Asian Countries more closer and Powerful....

Ask your country to give this suggestion we have no issue.

All Asian countries means you want your hindu army there right ?

send it i have no issue lets see how it brings peace there.

on the other hand we are talking abour ground realities


I can see bharti dreams of riding on invaders back going down the drain with every passing day

 

[IndianArmy]

Ask your country to give this suggestion we have no issue.

All Asian countries means you want your hindu army there right ?

send it i have no issue lets see how it brings peace there.

on the other hand we are talking abour ground realities


I can see bharti dreams of riding on invaders back going down the drain with every passing day

you cannot turn me on by saying anything religious Jana, Your Efforts are Futile... I have been a Soldier and I am Not a Hindu but an Indian, I want an Asian Army comprising of anything and everything Asian Countries can offer for an Asian brotherhood....

I am Not against any Muslim Force, But a religious Force drained out of UNPKF, You need to understand that before making me a "Muslim Hater" Infront of others...

You have been the One Saying Hindu Hindu all the time while I was Opposing a Religious Army, May it be any Religion....

 

[mjnaushad]

We are not against Muslim Force sir.... But the Very Idea Of drawing Muslims From UNPKF.... Why Not We all can sit and Talk about this , and Make a team Comprising of All the Asian Countries?? Wouldnt that be more better?? It will not only solve the Afghan Problem, but it will Bring the Asian Countries more closer and Powerful....

One of Indian members said.....

India has NO PROBLEM with neutral countries. But we have a problem with the precondition that the peacekeeping forces should be MUSLIM.

And as i said if non-muslim neutral countries can participate good why not....bring in the names...

But you see the second post... It started "its to keep away hindus" and stuff derailed the topic.....


We are saying muslims because right now you cannot make peace without talking with taliban... They will NEVER EVER surrender with force only.... And they wont talk to you... They are not even talking with Afghan govt because its on Yankee payroll..... Thats why Neutral muslim countries...

2ndly They see current force as invaders and if you bring in christian or Hindu or anyother force they will not talk to them.....Would you like a Muslim telling a hindu that what hinduism say??? Even if i am right you'll not listen to me...And specially when u are in war from last decade....




The idea which Pakistan gave is not wrong.... But some people here wont accept it and keep bringing in other stuff because ITS PAKISTAN WHO PROVIDED IT.... IF same thing is said by Afghanistan or India... members here will jump with joy and say this is the best idea ever.....

 

[Aslan]

All Asian countries means you want your hindu army there right ?

And thats the bottom line, they cant digest a simple fact that they have already been defeated in Afghanistan. They though that their uncle will be sitting there for ever and they can do what ever they want to. But alas, life is always fair is it.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

And wats wrong with muslim peace keepers for afghanistan? indians????


Anyways nobdy gives a shmit wat u guys think.

 

[Aslan]

And wats wrong with muslim peace keepers for afghanistan? indians????


Anyways nobdy gives a shmit wat u guys think.

If and only if they had the answer to that question they would have answered it a long time ago.

And thus they have applied the below logic so we can all go in circles.

 

[PRACTICAL PATRIOT]

Tell this to your bharti members who are desperate to include india .

The Indian hindus once again proved that anything Muslim even in another country is unacceptable to them.

yeah off course thats why we cater more muslims than pakistan or many other muslim countries.
you need to work harder to convince with your BS propoganda.

 

[Spring Onion]

Afghanistan does not have any choice, It cannot Go beyond NATO and UN as there is no other force Which can Overcome the service they have been doing with the amount of Infrastructure and Manpower The organizations have... Next ANA is Not yet capable which the US admits, US also admits , when it leaves the afghan Soil it will make the ANA capable enough to defend, If It dosent, UNPKF can Take over, But certainly not a Religious UNPKF

Lets wait for all claims of US till they leave and we all will see what is the outcome.

Since You counter the Bharti Lies as always without any prior notice to what the bharti says its almost evident you are desperate to prove something but Fail to do so.... How do u say they would not loot??

I dont know why you stick to an idiotic claim because if you go by speculative claim then how do you claim that any other force specially the bharatiyas will not loot who had even looted BD wealth in 71?

This is your speculation of looting by a force and that too of something which is not yet been TAPPED in Afghanistan and which will need decades to do . so your stupid claim is the weakest and most embarrassing for Indians here even

For me saying they loot is quite Evident from the Statement passed by pakistan to urge the presence of a Muslim UNPKF in afghanistan after 90% of the work is accomplished by NATO and UN...

loot is evident of what????

secondly what 90% work? if they had 90% they would not have been running from Afghanistan.

Most certainly, only an Idiot can think so, Thats why I am Relating it to Pakistan...How can Pakistan think Like that??

Pakistan is not suggested for the force neither we are included whereas you are desperately trying to get your bharti army into the force which means the biggest Idiot who could think of looting the resources of Afghanistan can be your bhartis not us

Muslims are a Part of our society and they have every right to write IFS and Its Coincidence that they end up Going to muslim countries, how many Indian muslim ambassador do u know who are ambassadors to muslim countries??

yes we have seen that right given to Indian Muslims when hindus dont give them houses on rent even to known actors, when they are asked to go back to Pakistan when they raise voice for their rights.


when an imaginary hindu god is made contestant and given Babri Mosque land to hindus.


as far as ambassadors are concerned its not according to their wish to go to certain country but its about your interests keeping in view the certain cultures and customs and faith of a country where you decided to send certain people from certain faith

Absolutely non, as long as they are a part of UNPKF, not a Religious UNPKF....

This will also be part of UNPKF simple as that only if you see it through neutral glasses and not of an Indian Hindu point of view.

if you want to send your force ask your govt to request for it

They have been successful in Doing everything which a Normal force couldnt and cannot... Bloodshed and Violence are a Part of any major military movement,....

What is this everything? name few of it.

by repeating everything everything dont prove anything

You Being a Journalist are Not the Only one who is supposed to Open mouth, there are several others too Who can, Who are you to Stop me??

I can only suggest you to read about details rest you can continue your rant i am not stopping you

There Lies the Difference, They are "Indian Army" Not a Neutral "Muslim force" or a "Sikh force"

Lolzz Neutral is more powerful world than merely Indian

Indian army doesnt need a Brand value, it Cares Non for what you think of it...

it doesnt have one

There is an absolute difference between "UNPKF" and Forming a Religious team Out of UNPKF

religious team ? their professionalism is not based on religion. The faith factor is more acceptable to the locals in Afghanistan than having Non-Muslim boots which they consider hostile

 

[Spring Onion]

yeah off course thats why we cater more muslims than pakistan or many other muslim countries.
you need to work harder to convince with your BS propoganda.

you need to check your claims for verification.

above all how you cater them we all know.

leave it aside to some other thread otherwise Gujrat, babri mosque and so on will open up which you guys cant digest