Pak army operation in Waziristan: Over 100 Hindus among thousands displaced

[livingdead]

Ofcourse not. We are a poor country. But we are will still be the last country willing to accept the Dharmic people.


No. Rohingyas are of Bengali origin, which arguably is also Indian origin. So by your line of reasoning Rohingyas which number in millions should be granted asylum in India.

And if Muslims of Indian(broad sense) origin need a place for asylum, they have Pakistan - a country made exclusively for Muslims of South Asia. If that country fails them or refuses them, then they can go to Saudi Arabia for all we care.

And yes, asylum seekers when they number in millions will cause HUGE social complications in whichever area they settle in (if they are of non-Dharmic origin).
While you may be comfortable, I doubt that whichever city you hail from in India - your relatives back here will not be very pleased to suddenly find a million or more sunni rohingyas living next to their city.

So on account of all such facts, we are not obligated to help anyone but those of Dharmic faiths. We should focus our efforts - limited as they are- to people who are relevant to us.

are you implying indian muslims should live separately from hindus then.
Yes pakistan was made for muslims which is why we should not accept economic migrants from there. But if anybody faces threat to life and manages to come to us, you are saying we will send them back.
We have never done that, and I hope we never do.
BTW lakhs of bangladeshis live in India without issues.

 

[Contrarian]

Well that what you want in reality. Why hide behind asylum providing BS.

Thankyou again for telling us what we want 'in reality'.
The discussion at the moment centers on whether or not we should provide asylum to people of all faiths or just Dharmic faiths.

 

[JonAsad]

All I care is that Pakistanis are displaced-

 

[AugenBlick]

BTW lakhs of bangladeshis live in India without issues.

Ask people in the NE about the "without Issues" part.

 

[JonAsad]

Btw arent indian hindus surprised how the Pakistani hindus survived TTP all that time?-

 

[Areesh]

Thankyou again for telling us what we want 'in reality'.
The discussion at the moment centers on whether or not we should provide asylum to people of all faiths or just Dharmic faiths.

Providing asylum to dharmic people is not just not enough to change demographics. With Indian muslims(read illegal BD immigrants) everywhere in India, gujrat model should also be implemented along with giving asylums.

 

[Contrarian]

are you implying indian muslims should live separately from hindus then.

I dont think you can legitimately make an inference of that from what I said. This discussion is solely about non Indian citizens being granted asylum in India and what should our criteria be.

Yes pakistan was made for muslims which is why we should not accept economic migrants from there. But if anybody faces threat to life and manages to come to us, you are saying we will send them back.
We have never done that, and I hope we never do.

Yes we have done that. We have denied and turned away rohingyas from our borders in the last 2 years itself. We are not a dharamshala for anyone and everyone in the neighbourhood to land up here.

BTW lakhs of bangladeshis live in India without issues.

My friend, this is extreme intellectual dishonesty from you. Do you know that the majority of Bangladeshis in India live in West Bengal and North Eastern States. Are you aware that the tribals from that area have extreme issues because of it.
You are free to talk to any NE tribal and they will tell this to you.

So just because you donot know that there are issues, you presume that there are none, and since you have not lived with such refugees in India, you donot know the issues they impose on the locals.

You talk the way you do because you donot have to face the consequences of those immigrants living in India.The riots of Assam last year,when many Indians died - should be plenty of evidence about whether there have been issues because of Bangladeshi migration or not.

 

[SHAMK9]

Yes its true,in KPK infact in Bannu we have thousands of hindus and christian.After the last year Church Bombing in peshawar talking to my classmate father(English Teacher in Govt Degree 2 college bannu),We have relatives upto karachi and i have also lived in cities like lahore,Karachi,Peshawar and even Quetta.But Bannu is the only place where we doesn't feel any problem practicing our religion and we have never recieved anysort of threat from anyone.He's a reputed English teacher and has even name mentioned in the matric books issued by KPK Govt.

Mansehra and Abbottabad both have numbers of Sikhs, Hindus and Christians living peacefully

 

[livingdead]

I dont think you can legitimately make an inference of that from what I said. This discussion is solely about non Indian citizens being granted asylum in India and what should our criteria be.


Yes we have done that. We have denied and turned away rohingyas from our borders in the last 2 years itself. We are not a dharamshala for anyone and everyone in the neighbourhood to land up here.


This is extreme intellectual dishonesty from you. Do you know that the majority of Bangladeshis in India live in West Bengal and North Eastern States. Are you aware that the tribals from that area have extreme issues because of it.
You are free to talk to any NE tribal and they will tell this to you.

So just because you donot know that there are issues, you presume that there are none, and since you have not lived with such refugees in India, you donot know the issues they impose on the locals.

