Only 14, Bangladeshi girl charged with adultery was lashed to death

[DesiGuy]

it's so common n many developing nations, and i this is just one of these shameful acts.

We need GOOD Hitler to deal with these criminals. Rape is the biggest crime above all even above than murder in my view.

 

[Mech]

Why are islamic rules so extreme and without compassion? I dont mean disrespect, but these kind of rash laws are not for the 21st century. I dont even want to get started on saudi and other islamic countries.

 

[gubbi]

don't worry Islam bashing is a fashion in Pakistan too some ppl just want to malign shirat and they have made it their agenda no 1

We have all seen what this particular interpretation of Islam has done to Pakistan and its development. It is only but natural that many in Pakistan oppose the mullah brigade and their interpretation of Islam.

Qualifications for a Mullah/Imam should be made more stringent and under the strict control of the Government. Time for a change to free the oppressed.

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

Why are islamic rules so extreme and without compassion? I dont mean disrespect, but these kind of rash laws are not for the 21st century. I dont even want to get started on saudi and other islamic countries.

Which rule you are talking about??? elaborate please...

 

[gubbi]

Our male to female ratios are within the world average. In India this ratio is fine in Muslims, but not in the Hindu population. The issue is dowry. When you have a son he can make you money, daughter on the other hand can cost you fortune. So for these parents aborting or choking the life out of the baby is pure business.

Sources.


The message you have entered is too short. Please lengthen your message to at least 10 characters.

 

[F-16_Falcon]

shocking medieval punishment. bangladesh! social crisis.

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

Sources.


The message you have entered is too short. Please lengthen your message to at least 10 characters.

623 million male 586 million female... other then muslims the ratio would be higher then the present ..

 

[gubbi]

Which rule you are talking about??? elaborate please...

The rule where rape has to be witnessed by atleast 4 witnesses. Like the rapist would take four people as witnesses for committing the crime!

And when there are no witnesses, its usually the woman who faces the punishment - usually Death for adultery. Some justice system, eh?

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

shocking medieval punishment. bangladesh! social crisis.

Think about pakistan and its social crisis... you will not see in Bangladesh here n there people are blowing themselves up in crowded places and even stoning girls to death..

 

[gubbi]

623 million male 586 million female... other then muslims the ratio would be higher then the present ..

That still doesnt answer the question or your claim that male to female ratio of Muslims in India is better than that of Hindus.

Our male to female ratios are within the world average. In India this ratio is fine in Muslims, but not in the Hindu population

Again, sources for your claim.

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

The rule where rape has to be witnessed by atleast 4 witnesses. Like the rapist would take four people as witnesses for committing the crime!

And when there are no witnesses, its usually the woman who faces the punishment - usually Death for adultery. Some justice system, eh?

You are talking about adultery... that is because so that no one can charge or accuse any innocent woman n this related verse revealed when ayesha wife of prophet mohammad was accused of adultery for left behind in a tour and another man helped her to reach prophet mohammad..

For the rape it is not required as one can see the physical evidence and now the technology is much more advanced... in islam rape is considered as a worst crime and punished by death in many occasion...

But it is in the bible which has for stoned to death for adultery... n asked to give the victim father 50 shackle and to marry the victim by the rappist... so the question easily come whom bible god is actually punishing... the rapist or the victim by forcing the victim to stay with the rapist for her rest of the life..

I think this is also same for hinduism.. punishment for adultery is death... as purity is always given lots of importance... n sita also had to give the test... I am just wonder what will happen to many hindu woman if they have to give such tests..

But no where in the quran it has asked for death penalty for adultery.. it was just tribal culture and jews and christian used to precise it. N as many early muslims were converted jews and christians ... so many kept the tradition of stoning to death for adultery which is prescribed in the bible..

 

[guest11]

RIP to the poor girl. A very sad incident indeed but not very in this part of the world. Lack of education and law enforcement is the root of all this nuisance.

 

[guest11]

I think this is also same for hinduism.. punishment for adultery is death... as purity is always given lots of importance... n sita also had to give the test... I am just wonder what will happen to many hindu woman if they have to give such tests..

Yes, in Hinduism the sanctity of a woman is very important but we don't stone women to death or lash them. It's not written anywhere, IIRC.

