What's new

Pakistan kept sweet by China's money – and shared strategic interests

ao333

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Mar 15, 2010
Messages
1,289
Reaction score
0
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
Amid parks and lakes on the outskirts of Islamabad sits the gleaming, three-storey Pakistan-China Friendship Centre. The centre, which cost an estimated £35m, houses an 800-seat auditorium, exhibition centre, dining facilities, conference rooms, banquet halls, dance and art facilities.

Inaugurated in December 2010 by the Chinese prime minister, Wen Jiabao, and Pakistan's prime minister, Yousaf Raza Gilani, the centre was a gift from the Chinese government and "symbolises the durable and resilient strategic relationship, which is today the cornerstone of both countries' foreign policies," according to Mushahid Hussein, the senator and former information minister who runs it.

But the building, one of the most impressive in Islamabad with its contemporary architecture fusing Chinese and Pakistani Islamic styles, has also come to symbolise all the problems of a relationship which, despite goodwill on both sides, remains complex. Municipal officials in the capital said they had difficulty paying the heavy maintenance costs of the building.

Pakistan, with its strategic position, natural resources and warm-water ports, has long been an ally of Beijing. The Chinese see the south Asian state, the closest they have to a friend both in south Asia and in the Islamic world, as important to the security and development of their western, predominantly Muslim provinces, and as a useful aide in efforts to counter the influence of India. In recent years, links have grown closer.

"The relationship is based on mutual respect and shared interest. Our economic interests converge and we both have very pressing unresolved territorial disputes with India," said Irfan Shazad of the Institute of Policy Studies in Islamabad.

In the 1990s China offered Pakistan aid with its nuclear programme and now appears ready to honour longstanding commitments to supply Pakistan with two new civilian nuclear reactors. As Islamabad's relations with Washington have soured, Beijing has also become Pakistan's main arms supplier, selling it missiles, tanks, jet fighters, radar equipment and submarines.

Then there are the infrastructure projects. These range from help with the financing and construction of a huge new port on Pakistan's southern coast, projects to improve the currently vulnerable road link than runs over the Himalayas, assistance with railways and enormous hydroelectric schemes such as the controversial dam being built in the foothills of the mountains near the disputed de facto border with India in Kashmir.

There is also straight humanitarian aid – such as during the recent devastating floods – and growing commercial and cultural ties.

"They are very big friends. They bring machinery and knowledge. They do things we couldn't do ourselves," said Faseih Iqbal, a senator from the southwestern state of Balochistan, where Chinese state-owned companies have invested massively in mining and smelting.

For Professor Maria Sultan, of the Islamabad-based South Asian Strategic Stability Institute, "Chinese economic diplomacy has been far more effective than American security diplomacy over recent years."

"All the schools in Sindh [Pakistan's large southern province] now teach Chinese as a second language. President [Asif Ali] Zardari has done more than 20 state visits all over China, more than to any other nation," she said.

Yet, despite the consensus in Pakistan and the official rhetoric of ties being "deeper than the seas and sweeter than honey", some analysts believe the two states' links are exaggerated.

"There is certainly a strong relationship but China increasingly has the same concerns and caveats in Pakistan as the US has," said Lisa Curtis, a senior research fellow at the Heritage Foundation in Washington. "So there are limits to how far the Chinese are prepared to bail Pakistan out economically and they definitely have their concerns about instability. They also want good returns on any commercial investments."

Bilateral trade between Pakistan and China last year was estimated to be around $9bn – a fraction of that between India and China – and Chinese investments in Pakistan were not more than $1.4bn. Beijing has also made clear its concerns about the spillover of Islamic extremism from Pakistan into China's restive southwest.

"If you scratch the surface and look at what is happening with the Chinese in Pakistan, it's a lot less than meets the eye," Curtis said.

During Pakistan's recent floods, Chinese aid totalled $18m; the US gave nearly $700m.

Many Pakistanis also complain about cheap Chinese goods flooding their markets or alleged corruption in government contracts such as that for locomotives signed with Chinese suppliers.

There are other ties that bind beyond the commercial however.

At a function held in Islamabad last month to launch a new magazine published by the Pakistan-China Friendship Centre, successive speakers from both nations spoke of the warmth of their mutual feelings. One quoted the work of American political scientist Samuel Huntingdon.

"Huntingdon said the coming clash will be between the western civilisation and the Islamic-Confucian civilisation. He was right," he said, to general applause.