You talk the way you do because you donot have to face the consequences of those immigrants living in India.The riots of Assam last year,when many Indians died - should be plenty of evidence about whether there have been issues because of Bangladeshi migration or not.

bangladeshis did not create problem in NE, its a race issue there. Why is it that same bangladeshis face no issue in west bengal. But biharis migrant workers have been killed in NE.
assam riots were mostly by NE Indians, bangladeshis (and other bengali speaking muslims) were at receiving end.

 

[farhan_9909]

Mansehra and Abbottabad both have numbers of Sikhs, Hindus and Christians living peacefully

Ah the famous Sikh hakeem and Masalay wala

I also know a pashtun sikh from Hangu in AIMC

 

[Contrarian]

bangladeshis did not create problem in NE, its a race issue there. Why is it that same bangladeshis face no issue in west bengal. But biharis migrant workers have been killed in NE.

Again, who told you that there have been no issues in West Bengal?
Are you aware that there have been numerous small scale riots in West Bengal, as opposed to a massive one in Assam. The small scale riots are not reported in the mainstream dailies, please read up the vernacular press of West Bengal for news of this kind.

assam riots were mostly by NE Indians, bangladeshis (and other bengali speaking muslims) were at receiving end.

Regardless of who they were from and who was at the receiving end, they did happen yes?
And if the local people of NE India donot want Bangladeshi's there, how can you say that Bangladeshi's in India have cause no issues.

So in both cases, immigration of sunnis in India have caused problems regardless of whichever region they live in. Do you still think we should have accepted the many lakhs of rohingyas who also turned up at our border but were turned away?

 

[Kompromat]

Oh the evil Punjabis serve food to the Hindus in 'separate utensils' - heck with basic hygiene reasoning.

 

[Irfan Baloch]

Blood sucking Tiger won't eat grass even after it empties the forest. It will start eating weaker tigers.

the tiger is not discriminating it is eating grass and whatever that comes in its path being a vegetable is weak insurance policy

Oh the evil Punjabis serve food to the Hindus in 'separate utensils' - heck with basic hygiene reasoning.

habitual Punjabi hatred clouds the mind so much that its forgotten that a sizable eastern Punjabi chunk is in Inida and their men form the front part of Indian defences .

generally speaking, on forums , facebook youtube and twiter
blind hatred and hypocrisy does silly things. in order to prove Indian "concern" and and Apathy for Baloch Sardars.. they use sweeping Punjabi curses and in that process condemn their own Punjabi too.. it seems they also believe in Taliban's collateral damage and acceptable loss doctrine

 

[Contrarian]

Oh the evil Punjabis serve food to the Hindus in 'separate utensils' - heck with basic hygiene reasoning.

habitual Punjabi hatred clouds the mind so much that its forgotten that a sizable eastern Punjabi chunk is in Inida and their men form the front part of Indian defences .

generally speaking, on forums , facebook youtube and twiter
blind hatred and hypocrisy does silly things. in order to prove Indian "concern" and and Apathy for Baloch Sardars.. they use sweeping Punjabi curses and in that process condemn their own Punjabi too.. it seems they also believe in Taliban's collateral damage and acceptable loss doctrine

I never talk without proof.

This is what Pakistani Punjabis do. They have been at the top of the race in discriminating against non Muslims in Pakistan. And the discrimination has become literally inhuman. The tribals of Pakistan have been far better on that count when it comes to tolerance, which was rather surprising.

Oh and just FYI @Irfan Baloch , when Indians talk about Punjabis on a Pakistani forum, it is invariably Pakistani Punjabis.

Source 1:

He said during his study, he experienced firsthand some of the discrimination Muslims in Pakistan accord to non-Muslims, especially giving them food or drinks in separate utensils.
Book launch: Rediscovering Pakistan’s pluralistic culture – The Express Tribune

Source 2:

The eateries in the entire bazaar that is frequented by the local Sikhs either plainly refuse to serve them or have separate cups and glasses for them.
Kalyan Singh who has spent almost his entire here can even tell you which rehri wala will serve him and which won't.

Day 3: The Sikhs of Nankana Sahab - Pakistan - DAWN.COM

 

[Kompromat]

I never talk without proof.

This is what Pakistani Punjabis do. They have been at the top of the race in discriminating against non Muslims in Pakistan. And the discrimination has become literally inhuman.

Yea one or few incidents prove the evil hood of 80 million evil satan worshipping Punjabis.

Did it ever occur to you or the mental douchebag who wrote that above piece of crap that the simple reason behind serving in 'different utensils' to Hindus may aswell be the fact that they serve meat in the same utensils and don't want to cheat visitors into eating in utensils which were used to serve beef half an hour ago. #DeathToLogic #ShameOnPunjabis