In case of Sita, she was abandoned not killed.

 

[gubbi]

For the rape it is not required as one can see the physical evidence and now the technology is much more advanced... in islam rape is considered as a worst crime and punished by death in many occasion...

I am not talking about adultery. I am talking about many news reports where Islamic Sharia law had punished rape victims as young as teenagers with death punishment. Just because they didnt have 4 witnesses to save them, while the rapist goes scot free!

But it is in the bible which has for stoned to death for adultery... n asked to give the victim father 50 shackle and to marry the victim by the rappist... so the question easily come whom bible god is actually punishing... the rapist or the victim by forcing the victim to stay with the rapist for her rest of the life..

Yes, the bible may say that, but do you see any courts ruling or handing punishments on the basis what the Bible said? NO. But you indeed have judgments passed on what Islamic law says. There lies the difference.
All those Biblical laws make interesting reading but are not practically possible because their time has gone. So is the case with Islamic laws, but we still have people who want to live in that particular time period.

I think this is also same for hinduism.. punishment for adultery is death... as purity is always given lots of importance... n sita also had to give the test... I am just wonder what will happen to many hindu woman if they have to give such tests..

No. And you are confusing mythological stories with hard and fast rules. In Hinduism, there are no hard and fast rules, there is no death penalty - just the knowledge that Karma is a bi*tch. So be careful with what you do.

But no where in the quran it has asked for death penalty for adultery.. it was just tribal culture and jews and christian used to precise it. N as many early muslims were converted jews and christians ... so many kept the tradition of stoning to death for adultery which is prescribed in the bible..

That still doesnt absolve "Islamic scholars" wanting to impose death penalty on adulterers. Christians dont demand stoning or lashing based on Bible as punishment for rapists. There is the law of the land. Can you say the same about Sharia?

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

I am not talking about adultery. I am talking about many news reports where Islamic Sharia law had punished rape victims as young as teenagers with death punishment. Just because they didnt have 4 witnesses to save them, while the rapist goes scot free!

At 1st decide what do you want to say....punishment for rape or adultery... for adultery no charge can be borught if there are not 4 eye witness or enough proof... but if adultery is proved for the girl then also the same happen with the man... but hardly in any case they are punished to death.. these are just zionist propaganda...

N for rape the punishment of the rapist is death... it is very strict on the case.. if a woman is raped it can be traced from her body... no eye witness is required as eye witness is mainly for adultery where no physical evidence remain...

Yes, the bible may say that, but do you see any courts ruling or handing punishments on the basis what the Bible said? NO. But you indeed have judgments passed on what Islamic law says. There lies the difference.
All those Biblical laws make interesting reading but are not practically possible because their time has gone. So is the case with Islamic laws, but we still have people who want to live in that particular time period.

Hardly you can say that its time has gone...??? As the main word of bible is god's word is ever lasting to ever lasting... so what god has said can not be changed or undone...If you say christian or jews are not following this... then the question will come why they are not following it??? Is it not because of the leggings in their holy book... if they can not follow the god's command by saying its time has passed then how come they are worshiping that god.. n conducting ethnic cleansing and robbing other peoples land in palestine based on the same command of the bible???

No. And you are confusing mythological stories with hard and fast rules. In Hinduism, there are no hard and fast rules, there is no death penalty - just the knowledge that Karma is a bi*tch. So be careful with what you do.

That not only the case ... in hinduism woman even used to be burnt with their husband.... do not forget about that.. n still some evil deeds like wearing white saari, depriving from all sindur, bangles and other stuff and not allowed to get married after husband death is still in place...

That still doesnt absolve "Islamic scholars" wanting to impose death penalty on adulterers. Christians dont demand stoning or lashing based on Bible as punishment for rapists. There is the law of the land. Can you say the same about Sharia?

It depends on which islamic scholar you are talking about.... there are shaira law in dubai (UAE)... n it is also in saudi ... but both are not the same...as it depends which religious scholars are giving fatwa.... such as saudi wahabi scholars give fatwa like woman will have to wear niqab to cover their face... n can not study in same uni with mae, woman can not drive... but is not applicable to any other muslim country...