Pakistan kept sweet by China's money
 
.
Many Pakistanis also complain about cheap Chinese goods flooding their markets or alleged corruption in government contracts such as that for locomotives signed with Chinese suppliers.
LLLOLLLLZ .
this was the funniest part & gross reality which even pakistanis also agree
smiley-laughing025.gif
 
.
Amid parks and lakes on the outskirts of Islamabad sits the gleaming, three-storey Pakistan-China Friendship Centre. The centre, which cost an estimated £35m, houses an 800-seat auditorium, exhibition centre, dining facilities, conference rooms, banquet halls, dance and art facilities.

Inaugurated in December 2010 by the Chinese prime minister, Wen Jiabao, and Pakistan's prime minister, Yousaf Raza Gilani, the centre was a gift from the Chinese government and "symbolises the durable and resilient strategic relationship, which is today the cornerstone of both countries' foreign policies," according to Mushahid Hussein, the senator and former information minister who runs it.

But the building, one of the most impressive in Islamabad with its contemporary architecture fusing Chinese and Pakistani Islamic styles, has also come to symbolise all the problems of a relationship which, despite goodwill on both sides, remains complex. Municipal officials in the capital said they had difficulty paying the heavy maintenance costs of the building.

Pakistan, with its strategic position, natural resources and warm-water ports, has long been an ally of Beijing. The Chinese see the south Asian state, the closest they have to a friend both in south Asia and in the Islamic world, as important to the security and development of their western, predominantly Muslim provinces, and as a useful aide in efforts to counter the influence of India. In recent years, links have grown closer.

"The relationship is based on mutual respect and shared interest. Our economic interests converge and we both have very pressing unresolved territorial disputes with India," said Irfan Shazad of the Institute of Policy Studies in Islamabad.

In the 1990s China offered Pakistan aid with its nuclear programme and now appears ready to honour longstanding commitments to supply Pakistan with two new civilian nuclear reactors. As Islamabad's relations with Washington have soured, Beijing has also become Pakistan's main arms supplier, selling it missiles, tanks, jet fighters, radar equipment and submarines.

Then there are the infrastructure projects. These range from help with the financing and construction of a huge new port on Pakistan's southern coast, projects to improve the currently vulnerable road link than runs over the Himalayas, assistance with railways and enormous hydroelectric schemes such as the controversial dam being built in the foothills of the mountains near the disputed de facto border with India in Kashmir.

There is also straight humanitarian aid – such as during the recent devastating floods – and growing commercial and cultural ties.

"They are very big friends. They bring machinery and knowledge. They do things we couldn't do ourselves," said Faseih Iqbal, a senator from the southwestern state of Balochistan, where Chinese state-owned companies have invested massively in mining and smelting.

For Professor Maria Sultan, of the Islamabad-based South Asian Strategic Stability Institute, "Chinese economic diplomacy has been far more effective than American security diplomacy over recent years."

"All the schools in Sindh [Pakistan's large southern province] now teach Chinese as a second language. President [Asif Ali] Zardari has done more than 20 state visits all over China, more than to any other nation," she said.

Yet, despite the consensus in Pakistan and the official rhetoric of ties being "deeper than the seas and sweeter than honey", some analysts believe the two states' links are exaggerated.

"There is certainly a strong relationship but China increasingly has the same concerns and caveats in Pakistan as the US has," said Lisa Curtis, a senior research fellow at the Heritage Foundation in Washington. "So there are limits to how far the Chinese are prepared to bail Pakistan out economically and they definitely have their concerns about instability. They also want good returns on any commercial investments."

Bilateral trade between Pakistan and China last year was estimated to be around $9bn – a fraction of that between India and China – and Chinese investments in Pakistan were not more than $1.4bn. Beijing has also made clear its concerns about the spillover of Islamic extremism from Pakistan into China's restive southwest.

"If you scratch the surface and look at what is happening with the Chinese in Pakistan, it's a lot less than meets the eye," Curtis said.

During Pakistan's recent floods, Chinese aid totalled $18m; the US gave nearly $700m.

Many Pakistanis also complain about cheap Chinese goods flooding their markets or alleged corruption in government contracts such as that for locomotives signed with Chinese suppliers.

There are other ties that bind beyond the commercial however.

At a function held in Islamabad last month to launch a new magazine published by the Pakistan-China Friendship Centre, successive speakers from both nations spoke of the warmth of their mutual feelings. One quoted the work of American political scientist Samuel Huntingdon.

"Huntingdon said the coming clash will be between the western civilisation and the Islamic-Confucian civilisation. He was right," he said, to general applause.

Pakistan kept sweet by China's money


How can a 3 story building is the most impressive building in whole of pakistani capital??
 
.
This article is full of lies. US never gave $700 Million to Pakistan for flood aid. Check Wikipedia: Total pledge amounts to $84 Million. I wonder how much is released so far. Mostly Americans lie about their financial assistance. The biggest example is US aid to Pakistan during last decade:

Pakistan demanded ~ $13 Billion
Pakistan received ~ $8.6 Billion
Americans claim ~ $18.5 Billion

Most of the above was the fee that Americans had to pay for the services Pakistan provided to NATO-ISAF forces.

On the contrary, Consider China, Chinese have so far provided $47 Million in flood aid (Figures from Dec. 2010) and pledged another $200 Million.
 
. . .
This article is full of lies. US never gave $700 Million to Pakistan for flood aid. Check Wikipedia: Total pledge amounts to $84 Million. I wonder how much is released so far. Mostly Americans lie about their financial assistance. The biggest example is US aid to Pakistan during last decade:

Pakistan demanded ~ $13 Billion
Pakistan received ~ $8.6 Billion
Americans claim ~ $18.5 Billion

Most of the above was the fee that Americans had to pay for the services Pakistan provided to NATO-ISAF forces.

On the contrary, Consider China, Chinese have so far provided $47 Million in flood aid (Figures from Dec. 2010) and pledged another $200 Million.


US has given over $20bn to Pakistan since 9/11
 
.
During Pakistan's recent floods, Chinese aid totalled $18m; the US gave nearly $700m.

Many Pakistanis also complain about cheap Chinese goods flooding their markets or alleged corruption in government contracts such as that for locomotives signed with Chinese suppliers.


:rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
.
LLLOLLLLZ .
this was the funniest part & gross reality which even pakistanis also agree
smiley-laughing025.gif

China is the factory of the world and produces goods for people with lowest to highest purchasing power. Poor countries buy cheaper goods that is in the buying power of their populace. Richer countries can afford to buy expensive goods.

During the past century, there where three phases in which technology was rolled out to the masses.

In the Euro-American era, the technology was available to the select few even in the rich countries.

In the Japan-Taiwan era, the technology was available to the most in rich countries and select few in poor countires.

In the Chienese era, technology is at the disposal of all and sundry around the world.

In the end cheap is not bad, it is rather good; it has turned out to be an equaliser of the humanity.

US has given over $20bn to Pakistan since 9/11

The answer is in my post you have quoted; they are lying as usual.
 
. .
China is the factory of the world and produces goods for people with lowest to highest purchasing power. Poor countries buy cheaper goods that is in the buying power of their populace. Richer countries can afford to buy expensive goods.

During the past century, there where three phases in which technology was rolled out to the masses.

In the Euro-American era, the technology was available to the select few even in the rich countries.

In the Japan-Taiwan era, the technology was available to the most in rich countries and select few in poor countires.

In the Chienese era, technology is at the disposal of all and sundry around the world.

In the end cheap is not bad, it is rather good; it has turned out to be an equaliser of the humanity.



The answer is in my post you have quoted; they are lying as usual.

No your figures are wrong checkout the actual funds given according to the US dept.
 
.
The funny thing about the article is about how usa has been aiding Pakistan and compare the numbers with China but the author has failed to mention the part that US troops and drones brutal intrusion into another sovereign state and killed its civilians. Now someone acknowledge the guardian has published a good article! hilarious but sad!
 
.
Mate its simply not just about money. There is something about winning hearts and minds. In any event China teaches us to earn money America teaches our leaders to beg. eg: F16 and JF17.


China does what is in it's interest nothing wrong in that but Pakistan should also take into account what is in it's benefit.

The funny thing about the article is about how usa has been aiding Pakistan and compare the numbers with China but the author has fail to mention the part that US troops and drones intrusion into another sovereignty state and killed its civilians. Now someone acknowledge the guardian has published a good article! hilarious but sad!


Those same drones have also killed many terrorists keeping western cities safe from punks like the french killer.
 
.
Those same drones have also killed many terrorists keeping western cities safe from punks like the french killer. - Yeti

Those drones don't kill "terrorists", they kill civilians. Also the best way to protect your own country isn't to invade another, but to strengthen your own security
 
.
why arent indian members congratulating pak over win in asiacup? Bt they are to much busy where they can speak against pak. Get a life.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom